Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Knots or Not knots. That is the question

Posts

Knots or Not knots. That is the question

#1

Knots or Not knots. That is the question

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.


The drawer fronts will be veneered with this nifty swirly wood. But what part of the nifty wood to use? The vision is for the grain on the left side to arc right, complimented by arc left on the right side. Two adjacent slices will yield the 4 faces.

So what choices were made? Knot saved for another day.

Re: Knots or Not knots. That is the question

#2

Stabilized before resawing?

Jim Matthews

Will the knit just disintegrate while resawing?

Can your blade manage an epoxy inclusion?

Re: Knots or Not knots. That is the question

#3

Re: Stabilized before resawing?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

What is shown is the resawed veneer. The defects will be rejected. I am not into this modern notion of filling and stabilizing defects to make them fashion elements.

Re: Knots or Not knots. That is the question

#4

The knot survived resawing?

Jim Matthews

I'm genuinely surprised the knot remained.

I'm "knot" a fan of including sapwood in show faces.

This stuff is pretty wild - almost a burl.

It should shimmer like a rave, under finish.

Re: Knots or Not knots. That is the question

#5

Rafael from PA

Re: Knots or Not knots. That is the question

Rafael from PA

That's definitely not usable.

On the other hand, I made a small box for my wife over the weekend from some discarded lumber I found in the building I work at. When making the lid, I chose to use knotty pieces as accents.


Re: Knots or Not knots. That is the question

#6

Re: Knots or Not knots. That is the question

TomD

I do not generally include knots, it is a design decision. A bark inclusion on the edge of the board just looks like one was going cheap on the wood.

I would not use that wood for a drawer front as if I did, there would be a huge shear force and possibly biding force given it appears to be crossgrain to the drawer opening. IKEA does that kind of thing, but the teak veneers were paper thin. My Dad's Bechstein grand piano is done that way, I think, but it is also very thin veneer, and it failed almost totally over the 50 years he had it. It had been rebuilt, so I do not know how it came from the factory.

Re: Knots or Not knots. That is the question

#7

Re: Knots or Not knots. That is the question

Bruce McCrory

That will look really nice Bill. I presume the sap will be toward the carcase sides.