Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Detailed Unicorn Article is Up

Posts

Detailed Unicorn Article is Up

#1

Detailed Unicorn Article is Up

David Weaver

This is old hat now with all of the discussion, but has a paint by number setup for geometric ease and then commentary about the process, pictures of edges and some tests.

I believe for the most part, it's unedited at this point, and it may sound smarter if it gets a full edit, but the information in it shouldn't change.

http://www.woodcentral.com/cgi-bin/readarticle.pl?dir=newarticles&file=articles_958.shtml

method summary is at the beginning, and the rest is just supporting information.

Re: Detailed Unicorn Article is Up

#2

Confirmations and Question

Curt Putnam

Thus far, you have concluded that quality O1 has more impact resistance and less abrasion resistance than do A2 and PM-V11.

What are you suggesting for heavy-duty mortise chisels?

Thank you for this summary. It represents an enormous amount of work for which I thank you very much. This is a huge public service.

Re: Detailed Unicorn Article is Up

#4

Re: Detailed Unicorn Article is Up

Wiley Horne

David,

Your industry and perseverance, your scientific curiosity and drive, seem to be without limit. It has been a marathon from your initial conception to this milestone. This work will stand as a landmark for as long as people use edged tools.

Big thanks, Wiley

Re: Detailed Unicorn Article is Up

#5

Really glad to see it published!


Re: Detailed Unicorn Article is Up

#6

Re: Confirmations and Question

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

What are you suggesting for heavy-duty mortise chisels?

Unicorn the tip and it doesn't matter. Ergonomics is so compelling in chisels of any kind that the steel has to be really bad to trump the ergonomics that one may prefer.

Re: Detailed Unicorn Article is Up

#7

Re: Confirmations and Question

David Weaver

Anything, any steel. A mortise chisel will get hot before you need to resharpen it.

I like a small taper side mortise chisel for most cabinet size mortises.

Re: Detailed Unicorn Article is Up

#8

Thank you very much, Professor.


Re: Detailed Unicorn Article is Up

#9

Great job Dave!


Re: Detailed Unicorn Article is Up

#10

Re: Detailed Unicorn Article is Up

Eric Rathhaus

Thanks, David. I enjoy your curiosity, hard work, and generosity!

Re: Detailed Unicorn Article is Up

#11

Thanks for the nice comments guys..

David Weaver

...I fully expected when I posted about this that I'd be called some kind of boob.

I knew it proved out fine for me, but it sounds like goofery, and I also figured that if it started to catch on, maybe I could get someone else to try it (and no microscope pictures, etc, as I'd never done that while working up the roll and going to this).

It was as simple as buffing the tip and lowering the angles, just like the knife folks.

Just like the cap iron, it works in a range. If the chisel doesn't hold the edge longer, buff more. If it holds its edge but doesn't get through work faster than a flat bevel that holds an edge well enough, buff less.

Re: Detailed Unicorn Article is Up

#12

Re: Thanks for the nice comments guys..

Curt Putnam

Those who are so inclined dismiss unicorning as simple power stropping. Tjey, thereby, miss the basic notion of removing previous work/damage with a few strokes on a 1200 grit DMT or whatever and then polishing at an angle to the tiny bevel and thereby polishing and removing the wire edge.

To my mind, it is the quick wire edge raising and the polishing at an angle that are the really "new" aspects to this. As you say, it may well have been done before but nobody has described the method as you have.

As with Derek and the blue tape trick, it matters not who did it first. What matters is who usefully described it first.

Re: Detailed Unicorn Article is Up

#13

Re: Detailed Unicorn Article is Up

Oskar

Thanks David.

For putting in the time and work to make this easily accessible and understandable.