Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Cutting Edge Wear

Posts

Cutting Edge Wear

#1

Cutting Edge Wear

Garthinsandiego

Much discussion about tool edge wear and sharpening techniques here lately. Particular interest in the ease of creating and resulting durability of the unicorn edge profile for chisels and plane irons. The linked article discusses edge wear for razor blades. Wondering if the unicorn profile eliminates some of the cracks, thereby explaining the increased durability of that edge profile.

https://science.sciencemag.org/content/369/6504/689

Re: Cutting Edge Wear

#2

I just happen to have...

David Weaver

...the picture of a straight razor edge after somewhere between 100 and 200 shaves.


This looks far different than a commercial edge for three reasons:

1) it's hand honed, commercial blades are honed by a machine nearly to a point (I haven't seen video showing exactly what's done)

2) it has a number of shaves on it in three digits

3) it's seen linen probably 40 times and leather 150 estimated

The edge looks uneven, but I literally shaved a week's growth off two days ago in one blade buffed pass (google is your friend on that) and the amount of blood involved was about the size of a grain of sand.

Because the bevel is so shallow, the actual thickness of the edge even when it's battered back a little bit is very thin. It shaves hair easily. This is a unicorn edge on a razor, of sorts. The very early edge that gives you the blinding shave on a feather razor is long gone and I would suppose their reputation for being nice after 3 shaves is due to the deformation of the edge battering it to a certain point where it is more stable.

When i hone this razor again, it will look straight. I don't usually re-hone unless I have a reason, but I will to take another picture. I used to grade stones for people as a courtesy just to let them know if there was more out there for them to acquire or if they were already pretty much at the limit for natural stones.

I have a DE razor that's been shaved a couple of times. I can't match the MIT SEM pictures but we could tell whether or not the damage is bad enough even to be visual (i'll bet it is).

Re: Cutting Edge Wear

#3

resharpened straight razor and DE blade

David Weaver

The same razor resharpened with said earlier japanese stone. This can be chased finer, but it just leads to blood and razorburn. The go-to for the average beginner if they come up short here is to wipe it all away with graded chromium oxide, and that works to some extent. It leaves an edge that's transient, and you really want the strop and linen to do what was done in the other picture. That blade with the uneven looking edge is probably more pleasant than this one will be for a week or two.

At any rate, dennert razor honed (dennert is an old company from solingen-foche - old razors are generally better than anything new because the alloys weren't gamed for stability very much).


This is a light round on the linen. With the edge exposed from fresh honing, no heavy hand is a good idea on linen and leather, you can deflect things. As the edge gets a couple of weeks of shaves on, then it settles in to long term use and changes very little.

You can see that the tips of the abrasive grooves and the edge are just starting to burnish. The shave will be good. If this were finished with oxides, the edge would be a bit transient, but it would be sharper (than it needs to be) in technical terms.


And two pictures of damage to an astra blade with a few days of shaves. Some parts are undamaged, and some are like this. I have no idea what the effective angle is, but the blades are so flimsy that they can bend around inside the razor as it's used. I wouldn't be surprised to find that the razors that seemingly make blades last longer do a better job of preventing bending at more than just the tip. If the tip bends, the razor starts to shave the hair on more of a diagonal and the force pushes the edge up while it's happening. I am no expert on DEs, I only use them when visiting relatives.

The straight razor would seem fragile to us, but it bends much less than these do.




I could've told the guys studying razors three things, but they would've known too much to listen to me:

1) the blades could be a little bit stiffer with the tip rounded some to mimic a straight razor in use for a while (the chromium coating on them is wonderful, though - it's slick. Straight razors generally seem nicer to shave with if the bevel is tiny - mine is just over a hundredth of an inch because it was wonderfully ground - as thicker razors get a fatter bevel, it literally does add to the friction of the cut and make them feel more dull).

2) the more plain the alloy, the better the razor will be in not losing bits of its edge, but it will also be harder to manufacture due to warpage

3) i can't remember what it was, it looks like there are two things in 1, but failure due to deflection in commercial irons is obvious. We're not made of sand and the razors have a chromium or sometimes other coating on them. It would last a long time on skin.

Re: Cutting Edge Wear

#4

edge corrected used DE Astra

David Weaver

OK, i don't know if I'll try shaving with one of these soon or not. These are two used astra blades. One, I hand honed on corian and chrome ox. These blades are soft, flexible, an this is fiddly. If it could be made reliable (angle wise), any amount of pressure would bend the edge.

So i freehanded the first one. We'll see:


Then I buffed on the corner of one of my wheels. This is a situation where the razor blade is tiny and flimsy to hold and my high speed buffer wheel is pretty swift. It felt like asking for trouble, but I doubt much could happen (famous last words) as long as the blade isn't fed in the wrong way, stabbing the other side into my hand. There are no visible defects left in the edge (nothing that shines back to the naked eye). 5 micron compound probably way too harsh for this, but just the battering of the wheel is also probably too much. you can see the super even original coating is now rowed with abrasive grooves. We shall see.


Re: Cutting Edge Wear

#5

this is not a matter of utility...

David Weaver

...these blades are about 12 cents each. This isn't a matter of spending parsimony, it's just to see what happens when you actually hone these. The old glass hones are probably too harsh for them because they feel so soft.

It could also be that they're impulse hardened near the ends and the floppiness is just to make sure they can't break in a poorly made razor.

Re: Cutting Edge Wear

#6

Re: this is not a matter of utility...

David Weaver

Hand corrected razor blade shaves like a slightly duller but smooth blade. Buffed blade shaves but is more dull, way too rough for the dainty blade.

Next try is iron oxide, which leaves no visible scratches even on the soft blades.

Re: Cutting Edge Wear

#7

iron oxide sharpened blade..

David Weaver

...with reference to the iron oxide pigment that kremer specifies at .09 micron is fine on the stainless DE blade. It doesn't remind one of a brand new blade, but it shaves without any irritation. Better than the first two (buffer, and chrome ox freehand).

Astra superior stainless (good blades) are $13 from amazon with shipping for 100, though, so the only utility I could see in any of this is for those of us with uncooperative skin, shaving with a razor that is a little bit duller than new but seemingly stays the same for a long time.