Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

TL DR of the LN 62 from lunch

Posts

TL DR of the LN 62 from lunch

#1

TL DR of the LN 62 from lunch

David Weaver

It works about the same as the block plane (but with the comfort of a bench plane). I won't go into the nits about the adjustments or the feel of the plane - someone can get used to those if they like the plane that much (it won't be a keeper for me).

Now that it's flat, it makes an edge flat to ever so slightly hollow without having to use a straight edge to check that it's flat.

Set at 57 degrees plus heavy unicorn buff and dursol back side, it works about like the block plane did at 62 and 55+buff (you can induce tearout at extremely heavy shaving depth - like 5 thousandth in cocobolo). 5 thousandth shaving is a little bit easier than the stanley 4, but could be due to the plane being bigger and the fact that I had the cap iron shut way down. The stanley 4 left no tearout at 5 thousandth, the 62 left some (as did the block plane set with a 62 degree flat bevel).

I tried a stanley 5 to follow up to that and it was similar effort to the LN 62 in like shavings. There's a reversal, though - with thin shavings, the 62 controls tearout well. The stanley as I set it is able to go to 5 thousandth and control tearout well. The closer it is to its magic cut depth, the better it does with uniformity.

There's a strange sensation with the 62 that it needs to be in front of you more, it picks the shaving up less easily (this may be partly responsible) at the near end of the board (possibly due to the effective angle around 60-65), it lasts less long before it's unreliable starting the shaving and the A2 iron in cocobolo has what looks like tiny chipping and deflection along the edge, even with the super high effective angle. The chipping is like wear from underneath and the edge line remains clean. This could occur on the bevel side of BD planes and I wouldn't see it because I see the back of the iron. Larry's "long wear" doesn't appear in this test, it's abrupt at the tip.

The handle is more upright than a stanley handle which may also create some of the problem in picking up a near shaving.

Given how fast it refuses to pick up a shaving at the near end of a board, and how long it will take someone without a grinder to refresh the bevel side of a chisel, and the slow depth adjuster with poor lateral adjustment, it's a strange choice for a beginner's plane.

Size is too small to be effective shooting except for tiny items.

It is LN, though, and saying all of that, it's solid and feels solid and smooth. It's relatively easy as a smoother through the really dense cocobolo.

Re: TL DR of the LN 62 from lunch

#2

Thinking a little further on the cause...

David Weaver

..of the plane not entering the cut that easily and being confused as the mouth is actually further back (my habit is to start the cut planing at the beginning of the stroke, or with my hands back, and then push forward - as I think would've been typical until modern times).

I haven't ground the steep bevel off of the plane yet, but expect to find that may have been due to the blunt (around 60-65 degrees effective) total angle at the initiation of the cut.

not starting the cut cleanly may not be a big deal to some (turn the board around and plane off that direction a couple of times), but it's necessary for efficient planing, especially if planing to a mark.

Re: TL DR of the LN 62 from lunch

#3

The strange wear..

David Weaver

..this is the back of the blade, which is doing the same work as the bevel side on the BD planes.

We don't have pictures of the bevel side from me as I don't have a working hand held scope right now.

Note that in this case, the wear on the flat (down) side of the blade, A2 iron, cocobolo, and very steep effective angle - that wear is very short. See the black line? I've never seen anything like that before and wonder if the shape is different because the angle is blunt to start. This plane worked comfortably given its type, but did seem to get dull and unwilling to star the cut easily pretty early (no cap iron to start a cut and keep the plane in the cut, and lower pitch to go along with the cap).

I expect this will look different with a more acute angle and wood with more spring back. No sign of additional wear. This line is well less than a thousandth, I'd guess. height of the pictures is about 0.02" for scale (top to bottom).


Re: TL DR of the LN 62 from lunch

#4

A2 and Washita hate each other

David Weaver

I finished this iron from the factory with a washita. I can feel something funny happening, but the washita removed the LN mill marks at the edge within a few minutes (one of its specialties is fast cutting on uneven surfaces, then slow on polished).

None of the texture left in this iron is an artifact of LN's treatment (the mill marks were perpendicular to the edge, deep and consistent). Well, relatively deep to this, not deep compared to cheap tools.

The washita leaves removed areas of something or other all over the iron, and then at the edge of this iron, there's no smoothness. the line of the iron looks straight, the plane will cut, but there's little voids like the one in the middle of the circle all over the place. I haven't seen this with anything else but A2. I see it consistently with A2, though - the plane will cut, but it's gritty half dull feeling without feeling like clearance is limited.

V11, no problem. chinese HSS, no problem. O1, no problem. Water hardening (of course no problem). A2 - never quite right except for some very fine washita stones.

Before testing this plane, I gave the iron a heavy dose of dursol which put it in nicer condition as seen in the strange wear picture above.


Re: TL DR of the LN 62 from lunch

#5

Re: The strange wear..

Wiley Horne

Is this before use, or after X feet planed?

Wiley

Re: TL DR of the LN 62 from lunch

#6

Re: A2 and Washita hate each other

Monty Bates

Is this strictly a Washita problem or oil stones in general with A2 ?

Re: TL DR of the LN 62 from lunch

#7

Re: A2 and Washita hate each other

David Weaver

Just washita. I haven't seen the same thing on trans or black ark. Not sure about the soft ark stone as it's not something I use, and no such similar problem on synthetic oilstones.

Re: TL DR of the LN 62 from lunch

#8

After the plane stopped entering cut..

David Weaver

...at the beginning of the cocobolo test piece.

Before using the plane, it was crisp all the way to the edge.


(a little scratchy looking, but still crisp - I used the dursol splotch that I made several days ago and it's dry)

Re: TL DR of the LN 62 from lunch

#9

short video in cocobolo test piece

David Weaver

I wanted to see what it looks like to use a plane like this in short wood given the ergonomics discussion - the steep bed makes entering the cut kind of a pain, you have to get further behind the plane, which is a little unproductive vs. a stanley.

The same thing (steep bed) also makes the smoothness of the action a little less sure, but it feels smoother than it looks. It's not unpleasant for smoother work, or heavy cuts initially when it enters the cut easily.

This is an unlisted video, which means it can only be seen on youtube through links.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tUMwf7t5PK0&feature=youtu.be&ab_channel=DavidW

I have to apologize for something i don't notice that I do - my habit is to grab the shaving and make it exit the scene so it can't spoil the next cut. I failed to think about the fact that putting them in a stack on the bench would've made for better shavings pern.

I thought by feel in something like this that I may be dropping my hips, but from the video, it looks like I don't at all, or nearly none at all. Because of this, I start with the plane a little behind me and I'm not a huge fan of the handle on this plane, but it must be more upright for a reason (it's not as upright as the LV version, which is why I got this one in the first place).

Re: TL DR of the LN 62 from lunch

#10

A2, austenite and Oashita particle size

Jim Matthews

I'm wondering if the Oashita particle size (and hardness) are fitting between Austenite "deposits" and revealing where the billet is not homogenous.

Does the same discontinuity happen on diamonds near the same particle size?

Re: TL DR of the LN 62 from lunch

#11

Re: A2, austenite and Oashita particle size

David Weaver

Not that I'm aware of. I've only ever seen it on washita. It seems to grab something in a2, in 3 different a2 irons now.

Re: TL DR of the LN 62 from lunch

#12

Here's a SWAG...

Jim Matthews

The difference in performance, on a given Oashita stone, between O1 and A2 has to dowith reversion during tempering - if there is a localized overshoot in temp, annealing occurs and Austenite is reformed. Likewise large carbide inclusions could fracture out of the matrix

and are unlikely to form in alloys used for 01.

It is my suggestion that this happens after the blank is stamped and tempered, when overspeed grinding raises temperatures in the narrowest cross sections.

Unfortunately testing and verification of this are way above my paygrade.

Re: TL DR of the LN 62 from lunch

#13

I have a separate SWAG

David Weaver

but I can't test it as I"ve only used LN blades. LN cryo treats. I think the carbides probably spread out in a matrix like this, and they just get pulled out.

It's happened on bevel and back side of a brand new blade, as well as one I've had for years (i actually concluded early on that it was just a lack of fineness of the stone).

On other tools (I'll see if I can get a picture in the near future) made of certain alloys, behavior like this occurs, but on all of my other plane blades, I haven't seen it (japanese, O1, HSS, V11). On an SGPS stainless knife that I have (I think that may also be known as SG2), it happens on all kinds of stones and hard surfaces, and not just the washita, but the holes are ball shaped rather than high altitude cloud pattern.

Re: TL DR of the LN 62 from lunch

#14

Re: TL DR of the LN 62 from lunch

Mark Nowicki

TL - Transit Line?

DR- Dead Reckoning?