Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

I did a double grinding and sharpening..

Posts

I did a double grinding and sharpening..

#1

I did a double grinding and sharpening..

David Weaver

...as in, I ground an edge by hand and then did initial hone and then polish with less than $3 worth of materials and will post it on youtube, and then re did it to show that it wasn't a fluke.

I realize that this is the kind of circus nonsense ....well, it really draws me in, but that someone who is selling a very expensive sharpening system may not like - but I attempted to make a video with about $110 of materials including the buffer and then figured, I need to beat the next person to the punch who tries to show something even cheaper.

What I used in $3 worth of materials is something I could literally get by with just fine if I had nothing else, including no buffer, but applying the same principles as the buffer allows us, and not resorting to sandpaper for anything beyond grinding. Sandpaper applied to glass is just a demand for a super clean shop and the chance of cutting sandpaper or notching irons. Something as simple as a contaminated thumb or honing guide wheel can spoil it.

Re: I did a double grinding and sharpening..

#2

I have no idea what you did

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Some details? But I am attracted to the $3 part

Re: I did a double grinding and sharpening..

#3

Re: I did a double grinding and sharpening..

David Weaver

$1 flea market fine india - dirty, but still flat (machinists seem to use india stones here until they load and then throw them away, or at least did in the old days and the float around the flea markets with shaped stones, etc).

In reality, this stone came from a bag full of hard arkansas slips from a machinist and the slips were worth about $100, the bag was $20, and this stuff is just freebies, but there's a guy here who sells india stones for $1 to $2 (he never has good natural stones - I think he keeps those and sells them elsewhere).

I used about 18 inches of PSA 80 grit roll on a piece of scrap wood that "looks" flat, and that I'd used previously just to see if an older can of paint would dry in good time (that's about 60 cents worth of 4" wide psa roll)

And a white buffing bar that I bought years ago branded "craftsman" that I got on a clearance rack at sears (it was either a dollar or two for a dollar - I got green, too). I used it on cherry without smoothing the board - all I did was find a twisty offcut and card scrape the surface to remove any possible metal/dirt and then used it right on the otherwise rough twisty surface.

I didn't use a buffer as the principles of this are the same, but I saw people complain about not wanting a grinder or a buffer (which I think is an issue of a nickel holding up a dime, but some people would rather be consistent than smart).

Cherry shaving from this high-toned system:

(it was obligatory to use the $2.99 buck iron with this, of course - we don't want to go upmarket).


And a picture of the edge under the scope.


Re: I did a double grinding and sharpening..

#4

picture of the rig

David Weaver

I like that term - the sharpening rig. Really official.

The wood is from the offcut bin, the stone as mentioned was really free in my case, and the more coarse from this batch, I threw away. I think the reason that I kept this one is that you don't often see ultra fine india stones except they're relatively common in japan (used, I think waterstones have phased them out).

You could never sell anything like this stone, but they don't seem to pin like fine and medium india stones, at least not as much, and they make a nice clean secondary bevel.

It looks like most of the internet listed white stuff is like $6+, which is a bit of a scoffer, but I guess that's the cost of internet convenience. I think the original price for this stuff was in the ball park of $1.99 or $2.99. The fact that it was on clearance suggests that nobody really buys much of this at retail in the first place. It's called "medium". I guess the green was called "fine", but I lost the package long ago and it's not much different. The scope pictures show this to be awfully fine.


part number on that package of buffing bar is no longer functional, but neither is sears retail.

Re: I did a double grinding and sharpening..

#5

To be clear.....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

You prepared the blade with 80 grit paper. Then refined front and back with India stone (silicon carbide). Then with white compound on a piece of wood you rocked the blade to apply the Unicorn Profile?

Got that part.....but what was the wrench used for? ;)

Re: I did a double grinding and sharpening..

#6

Re: To be clear.....

David Weaver

I use that to get back upstairs after the mrs locks me out. :)