Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Bevel Down Plane Irons and the Unicorn

Posts

Bevel Down Plane Irons and the Unicorn

#1

Bevel Down Plane Irons and the Unicorn

David Weaver

Keeping with my comment that the bevel down methods are a lateral move for someone good at freehand honing, it is a little curious to me that most people are reporting hit or miss results with bevel down planes.

I posted a 7-iron video (not golf!!) where I honed and planed with 7 irons just as a matter of demonstrating that consistent usable results are probably right around the corner from initial frustration.

But, two things - a question and a supposition about what might lead to different results:

* has anyone had consistent luck with bevel down planes?

* for those who haven't, i wonder if there is a case for the more aggressive abrasive in the 5 micron bar combined with the wheel speed on the buffer. you can tell from Winston's edge pictures vs. mine that the stronger combination takes a longer higher volume amount of material off of the edge, and I suspect this might be better for plane irons.

Just curious.

BU planes, without a doubt, the method works really well and the considerations for clearance aren't there.

Re: Bevel Down Plane Irons and the Unicorn

#2

Re: Bevel Down Plane Irons and the Unicorn

Winston

I've been able to get bevel-down planes working, with the soft drill-mounted buffing wheel and finer abrasive. I haven't used these blades enough to get a sense of far the blades would go before having clearance issues, though.

I have tried to do less buffing, and with a closer-to-tangent angle. Maybe that's part of it. With chisels, I just sort of stick them in the buffing wheel until they look done -- not much finesse needed. But BD plane blades probably need more care.

I'll try to get a profile shot of one of these blades later today. I'm not fully convinced that the differences in profile that we've seen between us are due entirely to the equipment; it may be possible to get similar profile with both types of equipment.

One more question to add to David's: for those that haven't had good success with bevel-down planes, what kind of problems have you encountered?

Re: Bevel Down Plane Irons and the Unicorn

#3

Re: Bevel Down Plane Irons and the Unicorn

Monty Bates

One thing I have noticed is there are 40,50,60,70 and 80 ply buffing pads available. i would think that an 80 ply pad would be a good deal harder than a 40 ply pad. What do you use? Also from your video it sounds like you are pressing into the buffing pad fairly hard. True?

Re: Bevel Down Plane Irons and the Unicorn

#4

Re: Bevel Down Plane Irons and the Unicorn

David Weaver

Yes, I put some pressure into the buffing pad. Not like my hands would shake with just a little bit more, but enough to ensure that the iron is getting solid uniform treatment at the edge of the wheel.

Ply information has to go along with width, and I don't know how much it would vary based on differing ply thickness. I don't think it's too important as long as the wheel is stitched within a reasonable distance from the end. The number of plies in the wheels that I have that are 1/2 inch stitched width (The fanned open part is a bit wider) varies from 42 to 60 and all work fine.

A low number with loose space between the plies could be a problem, though.

Re: Bevel Down Plane Irons and the Unicorn

#5

deformation is what is important

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.


The wheel surface needs to deform into a concave profile to result in a convex tool profile. Pressure and wheel density combine to make the correct profile.