Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

More ARK stone question

Posts

More ARK stone question

#1

More ARK stone question

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I have been corresponding with David on this topic but thought this question could be of general interest.

I have two stones of unknown provenance. I have owned them for several decades but when they were manufactured is unknown to me. Their density, accurate to better than 1% is 2.24 and 2.27. This density puts them at the boundary between Washita and Soft ARK I think.

There is a hard boundary in name between Washita and Soft ARK but a continuum of density. Hence, categorized by density a Washita differs from Soft Ark by name only at the density boundary.

Question: Near the density boundary is the sharpening performance of the Washita and Soft ARK stones essentially the same? That is to say are the sharpening properties of a "dense" Washita essentially the same as a "light" Soft ARK? If judged only by rate of material removal would they be the same?

How tight do sharpening properties correlate with density?

If we go back in time 100 years +/- were the stones graded by sharpening properties instead of density?

Re: More ARK stone question

#2

Washita and others...

David Weaver

..if you're dealing with the more typical soft arkansas stones that look like a bunch of sandy particles stuck together, they tend to go in coarseness with density pretty well, but unless they're abraded, all settle in a little.

When a stone is the pike mine type, or what we call a "real washita", I can't draw as big of a connection with hardness and fineness, and in my opinion, the pure white stones often have less cutting power than some of the more mottled stones even though they're lighter. They have a lot of cutting power when they're first abraded, but seem to run out of steam earlier. If a washita stone is almost entirely pore free, it looks like a chunk of solid earwax and can be relatively fine and strong cutting at the same time (but it won't cut strong like any of them freshly abraded).

In all my fits of buying, the only thing I can really say is the rules sort of hold true and then beyond that it's which vendor's mine. As mentioned previously, dan's softs tend to seem more like hard stones to me. Natural Whetstone usually has coarser softs in the 2.3-2.4 SG range, but I have only bought perhaps 4, so that may not always be true. Their stones are more gritty feeling (the softs) and dan's are less strong cutting from what I've had and are better suited between fast and fine stones.

Brand isn't always a safe way to go, either. Many of the old black stones that norton sold (more common for me to see trans stones of the old type, back to when they were mostly pike branded through more recent) were dark gray translucent looking - they have a different feel than a true black stone, more like a translucent stone. the feel difference is small, but the owner of "natural whetstone" apparently doesn't have particularly good black stones, but he does have good dark gray translucent stones that are high density and have good cutting properties. He calls them "black trans".

And then other times, I've seen norton vintage stones in boxes that were true black stones. I think dark gray and black can sometimes reside together and you can get stones that are a mixture of the two, also. The're close enough when pore free that it doesn't matter unless they have the one odd characteristic of some black stones - releasing the odd clump of particles here and there, which feels the same as a stone with a contamination problem, and then nothing for a while, and then again (I've had that with halls black stones, and I think they're preyda brand now).

I have a chunk of earwax stone labeled by the carborundum company (it's obviously pike washita) - i'll measure it and see what it is.

Point being with all of this that while visual and density characteristics can be a decent predictor of behavior of the non-pike washita mine stones, comparing a pike washita stone to another based on density doesn't always yield expected results and comparing a 2.35 SG soft arkansas, for example, to a washita with the same density will never really yield a stone that has similar properties - the washita will always present a finer edge once stropped in terms of how easily it catches hair and shaves it.

Re: More ARK stone question

#3

Re: More ARK stone question

David Weaver

waxy look stone, 283 cc volume, 695 grams.

2.456 SG. Heavy for a washita.

Still retains a label that someone repaired and reinstalled, which will come off again if I use it "carborundum corp genuine washita oilstone".

Carborundum and pike both sold coticules, too. I guess from time to time, they could play nice enough unless the carborundum stone that I have predates norton pike or was gotten from rough stock that someone else owned.

It is a little strange to see high grade high cost pike coticules (they're better on average by quite a bit vs. what is sold now, but also not very large usually and expensive because of the label value).

At any rate, I'll use this stone at some point after I figure out what to do with the label. The label is worth 50% again as much as the stone, and it may be better to let it float off and just glue it in a box.

That's the pain of nice stones with labels and stamps. Unless you can get the stone in a box that's practically watertight, the oil will eventually make its way down the side of the stone, into the bottom of the box and the label will come off.

I got a super nice deep rock (branded label) natural coticule from George Wilson years ago. It was very pretty, a combination natural which isn't as common now, and almost none of the current combination (where the yellow and blue veins meet) have seemed very good to me. The one I got from george was razor size, but it was coarse and fast cutting. On the third use or so, the water that went down the stone and onto my hand left the label in my hand when i put the stone back on my shelf. I decided to sell it while the imprint of the label was still obvious on the blue side (too many more uses and there may not be much evidence that the label as on the stone recently). I sold the stone as coarse, but the aesthetics and label made it so that it sold almost right away despite being clear that it wasn't a razor finisher.

Long unneeded story. My opinion, though, that if one wants arkansas stones to use, a gaggle of washitas found on the ground with no labels for cheap and then perhaps one llyn idwall or a high dollar trans or black stone (most people will not appreciate them because of their speed being slow once settled) pretty much covers everything good.

I go less on density for washitas when the urge comes and more based on visual characteristics of the stones. A very fine looking white uniform washita will be slower cutting. One with mottling and the waxy look, it's a grab bag, and one that's got more open pores and is pure white will have larger particles but all will settle into fine cutting if they're not abraded, and none will seemingly cease like a black or trans ark will.

Re: More ARK stone question

#4

confused

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I think you are saying a Washita is not a Washita because of its density. There is not a strict correlation of name and density.

1.So by your definition, what properties makes a Washita stone a "Weaver Washita" stone?

2. How would anyone know they had one?

Re: More ARK stone question

#5

Re: confused

David Weaver

I'm saying that the original stones that were called washita came from a single mine that I call the pike mine. Dan called it perryn rock or something like that when he was speaking over the shoulder of the CS guy.

Pike also sold fine stones, but their washita mine made pretty much all of the early stones that have this look of a matrix with pores rather than particles with space between them. I've never seen a similar stone from anywhere else.

Most of the clear white ones were low density and many of the labeled stones from pike, especially old, were very clear stones without the mottling. They graded them in soft/coarse and fine/hard. They are lighter than most other mines' soft arkansas but can create a much finer edge.

Norton still owns that mine. Norton doesn't mine anything from it, so there is no equivalent new stone.

Later branding from smiths and case branded stones and others are just really coarse softs, and they're not the same kind of stone.

I don't know the nature of the different density charts, but they may have just been typical. The carborundum corp stone that I have is obviously from the pike mine (as are many older stones that are thicker than 1" perhaps before the labeling became so common, and branding became more important for the huckster wagon), but that carborundum corp stone is 2.45-2.46 SG. It wouldn't fit in a washita category, but the label says "genuine washita" because it's from that pike mine. I'm assuming carborundum and pike were competitors and haven't seen many carborundum washita stones, but they could've gotten stock from someone else. The really old stones that I have that are almost as tall as they are wide often have evidence of more hand work in their backs and they aren't perfect rectangles - I've never seen one like that with a label and am assuming that at some point, because the stones from the washita mine vary in looks, that pike realized they could get a premium for the really white ones.

Whatever the case may be, literature says they're the best. In reality, it makes little difference in practical use. I actually prefer the ones that aren't pure.

You will see people refer to stones like dan's sells (which he said "not the same thing, just a low density stone that we have off and on") or especially the very coarse gritty case softs called "washita" as fake washitas.

Never had a smiths washita, but they were operating early enough that they may have purchased actual washita stone. Otherwise, I'd go on visual characteristic and not density - anything that's not from the pike mine won't satisfy - the edge off of the stone will be more coarse.

The virtue also of the pike mine is that big clear sections of rock could be cut out, unlike some mines of the black and trans. And there's apparently still plenty there, so there's no real reason for them ever to be expensive and thus they were popular for carpenters and cabinetmakers. They're easy to get from england on ebay right now because (I think I might be responsible) I turned on the shaving people to washitas and most of the sellers in england cater to razor shaving stones (because england's carpenter/cabinetmaker type stones are subpar compared to arks ans washitas).

But, from holtzapffel's later volume, it's clear that washita stones raided england between the editions as he more or less used those word - took over, or something like that. So there's lots of them on the ground there, and better samples on ebay.

Unfortunately, they're also expensive now. When I first started, I could type in "vintage sharpening stone" and buy 5 stones. 3 or 4 would be washitas, and the others would be lookalike sandstones or gritty softs that were too dirty to tell. They'd be $30 each on average...hard to do that now. Most listings of 8x2 stones are about $100 because the shaving people will pay big for them.

I know they're still on the ground as tony z. mentioned that he's gotten a bunch and favors getting stones nice boxes (as in, I doubt he's bought every one he's seen northeast of me where he lives).

My various washita videos have gotten about 50k views in total, I sharpened some razors with washitas, pointed it out on the razor forums, and since then, lots of videos have popped up about degreasing washitas, etc, and we end up with people who will pay a couple of hundred dollars for other stones not minding spending $100 for a nice clear washita. They are obsessed with only using razor stones with water on those forums because of some of the dopey moderators claiming that oil should never be used to hone razors (you could get kicked off of the forums at one point for showing a picture of a coticule label that said "use with water or oil"). They work best with mineral spirits, WD 40 or a light film of mineral oil of the surface being honed is more than a point. I'm guessing (warren could probably confirm) that light mineral oil like norton sells probably works well with carving tools as the suspension problem for a tool doesn't apply to carving tools (that problem being getting a layer of oil stuck between tool and abrasive and making it hard to get good bite on the stone).

interestingly enough, dans' showed a video of someone literally putting a drop or two of oil on a stone, smearing it around with fingertip and never using more than that. I guess all kinds of arguments could be made about what the right type and amount of oil is, but it doesn't matter much as long as any is used in a way that particles don't accumulate in the stone surface (too little and too thin) or a tool back can't make good contact with the abrasive (too much and too thick).

Even then, I've gotten two strop top razor washitas that intentionally have the pores clogged neatly and were very shiny and neatly done on the surface, probably to make the stone work finer than it would otherwise work for razors. They were almost reflective.

Re: More ARK stone question

#6

earwax stone pic

David Weaver


Problem with telling shaving people about stones is they will buy and trade stones around, so they don't care that much about spending a lot of money as long as they can get most of it back if they change their mind.

That results in people buying 10 stones of the same type. if someone buys a stone and they love it (shavers), they'll buy 10 more. If they buy a stone and it's OK but they hear someone else loves them, they'll buy 10 more to find one they like.

I gave the shaving forums a method to use with washitas as most of the old published discussions came up a little short (coarse edge). It was more or less to use the washita to set the edge of the razor, strop it (to remove any foil) then lightly use the washita, then linen and strop again, then very lightly use the washita, and then linen and strop again - shave. Then linen and strop separately and a couple of light strokes on a washita.

This may not look familiar, but it's basically using the stone to set the geometry, and then conditioning the very edge of the razor with linen and strop. In the old days, that's how most razor hones advised - get the edge set and then never remove it. It takes some skill, but not much, and some perception. Two or three people report a great shave and its off to the races.

I see only one video on youtube talking about a washita stone that's older than

mine and perhaps 75 that are newer. The only video older than mine is a russian guy opening a stone that he got from the US along with other arkansas stones.

They work so well on razors because they're just fine enough to give a rough shave, but linen and leather can refine the edge without thickening it and the washita can keep the bevel thinner....AND ...razors are about the simplest steel you'll find as even a little bit of alloying like O1 makes for a crappy razor. Hard really plain steel always works well in terms of edge treatment. I'm guessing that medium and medium hard temper razors are in the 61/62 hardness range, about where chisels also have super behavior.

Lots of little things to manipulate. Best to find out what works with experimentation and then find out specs later so that you find out what's good, and not what sounds good and then convince yourself that's what you like.

Re: More ARK stone question

#7

Re: earwax stone pic

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

mine looks just like that stone

Re: More ARK stone question

#8

Re: earwax stone pic

David Weaver

I usually see good fineness and good cutting power from stones like that - they have a harder feeling on the surface and a sense of more control than the lilywhite, too.

But that could just be perception.

That stone was glassed on the surface by the seller (lapped to a point that it was reflective with something - I have no idea what, but that's popular for some stone collectors to flatten and completely polish stone surfaces).

I worked a back with it a minute ago while eating lunch, and it's pretty fine. It'll be interesting to see what happens with it after it sees wrought iron on a japanese tool (that usually pulls a few particles loose and really wakes up a stone).

I'll post the scope pictures tomorrow.

Re: More ARK stone question

#9

Re: earwax stone pic

Mike In Los Angeles

I have three stones here, a 6” lily white, an 8” No1, and another (repaired) Pike stone i don’t know If it’s a washita or a soft ark, but it looks and feels a lot like the Lily White.

Comparing the busted stone to the No1, which is more like your earwax, you’d say theres not much similarity. But when I got the Lily White it was a lot like the broken one. Of course it could be a soft ark in a Lily white box.

I was surprised to find the Lily white so much lighter and coarser feeling than the No1, is that how they are? Obviously it might just be woken up from abrading and not settled in yet, I honestly just got it to see how it compares to my broken 8” pike stone.

My question, and this might have been answered somewhere already, is how do the No1 pike washitas compare to the Lily Whites or is it more a matter of era or chance or some other factors?

E9458-E19-FB2-B-4416-9969-8-AE1-BA80-CB86

63-AE9-E15-DEF0-43-D2-95-FF-EC8-B4-BFC8-C80

C7-EABD1-C-3184-4085-84-EE-3867-D98-A8-C13

6790210-D-62-AE-4181-BD8-B-5-DADAE6-BC5-DE

2-D358720-0-B2-D-48-DC-BBD9-F9857057-EFA9

E9442620-6-A8-F-4493-882-D-59-BD1-A098649

Re: More ARK stone question

#10

soft lower density vs...

David Weaver

...higher density "earwax" stones - yes if you're abrading them. The lower density stones *will* definitely feel softer and more coarse. If you use them long enough without abrading, though, they will definitely settle in to good fineness. Without abrasion, and with the introduction of a really hard tool or two, I found that they run out of that smartness pretty quickly.

Then when they're all settled in, there's not that much difference. The higher density stones have a harder biting feeling and less softness (it's like using a small tooth saw with aggressive rake vs. a larger tooth saw with less aggressive rake - maybe it's about the same speed in either stone, but it feels different).

As far as no 1s, some are bright and clear like lilywhites and some are a good part mottled (earwax) looking. Other than knowing that no 1 were select stones that were a grade below lilywhite in general, I don't know if they would just use clear stones to fill that grade when they were available and mottled stones when not.

I vaguely recall seeing only one lilywhite stone with some mottling, and if one has seen very little of something, it raises the question of whether or not a label was just floated off of one stone and put on another. There was a time when the lilywhite label brought $100-$200 (the latter being the older stones with top and end label, and unused), and no 1s brought about $50. I think the revival has narrowed the value difference a lot. The only uninspiring labeled norton washita I ever had was one that wasn't graded lilywhite or no 1, it just said "washita oilstone" or something on the side (behr manning label). That particular stone was clear, but fine. It just didn't have much cutting power compared to most of the stones that I've used.