Re: Beyond wiley and Orlando's answers..
Orlando in So. FGl.
David, the reason I replied here is that I just didn't know where to reply and is not to be taken as a direct response to your post.
--------------------------------------------
Wow!! I didn't mean to start a war over this. My main point, and I'm sorry if I wasn't clear about it, is that in today's world the level of QC in not only Japanese chisels (the topic of the thread) but in many other products have given way to the bottom line.
I believe that if you are going to pay top dollar for an item that is supposed to be of high quality, you should expect it to be made to match it's price point regardless of the brand/blacksmith. This is the reason for the comparison pictures. It was to show the difference between two chisels, of the same size, with similar price points, and the difference in QC.
Koyamaichi, Iyoroi, and the others make good products that have their customers/markets that like & use their products. However I don't think their QC is what it used to be (?) or should be. I say this from experience not only by my example of the Koyomaichi chisel but I once ordered 4 shinogi pairing chisels from a vendor and 3 out the 4 hand chipped edges. I guess caveat emptor is as prevalent today as when the saying was coined.
When I mentioned heat treatment and tempering it was from a QC perspective not actualities since I don't have the knowledge or experience on this topic. I can't tell a chisel hardened to Rc 61 or Rc 66 if you placed it in front me. All I know is that I like what I have - Fujihiro, Nagamitsu, Tasai, Koyamaichi, Masashighe, Koyama, Matsumura, old Buck Brothers, Stanley, and blue handle Marples. Each has a purpose in what I do within my limited abilities.
I guess opinions are abundant whether this brand of chisel is harder than this other one, or that one is softer and more prone to chipping, or that one region is this and other regions are that, and that my chisels are better than yours.










