Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Which view tool?

Posts

Which view tool?

#1

Which view tool?

Eric Rathhaus

I'm wondering what type of microscope you all have been using to examine the edge of your tools. A stereo microscope or a compound microscope, or ?

Re: Which view tool?

#2

Re: Which view tool?

Winston

I'm using an inexpensive microscope from AmScope:

https://www.amazon.com/AmScope-M150C-PS25-Magnification-Illumination-Brightfield/dp/B00A6LY5JA

The light is also important. I'm using a small handheld camping lantern, which provides a diffuse light source. I hold it in my hand and move it around to find the best lighting for pictures.

This is what the setup looks like:


Re: Which view tool?

#3

I'll defer to winston..

David Weaver

I have a metallurgical scope (the current cost would be about $550 or so) with camera. It's great for flat things, but less so for other things.

I also have hand held scopes ($<20) that are fine for inspecting edges when hooked to the laptop, but they are low resolution, low clarity, and as winston mentions, the lighting isn't really good enough for anything other than perfect situations - the scopes and their software don't do nearly as good of a job as a digital camera (like winston's setup) in determining what light is important and what's not, so any significant variance (and there will be a lot on a curved surface) is seen as a washed out bright spot and not much else.

A dissection scope (which is also top view rather than through the bottom view like a biological scope) could also be a decent idea if an eyepiece camera with enough resolution is available. The software glare limitation in expensive cell phones is really useful, though.

The cost of a replacement camera for my scope (the one it came with doesn't work with win 10) was $185, and that was one of the cheaper ones.

Winston's setup works pretty easily, too - holding a hand held scope can be a bit of a trick sometimes and after a minute or two with no decent pictures, time's up for me. The reason I post so many pictures with the metallurgical scope is just because it's really easy to use on flat things.

Re: Which view tool?

#4

Re: Which view tool?

Don Emmerling

What do you use to hold the iphone?

Re: Which view tool?

#6

lighting

Eric Rathhaus

Winston - Does your microscope only have lighting beneath the stage, which is why you use the camping lantern? Some of the stereoscopes have lighting from above as well. I've read that stereoscopes are better for solid objects like rocks, electronics, etc, but the magnification difference (and price) between a stereo and compound is dramatic. 80X is the most you can get with a stereoscope in the lower price ranges. Could you use your mobile phone as the view finder too?

Re: Which view tool?

#7

Re: lighting

Winston

Right, it only has the light under the stage. I don't know anything about the lighting that comes with stereoscopes, but I can say from experience that, because blades are very reflective, it's very useful to be able to move the light around to just the right position to get a good picture. If you had a microscope with lighting from above, I suppose that wouldn't prevent you from using a separate light if you wanted.

When I'm set up to take pictures with the microscope I do use my phone as the viewfinder.

Re: Which view tool?

#8

Re: lighting

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Winston gets pictures near as good as I did on a Nikon $30,000 scope built for metal work. He gets better pictures than on a Nikon $30,000 scope not built for metal work. Do what he does. Lighting is everything.

Re: Which view tool?

#9

Re: lighting

Eric Rathhaus

I'm not intending to take pictures as much as wanting to view the metal as I move thru my work on the metal.

Re: Which view tool?

#10

lighting is not about pictures

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Don't confuse the lighting discussion to think that lighting is only important if you are taking pictures. There is something about reflected light from a metal surface that makes observing/imaging it difficult. By diddling with his light source Winston is getting better observation of the metal surface than I was getting with all the lighting options that come on a Nikon general purpose biological scope. The metallurgical scope I used has some special kind of lighting that made observing, or imaging, the surface of metal more accurate.

Re: Which view tool?

#11

top lighting

David Weaver

It won't be news to you, but it may be helpful for other people - metallurgical scopes usually have a shallow depth of field and are top lit with a separate light control as well as a shutter. Even my relatively cheap scope (about $500 now? guessing, it was $425 several years ago) has a separate halogen light source, and then ability to choose between camera or eyepiece for light priority and the shutter can vary the light effect (on top of the dimmable control on the light source itself).

What would really make the whole thing work would be software and electrical control to take pictures in layers and then put together a 3d image. I'm sure that exists, but at what cost, I have no clue.

For the cheaper hobby scopes and hand held scopes, top lighting is available (the hand scopes are top light just because there's nowhere else to put the lights on them other than to arrange LEDs around the lens), so they end up being a good option to view things without any other light - the software for them is real time so you can view what you're looking at on your screen without needing a third hand to snap a picture (one hand holding the item firm, the other holding the hand scope).

Take pictures complicates a lot more. I got my hand scope working again yesterday, but it's older - it claimed to be 600x, but it's probably 50-60 and the resolution is 640x480 - it's plenty good to identify sharpening problems. zooming in to even something like 150x makes the pictures worthless, though.

Not sure about bio scopes other than dissection scopes (those are usually something like 10-25x, good depth of field compared to metallurgical scopes and lighting is less concentrated). but a phone or eyepiece camera would have to have supplemental magnification to see the very edge - they are good as is to find out which stones actually provide a true polish. A simple dissection scope exposed my $400 japanese stone from hida tool as not being that fine compared to the folklore on the internet at the time that all japanese finishers were much finer than synthetics. It was more like a 6-8k synthetic equivalent.

My point that I'm slowly getting to is the light has to be OK for viewing, you can move objects around, object holding around and see what you need to see. To hold it in place, not bump it and get a picture that looks good at high resolution is a much taller order.

Re: Which view tool?

#12

Moving the light source around

Steve Elliott

When examining blades under a microscope, lighting can be tweaked to make the blade surface look good or to reveal as many scratches and defects as possible.

If the scratches from sharpening are perpendicular to the cutting edge, light from the side of the blade makes the scratches show up. If the same lighting is used on a blade that has been side sharpened (scratches parallel to the cutting edge) the scratches hardly show and the surface of the metal seems more highly polished even though it isn't.

My goal was to reveal as much of the surface texture as possible even if my sharpening results didn't look as good as some of images I found online.

Metallurgical microscopes have a light source that shines down along the optical path of the lens. That's a good way to illuminate shiny surfaces, as I found out when I did some over-the-top honing using fine diamond on a boxwood lap. The scratch pattern disappeared completely and my images showed the blade surface as black. None of the light had been scattered by scratches into the microscope lens. Maybe a physicist could say what level of surface refinement that would indicate based on the wavelength of the light source. David's microscope uses optical path lighting and I imagine his highly polished blades would also show no scratches under Winston's microscope.

Re: Which view tool?

#13

Re: Moving the light source around

Eric Rathhaus

Steve, that was my experience with the scope I'm returning. It's a stereoscope with 40X max magnification but no light source. I held my camping headlight for light and the variation of image depending on locations and angle of the light was dramatic. I just bought a better stereo scope that has an LED light source from above.