Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

plane stiffness

Posts

plane stiffness

#1

plane stiffness

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Objective: Determine how much force is required to flex a plane 0.0015"

Experimental: Planes are a Bedrock 505 and a Stanley #7. Two 90 pound rail sections, dial indicator and assortment of 2.5 and 5 pound lead bars. Plane is bridged between the rails. Lead weight added above mouth. Flex measured by dial indicator.



Results and discussion: Assume all the flex is from the plane and none from 90# rail sections. It took 7 pounds of force to flex the #7 0.0015" and 5# to flex the 605 this amount. Error bars estimated to be +/- 1 pound.

Conclusions: none. I don' t know enough about how people plane to know how much weight they apply and more important I don't know how much force is applied by the blade sucking the plane bottom to the board. From Kato's work this value would be 1 to 3 pounds for a 1" wide shaving.

Re: plane stiffness

#2

Re: plane stiffness

David Weaver

practical test. Measure how convex or concave that plane is. Attempt to plane shavings that would compound to the error measurement.

For example, if it's exactly level, plane 4 thousandths hollow with it easily on two joints, though shavings and then put both boards together and show a gap of nearly a hundredth. If the board is twice as long, plane the board 1.5 to 2 hundredth.

This is the same thing as just achieving level with a plane that's two thousandths hollow over a 12 inch interval.

This discussion annoys me because I've been presented with it twice before this last round, and never has it made one of my hollow planes usable to make a flat board that's not even sprung.

I have an exactly level LN 62 now. I will take that cherry board iwth a 2 thousandth shaving and see how hollow I can plane it with the plane level (this doesn't address the fact that you can't flex the plane as it's going off the end of the board, precisely where the biggest problem will be).

Re: plane stiffness

#3

Re: plane stiffness

David Weaver

by the way, the weights need to be hung where the two handles are - two separate sets. you're not going to be able to plane with your hand on the frog.

The amount of supplemental downforce that we generate when we're planing a smoother shaving is probably about 3 pounds, maybe 4. When I created a static board to push into and put a 35 pound postal scale under the mouth of the plane, it was pretty hard to generate more than about 12 pounds of downforce at the mouth by pushing on the back handle. The front handle won't provide much assistance in flexing the plane, and when you bear down on it going through the end of an edge, you'll plane the end off of a board (the opposite of what you want to do).

Re: plane stiffness

#4

testing a level plane...

David Weaver

...I can plane a 28" cherry board 5 thousandths hollow with a 2 thousandth shaving (that's after the first continuous shaving that follows stop shavings).

3 thousandths hollow with a 1 thousandth shaving. That's just planing stop shavings and not adjusting for lateral (which will move the hollow back toward the bias of the plane).

There is no tendency of a flat plane to go over the edges one way or another so this is probably more "gameable" than planing with a concave plane sole.

The tips of my plane are a little proud so it may have a slight bias toward hollowing a board, but not much.

I have more skill planing than most people, feeling for hollow, planing hollow, taking a minimum number of shavings after planing hollow to get continuous. It seems like the amount of hollow corresponds fairly closely to the cut depth (two thousandth is almost double one in terms of how hollow the board is).

If I go with this method and have a plane that's about as hollow as the error that I'm showing, then I'm at zero if I'm lucky with no wiggle room. Anything less than perfection or any subsequent adjustment to square and I have convex ends. Everything that gets smoothed, same thing, it will have a hump in the middle. It's intolerable.

Re: plane stiffness

#5

Re: testing a level plane...

Wiley Horne

David,

Agree with all that and your previous as well.

One other thing about trying to edge join with a concave plane...when the blade is cantilevered out, in order to reach beyond the hollow to get to the wood, weird things begin to happen—it’s in the cut, now it’s out of the cut. And when it comes out it tends to bring a torn shaving with it. And one thing you can’t have in a joined panel is tearout at an edge—it will be right on the seam, where the grain pattern changes and jumps out at you.

I have respect for Bill’s argument as well, but there are some differences when you move to hand planes. Machines can sometimes power through the details—like a dull blade, say—but with hand tools there are certain details that will make the tool just about unusable and mouth-in-the-air is one of them.

Wiley

Re: plane stiffness

#6

Re: What's the big deal…

Steve Voigt

…about a little hollow? It only takes about a minute to flatten the sole of a pla--

Oh. You guys are talking about *those* planes. Sorry.

:D ;)

Re: plane stiffness

#7

Question

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I am struggling with whether LN is selling planes whose specification make it risky to purchase a plane from them because at the limit you are claiming the plane will not work to joint an edge, and who knows what else. But on to the question....

If the plane is concave by the limit of their spec , 0.0015, and the blade is set for a 0.002" shaving, which seems a reasonable shaving thickness if the objective is to level an edge, will the plane take a shaving of some thickness the full length of a 3' long board? The question begs a simple yes, no answer.

Another question, has anyone looked at a feeler gauge and seen what 0.0015" looks like. No response desired to this one.

Re: plane stiffness

#8

Been there and done that

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Made a Krenov style plane when that was popular. I think one of them had cramps. I don't know if it ever stopped humping but I quit dealing with it every few weeks/months. I do understand that some amount a hump is intolerable.....and I was a lot more successful flattening wood that cast iron.

Re: plane stiffness

#9

Re: Question

David Weaver

If a board is flat, it will not take an equal thickness shaving on the first pass. It'll take full thickness at the end of the board and at the beginning. After a few passes, it'll take an equal thickness pass on edges. On board faces, it becomes more of a pain because there's lateral parts that are still flat as you're trimming edges off so you have to go across the board trimming edges off. If your jointer isn't convex and you've planed boards slightly hollow with it as part of dimensioning, the problem is magnified.

I literally put a .015" feeler under this plane - it's a tiny amount. A fraction of a sheet of paper which is what makes it annoying that such a small amount in one direction can cause problems and a larger amount in the other doesn't.

I think most people who buy LN planes joint their boards on a power jointer. So do most people buying vintage stanley planes for that matter.

If someone is buying a plane like this to use in a shooting board, I can't think that they'd care too much about the concavity. LN is making planes to a very fine spec - if some of them are less good to use than others right out of the box, that's life - it's still a factory made tool made to a high standard that nobody else seems to be able to compete with (stanley types). Clifton couldn't come close and some of their planes were several times more hollow than this.

Re: plane stiffness

#10

Re: Question

Wiley Horne

The plane will make an uncertain start, taking between a 2 thou and a half-thou (5 tenths) shaving, depending on exactly how the user enters thencut. At the far end, same thing—depends on how the user is biasing the hand-pressure. In the middle, it will almost certainly not stay in the cut, because you're trying to take a 5-tenths shaving, and almost anything will interrupt the cut—depends on how the grain lays and whether the board is flat tomwithin 5-tenths, etc.

The user could then project the blade more, trying to fix what’s wrong, and then get a heavy cut on the ends and—maybe—a thinner cut in the middle, if he holds his mouth right. Or else the iron will dig in and then tear out, depending on the lay of the land.

Wiley

Re: plane stiffness

#11

Not to pick nits, but

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Bill said .0015, not .015.

Re: plane stiffness

#12

Re: Not to pick nits, but

David Weaver

That's my mistake, .0015" is what I meant as that's how far out this bu plane is.

Re: plane stiffness

#13

Re: Question

Orlando in So. Fl.

Wiley, I understand what you're saying and agree but the math threw me for a loop.

2-thou = .002

1-thou = .001

half a thou = .0005

5-tenths = .5 or 1/2"

Did you mean the .0005 which is very thin or the thicker .5 (5 tenths)

Re: plane stiffness

#14

5 tenths=5 ten-thousandths=0.0005”


Re: plane stiffness

#15

Re: Question

Warren in Lancaster, PA

A cut of .002 would be too thick for a jointer. Something like .0005 to .001 is more reasonable because it is easier to take off stuff right where you want it. I go for no light showing and no rocking. A bright teenager can learn to do this in a few weeks.

A joint made with a plane is much less visible than one made with machines. Of coarse if you have poorly matched pieces glued together, It does not matter how good the joint itself looks.

One test one can do to see the effect of concavity is to skew the plane on the edge of a board so that the two ends of the plane are not resting on the board at all. If it cuts with the plane skewed and not with the plane straight, there is more concavity than you want. A plane with .0015 concavity is not suitable for a jointer.

David Charlesworth once claimed on this site that if one had a board with a flat edge and then took five or ten full length passes the edge would become convex., and more shavings would make it worse. I could not imagine this being the case, so after planing an edge true, I took 100 shavings after which it was still flat. Today I was wondering if maybe he had a concave plane.

Re: plane stiffness

#16

Re: Skew the plane

Mike In Los Angeles

That is actual genius, like all genius it’s obvious but I would never have thought of it. If there was a book with that information in it, I would pay to have it.

Thanks!!

Re: plane stiffness

#17

Re: Question

David Weaver

>>David Charlesworth once claimed on this site that if one had a board with a flat edge and then took five or ten full length passes the edge would become convex., and more shavings would make it worse. I could not imagine this being the case, so after planing an edge true, I took 100 shavings after which it was still flat. Today I was wondering if maybe he had a concave plane.<<

Same experience. I described setting up the plane and what one does to plane a through shaving (i'm sure you can do it, too, but I can plane a board hollow with through shavings). David didn't find it believable, so I did it twice in a row in a video - using the starrett edge to show a board being planed hollow with through shavings.

I'll give david credit after I showed him the video, he revised his thoughts somewhat.

I don't doubt that most beginners do it, which makes the idea of a hollow jointer even worse.

Re: plane stiffness

#18

Re: plane stiffness

Bruce Mack

Bill - Last night I was sitting in my basement shop with a couple of cats (no, I'm not a productive woodworker) thinking of how little force it took you to deform a cast iron plane. I took 2 narrow pieces of cherry I use to check blade sharpness and placed their edges together. I could see light. Then, I pressed them together with my thumbs and forefingers. No light.

I remember the 1990's when I was building furniture for the home with a circular saw, Japanese pull saw, and a handplane, amazed at the concept of edge-gluing narrow boards to make a tabletop. I used the match edge method, taking thin shavings to try to eliminate the light leaks I could see while resting the edge of one board on another. Then, using pipe clamps and PVA glue and a mallet to persuade bowed boards to flatten, I made my first tabletop. The final flattening was awkward, crappy planing technique with a jack plane whose blade I could not sharpen adequately followed by belt sanding to remove the tear-out. The top of this credenza which I still have looks pretty good to me, with acceptable if not invisible glue lines.

My point - wood is forgiving and to me, then and now, my concern is does it look good rather than is it perfect. This is simply my musing and is not meant to disparage the better skills of many participating in this forum or to detract from this fascinating discussion of sharpness and tooling in which I have participated.

Re: plane stiffness

#19

Re: wood stiffness

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Then, I pressed them together with my thumbs and forefingers. No light.

If skilled with planing perfect edges can be created (not by me). With a power jointer they sometimes can be created. You soon learn what you can live with if you make many panels.

Could someone tell a panel I made on a jointer vs perfectly hand planed? No. Unlike my pedestrian dovetails I take a great deal of pride in my panels. The joints are perfect and the grain matches are attractive as the lumber available will allow (and I have hundreds of bdft to choose from). In both cases the glue would be squeezed out and the joint would be wood to wood with no glue line visible in between.

Could jointer edged lumber be successfully glued with hide rub joints. Maybe but not by me. There is a reason I own 48 panel clamps .

Re: plane stiffness

#20

i'm sure...

David Weaver

on an ideally set power jointer, you could get a rub joint. My mechanical engineer friend has gone to enormous pains to set his tools up (to the point of it being unproductive) and I don't ever remember seeing any part of an open joint coming off of his jointer. He was obsessed with the cast fence that delta made (I think it was a DJ-20 because the fence had twisted to a tiny minimal amount so a starrett certified square would find no light at one end and a tiny small amount at the other).

The point with the hand tooling bits here is that rub joint quality joints can literally be gotten during the normal mode of just planing the rough edge off. If they aren't gotten right away, it's a very short period of time before truing achieves them (less time than most hand jointing or match planing methods would take just to go through the steps once).

There's a link you're missing here, too, as you're comparing power tool joints to hand tool joints. Let's say you have one of these concave planes - the length of the curvature may be over 14 inches or something. Your jointer tables are probably 30-40 inches. Whatever error you have will be spread out gradually over a distance. The plane will generate its flatness error on the edges in the distance from the start of the hollow to the mouth. That's something like 1 1/2 thosuandths over 3 inches. Even if the rest of the joint is mostly flat, you have a gap at the end that's steep and short. It's not like pulling together a gradual error on a power tool joint (as in, you can't actually do it by hand and sometimes it's hard to even get it to clamp shut)

What you're thinking for power tools isn't the same. You can reason through all kinds of scenarios, but until you experience the issue with a hand tool and account for all of the things like what I just mentioned above (the whole error occurs just in a couple of inches on the end of a board - I just realized that - it's not the length of the error that's the issue - it's the length of the distance from the toe to the mouth), it won't make sense to you.

Same error, as we've discussed, in the opposite direction (Convex sole), and the plane creates a long gradual hollow at the most. You can just pull it shut, just like a power tool joint.