Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Turkey Stones

Posts

Turkey Stones

#1

Turkey Stones

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

These things seem expensive. Date and price comparison to follow

1790 Turkey stone L:3:9, Six chisels and two gouges L :4: (English money denominations ) stone = 6 chisels and two gouges, or 40% cost of two smoothing and one jack plane

1797 Turkey stone $0.50, 10 molding planes $1.50, 1 hand saw $1.50

1794 Turkey stone L:5:0 Two smoothers and a jack L:5:0, plow and a fillister :6:3

mention of Turkey stones in inventories absent early into 1800's. In fact sharpening stones are not mentioned in shop inventories after early 1800's. Did they become too inexpensive to show up?

Re: Turkey Stones

#2

Warren - turkey vs. turkish

David Weaver

Warren - I know you stay a lot of the time in the 1700s. Do you know when the term turkey stone went from being a turkish oilstone (the type that I posted in the stone omnibus, admittedly, mine is lighter brown and not as choice as the blackest of the type), to other novaculite stones?

I have bought washitas in the past that don't seem quite like washitas and often they're a little taller. I've always wondered exactly what they were, but that's separate from this question. I think they may just be oddball washitas, because they're nothing like the cretan or turkish stones even though they may have some similar aspects.

Lastly, I've read more than once that the discovery of huge amounts of novaculite in the US, and then viable mining of said material wasn't until the 1800s (and I believe I've had several washita stones that were taller and longer with hand cut backs), leading to the supposition that notation of a turkey stone in inventory would not be our washita type stones (which todd hughes often sold on ebay as "turkey stones").

The other types of novaculite stones that I've seen are:

* magog (canada -i can't imagine that magog stones were mined that early)

* idwalls, like the ones shown in this thread

* charnley forest (from light green to dark green with red splotches)

I don't know the history of the magogs except that they were true novaculite from a lake area in canada, in various colors and fineness. I have seen historical references attaching the label "turkey stone" to them, but that flows back to the prior comment about turkey stone naming being given to any novaculite stone that would cut reasonably well and finely at the same time.

I have never bought a labeled magog stone - too expensive, but it wouldn't be out of the question that I've used one at some point. I wouldn't have noticed.

Idwall and charnley stones are very fine and slower, charnley being a little soft at least in some cases and can be gouged.

Re: Turkey Stones

#3

separate cretan for reference

David Weaver

There is a modern batch of stones being mined, I believe in crete. They can be had in very large stones, and at one point, were about $55 with shipping in the US. They work just like my turkish stone (which I believe to be on the coarse side for turkish), but are a little bit more coarse yet.

Mine is a "white" type. The stones labeled black are apparently finer and may be a good finish stone, but the retailing of them is inconsistent and I haven't tried to get one. Shipping for a stone of any decent size from europe would be more than the price of the stone and you could get one with a giant inclusion front and center, so no go.

https://www.badgerandblade.com//forum/proxy.php?image=https%3A%2F%2Fuploads.tapatalk-cdn.com%2F20190615%2F98c6cee95211e1f916862f07398fcc05.jpg&hash=f4e8f79d0d91f865556b2bce19343afc

If that links works, that is one of the white ones. The shavers don't like them because they're not as fine as they want and they try to use them with water (I still have no idea why they try to use all of the oilstones with water)

Slowly getting to my point - you mentioned roubo talking about the decline in quality of the cretan/turkish stones. There may have been a mine area with excellent stone that's exhausted - or maybe it was a different area than the cretans now. I've seen around half a dozen of the stones like mine (but most are darker). with laminated steel, they shed particles and cut fast, reasonably finely and are easy to use (as is mine), but with softer tools, their aggression can be tricky.

Anyway, short on sleep and pondering around - since you read a lot more than I do, I was wondering if you knew anything further on the original turkish stones.

Re: Turkey Stones

#4

Re: Warren - turkey vs. turkish

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I think Roman historian Pliny (79 AD) mentions Turkey stones. Maybe Isidore mentions them in the 7th century. So the trade was going on for quite some time. Actually Pliny talks about oil stones "in ancient times".

Botanist Thomas Nuttall explored Arkansas 1818-1820. I don't think there are any buildings in Akansas that predate this time. He brought back Arkansas stone samples to Philadelphia. The Academy of Natural Sciences has his herbarium specimens and they probably still have his stones also. From Nuttall's journal remarks I don't think there was a whetstone industry in Arkansas in 1819.

Here is a list of American stones from an 1890 article:

https://www.motherearthnews.com/nature-and-environment/sandstone-novaculite-zmaz83mazraw

Re: Turkey Stones

#5

Re: Warren - turkey vs. turkish

David Weaver

Thanks, Warren. I'd heard that there was novaculite in other places, but never looked further to see where they were.