Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Late to the party

Posts

Late to the party

#1

Late to the party

Oskar

Hi all,

I´ve been away from home, and been offline since end of May. Just returned and found the hand tools forum boiling with unicorn stuff. I´ve tried to catch up on unread posts and threads but for sure have missed some parts.

I´d like to try this, especially on my paring chisels that often get edge damage, and I don´t like to raise the sharpening angle anymore.

I don´t have a buffer. I do have stones, from course to very fine, and flat leather strops, some with fine compound on (for carving tools).

Is there a short description of bevel setup, angles and all and unicorning by hand?

Sorry if this has been written out a thousand times already. Please direct me if this is the case.

Best,

Oskar

Re: Late to the party

#2

Re: Late to the party

David Weaver

do your normal honing, but only around 25 degrees. no need to use a polish stone on the bevel side, just through the medium stone.

Do about 20 heavy handed pulls through your loaded strop at about 40 degrees. See if the wire edge is gone (if it's not, keep going).

Between my results and winstons, it looks like a longer more gradual bevel works, or a shorter steeper one as winston has works OK, and maybe that's a better idea for a strop since it's physically easier.

I found somewhere around 50-100 strokes with pressure were needed to make an edge cosmetically similar to what the buffer gave me, but you're not necessarily looking for that.

A more practical solution (to me) is what I've been doing for a long time, which is to roll the edge up steep and make the roll with a finish stone. Just don't lean too hard on the chisel or you'll deflect the edge. I never stropped after that with compound, but stoning a tiny visible flat on an edge and then just stropping lightly is probably more sensible than stropping the whizz out of a blade and tiring your hands.

Re: Late to the party

#3

Re: Late to the party

David Bassett

Not what you ask, but Winston's $10 Ryobi "Metal Buffing Kit" from Home Depot in a hand drill is an all-in power solution with minimal commitment.

Re: Late to the party

#4

What I did-worked fine

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I was facing having to make 5 ash drawers when David described Unicorning with a buffing wheel. I did not have a buffing wheel, but I knew I had to make a convex profile on the chisel tip to get the benefit.

I sharpened a Narex chisel 30 degrees- hollow grind, fine Ez-lap diamond plate, 1 micron diamond on cast iron. This is my usual procedure. But at the end of the final honing I rocked the chisel up on the plate, with a pull stroke, about 5-10 degrees, a total of about 5 pull strokes. Then I did the same with 5 pull strokes on a leather strop charged with green stuff.

instead of the edge damage I expected during making 5 drawers I saw no damage . You can do the same as I did. On your last sharpening step just pull and rock the chisel up on the stone. You want to make a convex profile. Just imagine what kind of rocking on the stone will make a convex profile.

Re: Late to the party

#5

Winston’s how-to video (using drill)

Wiley Horne

https://vimeo.com/444232624

Re: Late to the party

#6

Re: What I did-worked fine

John Pappas

What you are describing is a "cousin" to Paul Seller's way of honing a convex bevel. There is also a video on YouTube by a Steve Grimsdale dated 4/2010 in which he demonstrates his method of producing a convex bevel. There will be some differences because the unicorn method only affects a small part of the bevel whereas the Paul Sellers method affects the entire bevel. In a way, it all meshes together to lend credence to all of these methods. Note: I adopted the Paul Seller

approach about a year ago, and while I have been fairly inactive as far making things, I have experimented with my chisels and am happy with my simple tests.

Re: Late to the party

#7

No, Sellers’ profile is not the same.

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

This comes up frequently. Many confuse Paul Seller’s rounded bevel with the Unicorn profile. They are not the same - quite different, in fact.

PS concentrates on honing the face and bevel using a sweeping motion that leads to a rounded bevel face. This is not rounding the bevel. In fact, it has more in common with honing a flat face. He aims for a bevel angle around 30 degrees. The Unicorn angle is around 45 degrees.

The Unicorn profile is all about the edge of the bevel, when a nano secondary bevel is created. See this photo by Winston ...


Could PS create a Unicorn profile at the end of his rounded bevel? I do not see why not. However, he has never spoken about this as far as I am aware.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Late to the party

#8

confused

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

PS concentrates on honing the face and bevel using a sweeping motion that leads to a rounded bevel face. This is not rounding the bevel.

Don't know anything about PS or how he sharpens but this report seems in conflict with itself.

Re: Late to the party

#9

Re: confused

David Weaver

imagine you're rounding the entire bevel instead of just the tip. This is what sellers does.

In my experience, people do two things more often than they do something that ends up similar to the unicorn:

1) they do a lot of hand work and the finish stone gets used over a large part of the bevel but doesn't remove all of the damage at an edge, even if it looks OK.

2) they go to a different method because every time you have to refresh an edge, you do a large rotating motion on the entire edge.

I believe PS's contention is that it's a more natural motion (or some adherents say that), and he finishes with fairly aerobic seeming work on a strop.

It's kind of like a mini unicorn, but without taking advantage of the fact that using a bunch of stones on the bevel is a bit of a waste of time.

He does it well. Students do it OK, some don't.

We've had this discussion very recently, but if the whole bevel is seen as one thing and stones get used all over it, most people don't finish the edge. Separating setting up the tool so that just the face and tip can be sharpened usually leads to more success because the finish work is only done at the tip.

sellers advocates using a progression of 3 diamond hones (admittedly, I saw this about however long ago sellers' blog became the next big thing because he was a "real" woodworker and was advocating sparing spending and "lifestyle woodworking") and then a big piece of loaded leather.

It's seen easily if you have bandwidth for video, but harder to communicate something simple without it.

Without a buffer, the strop uni dominates his method because the stropping part is still there (strenuous stropping) if the edge rounding isn't done, but you can just blast the bevel away with whatever you want and people will not start walking away from the stones before the work at the tip is finished.

Some folks here have been to his classes and said that he does mention avoiding chasing the edge steeper to take a shortcut.

This rounding sweep over all or most of the bevel has been described by the names of different people, but there are folks on the UK board who learned it just as part of their apprenticeship (over 50 years ago), so it's neither person's method - it's something they were taught because it's workable on site.

I gather than sellers' training was as a joiner (vs. cabinetmaker) and site sharpening would've been important.

Re: Late to the party

#10

video if you can use less bandwidth

David Weaver

I don't have a way to measure bandwidth, but this video can be loaded and then viewed at 144p and should not take much bandwidth.

The trouble with this video is that paul uses a new chisel and it takes little time to work the bevel (of course).

What I see coming up short when I come across rounded tools (including japanese rounded tools) occurs after this has been done a dozen times.

Which is why our article says to refresh a secondary that's small and then grind a primary when the secondary takes more than a very short time to completely refresh.

Charlesworth's discussion of the parts of a three bevel system (that he likes to use) actually discusses these things similarly. hone a secondary, regrind when honing the secondary becomes a lot of work, and then a third bevel at a few degrees more is placed on the edge.

Every "named" system has some parts of someone else's method.

Re: Late to the party

#11

Re: No, Sellers’ profile is not the same.

John Pappas

Derek, re-read my post. I did not say they were the same....and I said there were differences. "Cousins".....somewhat related.

Re: Late to the party

#12

not poo pooing other peoples methods..

David Weaver

...all of the gurus seem to have slightly different methods. I know they also all teach a lot of beginners, so I have no idea what it's like to talk about the most practically ideal (as in not theoretically ideal, but something people will complete when maybe they're on the edge of having to run off to the bathroom when they're finishing sharpening, or something where immediate edge damage after putting a sharpened plane to wood won't lead to walking out of the shop or dreading the job with hurt hands).

I have a seriously unhealthy spending habit with sharpening stones. It's slowed down a lot. The problem isn't that none of them work, the problem is that when you're curious and all of them work and they're all a little different, then you don't get the failure a few times in a row that you need to have to say "ok, this is a waste of money". I understand there are folks who like to fly fish who just go from one rod to the next and they like to really go through fly reels.

As much of a pig as I am, I still have the same basic fly rod (not even wood, and I think it was $40) and shakespeare reel as I did in high school. It hasn't broken yet, and i'm not fascinated with reels.

Back to the different methods. They all work. It's confusing as to why they're all different, but not that confusing when you see people have trouble, I guess. And for someone giving an $800 class, getting stuck the first day sharpening other peoples' tools is probably a strike out. Except for gurus selling honing equipment, the guru methods seem to address honing without addressing grinding (or the grinding is part of the honing).

Given that they all work and I've tried them all, with an endless supply of stones, nothing really works more easily than doing the material removal with a power grinder, and separating geometry from finish so that each is completed properly (rather than as part of an integrated method). The sellers method works better with an IM 313 and a crystolon stone, but then what do beginners do to flatten the backs of tools (sandpaper) without making the system confusing?

The charlesworth method got me started with a fully prepared iron and a sharp edge before I ever used a plane. I only had a king 6000 stone so the blade shaved marginally and I spent the next several years listening to everyone say that if I ever got a properly sharpened tool, my eyes would be opened. I thought there was something else out there, like some magic. There isn't. It's just a matter of manipulated geometry and speed after that.

Re: Late to the party

#13

I'd say cousins is accurate...

David Weaver

..we had a discussion in the background, bill notwithstanding since he doesn't watch videos, etc and likes to get his info from the headley shop.

The first thing people will say when they see a rounded edge is SELLERS!!

The first thing I'll think of from the UK board is JACOB! (they use the same method, but I've gotten more repetitions from jacob).

In theory, if you lowered the bevel with sellers' method, flattened out the coarse stone work to a 20 degree nearly flat bevel and the secondary just above that to raise a wire edge and then only stropped the tip, they'd be the same. Except for the amount of work and the very steep rounding that the buffer does at the edge and corners - corners chipping off on hard chisels, and bending on softer ones being another typical failure problem - esp. on parers.

parers always seem to be fine if the corner is just a bit shiny gone, but almost too hard to see, and not big enough to be blunt).

Re: Late to the party

#14

Re: What I did-worked fine

Rafael

I would opine that both methods polish the cutting edge without actually rounding off the actual edge. They accomplish something similar, I'd say they're related.

What happens with the heel of the bevel, on a chisel, is probably irrelevant.

Re: Late to the party

#15

Re: Late to the party

Oskar

Thank you all that have answered my question. I´ll give it a shot and see what happens.

What is the role of the primary angle, 20, 25 or say 30. Is it relevant for the cutting action or otherwise?

Re: Late to the party

#16

angles...

David Weaver

..to my knowledge, nobody has followed the angles across the board. I spend a whole lot of time playing with sharpening, and far beyond tools- but with the desire to figure out how it's easy and makes things more pleasant.

When I was playing with this method, I already had a tip round over method for chisels and didn't know exactly what I was doing, but I was doing shallowing the bevel that the tip was installed to because it felt better in cutting. That has changed gradually over years, and I thought I had a 25 degree primary because I uses to set a rest there.

But when I measured the primary at Bill and Wiley's request, it was 19. The secondary bevel was hand honed. I guessed 25 degrees then knowing that, and it turned out to be about 23, and then I rounded the tip. If I was using only one stone, then the whole secondary and rounded tip were in one step, but the rounding is always "tiny".

So, given that all holds up and it does make cutting action easier (and why bother using a buffer if something else is better), it's my recommendation to use 20 for a primary bevel, a slightly steeper secondary (because you can easily do it freehand without having problems - just lay the bevel on a stone and lift it a tiny amount and raise a wire edge. You get the feel for an angle that varies only a fraction of a degree each time you do it not because you feel some angle, but because up or down from it feels not right.

So, then, you have a clean secondary bevel that's all the way to the edge and you can just buff that. The result holds up well and because the angles are dropped, it's slick through wood - more slick than just adding a tiny microbevel.

BUT, everyone who doesn't care about effort quite as much as found edge improvement just buffing what's there.

The two pre-buffing angles are there just to make it easy to do the job completely each time you sharpen, in 30 seconds or so, plus a little more every 3 or 4 times when you grind. The grinding refresh is quick, no threat to burning and all you have to do by hand is a small secondary with a medium stone - so you'll complete it each time. And then the buff, which almost completes itself.

Someone else (can't remember who now) asked what to do if you really like to hone right on the hollows, then I'd grind at 23 degrees, hone right on the hollows and then buff. IF it's 25, it doesn't matter, if it's 27, i'm sure it'll still work. The higher it is, the less you should have to do buffing but at some point, if the buffing isn't enough, the edge will crumble.

Dropping the angles and then buffing the tip makes the chisel take about as much effort as a flat bevel at 25 degrees in my tests. Except it holds up. a 25 degree bevel is really nice to use when it first starts cutting - it goes right through the wood. But it doesn't hold up.

Re: Late to the party

#17

Re: No, Sellers’ profile is not the same.

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

John, my apology if my reply appeared heavy. It was not aimed specifically at you. I read a few forums and, when the unicorn is mentioned, someone jumps in to say it is the same as Seller’s. If left there, newcomers are at risk in getting the wrong introduction.

I agree that there is a resemblance. I hesitate to agree that it is a “cousin”, other than both methods are about sharpening the bevel. One aims at creating a wire from two joining edges (regardless of the shape), and the other aims at modifying the joined edge.

There is another response that comes up, usually from carvers. They will say that hard leather buffing wheels have been around for a long time. Then it needs to be clarified that the unicorn is not about buffing the bevel to create a sharp edge, per se. It is about strengthening the edge, and that this is better done with a soft wheel.

Okay, cousins, but two or three degrees removed. :)

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Late to the party

#18

As a student, convex bevels help

Jim Matthews

In the nine day Sellers course, many of us ran afoul of making ever steeper final angles on our plane blades. If the only thing your after is a burr, a steep honing angle raises one quickly.

The emphasis on honing the entire bevel was mainly to reduce confusion: inspection of a larger surface for similar luster - to the edge of the blade - was simple.

****

What wasn't discussed (due to time constraints) was the interaction of clearance angles, setting of chip breakers (cap irons) and mouth openings.

I think Sellers was canny enough to realize any open discussions would derail progress to actively making things in a compact schedule. Anyone who as attended an Public woodworking forum has seen the pitfalls of addressing alternatives to the demonstrated method. People get testy over things like this.

*****

There were (in retrospect) problems introduced by having workbenches too high for shorter users (me, for instance) to comfortably hone in the requisite "start" position.

I had an epiphany when demonstrating this technique on a concrete floor. I "disvovered" something obvious to generations of Shokunin - so obvious I couldn't see it.

Where the iron meets the stone at the start of the hone determines the cutting angle.

The convex bevel works is what I call fault tolerant, in that it can produce a usable edge with coarse materials, rough handling and limited essential knowledge. It's like basic training for woodworkers.

Once you're extruded from boot camp, improvements are a matter of adaptations by the user, and only limited by our willingness to make attempts that could fail.

The breakthrough with DW's method is that the terminal angle is set LAST, and with a measure of control. The bonus is in the time saved.

I struggle with consistency, just as I did learning to make a full convex bevel.