Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

LN 62 comparo in ribboned khaya

Posts

LN 62 comparo in ribboned khaya

#1

LN 62 comparo in ribboned khaya

David Weaver

I have a test piece of khaya (it'll be a guitar body at some point). blanks like this aren't always on ebay, but when they are and appropriate density, I get them (more often two piece flatsawn or one piece flatsawn - the ribboned blanks make a nicer looking guitar).

I think most people wouldn't be able to plane this without using a very steep plane - one ribbon goes one direction, the next goes another. I had trouble with this kind of stuff when I was a beginner, and working with a 60 degree angle or something on much of this from rough would be miserable. It can be done, but it's miserable.

A 55 degree flat edge will tear this out some in a heavy cut but clean it up in a fine cut. It's not quite as bad as the cocobolo blank that I showed, but the problem is different - the ribbons facing away will be fuzzy if you just choose to scrape or plane them with a really steep angle.

I came up with a freehand (but with an angle reference) hone of the iron with a diamond hone totaling about 50 degrees, and then a brisk buff on the yellowcake. I think this equates to about 50 degrees. The beauty of using the buffer for this instead of going to a guide is that it's a lot faster. My angle guides are just a triangular gap that I used to use to stuff an iron under while it resided on an eclipse guide. I don't use them (obviously), but you can stick an iron under one freehand and then lift a little and have a pretty reliable angle (but it can also be done well enough by eye). The importance is that the sharpening cycle time is cut and with a bevel up plane ,you'll be sharpening at least twice as often.

So, just as with 55 degrees, this yielded some fuzziness in the ribbons in a heavy cut, but a lighter pass (standard procedure) resulted in a really nice surface.

https://i.imgur.com/GmMpr0t.jpg

The last guitar I made of khaya had more interlocking and it took a little bit more in terms of smoothing passes to get all signs of tearout out. I started to think I might keep this plane and use it as a smoother on guitars.

What I learned is this - these planes do have a feel that make them not stay in the cut very well compared to a stanley - the urge is to get behind them and push them, but a better idea is to use the off hand and give more assistance on the front knob - they start the cut much better that way and the cut accuracy is far better than getting behind them. That is, it's more of a two handed affair and then you can take even shavings.

https://i.imgur.com/xoPqu2A.jpg

Just for comparison, I'd sharpened the trusty late stanley 4 with washita and linde A and then set the cap iron about twice as close as I would normally set it ( this is probably a setting of about 6 thousandths).

The stanley is much sweeter to use. The cut is more regulated and far more even feeling. BU planes have sort of this on and off again feel in a cut as long as the shaving has any strength (in figured wood - it reminds me of a push version of what it feels like to go fishing and pull a line in while fish are nibbling at the lure - you get a pattern of little tugs that make reeling in the line not feel totally smooth). Something about the cap iron makes the stanley plane cut far more evenly in the alternating ribbons, but you still have good feel (with the bronze LN 4, i can't feel much of what's going on even though it will produce the same result - it's arguably better with all of that weight in super hard woods that we don't use often).

https://i.imgur.com/ofjaLbj.jpg

https://i.imgur.com/McpYJAH.jpg

I don't have the camber honed into the LN yet, but I don't believe it left any significant tracks.

With the stanley, I'm more accustomed to honing the iron to finish smoothing camber, and the blank is completely mark free on the surface.

https://i.imgur.com/PB3MMv3.jpg

This could be finished as-is, even the opposing ribbons are smooth.

The pictures show the surface much closer than you can actually see it in person, so if they show no defects, then you will see none in person. How cleanly this is planed shouldn't bely how it can turn on you. I planed the board through and through, but with this plane setting, even something as simple as skewing the plane induces tearout (both planes) in the ribbons oriented facing toward you. Since the ribbons alternate one after the other and are close to each other, you can't just plane downhill everywhere and avoid controlling the tearout.

The conclusion - freehanding the irons is what I would do if I used this type of plane to avoid faffing with a guide and to have the hand control to apply camber more freely and quickly. It's doable. If an edge isn't steep enough, you can freehand it steeper next time or just buff the edge a little bit steeper. In an earlier trial, the edge honed at 45 degrees total bed+ bevel and then buffed heavily didn't match a 55 degree flat bevel on the block plane. It was remedied quickly by buffing a little bit more and a little bit steeper.

In a world where an LN 4 was considered ready to go and this is considered ready to go and a deep pocketed beginner asked which to get, I'd never recommend a BU plane, though. A beginner taught the cap iron right away (and the cap on LN planes modified with a front edge curve and then blued so that the set is easier to see) would master it faster and it just works better in the cut and has far wider range.

All that said, there is a quality to buffing the front edge with yellowcake that's a lot like chisels - with chisels, if you still get edge damage, buff a little more. With a BU plane, if you're not getting a clear surface, buff a little more and you can just hone a little steeper next time.

Re: LN 62 comparo in ribboned khaya

#2

Observation 2

David Weaver

The buck irons are soft (that's what's in the stanley). A soft iron is better for use with the buffer - for whatever reason, they are easier to get right with geometry and the sharpness seems smoother off of the buffer. No clue why. I did a video with the buffer and sharpened hard and soft irons, so it is, of course, not a problem to buff any of them to finish, but the cheap buck irons have come out as great users.

I had no issue planing cocobolo with them, either, nor bubinga. They will get dull faster than the latest wiz bang whatever, but the harder irons will sustain damage in the hardwoods, especially with silica, and it will become a challenge to stay ahead of that damage.

I'll be using these inexpensive irons for a while as I found no real shortcoming with them planing all of the bed parts (which was full of knots) and the pain in the rear of getting them to take a good edge on natural stones (they are cut too easily and the softness makes them retain a wire edge more than a harder "dryer" feeling iron) - that nuisance doesn't exist with the buffer.

Here's the most interesting part. In medium hardwoods and in cocobolo, the buck iron in a stanley plane will plane a greater volume of wood than the A2 iron in the bevel up plane, even when sharpened with the same abrasives.

I don't know if I could create a standardized test to show the shortened edge life of a 55 degree effective edge vs. a stanley plane with a 45 degree iron and cap iron set close, but it probably wouldn't be that hard. Standardized tests often don't do a good job of showing nuances in actual work, though, and in this case, the stanley plane stays regulated in the cut far better and that equates to it feeling the same for much longer on top of the nominal longer lasting edge without respect to feel (i.e., it's more better than just the extra volume planed).

The BU plane is a beginner's trap. I know from experience in the past that a lot of end grain work (from making kitchen cabinets) in the vise is done far better with a stanley 4 than a bu jack. The stanley is less sticky and gets through the cut with less resistance.

Re: LN 62 comparo in ribboned khaya

#3

Observation - Back Wear

David Weaver

I've looked at back wear under the microscope on the BU iron in cherry, cocobolo and khaya now. The microscope shows no appreciable back wear that isn't removed as part of normal honing (without spending gobs of time on the back of the iron or resorting to coarse abrasives or anything - just dursol or something similar does the job fine).

The act of fully refreshing the bevel side on the BU plane pretty much gets rid of any progressive back wear and I haven't seen anything in any of the three woods mentioned above that extends more than a couple of thousandths into the back of the iron (and that's before rehoning).

Thinking back to my own BU plane where I observed cosmetic scratches that only bothered me (cosmetic bother, not bother in use) after seeing that they existed, I don't know what they were - they could've been stray marks left from dirt on wood.

Having the chance to see the edge close up so that you see what counts and not just cosmetic things, I think what Larry concluded is incorrect (that back wear would be a progressive problem) and that people bringing him planes out of clearance probably weren't doing much sharpening, or were adding a back bevel trying to chase wear off of the edge either with a thick ruler, or by lifting an iron on purpose or not while honing.

There are no clearance issues with the plane as a matter of use and after several shaprenings, nothing progressive is appearing.

The danger of declaring shortcomings in planes that you're not familiar with (as the clearance war aggressors did - all commenting about planes brought to them that they'd never used much, so they had no clue what was causing the problems -and then some of the clearance war soldiers were just repeating incorrect information rather than first hand information) is that you risk telling people that user-created problems (which you remember more clearly than planes that work just fine, so you get a skewed view) are plane design problems.

If a ham handed user lifted a plane blade a couple of strokes on a sharpening stone or bumbled one around into the same effect, then it would be pretty easy to make this type of plane run out of clearance - but lifting too high on the bevel side of a common pitch plane would cause the same. Lifting too high on a 55 degree single iron plane would just drastically shorten the interval until the next sharpening.

Re: LN 62 comparo in ribboned khaya

#4

Back wear - bevel-up vs bevel-down

Winston

I don't know what the "clearance wars" were, but it sounds like people were arguing that bevel-up planes have more wear on the back of the blade, and that this would cause clearance problems? I agree with you, David, that the wear on the back of a bevel-up blade is insignificant and is easily honed off during sharpening.

From the close-up images I've taken, it's clear that there's more wear on upper side of a plane blade than ton the lower side.

This is what the back of blade looks like after sharpening (Sigma 6000):


With a bevel-up plane, this is what it looks like after doing a significant amount of planing.


And with a bevel-down plane, this is what the back of the blade looks like after use:


Note that these blades were used in differently -- the bevel-up blade did more planing, but was also a more durable steel. Still, the difference is obvious.

For the bevel-up plane, the back wear is insignificant compared to the bevel-down plane, and I'm pretty sure that sharpening the bevel side will completely remove it. Now, these photos don't show the depth of the wear, but in the case of the bevel-down plane, it's worn enough that the horizontal scratches from the stone are gone -- it looks dark because the scratches are no longer there to reflect light.

The profile pictures from Steve Elliot's site show that at first, there's more wear on the upper side of the blade, but if you keep going and keep using the blade past the point where it's difficult to use, then it will develop significant wear on the bottom side.

https://bladetest.infillplane.com/html/wear_profiles.html

Re: LN 62 comparo in ribboned khaya

#5

clearance wars...

David Weaver

..an internet argument where one side concluded that only a high angle single iron plane or 20 degree bed or more bevel up plane would have adequate clearance to shear wood. Anything else would have clearance issues limiting performance or burnishing wood.

The second part of this that goes with the first is that common pitch planes and bevel up low angle planes couldn't maintain clearance to work properly and that progressive issues (or user added back bevels) with an ever growing wear bevel on low angle planes would render them unusable quickly.

Despite some folks having some around and using them a fair amount.

I guess the BD factor for common pitch planes wasn't considered to be as bad because the wear is removed when the bevel is honed.

The back and forth about this went on for years, and some of the assertions made by the anti-BU planes showed lack knowledge (including things like asserting that the ruler trick adds 5 degrees to any bevel - it's more like a fraction of a degree). Not sure if someone mentioned that they added 5 degrees on purpose, but the "trick" was demonstrated by charlesworth and then others with a half mm rule.

I believe the assertion that less than 20 degrees wasn't workable was because you could dull a plane on maple and then it wouldn't cut on softwoods (which is missing a step - if a plane is cutting on maple and wearing, you can advance the iron a little bit and it will still cut on pine).

Re: LN 62 comparo in ribboned khaya

#6

rewording

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

When BU and BD are mixed in a discussion it becomes hard to follow what side of what blade we are talking about. Throw the word "back" into the discussion and it becomes more difficult(for me).

Are you showing that the side of the blade the shaving slides up wears the greatest in both cases? We have shaving abrading the shaving side of the blade and the blade rubbing across the wood on the other side. Which situation is most abrasive and is it the same or different for BU, BD? Or did I miss the point entirely?

Re: LN 62 comparo in ribboned khaya

#7

Re: rewording

Winston

Sorry, here's a clarification.

Upper side: The side of the blade that the shaving passes over. It's "up" when in the plane.

Lower side: The side of the blade that is facing down when in the plane.

So, on a bevel-down plane:

upper side = back

lower side = bevel

And on a bevel-up plane:

upper side = bevel

lower side = back

I think the upper side has more wear, regardless of BU or BD plane.

I showed only the back of a BU and BD blade in those pictures. (I implicitly assumed that the wear of the upper and lower sides of the blade will be similar for both types of planes.)

******

With my microscope equipment, it's hard to directly compare the wear of the upper side of the blade for BU and BD planes. In other words, it's hard to directly compare the wear on the bevel side and back side of a blade. This is because I can't light them in the same way.

When I look at bevel side of a blade, the surface tilted 25-30 degrees from perpendicular. In the bevel side case, I can position the light so that light reflects directly off of it and right up into the lens. (Not that I generally position the light that way for pictures, but this just illustrates one thing I can do.)

When I look at the back of a blade, the surface is perpendicular to the direction of view of the scope. It's not possible in this case to hold the light in a place where light will reflect right up into the lens -- not even close. The light is way too big to position it close to the lens axis.

Here's an example of why this matters. When I took pictures of the bevel-side (upper side) wear on a BU plane blade, it had a texture and I wondered where it came from:


Presumably, a BD blade has a similar texture on the back (its upper side). But I can't light the blade in a way that shows it -- with the blade in the scope, I can only hold the light off to the side. So this is what it looks like:


They probably have the same kind of wear, but I can't look at them in the same way with the microscope.

Re: LN 62 comparo in ribboned khaya

#8

thanks for clarification

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I have been recording 3 Stooges shows (maybe too old for you?). What's up, back? not down....etc. Upon first read it sounded like a 3 Stooges routine (with me as the 3 Stooges)

Interesting observation even without the electron microscope (private humor relating to heap of ignorance on FWW forum)

But I get it now.