Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Why certain sole profiles are important...

Posts

Why certain sole profiles are important...

#1

Why certain sole profiles are important...

David Weaver

Bill mentioned below that looking at these things comes across as making things hard. That's actually the opposite of being correct. If one comes across as many planes as I have, I would speculate they'l find some reasonable fraction of planes usable - smoothers and jack planes maybe a higher percentage than jointers. More than half of the jointers that aren't heavily worn will be somewhere around flat, and the rest of the fraction will have varying levels of low toe. I've seen (only once or twice in may be 25 metal jointers) very low toes nearing a hundredth. I'm guessing this is due to movement of castings (when it happens, I don't know, but certainly after grinding - presumably the castings season themselves in a short period of time and then stop - I've never lapped a plane and then had to correct it years later, not even infills).

If someone doesn't want to identify and define what problems are, that's fine. It's easy, just get a different plane, it's not mandatory to fix a plane that doesn't work well, nor is it that big of a deal to buy a couple of stanley planes (when materials for this hobby cost a mint, and they're never to be recovered again in value).

After flattening the #62 to dead nuts flat, and planing the edge of a board to get thin shavings, this is what the edge of the board looks like. This is just normal planing, planing through shavings (where I would normally get a slightly hollow edge - I can't actually tell if it's dead flat or a tiny tiny fraction hollow).

https://i.imgur.com/8kmf7vu.jpg

I didn't check this joint and replane or anything to get this, it's just what the plane does (ignore the oxidation on the left side of the straight edge, there's no gap).

Twist and concavity are the only real fatal flaws in planes - severe anything can be a problem. I've had exactly one modern stanley jointer that had little wear and had a significant amount of twist. I don't think it's worth worrying about. If in my giant sample size, I've seen one, then no big deal.

What makes hand tool woodworking easy is actually doing the right things to make it easy, and casting off (or fixing) tools that don't so that someone doesn't run around forums making it out like dogmatic routines have to be followed (e.g., spending 10 minutes with a table sawn board just to get a single edge joint, or dictating that the joint can't be had without match planing or fixtures - it's just not true).

When I post things that I've measured (not to measure, but due to problems) and give a heads up to what the issue may be, I'm not real jazzed about disproving suppositions - it's a waste of everyones' time and it confuses things even further. I'd be glad to address proof - in this case, "proof" could be gained only with an inaccurate straight edge. Testing what I say isn't hard - find a plane that's hollow in its length and try to make a rub joint or sprung joint. You can't do it. If you manage to bull or stand on a plane to get it to make one joint, then consider doing 20 on something important. The stuff about putting a plane on two boards and standing on it and getting it to bend more than a couple of thousandths is fine and good, but it's got nothing to do with using the plane.

Interestingly enough, the two planes that I found with bad problems - twist without much wear, and really low toe and high mouth - neither had much use. I wouldn't be surprised if they had little use because they were confusing to a user.

The millers falls jointer that I showed in a video on youtube (the seasick video) also had very little use, only a couple of thousandths hollow. I'm guessing lack of use is due to lack of success using. I've never had a significantly hollow plane with a lot of wear on it (a couple of thousandths hollow more more in shape of the plane (not mouth erosion, etc).

Re: Why certain sole profiles are important...

#2

Yep.  "Closet horns" are like that

Jim Matthews

"Interestingly enough, the two planes that I found with bad problems - twist without much wear, and really low toe and high mouth - neither had much use. I wouldn't be surprised if they had little use because they were confusing to a user."

Young sax players fall into the predictable trap of pursuing vintage horn, as if there's some magic baked into the ancient lacquer. Bright and shiny horns over 75 years old stayed that way because they dint git played.

RatRods parallel this - they look that way because they were driven daily.

Re: Why certain sole profiles are important...

#3

I double dog dare you...

Jim Matthews

Put shaving "streamers" on your bike handlebars.

SWMBO would just *love" that.

Re: Why certain sole profiles are important...

#4

pretty vintage les pauls...

David Weaver

oh boy, I remember as a youth, the mark VI was already out of production and before the internet could sort you out and let you know that there were other equally good saxophones, anyone walking around with one was considered to be a meistro. Our first chair was serious, and his parents got him one without lacquer- I don't know if it was removed. It looked almost brown. Sounded great, but with a decent mouthpiece, he could've made an intermediate japanese sax sound great.

I see parallels in vintage japanse high dollar guitars and vintage american high dollar guitars. Anything that looks great is usually refinished. If it's not, there's usually a structural problem.

A savvy dealer calls a structural problem (that would be value killing if fixed) "personality". Based on what I've heard of most well regarded vintage dealers (high regard is usually curated from famous customers and by selective testimonials), I haven't yet found one where someone has provable misdealings from the "well-regarded dealers" (usually repair or fixing of certain things, and then refinish to try to cover it up and then no disclosure of things like planed fingerboards, past internal repair history, etc).

"oops!! we can't catch everything!"

Internet forums with well heeled buyers kind of exposed all of those dealers. I don't think it's possible for anyone honest to run a brick and mortar business selling vintage guitars.

(just checked the Mark VI stuff on ebay -they're up some, but less than I'd have expected. The YAS-82s are up more than I'd have expected!! Metal instruments wear out. If I ever won the lottery and wanted to relive my youth, I think I'd buy a new one. More fake instruments made now that we ever had to think about 30 years ago. More modified and faked vintage guitars, too).

Re: Why certain sole profiles are important...

#5

Separate Planets

David Weaver

My spouse spends about 15 or 20 hours a week cleaning various things (upstairs).

The basement and garage are my domain, and they are a mess (something I don't hide). I don't touch much up in the "regular parts of the house". It's not a safe thing for me to do.

She has a healthy distaste for anything that looks like a byproduct of woodworking, but the kids themselves love the shavings. the LOVE the long flat shaving that come out of the try plane and that are longer than they are tall. Once in a while, they go up the steps with a couple of them only to return in very short order and throw them on the shop floor.

We're on separate planets in this house. I always wonder what it's like for other folks. The mess, I could do something about (but I don't). The hobby itself would still be discouraged.

Re: Why certain sole profiles are important...

#6

Re: Separate Planets

Orlando in So. Fl.

I'm banished to the shed workshop outside the house. We don't have basements in Florida because we would need scuba gear to be in them. :D

My wife, son, and daughter all have a severe aversion to woodworking, or for that case, manual labor. Wife doesn't have a voice in what I buy, she just leaves it alone.

Re: Why certain sole profiles are important...

#7

Since the Mauriat horns came out

Jim Matthews

It's pretty clear that Taiwanese and Mainland Chinese factories can build modern horns that play as well as the best vintage ones, within a realistic budget.

I go for overlooked brands, in Silver plate.

Re: Why certain sole profiles are important...

#8

She's a keeper

Jim Matthews

"Wife doesn't have a voice in what I buy, she just leaves it alone."

You only need worry if your life insurance coverage dramatically increases before a Sea Cruise. Husbands of a certain age should avoid aft railings, after dark.

Re: Why certain sole profiles are important...

#9

already playing too little guitar...

David Weaver

..and being wary of getting a saxophone and feeling like "nah" after a month...

...tell me more about these taiwanese horns. Or so as not to tax your time, where to read about them?

I'm interested in an $800 kind of horn that comes close to a used YAS-82 that would be more like $2500 from japan (and more here, plus tax, etc).

Re: Why certain sole profiles are important...

#10

Touring pros and choices

Jim Matthews

When I was actively playing (more than a decade ago) I played the P. Mauriat Alto.

They only had one model at the time.

Nice action, a little heavy and crystal clear in the higher range I can reach.

https://www.musiciansfriend.com/saxophones/p.-mauriat

If you would consider secondhand I recommend Bill Cole.

His set up is impeccable and he's honest.

No idea what he has in his stash.

(I'm about to paw through mine.)

Re: Why certain sole profiles are important...

#11

Thanks...

David Weaver

i went out and looked at the P. Mauriat stuff and fortunately it's high enough that I won't make an impulse buy.

I"ll sit on the idea for a while and see if it passes...a novel idea that I haven't employed much in the past.

Fun thing about guitars is that you can get about $400 of materials at least for some types of guitars and make a guitar that jingles and plays like a world class instrument. Saxophones don't have the tinkering lure, and that's strong with guitars.