How to measure density of ARK stones
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
The question relates to how exactly does one either weigh the stone under water, or alternatively, measure it's volume. What are the density ranges for the various grades?
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
How to measure density of ARK stones
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
The question relates to how exactly does one either weigh the stone under water, or alternatively, measure it's volume. What are the density ranges for the various grades?
Re: How to measure density of ARK stones
David Weaver
There are charts at dan's, but the ratings in different systems are confusing. Here's why:
* some of the ratings consider anything over 2.4 or 2.5 specific gravity a hard stone
* we generally would start to regard a stone around 2.6 SG as a marginal finish stone (translucents start to not pass light very easily around there)
* Stones from dan's or good older translucent stones will be in the upper 2.6s for SG
Stones around 2.5 make a nice stone for prior to finish work.
All you do is measure the stones with something accurate (if they're new - if they're old and not flat, you're sol unless you can do water displacement), calculate volume and then compare volume and weight to the weight of water. probably easiest to do in CM and gram.
I have measured somewhere around 20 stones. It turns out that what we consider to be good stones are in a much narrower range than the charts would suggest.
I believe 2.65-2.7 range is the theoretical limit (siO2 itself is 2.67 on charts I've seen). This makes sense. If a stone starts having anything like 2% volume in air, it shows up as pores all over the stone.
The other issue with measurements is that the pike mine (dan called it perryn rock or something) stones can vary quite a bit. They are listed as a grade less dense than soft, but most of the folks who would use washitas and notice their qualities being different than other stones would say "Dense washita" or "low density washita".
I don't think cutting power of the washitas is quite as exactly related to density as the bright white clear low density washitas, to me, seem to settle in faster than the more mottled stones. I like the mottled type better.
Re: How to measure density of ARK stones
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
If I remember my statistics correctly the error in measuring volume of a stone will be cube root of three (1.7) times the error in a single measurement. To distinguish 2.6 from 2.5 requires detection of a 4% difference. The single measurement error must be less than 2%. This accuracy is easily achieved with calipers. But. my stone has rounded edges, How to account for that loss of weight?
If I can find a graduated cylinder the stone will fit in it will be able to measure volume with an accuracy better than 4%. I have no means of measuring submerged weight, but that would be the way to go.
Re: How to measure density of ARK stones
John in NM
You need a hanging balance scale to measure SG easily. I have a tiny one with carat weights, you need something much bigger for an ark stone. You hang the stone from one side in a vessel of water and then add calibrated weights to the other. This gives you the weight of the water displaced of course.
Re: How to measure density of ARK stones
Oskar
thats clever, will keep in mind!
Re: How to measure density of ARK stones
David Weaver
you can calculate the quadrant of a square and the loss of volume in that square from the radius and then measure the length of the radius around the edges of the stone if it's consistent.
Of course, it's unlikely that it will be that regularly shaped, but you can estimate the error due to the radius by assuming it's 50% bigger than your measure and see the maximum volume reduction - it probably won't be that small.
I can't judge density of porous stones very well, but for black and trans stones, I can look at the surface and guess pretty well.
Good old Archimedes....
John in NM
Bear in mind though, its a lot easier with a gem the size of a quarter than a big old Arkansas stone 
For a porous stone I doubt it will work - air in the stone. For dense stones I think it would do fine if one has a big enough beam balance to weigh the stone in the first place.
that's the idea I think.
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
The property one wants to measure is the fraction of air in the stone for it correlates to how open the structure of the stone is.
Re: How to measure density of ARK stones
Chuck Bjorgen
I don’t recall exactly where I was able to copy and save the following post but I know it came from one of my favorite woodworking forums. I found this information useful after I had purchased a supposedly translucent Arkansas stone that defied the usual characteristics. The stone was sold as”Sapphire Blue Translusent” and I used the following information to confirm that it did indeed show the specific gravity of a translucent stone. I only saved the author’s first name, Bryan, but this info was useful to me. A postage scale was used to take the stone’s weight. Hope this helps.
=================================================
Calculating Oil Stone Density
>I was asked to show how to calculate the specific gravity of a oil stone to aid in identification. To do this, you need to be able to accurately measure the dimensions of the stone, and the weight of the stone. I am an engineer, but for simplicity, I'm ignoring significant digits and I am rounding numbers with a bit of liberty. So be forewarned if you get hung up on such notions. I've tried to make this as simple and self explanatory as possible, for people not used to doing much math.
Specific gravity (SG) is simply the density of the stone divided by the density of water. Density (D) is simply the weight or mass of the stone (M) divided by the volume (V). Volume is simply the length (L) multiplied by width (W) multiplied by thickness (T).
So...
SG = D (stone) / D (water)
D (stone) = M / V
V = L x W x T
The only trick is making sure that your units of measurement are all consistent, but I’ll take care of that for you.
I found the specific gravity information for Arkansas stones on Dan's Whetstones website @ www.danswhetstone.com/stone_grades_101.htm
The specific gravities are as follows:
Washita: < 2.25
Soft Arkansas: 2.20 - 2.30
Hard Arkansas: 2.30 - 2.50
Translucent/Black: >2.50
To calculate specific gravity, first measure the length, width, and thickness of the stone, in inches. You have to be pretty precise, so measure to the nearest 1/16"l of the inch or better. Now weigh the stone.
Next, multiply L x W x T, This gives you V in cubic inches. Now divide V by 1,728. This converts the volume into cubic feet. It should be a small decimal. Second, take the weight or mass (M) of the stone in grams and divide this number by 454. This converts the mass into pounds (lbs). Third, take the mass divided by volume to get density . Forth, divide this density by the density of water (62.4 lbs/ft3). The resulting value is the specific gravity of the stone.
For example, I had a stone measuring 1" x 1-15/16" x 5-15/16". It was in perfect shape and very symmetrical. It weighed 494 grams. So my stone had the following measurments:
. L = 5.938"
. W = 1.938"
. T = 1"
. M = 494 grams
Now to calculate SG, do the following...
1) Calculate Volume
. V = L x W x T
. V = 1 x 1.938 x 5.938
. V = 11.508 cubic inches
2) Now divide this by 1,728
. V = 11.508 / 1,728
. V = 0.00666 ft3
3) Divide mass (M) by 454
. M = 494 / 454
. M = 1.088 lbs.
4) Calculate density:
. D = M / V
. D = 1.088 lbs / 0.00666 ft3
. D = 163.36 lbs/ft3
5) Calcualte specific gravity
. SG = D / 62.4
. SG = 163.36 / 62.4
. SG = 2.62
So, the SG of this stone is 2.62. Comparing it to the information from the web-site, this confirmed what I already knew. It's a translucent Arkansas Stone.
Good Luck
-Bryan
It is a whole lot easier in metric
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
Especially if one happens to own a metric digital caliper capably of 1/10000 accuracy and a scale with 0.02 gram accuracy. Density accuracy then becomes limited by reliability of stone shape.
Re: How to measure density of ARK stones
Rafael
Google came to the rescue: http://www.woodcentral.com/woodworking/forum/archives_handtools.pl/bid/3106/md/read/id/86842/sbj/oil-stone-calculations/
I'd suggest using the amount of water displaced by the stone when submerged in water to measure its volume.
At room temperature the density of water is 62.217 lb/ft^3.
But...
John in NM
That is not specific gravity, its density. I thought I saw SG in previous posts....
Ok, so you could do the same as weight vs. calculated volume much more accurately, because a porous stone will soak up some water so that will be an inefficient way to try to measure volume.
Re: How to measure density of ARK stones
Chuck Bjorgen
Yeah, that was the file from back in 2006 by Brian in Indiana. Thanks for locating it. Not being any kind of math genius I was able to follow his process.
Re: But...
Warren in Lancaster, PA
Let us say that the stone weighs 8 ounces suspended in air and 5 ounces suspended in water. Then the stone has displaced 3 ounces of water. So the same volume of stone that weighed 8 ounces is the same volume of water that weighed 3 ounces. The specific gravity is 8/3 = 2.67. The beauty of this method is that you don't have to know or calculate the volume at all.
The stones do not absorb appreciable water.
what's the difference?
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
If the reference substance is water aren't they the same value? Indirectly we are measuring the porosity of the stone relative to quartz. I presume the silica in these rocks is crystallized.
It seems the price goes up as the material approaches silica with no pores. I wonder how the performance of the most dense stones compares to chert.
Re: But...
John in NM
Yeah, that is basically what I was saying too. But Bill is interested in something different - I missed that on the first read.
Re: what's the difference?
John in NM
Sorry, its been a long day. How to measure what you want may make more sense to me tomorrow morning.
It doesn't make sense to me to try to measure the composite SG of a rock in that standard way I described because the air component of the rock can migrate out of it when you immerse it in water. If the rock is permeable enough, that will happen (permeable sandstones were some of the earliest water filters).
Re: what's the difference?
David Weaver
Chert is a much weaker cutting material per grit size and the abrasive tires more quickly.