Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

i wonder who here has the gumption...

Posts

Re: i wonder who here has the gumption...

#26

Re: Beyond wiley and Orlando's answers..

Orlando in So. FGl.

David, the reason I replied here is that I just didn't know where to reply and is not to be taken as a direct response to your post.

--------------------------------------------

Wow!! I didn't mean to start a war over this. My main point, and I'm sorry if I wasn't clear about it, is that in today's world the level of QC in not only Japanese chisels (the topic of the thread) but in many other products have given way to the bottom line.

I believe that if you are going to pay top dollar for an item that is supposed to be of high quality, you should expect it to be made to match it's price point regardless of the brand/blacksmith. This is the reason for the comparison pictures. It was to show the difference between two chisels, of the same size, with similar price points, and the difference in QC.

Koyamaichi, Iyoroi, and the others make good products that have their customers/markets that like & use their products. However I don't think their QC is what it used to be (?) or should be. I say this from experience not only by my example of the Koyomaichi chisel but I once ordered 4 shinogi pairing chisels from a vendor and 3 out the 4 hand chipped edges. I guess caveat emptor is as prevalent today as when the saying was coined.

When I mentioned heat treatment and tempering it was from a QC perspective not actualities since I don't have the knowledge or experience on this topic. I can't tell a chisel hardened to Rc 61 or Rc 66 if you placed it in front me. All I know is that I like what I have - Fujihiro, Nagamitsu, Tasai, Koyamaichi, Masashighe, Koyama, Matsumura, old Buck Brothers, Stanley, and blue handle Marples. Each has a purpose in what I do within my limited abilities.

I guess opinions are abundant whether this brand of chisel is harder than this other one, or that one is softer and more prone to chipping, or that one region is this and other regions are that, and that my chisels are better than yours.

Re: i wonder who here has the gumption...

#27

Without seeing what the different..

David Weaver

....smiths do, it's hard to know where things went wrong. The older smiths turned chisels in a power hammer to create the tang. If the chisel is dropped in angle a little bit and the hammer strikes, the tang could be off center.

Koyamaichi's chisles have always been pretty quickly made - they're made to a shape, ground relatively coarsely, and then they get their oxide finish. If they're making them fast or to meet the order of a distributor, they may start to let things pass.

The really expensive chisels tend to have a lot of attention to aesthetics. Someone looking at a chisel for a while is going to have trouble looking at one that's a little bent and it'll be addressed one way or another. If they're being press forged in dies, the potential is there for everything to work well, but less eye time and a lower price point, and maybe it goes out that way.

Same on the chisels that arrive chipped - they may have been heated in open air for a while or the tips hotter than the rest of the chisel and then not ground back that much and who knows if there's a "good chisel inside of the original chisel" or if they're that way across the board. It's not much fun to buy a new chisel and have to work through some of it to get a good chisel.

The way all of the smiths did their hammering and tempering, at least in the past, what one smith does may be slightly different than another (what steel, how hot, how long in the water, what way do they move through the water). An experienced person becomes sort of like a robot doing what works. When that person isn't doing it (the frictionite stones literally stopped being made because there was no incentive to replace the lady who mixed them, and nobody could figure it out after her and there wasn't enough money in them to figure it out again), then things change.

The spooky talk used to be that tools need to be hardened in pine charcoal, then done in dim light, etc. and then suddenly we hear about tsunesaburo being good because they adhere to modern process.

The reality of all of the tools is if they're done with care and someone pays attention and stops for a second to look at each one, they'll be good. Even the hardening and tempering is far more forgiving than they make it out to be now that the steel is extremely consistent. That's important enough to the japanese that they used western modern process steel 80 years ago instead of their own sand iron steel.

If any smith got the good stuff from hitachi and went straight down the middle in the hardening and tempering ranges, they'd have no issue. But, that's boring to people.

The hand file work, managing distributor expectations and pain in the neck customers who are telephone experts, etc, that's a lot harder. Not the fun part, either.

Re: i wonder who here has the gumption...

#28

Re: Stan's opinions..

Miedema

I know plenty of miyadaikus in Japan who happily sharpen their 100C Kamon Kiyohisa blades on natural stones. According to you that shouldn't be possible yet they do it almost every day. But if you are who I think you are (David W on YouTube) what you say doesn't hold a lot of value. You're a typical example of the weekend wood worker who fancies himself an expert on everything.

Here's what I make for a living. I've been doing this for 25 years. I know wood and I know tools. Show me what you make instead of babbling on about Washita stones on YouTube.


img

Re: i wonder who here has the gumption...

#29

Re: Stan's opinions..

David Weaver

Show me the tools you've made, Nico. Hitachi shirogami tempering schedule starts at 160C. You have no clue what you're talking about.

Wait, don't, you'll show pictures of other peoples' work.

Just by chance that your email account ties back to the netherlands, I guess. And you're still showing pictures of boats that you lift off of google.

Re: i wonder who here has the gumption...

#30

Re: Stan's opinions..

Miedema

First of all, my first name is Henk. Not Nico. I don't know why you think it is. And have you told Kiyoei or Nakano they can't temper at 100 or 110C? I'm sure they would like to know what they're doing is impossible. I'm sure they will take the word of a master blacksmith like you.

Oh, and please go ahead and do a reverse image search if you think the photo I posted isn't of my work.

Re: i wonder who here has the gumption...

#31

we found one of your posts from 3 years ago

David Weaver

"I don't know anyone who has a Japanese chisel so I didn't know what to expect but I wasn't expecting this."

That was your gushing over a matsumura chisel.

:b

People would pay you to write comedy. Seriously.

But not on this board.

Re: i wonder who here has the gumption...

#32

Re: Stan's opinions..

David Weaver

as a guy who buys chisels but doesn't make them, you'll have to explain to me what difference you think it would make to temper a chisel almost 100 degrees F outside of the schedule of that from the actual maker of the hagane.

I figured the discussion of starting heat, transition speed, all of that would go over your head.

if I were selling tools and trying to make people believe they were harder than I was saying, but somehow sharpen magically well, I may (OK, I wouldn't, but a retailer would) make claims about tempering temperatures that aren't true.

That creates a group of disciples who run around giving meaningless information like you're doing now and distracts from reality.

Ever have one of those struck on a versitron?

I've heard all kinds of claims about iwasaki making 68 hardness razors and other nonsense, but that they sharpen like a dream. Reading a little bit further finds that's iwasaki's claimed hardness, and when the story comes from him instead of from a distributor or retailers, he said he guessed at that hardness based on some circumstances but never had any of those razors tested. Those razors sort of hovered around in obscurity but are suddenly sold for four figures now. People have them a little bit and then they sell them again (which is an odd thing if they're that great).

I could temper O1 steel at 125 degrees F. It would do about as much as tempering shirogami at 100C. Nothing.

Re: i wonder who here has the gumption...

#33

Why people think you're Nico

Winston

The reason that people think you are Nico is because you obviously are Nico. You write the same way, you have the same propensity for pointless insults, and you have the fascination with the same tools, and you claim to do the same work (boats). What are the chances that shortly after Nico stops posting here, "Henck" starts posting and has the exact same attitude, writing style, trolling style, likes the same tools, and also makes boats?

You're the same Nico who got banned from the Japanese Woodworking group on Facebook. You're the same person who got called out on this forum for writing fiction.

Re: i wonder who here has the gumption...

#34

Re: Why people think you're Nico

David Weaver

lots of stylish toolmaker names, looks like a nico alias.

Lots of stylish names, supposedly doing this for 25 years but somehow came up with only recent kit and stylish current makers.

Someone once asked George what chisels he used, i guess hoping to buy what he had.

But because he was an actual maker and not an internet cut and paster like this alias, George said "wood handled marples".

Unfortunately, they were from a different era when George was up and coming. He used the whole set of bevel edge chisels his entire year and would've had no idea what was stylish at the time if he hadn't been a toolmaker at Williamsburg. I'm sure the answer was kind of disappointing - a guy who does work as good as any in the world, and most of the activity related to him is unreachable, though he's clearly on video using those same chisels 45 years ago.

Since then, the conversation goes more like "I had to make small carving chisels for this job".

Shigefusa makes expensive knives, but it's a bunch of dudes sitting around and doing a whole lot of things by hand because that's what their customer is. I recall a japanese stone hound wanting to know what shigefusa used, and the guy he talked to showed a stone with good cutting characteristics and no stamps and pretty much had some fun at the expense of people who buy stylish stones rather than sorting through a bunch and finding a good one. That was a maker, not a buyer.

I'm starting to wonder if there is some commonality between nico and someone who asked me a bunch of questions when I was selling stones on etsy. When you pass about 200 stones through and look at them all through a microscope, you start to become comfortable with what you have. This person sent me a picture of a stone from ohira mine, said they had a friend in japan (that friend's page sold common looking stones for exorbitant prices and was full of that "i'm your friend" kind of talk, which I doubt plays that well in japan - in short, it was a fleecing of gaijin). They said that their "Friend" offered a stone for $2500 (it was just a green tomae stone with some yellow markings, and it was probably a decent stone, who knows). What followed was the kind of stuff someone would only do to take advantage of a buyer ("i'm only here today, let me know if you want it, it's got the best feel of any stone I've ever seen and it's faster and finer than synthetics").

No experienced buyer would ever give it a second of time. I'm starting to wonder if Nico may have been the person who was asking me questions about that. The "friend" selling stones was nobody's friend, but I think he found some marks.

The current stylish makers only (somehow the tools that would've been bought more than 10-25 years ago completely escape discussion), and the nonsense tempering temperatures....kind of reminds me.

Unfortunately, I'd get one of those every couple of months. Someone asking me about stones, then asking my opinion about stones on another page with a "friend" from japan. What can you say? The pages could be set up by college students who are just trying to make easy money.

"henk" here had a rosy conversation with stan, too. search his name and up comes stan's blog. None of the schizo-style criticism here shows up, less than a year ago, it was all flower talk.

What drives this kind of behavior? I don't know. When you're just an amateur like most of us admit to, following legitimate curiosity and making things, it gets tiring.

Re: i wonder who here has the gumption...

#35

Well Said

Orlando in So. Fl.

Well said. Right on the button David.

Re: i wonder who here has the gumption...

#36

Hilarious!

Winston

Recall what "Henk" said above:

> Someone else who fell for Covington's nonsense. The guy wouldn't know a professional grade chisel if you hit him on the head with it. I've tried his Nagamitsu brand chisels made by Nakajima and they're really nothing special. I have some old oiirenomis that were made over 50 years ago and they run circles around Covington's Nagamitsu brand.

http://www.woodcentral.com/woodworking/forum/handtools.pl/page/1/md/read/id/495296/sbj/question/

Here he is saying the opposite in a comment on Stan's blog.

> Even though these are all top notch tools Nagamitsu impressed me the most.


From: https://covingtonandsons.com/2019/11/25/the-story-of-cs-tools/#comment-194

It's just too funny. I don't know how people can take him seriously. Unfortunately, to those who aren't very experienced, he can sound like he knows what he's talking about. And maybe he does know what he's talking about in some domains, but it would be impossible for someone to separate the wheat from the chaff.

Re: i wonder who here has the gumption...

#37

Re: Repeating the question

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Here is what I do. I grind chisels on a King 800 stone. Full flat bevel. Then I polish on Washita and Arkansas stones and finish on a clean leather strop. I use the same routine every time, about 70 seconds.

For chopping I use a chisel 10 to 11 inches long and always hold it by the handle.

I avoid excessive force, avoid scraping, twisting and levering. Many do these things unconsciously and constantly. The wear I get is similar to a plane iron.

One phrase I noticed David Weaver using earlier, "done with care". Sloppy and careless does not produce speed and precision.

Re: i wonder who here has the gumption...

#38

I built this one....

Orlando in So. Fl.

.....using only Marple chisels, a circular saw, a peen hammer, and a folding ruler.


Re: i wonder who here has the gumption...

#39

Yo Henk, Nico, Wynomas, PalmRoyale.....

Orlando in So. Fl.

..... or what ever your tag is for the day. What do you have to say about your hypocrisy now.

Good job Winston in showing him up.

Re: i wonder who here has the gumption...

#40

Re: Repeating the question

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

What is brand of chisel and bevel angle?

Re: i wonder who here has the gumption...

#41

Re: Yo Henk, Nico, Wynomas, PalmRoyale.....

David Weaver

I don't know what adult would use that avatar, but the language about one cutting a lot better than another is funny.

That's the religious part of all of this, though you could certainly make it up if you never had any of them.

Even if that were true, I'd attribute it to most people never subjecting their sharpening to the microscope, or having a clue why they fail to sharpen one thing well and then fail at the next. As Todd Hughes would say, "I sort of collect" sharpening things and sharpening methods.

Re: i wonder who here has the gumption...

#42

Re: I built this one....

David Weaver

You're way better at boat picture hoarding than nico henk matsumura-san-not!!!!

:)

Re: i wonder who here has the gumption...

#43

Re: I try....

Orlando in So. Fl.

....to be the best I can. ;)

All we hear now from our guest are crickets. I wonder why. :D

Re: i wonder who here has the gumption...

#44

Re: Repeating the question

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I have used a 30 degree bevel since 1970. It would be hard for me to change angles any more than one degree.

I use 19th century bench chisels. If they are short from use, I put new handles on to bring them to 10 or 11 inches. A commonly available maker that I have several of is Butcher.

Re: i wonder who here has the gumption...

#45

Re: Hilarious!

Miedema

Hahahaha, I knew this would happen! LOL!. Henk Miedema is a douchebag so I've been pretending to be him and trolling on forums hahaha. Stole a customer from me and bad mouthed me. I'm just trying to ruin his reputation lol. Funny thing is I didn't write that bit on Covington's blog. What he says may well be true. I wouldn't know. Hell, I just like to troll online because people take everything way to serious. Posting those pics on ukworkshop was especially fun because it caused so much drama on the Dutch wood working forum. They all had a melt down lol.

And here's the real kicker. I really am a shipwright with 21 years of experience. I've worked for Privateer Yachts, De jong yachts, Feadship, K&M Yachtbuilders, Succes Yachts, Dörr and now I work for an old colleague. We both started our careers as shipwrights at Privateer Yachts. He's always busy with clients, meetings and other stuff so he hardly gets out of his office. He desperately needed a lead shipwright so he contacted me. I guide and steer the younger guys, keep track of everything in the shop and maintain the machines. And believe it or not, everything I posted as Wynomas on Reddit is my own work. The Skutsje I worked a couple of years ago, the desk, the cabinets, the small wooden sail boat, everything.

Re: i wonder who here has the gumption...

#46

I have to say it....

John in NM

If true, that is worse than the fiction of simply changing names as one's trolling adventures are exposed. Posing as another for such a purpose is about as low as it gets... Admitting to it is exceedingly foolish, you'd do the guy more harm by leaving it alone and letting people think he turned tail.

Either way, shame on you, nothing but a dirty little liar either way you cut it. Don't let the door smack your ass as you leave.