Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Why do I cling to Unicorn-Lite bevels

Posts

Why do I cling to Unicorn-Lite bevels

#1

Why do I cling to Unicorn-Lite bevels

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

As I reflected on the preparation of chisels for the project at hand I tried to justify what I was doing in light of all the work that has gone on in the past few months.

David has provided a tutorial on preparing a chisel with a Unicorn Profile and described in detail the rational for why it is the way it is. I find no fault with the recommendations nor the justification for them. So why am I staying with Unicorn-Lite, defined as doing what you have always done and follow with a brief buff to add strength to the edge?

To review: David recommends 20 degree primary bevel, 23 degree secondary bevel, buff. I am hollow grinding 25 degrees, refining the 25 degree bevel with finer abrasives, front and back, then buffing.

Some differences between our work.

One difference is experience. I have spent at least 1000 times less time honeing things than David. I need a process that works reliable and consistently when one's sharpening needs occur days and weeks apart. I have not had need to sharpen a chisel in nearly two months when I last was making drawers for the desk.

A hollow ground bevel sucks down on a lubricated diamond plate which provides reliable registration of tool bevel to "stone". What ever angle I grind at will be reliably replicated, and maintained, in the subsequent honeing steps. In the end I reliably wind up with a hollow bevel at 25 degrees vs David's 23 degrees.

Diamond cuts any steel quickly, which is the reason I have advocate using it for quite some time. To refine a hollow ground bevel with a "fine" fixed diamond plate or 15 micron diamond on cast iron takes less than a minute. Following with 1 micron diamond on cast iron takes less than a minute. For me the time advantage of what David is doing is not significant to me.

Inertia- Adding buffing to what one already does is a small step forward. I can maintain focus on how I am going to engineer the drawer support for this rock topped table. Adding 2 seconds on the buffer doesn't take any brain power and I can get on with the woodworking.

Re: Why do I cling to Unicorn-Lite bevels

#2

buff stropping

David Weaver

I think that's what mike dunbar called it in the text passage that was forwarded to me. Hone as normal, buff a little.

What drove this early on was creating a tough edge on a knife that wiley recommended - one that people usually say "has tooth" after it's sharpened. It has tooth because it gives up some of its edge, and then stays like that for a while.

Then, the fast acceleration after buffing some knives for years was pushing the bevel of the incannel gouge way back to make room for buffing and finding out that it went through wood easier than it did hand sharpened, and the back of the gouge would get visible lines on it from silica in rosewood (like light webbing) and the edge itself wouldn't chip.

So, two different things. But if buff stropping does enough, then no problem.

if it doesn't work at 25 degrees, then buff longer and it becomes unicorn. 23 degrees is my recommendation not because I tested to it, but because I came to it by feel as what gives room and makes things easy (derek is fighting his way back to buff stropping instead of doing more significant work with the buffer - that's OK, but good refinement and edge toughness then requires more refinement on stones).

In the end, does it really matter? I don't think so. I think when derek and others struggle to get the same results on plane irons, it's due to some relatively simple factor, and in some cases, it's fighting the idea of chasing bevels back as far as they will go and still work without issue.

(I buffed a japanese plane yesterday after norton india and dan's hard (which is really a soft ark - so now even that is doable. IT works great).

You know I'm a wonk for completing the job - that's really where the bias toward more buffing rather than less comes from - a little more buffing is insurance that the edge has more toughness and is "completed" ....more completely?

I'll change geometry to accommodate that, but nothing is mandatory, thus not putting my name on the method. It's not my method, it's just the way I'm manipulating factors in a way that accommodates the widest range of tools.

Re: Why do I cling to Unicorn-Lite bevels

#3

Re: I go back and forth;

Bruce McCrory

and then, add something new. I learn a great amount on this board. Thank you everyone.

I started with manufactured Japanese stones--actually, Ark stones and those coarse grey things 50 years ago--then jumped to diamond when the stones didn't satisfy. Pre-loaded (DMT?) quickly faded to something near 2000, which sent me to TFWW diamond paste and LV steel plates. The back of the worn DMT was used for the coarsest diamond paste.

Recently, PM-VII and Japanese chisels got me searching again because sharp was not satisfactory and edges wore too quickly. Also, rolled bevels due to multiple secondaries caused no end to dull edges. I depend on guides as nerve damage and bad shoulders kill freehand sensitivity.

Hand sharpening with a flat, consistent bevel for Laminated steel is a shoe-in to similar technique for other steels. Finer grits, up to 10,000 produced sharp edges, with care, in honing. However, the slightest motion would destroy the edge, sending me back to 2000 grit.

Whipping my pride, I added a strop for the final finish.

The strop may be a step down from .5 micron diamond, however, it saves me the trip back to a coarser stone grit after a nicked edge. And, it really makes the edge keener, and consequently sharper. The sum is a two-bevel blade, the micro being your strop, a buffer wheel, or pine board.

The activity on this board, and in wet shave honing, and other research indicates that a coarse flat edge, no matter how finely finished, will fracture faster than one that is smooth and rolled slightly at the edge.

That is, until they come up with finer alloys, and finer sharpening methods....

Re: Why do I cling to Unicorn-Lite bevels

#4

Re: buff stropping

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Did you misinterpret what I wrote in spite of the title? I have no doubt I have applied a convex bevel to the end of the chisel equivalent to the convex edge you apply to a more acute "supporting" bevel. I can clearly see the tell tale glint across the edge. It is the same glint that enabled me to dovetail 5 ash drawers on a Narex chisel. It is what is behind this convex bevel where we differ, not the strength providing convex bevel.

Re: Why do I cling to Unicorn-Lite bevels

#5

Re: buff stropping

David Weaver

I did (misinterpret). For some reason, I read 1 micron diamonds and stuck in my head was "light buff after a fine finish".

presumably, near unlimited edge life again without issues?

Re: Why do I cling to Unicorn-Lite bevels

#6

Re: buff stropping

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Dovetailing these blades was not harsh like making drawers and leg mortises. No damage detected but it was not the test drawers and legs will be. They will be coming tomorrow. Would have been today but an unanticipated cattle fencing distraction cropped up.