Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Bevel up trials - stanley 18 -cocobolo

Posts

Bevel up trials - stanley 18 -cocobolo

#1

Bevel up trials - stanley 18  -cocobolo

David Weaver

OK – the following set of posts are a comparison of

* 55 degree flat bevel

* 62 degree flat, and

* 55 degrees followed by a stiff buffing on yellowcake (BU UNI). Stiff buffing is four stiff passes through the buffing wheel with fresh yellowcake and a relatively heavy hand (and into the wheel a little steep, not tangent to it).

The plane is a stanley 18. I have five blades for it, so it's a good ranging tool for testing a bench plane when I get one from LN.

Back and bevel finish is ungraded chrome ox on softwood (just behind dursol, finer than 8k waterstone or black or trans ark).

The wood is quartered cocobolo with silica, 1.05 specific gravity. The second worst thing that I have to plane, and perhaps the most dense. The fact that it's quartered does make it a little less planing resistance than the flat face.

Re: Bevel up trials - stanley 18 -cocobolo

#2

55 degree flat bevel

David Weaver

(35 degree bevel on iron plus 20 degree plane bed).

NOTE - this cheap imported caliper is zeroed at .001" - i forgot to change it for the pictures - all shavings are .001" less thick than the indicator says.

****

max comfortable shaving – 4 thousandths. This is a gamed test, the wood was already cleanly prepared with a Stanley – so no guessing as to whether the wood is tearing out. It’s easier than starting with rough wood and getting to smooth. I think it's probably also easier for a plane to maintain tearout than remove it, but that's something for another time.

At 55 degrees with any appreciable thickness, you get holes in the shavings and these little innocent looking light brown tearouts. They are several shavings deep, though, and broken apart. If you go to scrape them out, it takes a long time and you will see a divot. Pictures of the tearout spots plus what the shavings look like with holes - holes in a shaving several thousandth thick indicate big trouble if you're intending to finish a surface.







Lighter shavings may prevent this but they’d be light enough that they’re not practical for anything.


This also is still in agreement with something I did with this piece of wood 8 years ago - plane it with a 55 degree infill with a tiny (.004" at the time, it's now .003") mouth - I couldn't chase the tearout out of the surface no matter what and sharpening was constant to try to do it with thin shavings. absolutely unworkable. I almost planed it cleanly with a stanley at the time - before I even completely learned the cap iron - but not quite. I declared it a pain in the ass and put it aside because it would make nice handles perhaps fingerboards where the other side of the billet doesn't have a wrinkle/reversal.

Nobody (no hobbyist, typical furniture maker) would make a large furniture piece out of wood like this, and in the world of guitars, it goes through a drum sander, gets its pores filled and is then sealed and lacquered if anything. It's very aromatic and sanding could be troublesome for some, but planing it just makes shavings and a little bit of filthy fingers handling it.

Re: Bevel up trials - stanley 18 -cocobolo

#3

62 degree flat bevel

David Weaver

Follow up with 62 degree bevel. Max comfortable working shaving – 3 thousandths. More is uncontrollable – possible in a mountain climbing contest, but not comfortably controllable. An accidental start at 5 thousandths...oops


and I couldn’t get the block plane through it, and there was tearout in what I could get through, anyway – nothing major, just not a great surface.

The rest were at 3 thousandths or so.



While there is much dullness on the surface, none of it is deep. It’s workable, except near the grain reversal in the middle (that remains broken out). The rest of the wood could be scraped, and ultimately that could be, too.

My apologies that this is not easier to see. I would rate this setup as capable of prepping this wood, but you wouldn’t want to put finish directly on it. Scraping would be necessary, but much more workable than the narrower deeper tearouts at 55 degrees.

Re: Bevel up trials - stanley 18 -cocobolo

#4

Unicorn tip on a 55 degree iron

David Weaver

Try 3 – the first plane (55 degree effective) but four stiff passes on the buffer to put a pretty significant uni on the tip of the iron.

Again, working with 3 thousandth shavings (but thinner shavings are so smooth that it's hard to resist taking them). Similar results to the 62 degree edge in regard to tearout, but the behavior of the plane is much better. The shavings have a waxy look and the plane works more smoothly and easily. This is the 5 micron yellowcake uni edge, not something super fine, and the same iron as test 1 – it is almost inexplicably more pleasant to use, but a push into a 4-5 micron shaving will leave a little nastiness. It's also still not easy to take those big shavings.

At 3 thousandths, everything clears up and the plane works comfortably, much more smoothly than either of the flat bevel test beds.



Take a look at the shavings – you can actually tell which came off of the uni and which came off of the flat bevel. They have a different quality geometrically, too – they have sort of a wavy quilty quality to them instead of all curled up – there is something different about the way they look.



If heavier shavings were desired, then maybe heavier buffing, but it’s really pushing things whereas the 3 thousandth shavings are comfortable and leave an amount of tearing similar to 62. The plane is noticeably easier through the cut – the quality of the feel is hard to describe – more pleasant, more controlled feeling, the plane stays set better.

A pass of thinner shavings, which was so pleasant with this setup compared to the first two setups yields a pretty good surface. not perfectly clear, neither was 62, but good enough to do a little follow up scraping and then finish.


Re: Bevel up trials - stanley 18 -cocobolo

#5

Bringing this back to earth with...

David Weaver

Bringing this back to earth with a stanley 5 and home depot iron. If one knows how to use a stanley, it's just a better rig. I suppose someone could endlessly experiment with a BU plane and try to match a stanley at a given task, but nothing needs to be done to the stanley to work well, and if that much effort is going to be spent making an inferior rig work, then there's plenty of time to learn to use the cap iron.

I can bull a shaving out of the cocobolo with the stanley and no tearout. I'm surprised given the wood density, but it's the quartered side and that side of a board is usually easier to plane, if harder to plane cleanly. Notice that these heavy thick shavings have no holes in them, though they can have disconnects at pores.




A set of 3 thousandth shavings is entirely pleasant (well easier than the block plane despite being much wider) and a better quality surface comes from it than the bevel up orientations.


Even the crease is mostly cleaned up (not doable with any of the bevel up orientations).

And the uniformity of the shine looking at the window is far better.


In order to get the final finish, i set the cap in a range where a shaving bigger than about 3 thousandths wouldn't have been tolerable, but I was looking to see what the best possible final surface would look like.

The whole process is much easier with the cap set because you actually can't get the plane to take a too-deep shaving. It stops you in your tracks immediately and you adjust. That's a nice thing that doesn't occur on bevel up.

The sharpening method for the stanley is washita back work, 1000 grit diamond secondary bevel, 5 micron yellowcake uni 1 bevel side finish (three passes with intentional rounding on the bevel side).