Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Bevel-up plane with a buffed blade

Posts

Bevel-up plane with a buffed blade

#1

Bevel-up plane with a buffed blade

Winston

I used my Veritas low-angle jack with an A2 blade to plane some western red cedar for an outdoor project. The lumber was originally from some rough-sawn cedar 2x4's. Using a table saw, I broke the 2x4's into pieces that were 2 feet long by 1 inch by 1 3/4 inches. There are 15 of these pieces, with surfaces from the original rough milling and from my table saw. This stuff was straight-grained and generally well-behaved.

My goal was to clean up all the milling marks, and I used two planes to do it: a #5 with a heavily cambered blade (bevel-down), and the Veritas low-angle jack with a barely-cambered blade (bevel-up). I filled a paper grocery bag about 2/3 of the way up with shavings from from the Veritas, so it was a decent distance traveled by that plane.

The blade in the Veritas was sharpened to 25 degrees on a Sigma 6000, then I worked the back to remove the burr, and then it was buffed.

The interesting thing to me is that at the end, there were no edge defects and it leaves no tracks at all in the wood. Usually by this point I'd feel some tracks, even if the wood is easy like this cedar. The surface it left behind at the end wasn't glassy smooth like when it was freshly-sharpened, but it was still good.


Normally after planing this much, I would be able to see some imperfections in the blade with the naked eye, but this time, the blade still looks undamaged.

Some interesting stuff about the blade's sharpness: it still feels sharp. Not quite as sharp as it was to begin with, but it still feels somewhat "prickly sharp" (to use a term Bill coined earlier). It can still take a reasonably fine shaving, and I don't have to push down at all to do it. It made the shaving here after doing all that planing.


Despite this remaining sharpness, it will not shave hair now, at all. Even if there's enough pressure that it's scraping against skin.

*****

Here microscope pics of the bevel. This is what it looked like before being used:


After being used, instead of being perfectly smooth near the edge, it has a rough texture.


Here's the bevel again, but at a higher magnification. Also, I moved the light so that you can see the very edge better.


And here's the back before:


And after:


I wish I could see what the edge looked like even more closely, with an electron microscope, so I could see what the texture and profile look like. The behavior of the blade at this point is strange to me -- in many ways it seems sharp but in other ways it doesn't. I am pleased that I con continue to use it to get a decently smooth surface without tracks.

One other thing I should mention: I did get occasional tearout in places where the grain reversed. At some point in the future I may experiment with higher angles (plus buffing) to see how much of a difference that makes.

Re: Bevel-up plane with a buffed blade

#2

Re: Bevel-up plane with a buffed blade

David Weaver

Looks excellent. The wood looks a whole lot like sitka spruce between the rings, or I guess that's earlywood.

Planes will continue to work well after the bevel has enough wear on it to not catch a hair and snip it off (catching being the first requirement rather than pushing down and sliding over), as long as the edge remains uniform like that.

I can go to 600x optical on edge wear but it's so close that tiny grooves of wear are literally not in the same depth of view and it's hard to tell what you're looking at. If you keep looking at the edges, you'll find optical oddities, like what the different steels look like in different woods. O1 and water hardening seem to look similar (like the wear is smudged off) in most woods, but the more highly alloyed steels take on different looks in different woods.

I found the same as you did on a block plane that really was unsuitable pre-unicorn (actually used it on ribboned bubinga last week - it dulls quickly, but the edge doesn't sustain damage - that was at a high angle. On easier wood at a lower angle, the performance was also good).

And the same on bevel down planes, the only thing that has damaged edges is white pine with knots and dirt. The effect at the edge provides near to total immunity from silica in abrasive woods as far as notching. There is probably some theoretical planing distance lost in most cases (But I was able to two-side buff bevel down irons and match a 32 degree flat edge for distance), but the reality is that if an edge is defect free and gives up 20% of its theoretical planing life, it's almost meaningless - it'll still be less trouble in use and much less in resharpening as there won't be sneak defects that go deeper than the uni-stripe would've already required extra removal for in resharpening.

Once again, the uniformity of the edge is generally better than our best hand efforts because there is no pressure issue (pressure on the very tip of the tool that can lead to things like very small notching), loose particles on stones, and no wire edge for any practical purposes.

Re: Bevel-up plane with a buffed blade

#3

Re: Bevel-up plane with a buffed blade

Wiley Horne

Really interesting Winston. The buffed blade stayed woodworking sharp even though it wouldn’t pass your sharpness test. I like David’s explanation, based on the advantages of even wear.

Wiley

Re: Bevel-up plane with a buffed blade

#4

Re: Bevel-up plane with a buffed blade

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I would be curious what just a quick trip back to the buffer would do for its performance.

Re: Bevel-up plane with a buffed blade

#5

Re: Bevel-up plane with a buffed blade

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Winston

The surface looks great, as does the edge in the photo.

Assuming that you added 20 degrees to the 25 degree bevel, the final bevel would be around 45 degrees. Yes? Now you have to compare the results of just using a 45 degree micro bevel. Will you have the benefits of a low cutting angle on this soft wood? Or are you in actuality planing with a high cutting angle?

I will repeat a comment I made on SMS here for those interested in BU planes: generally I would use a 50 degree bevel for a 62 degree cutting angle for BU planes on West Australian hardwoods. At these levels, there does not appear to be any reason to add a Unicorn profile. It is six of one and half dozen of the other.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Bevel-up plane with a buffed blade

#6

Re: Bevel-up plane with a buffed blade

Winston

I agree that the complete lack of edge damage is a big benefit -- not just in terms of being able to plane longer, but also in terms of making it easier to resharpen. No need to make sure you sharpen out all the damage (and then be disappointed when you see tracks in the wood and realize that you failed to get all of it).

I'm curious if O1 and PM-V11 will behave similarly (I'm guessing they will), but I only have A2 blades for this plane.

Re: Bevel-up plane with a buffed blade

#7

It's faster...

David Weaver

I think of all of the planes, the unicorn adds the most on bevel up.

I'm using it now on bevel down planes entirely, and I'd use it even on japanese planes for all but the finest of work, but on bevel up, it's a treat.

The block plane that I used in the ribboned bubinga video would be a total pain in the butt to sharpen at all, and now the process is much faster, and completing the job of sharpening can be addressed as the finishing part is taken over by the buffer.

The edge is tougher (this plane blade is one that can be filed easily).

https://youtu.be/ycHyOycY_CM?t=312

In fact, all of this work was done with blades that can be filed easily, including the shavings in a pile left of this board.

I don't really use bevel up planes, but as you say, getting an idea of angles involved is pretty simple - I had set this, my last bevel up plane that's not infill shoulder looking - aside and it had rust and crud on the sole.

I do expect people will have some issue on BD planes, especially if they don't modify the secondary angle and give things a little room, but on BU, things are nice. Of course, this video was partially motivated by some friendly competition when you put my name and rob cosman's in the same sentence!!! but the block plane was a pleasant surprise. Now I'll look at it differently when it sits on the shelf and does nothing!!

Re: Bevel-up plane with a buffed blade

#8

Re: Bevel-up plane with a buffed blade

Winston

I took it back to the drill-mounted buffing wheel for about 8 seconds.

Under the scope, the edge looked almost as good as if I had resharpened on stones and the buffed, but a bit more irregularity. The blade is able to shave, but with effort (enough pressure so that it's scraping against the skin). I can take a slightly finer shaving than before the re-buff, and the surface quality is smoother than before re-buff, but not as good as with the full stone-buff cycle.

This is just my first try with it, but I'd say that it work OK, but it's not a substitute for a full resharpening. I'd bet that this also increases the angle at the edge each time.

Re: Bevel-up plane with a buffed blade

#9

Re: Bevel-up plane with a buffed blade

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Winston

The next step could be to continue your use of A2 blades and determine whether there is damage with a unicorn profile vs high angle secondary, with both end cutting angle being as similar as possible.

I assume that it is the high bevel angle that sustains edge quality. For BU plane blades, a secondary bevel creates the high cutting angle. This is easy to do with a honing guide and, in fact, really needs to be a specific angle (or close) as BU planes are sensitive to cutting angles.

The issue for me is that, when using a BU plane, I want to know what the cutting angle is. This is important on West Oz interlocked hardwoods. A cutting angle of 60 degrees is unlikely to tear out. However a cutting angle of 50-55 degrees may do so. How does one determine what the secondary nano bevel of the unicorn profile will become ahead of time?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Bevel-up plane with a buffed blade

#10

Faster is not as important as accurate

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

David

In my email above to Winston, I noted the importance - on WA hardwoods - of achieving a high cutting angle of 60 degrees (60-65, but who is counting). Often 55 degrees is insufficient. I freehand all my BD plane blades, but use a honing guide for BU plane blades because the angle of the secondary micro bevel is central to the final cutting angle.

Close enough is not good enough. Getting close enough faster is just me being silly.

This is not an issue if the wood is straight grained ... but then why use a high cutting angle if it is not needed to control tear out?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Bevel-up plane with a buffed blade

#11

Accurate isn't a problem..

David Weaver

Follow me on this one, from that video - I had this plane sharpened at a shallow angle to take the spoof picture with the words "missing link" under a cherry shaving. It was probably equivalent to something around 50 degrees. I figured I'd take a whack at this board and that I'd get tearout, but we'd see how it went - it was so bad that the plane couldn't keep adjustment.

So I cut that off and then started with the video that I showed, the second one. What got me to double irons was the inability of a 55 degree infill to really fully eliminate tearout (along with a 47.5 degree infill working terribly for working flat panels despite having a hundredth mouth, and intolerable use with a 50 degree jointer).

Knowing that this adds about 5-10 degrees effective and perhaps a tiny more at the very tip, what I did in the video was the first shot at making it more steep. The bed is 20, i honed somewhere around 35 and then the buffer adds what's needed.

It worked better than expected.

That's just about all anyone would need to do - hone at an iron angle that makes 55 degrees total and then give the front of the iron a healthy buff and it will cut like one around 60-65 degrees.

As far as accuracy goes in general, this is less difficult to do properly than bevel down, i'd guess? Other than early trials with a bevel down plane, I haven't missed or had clearance issues since. The accuracy once you account for what the buffer does is actually wonderful.

For someone who is new to planing, this will allow time and thought for maintaining geometry and working the back of the iron to make sure the honing job is completed. Tearout and accuracy won't be a problem, and no guide and no specific hollow grind to maintain.

Re: Bevel-up plane with a buffed blade

#12

Re: Bevel-up plane with a buffed blade

David Weaver

Derek - take a plane that doesn't cut well at 55 degrees in a certain wood (if something doesn't plane at 65, there are better things to do with the wood than plane it).

Set up the secondary angle at 55, then give the blade a stiff (but even) buffing.

Then plane with it.

My point is, all one would have to do is maintain a secondary angle somewhere around 5-10 degrees short of the goal and then all of the benefits of the buffing are still there - no wire edge to deal with, far faster, removal of some of the tip so a job more likely to be complete.

It's better. The cocobolo billet in my second video was way too much for a 55 degree infill with a 4 thousandth mouth. You just couldn't sharpen enough times to make it work (it would've been fine, I'd guess, if a 10 degree back bevel was added to the infill). The ribboned bubinga is more demanding to plane than the cocobolo was and the block plane had no issues with it guesstimating 55 degrees and then buffing it steeper. It doesn't have to be an exact degree number, it needs to be enough. The idea of an exact degree number is really this, it's not just exactly what works - it's that plus some margin.

Except it'll be more inviting to do all of this without getting a guide out and learning to feel "about right" for nasty woods. beginners can apply the secondary with a guide until they get to feel, but all you have to do is suppose what the buffer does and experiment a small amount. It turned out, I had to experiment none.

Re: Bevel-up plane with a buffed blade

#13

Texture?

Winston

One thing I wonder when I look at these pictures: What causes the texture on the blade as it wears?

It's clearly not as smooth as it was to begin with. The texture does not consist of lines going the direction of travel, which is what we see when the blade has just been sharpened on a stone.

Re: Bevel-up plane with a buffed blade

#14

Re: Texture?

David Weaver

I'm curious about that, too.

This is V11 after 400 feet in maple.

https://i.imgur.com/ruRUCyu.jpg

(this picture looks drastically different than my current pictures - I had to get a new camera as the old one wasn't compatible with win 10 power management and it wouldn't stay connected - too bad as the old pictures were move vivid).

Anyway, same iron as above after 600 feet in maple (the depth of the cavity worn out is a bit of an illusion, it's not that deep, but that's how the microscope sees it. smooth, though.

And then, a picture of the same iron after 600 feet of beech

https://i.imgur.com/5rXYjjS.jpg

cherry made the same powdery look, too.

A2 in beech - 400 feet:

https://i.imgur.com/GxJM9Tg.jpg

A2 in maple:

https://i.imgur.com/7KiQk5F.jpg

So, what's going on there, is it really that different, or is it just because visual spectrum doesn't tell the whole story? Don't know.