Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

The hawley grinding video...

Posts

The hawley grinding video...

#1

The hawley grinding video...

David Weaver

Of the various videos, the grinding video is one of the more interesting, at least to me (I have no idea why).

In things like the grinding and fork polishing videos, there's not a whole lot that would be more than entertainment to us, but there is a short segment where the job grinder is working up a bevel edge chisel.

https://youtu.be/l9pCv5UkHwU?t=402

This does a lot to explain why certain scratch patterns are on chisels made after WWII.

I'm guessing this chisel is already hard and maybe it gets some polishing after this (and maybe not). The chisel gets hot in grinding, but it doesn't get hot enough to fizz the water off instantly.

It's incredibly quick that the job grinder does the grinding on this chisel and makes me wonder just how much money the makers were saving by cutting the time back on the grinder (and perhaps a follow-up polish step or two). $10? whatever the pound equivalent was? Of course, $10 in production becomes $30 at retail. A shame. The skill of these guys to work quickly and turn forged items into near finish is pretty incredible.

Re: The hawley grinding video...

#2

Rafael from PA

Re: The hawley grinding video...

Rafael from PA

Another interesting thing to note is the small scale of these operations. When one imagines an industrial setting where the target is the production of thousands or hundreds of thousands of items, these old workshops could no compete with automation in certain areas.

An article I read showed a rotating machine in a Stanley plant where dozens of chisels would be loaded for grinding. I think that's how the 700 series chisels were made.

Re: The hawley grinding video...

#3

Re: The hawley grinding video...

David Weaver

A good contrast to the grinders is a very recent video of the buck 110 knife being made. It goes into a machine that shapes the blade, into another one that hardens and tempers, and then into a couple of wet (automated) grinders that hollow grind the blade.

There's a penknife maker on one of the hawley videos, also. He works efficiently, but the factory version of assembling the knife is pretty much a jig that puts the pins/rivets through the knife and then peins them all at once.

I have two of those buck 110s - for what they are, they're nice knives. They can retail them for $45 on ebay with cocobolo handles and a fair amount of brass and decent stainless. George wilson turned me on to tidioute knives, which are factory made, but a higher level of refinement - I remember him being astounded at the finish quality on them for about $100-$125, and he said something along the lines of costing $1500 of his time at his shop rate to make a knife as good.

Given that these shops were doing mostly specialty work already in the 1960s, and most people now would see any human irregularity in a made tool as "poor quality" unless it's on etsy as a boutique tool, the ship has long sailed.

(the only issue with the buck knives in the past for me was that they're a lower carbon high-carbon stainless. a "plain" stainless. This whole dust up with the unicorn sort of solved the edge holding issues I had with them. I think they're intended to be a folding hunting knife, but I don't hunt. Without a buffed edge, they don't tolerate much box cutting or shop chore work, but they work great with the edge buffed off).

Re: The hawley grinding video...

#4

Re: The hawley grinding video...

Wiley Horne

David,

“ they work great with the edge buffed off).”

Been meaning to tell you, and this is a good place. At your suggestion, I got one of the Great Eastern Cutlery pocket knives—not the Tidioute, the other brand. 1095 as you know. Improved Trapper, which has a Wharncliffe blade.

Anyway, to your point, I’ve noticed a huge difference in edge-holding since I’ve been buffing as a last sharpening step. Of course, when you dig planting holes with it, it’s back to the 1000g starter stone, but just ordinary twig cutting, opening amazon boxes, and carving the tinfoil out of tylenol bottles—sharpening is long-ladting if buffed.

Wiley

Re: The hawley grinding video...

#5

Rafael from PA

Re: The hawley grinding video...

Rafael from PA

I have this old Jensen in the office to open boxes and such. It doesn't hold an edge very well. I'll take it to the buffer tonight.

I also have somewhere at home a folding knife similar to the Buck one you mentioned. It wouldn't take or keep a decent edge either, it looks nice with the brass polished though. I'll take it to the buffer as well.


Re: The hawley grinding video...

#6

Various buck knives...

David Weaver

..my dad had some buck knives that are older, and some generic copies. I recall them being very gummy steel as a kid (if a knife was still bright in his hunting knife group, it didn't take a very good edge).

I destroyed a chisel over the weekend that had been unicorned - it continues to fail spectacularly (it's a buck brothers chisels, older socket type) on pine whereas my other chisels don't. I guess what I'm getting at is that if steel is very mediocre but still at least that, the buffer seems to bring it up to spec. If it's butter soft, then there's no real hope (but the only way to find out is try).

The newer basic US knives have what they refer to as 420HC. It's fine grained for a stainless steel, and almost good. Once it's buffed, it's good, bordering on very good (for actual hunting use, which mine will never see - it would be spectacular).

I found favor with the tidioute 1095 knives because they're hard like a chisel and plain carbon steel - they hold an edge like we're used to with tools, but now have to admit I don't have a great need for it :\

Re: The hawley grinding video...

#7

unxld northfield

David Weaver

or something like that for the brand?

I had one of that line until this week (a sunfish knife - that was novel, but good to unload). The unxld knives have a bit more of an expensive look (longer grooves on the blade, etc, more bone and less wood) - I think they're similar steel, though. GEC says 57 hardness, but the wall street wharncliffe knives that I have are well above that - the washita rats them out as not being that soft. They sharpen wonderfully and hold an edge really well doing the things you mention (breaking down boxes, cutting twigs, etc). Strangely, a slightly soft knife set really keen just won't stand up to cardboard.

At any rate, it's fitting that the buffing works well as we stole the trick from the knife people in the first place (at least that's where I saw it). The wax from the wheel should help keep corrosion away on the 1095 bladed knives, too.

Failure on the buck knife started at the edge and then folding ensued when I had it sharpened just two bevel freehand (with the apex left on). the edge holds up now to literal hacking to whack branches off of trees for the kids to toast fall marshmallows.

Re: The hawley grinding video...

#8

Sparks

Winston

I'm impressed that the grinding is throwing off that big shower of sparks even though there's water on it. I wonder how much faster it removes material compared to my 6" grinder.

Re: The hawley grinding video...

#9

Re: The hawley grinding video...

Steve Voigt

The grinding video was cool. I spent a bunch of hours this week completely regrinding the tapers on two sets of plow irons. Some of the techniques I used were similar (like dropping the back of the iron down onto just the right spot on the wheel and then pushing forward) but these guys were so much more fluent and had so many more tricks.

After watching the guy grind a pallet knife, I know how the old saws, like the ones in the Seaton chest, were ground. Not sure what the power source in 1800 was--maybe water, or apprentice--but I'm sure that big water wheel is how it was done.

I'd love to acquire a grinder like that, maybe half the size, but same concept. But I'd wear a mask. Even with water to cut down on the dust, all those guys were dead from emphysema in a few years, I'd bet.

Re: The hawley grinding video...

#10

Re: The hawley grinding video...

David Weaver

I had the same urge....want one of those wheels! I'd imagine lineshaft and water for the wheels early on, maybe steam and lineshaft in some places. I was wrong in my timeline comments earlier, I'm sure you noticed but others may not have watched. The job grinder video is from 1993. The guys are brothers, with the one on the left 79 if he's still alive. Not sure when the intro was posted, but they were still alive when it was attached to the video, no doubt helped by using silicon carbide instead of silica.

I could find nothing of those wheels, though. You could turn your stub garage into a grinding room and start making all kinds of stuff!

Of interest for some may also be that at least as recent as 10 years ago or less, the pen knife maker was still at it. Online says that he adapted as the market got smaller and learned to do the smithing and other operations himself to keep going, and went upmarket in his knife making. I saw a used linerlock style or some other lockback type of his that sold on eBay for $370.

Re: The hawley grinding video...

#12

Re: The hawley grinding video...

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Thanks for pointing out the grinding video. It is a good reminder of what skill and experience can bring.

I had never seen a video of glazing before. Chisels from the 18th century and up to at least mid 19th century were glazed. They did not have side bevels so it was probably very little time. That is one of the reasons I was skeptical of the "factory grind" on the Sorby mortise chisels; I have never seen chisels of that era that were not glazed. A guy who was skilled enough to grind a mortise chisel could have glazed it it in not many seconds.

The bending test on the palette knife might have been partly to see how flexible it was, but also to identify places where the knife was too thick. Workers may have used this method for evaluating saw thickness.

Re: The hawley grinding video...

#13

A shower of Sparks

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

A shower of sparks is the mechanism of removing the heat of work of the abrasive on the steel. If the abrasive particle is sharp and milling out shavings, as opposed to plowing without removing shavings, a substantial amount of the heat leave with the shaving. A shower of sparks means the grinding material is sharp and staying sharp.

Re: The hawley grinding video...

#14

Large wheels

Winston

On eBay, under the "Metalworking Abrasive Wheels" category, there are a lot of large wheels available. A search in that category for items over $200 turns up many 20-30" wheels:

https://www.ebay.com/b/Metalworking-Abrasive-Wheels/258104/bn_7115562351?rt=nc&_udlo=200

Apparently Norton will make wheels up to 42 inches in diameter, though the max diameter depends on the type of wheel. That's what their PDF catalog says here.

https://www.nortonabrasives.com/sga-common/files/document/catalog-nortonindustrial-7362-lr-bookmarked.pdf#page=257

Re: The hawley grinding video...

#15

saw grinding...

David Weaver

it would seem that nobody else would've been able to quickly thickness saw blades, and this solves a mystery of how that could've been done. It would've been pretty miserable, far less healthful and more dangerous with a 6 foot silica wheel.

When I brought up the style of the round over that seems to always be present on i.sorby and ward chisels (but doesn't appear neatly on any marples), the folks on the UK forum reminded me that up to a point, all hand ground chisels would've been glazed on a leather wheel with loose grit (I thought the marks on the I. sorby chisels showed something other than a hard silicon carbide wheel - they do - but I didn't account for the fact that no matter what the base wheel was, until the budget for work was really tight, all of the chisels would've been glazed after grinding).

I still think the round over is factory, but there's never going to be definitive information about it. The arrangements in this video make me wonder if sorby and others (ward) did their grinding and glazing, or if it would've been jobbed out.

The names of the workers in the videos make it easy to search for them - it's clear that the penknife maker worked very late into life (and may still be working as the last reference to him said basically that even after most things on that sheffield island went fallow, he had gone upmarket and was making knives two days a week).

Some of those videos are from the 60s, some are from 1993. It's clear in 1993 that a lot of the workers are doing several roles compared to what was done earlier (the cutler at a now-closed knife company pretty much makes and finishes the entire knife after receiving the roughed blanks from the grinder. No separate handle makers, etc - he moves from area to area working).

I doubt that tooltique (where one of those I. sorby chisels was shown) has the means or skill to use high speed glazing tools shown in the videos - my 7 year old son was asking how the guy never grinds the tips of his fingers off. The 24 inch wheels that rafael linked to say they're good to a little more than 1350 rpm - at 60 grit, they would remove fingerprints.

Re: The hawley grinding video...

#16

Thanks, both yours and Rafaels'

David Weaver

posts...I didn't know the right term for those wheels. I see them listed as "centerless grinding", and there's no used machine on craigslist (they're out of my price range, anyway, but would be an awesome toy).

It looks like they're used now mostly in CNC machines (when looking up "centerless grinding").

But a wide enough range of pictures to really have no clue (I see machines grinding camshafts, and huge long machines grinding round stock).

Safe to say that in most small and mid production of tools and knives, the belt grinder has taken over, but I don't see how a belt grinder can do some of the things that a hard wheel can do (like thicknessing accurately from edge to edge).

Re: The hawley grinding video...

#17

forgot to make my point

David Weaver

..the dream machine for dangerous backyard use (as in, one abandoned industrially and that just runs like the ones those guys are using with the user left to do the rest of the influencing) appears to be nonexistent.

Re: The hawley grinding video...

#18

Rafael from PA

Re: forgot to make my point

Rafael from PA

It should be feasible to attach one of these wheels to a wooden lathe or some speed reduced electric motor assembly.

How about those vintage sandstone wheels that can be found in antique stores? Could it be attached to a motor?

Also, in one of the woodworker Facebook groups someone was making his own very large grinding wheel out of cement. Similar to those old sandstone ones. I haven't seen anything lately, once posts age it's difficult to go back and find them. I don't know how his project went.


Re: The hawley grinding video...

#19

Speed

David Weaver

those wheels do OK working bevels, especially on softer or laminated tools. Usually. George mentioned CW getting some wheels that were harder and finely graded and difficult to use.

I doubt most of those are well balanced and could work at a higher speed. The attraction (for anyone who has freehand ground) to an aggressive abrasive at a high speed is that it doesn't present a lot of grip on the work (just like a belt sander doesn't). The opposite effect vs. that is something like trying to grind freehand on a tormek - BTDT, can't really do it on small areas and the machine is too slow for large areas.

Realistically, the alternative is a larger hard wheel belt grinder (which is what the boutique knife users use - some kind of stop/jig and the hard wheel on a belt grinder for concave grinds, and the platen or slack belt for convex).

I saw a lot of those sandstone wheels as a kid - they were in the shed in most farms. I only ever saw one being used at a craft show, though (some guy was sharpening pocket knives for $1 each on a wheel powered by a hit and miss engine. That was over 30 years ago -not sure there would be enough guys with pocket knives for that to be worthwhile, but back then, most of the men locally carried a pocket knife, and usually ungodly dull).