Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Some accurate documented cap iron history

Posts

Some accurate documented cap iron history

#1

Some accurate documented cap iron history

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Below there was some inaccurate cap iron history posted by Warren. To correct this history:

Some time in late 2011 I was following the seminal work of Steve Elliot on sharpening, when he provided me with some still images for what we came to known as the K&K video. Apparently I was aware of the cap iron at this time and was sufficiently motivated to learn about how to use it that I set about to track down the source of these still shots of the cap iron working. It was not easy (they were in the midst of the huge tidal wave disaster) but I was able to make contact with the source. From my correspondence with Professor Kato he must have posted it on his University web site in January of 2012 so we could fetch the video from there. I believe from my correspondence Mark Hennebury fetched it for us. Audio was translated by someone in our woodworking club and the video and the translation sent to Horne, Elliot, Pan, Weaver, Hennebury, Ellis and maybe others in April 2012.

copy of email:

-----Original Message-----

From: Bill Tindall [mailto:BJTindall@mindspring.com]

Sent: Wednesday, April 25, 2012 10:35 AM

To: Horne, Wiley; elliott, steve; Weaver, David; Smith, Phil, eastman; Mica

Iwasakim Japanese lady

Subject: History of the Kato Video

Professors Kato and Kawai studied

planing in the mid 1980's. They

comprehensively studied the effect of

the cap iron(chip breaker), blade alloy,

grain angle, etc. under conditions

relevant to hand planing. (I believe

their research was directed toward

SuperSurfacer machines). Their results

were published in Japanese technical

journals is dense technical jargon that is difficult to translate. Some of

the journals have been impossible to find in the US. I have a translation

by Mica and summary written by me to clarify(I

hope) the technical jargon and concepts of the chip breaker study that is

most revealing.

In the quest to track down the journals I could not find in the US I found

and contacted Professor Kawai who has sent me the articles I was unable to

find in US libraries. I now have copies of everything these professors have

published.

These professors were at a technical

college and teaching students was an

important part of their positions. Part of the teaching program was

learning to use hand planes. The parts of Professor Kato and Kawai's work

that was relevant to hand planing was published in educational journals as

an aid to teaching students hand planing. (These were the articles that I

could not find in the US libraries.) To supplement the most important of

these articles(it is not translated yet) they made a video showing the

action of the chip breaker at various distances and angles from the blade

edge upon planing wood with and against the grain. The video reveals in

great detail the mechanics of shaving formation.

Professor Kawai posted this video on his University web site for me. It is

an

MP3 file and can be easily copied to CD for study.

To help understand the pictures it will be helpful to read the summary I

have made from the translation. I will have it ready to share soon. but

till then the variables studied are distance of chip breaker from tip, angle

on leading edge of chip breaker, and grain angle.

The response is the shaving formation, shaving structure and fracture

ahead of the blade tip.

*** end email

Professor Kato later provided me later with copies of his papers and the video in a package postmarked 05/15/2012. Many of these papers were copied and provided to anyone interested. I had translations made of the key ones and these made available.

I wondered about the apparent absence of interest in this work on WoodCentral. I wrote to Wiley and he responded April 27, 2012

***start of emails

Hi Bill and Steve,

Well, a lot of us are having to change our mind on what the chipbreaker does! Based on Steve's work on this topic, I came to believe that the cap iron could indeed bend the chip so as to prevent tearout--but I saw it as an impractical exercise, since I didn't want to get involved in optimizing the cap iron location at such small distances to the blade edge. For practical purposes, I have been seeing the cap iron only as a means of pretensioning the blade and making it more rigid.

Personally, I have opted for 47.5-55 degree bedding angles and tight mouths, using primarily C&W and infill planes. I love the knowledge and the breakthrough findings!! And I might adjust my LN and Japanese planes, as the spirit moves. But am I going to change my tool choices and planing technique?--probably only at the margins. I do want to make experiments with my Japanese planes--that's where I will apply this new knowledge.

More generally, these findings have tremendous power for two classes of users: (1) Japanese plane users, since the Japanese planes readily available are typically bedded at about 42 degrees and have relatively open mouths; and (2) Bailey or Bedrock type plane users, since these planes have adjustable mouths--you can use your 45 degree standard frog, open up the mouth, and use a close-fit cap iron. [Note that Bevel-Up aficionados are not affected by these findings.]

I don't think silence is quite so strange:

1. Those already committed to C&W planes or infills (high angle, tight mouth) have already made their choice, and may have a slight defensive circle-the-wagons attitude. It's human to do so.

2. Those already committed to Veritas BU planes will not see the relevance for themselves, even though the knowledge is intrinsically stunning.

3. Those using Bailey or Bedrock planes are right now mulling over whether they want to open up their planes' mouths, and tighten up the chipbreaker--or keep the mouth tight. Is the cap iron thing more of a hassle than they want to deal with?

I would ask you, Bill, not in a challenging way but just as a matter of curiosity--have you gotten out your LN 4-1/2, opened up the mouth and tightened the cap iron? What happened? I really think the best way forward from here is to demonstrate the power of this new knowledge by adjusting our Bailey, Bedrock, and Japanese planes and showing the difference in tearout control, while commenting anecdotally on any surface differences we can make out. Honestly, it's very tempting to just go with what is already working, rather than change equipment or relearn planing technique. Though the findings are a revelation in and of themselves.

Wiley

P. S.--Here are a final few notes on the edit I started the other day. Couldn't do much of value without the figures in front of me:

______________________

On Apr 27, 2012, at 10:32 AM, Bill Tindall wrote:

> WoodCentral's most vocal have fallen silent on this plane discussion. Strange.

*** end of email

Some time in the midst of all this Kees posted a video of setting up the cap iron and planing success. Things took off after the Kees video and the followup Article by Kees and Pan. As far as I am able to document Warren had no contribution to advancing use of the cap iron late 2011 till mid 2012 when its use gained wide exposure.

Re: Some accurate documented cap iron history

#2

Re: Some accurate documented cap iron history *LINK*

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Here is what I wrote when Bill Tindall asked "What is a double iron?"

This predates the above emails.


What is a double iron?

Re: Some accurate documented cap iron history

#4

comment about heavier woods..

David Weaver

..I was a little subtle at the time when I made that post.

Since then, well, curly cherry when it gets really curly and soft in the curl is actually one of the harder woods to plane perfectly cleanly - far harder than curly maple.

What I hadn't grasped yet was that the heavy infill felt good in really dense wood (I'm sure I was playing with cocobolo at the time as I had, and still have, a stick of quartered cocobolo that doesn't like any plane), but that as the user on lighter planes, you have to use yourself to make for some momentum in harder woods - the double iron planes still do better and get more work done per unit of effort, but you have to decide that you're looking for results and not for a plane that disconnects you from the wood like a cadillac of old disconnected everyone from the outside world).

In my morning omnibus earlier, it slowly came back that the plane was a millers falls 4, at least that was accurate. Looks like I remembered the price wrong by a dollar. As I'm a terrible reader, and terrible verbally, I remember literally what it looked like when I bought a plane like that (I got it in person) and what was around it, but sometimes I get the small details wrong. I can still see it in my mind. It was a type 1 and it sold easily. I got it at the black rose in hanover, pa.

That should be pitiful that I can remember that as I've had at least 150 planes in the last 15 years.

As I moved on past this and realized that the millers falls could take much more wood at once than the infill plane, and work with an iron that didn't need to be constantly sharpened, I got the rest of my foot in my mouth.

Re: Some accurate documented cap iron history

#5

Re: History *LINK*

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Here is where Wiley Horne presented the Elliott/Kato material to this forum in 2007.

Here is what I wrote a that time:

My feeling is that anyone who does not see the value of the double iron system probably does not understand how to use it. I know that this puts some people who consider themselves experts into a somewhat lesser category and I apologize for it.

and

the double iron is a sophisticated instrument. For things to work well everything has to be just so. There is no shame in having trouble with it. If the idea of learning to use hot hide glue turns you off, the double iron is not for you. It takes a fair amount of practice to get a good feel for it. I can say that the benefits of learning are well worth the effort and I would not want to be without it.


Elliott/Kato

Re: Some accurate documented cap iron history

#6

Thank you, thank you , thank you.

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I suspect your lame attempt to make me look stupid for not knowing in April 2012 the arcane term "double iron" hasn't worked. I hope everyone interested in what was known and being taught here on WC in April 2012 (that would likely be at most 3 people) reads the ENTIRE threads and sees how far we have come with no help from Warren.

It is abundantly clear that at least by late 2011 I knew the potential for a close set "chip breaker" (the term "everyone" used at the time) and spent more time than any of you tracking down the video that resulted in this technique flourishing.

It ain't what you claim to know; it's what you do with it that counts.

Re: Some accurate documented cap iron history

#7

The annoying part about this...

David Weaver

I didn't know anything at all about bill (that's not annoying). When I bought the millers falls plane, it would've been thanksgiving or Christmas as we don't back to the central part of the state after Christmas and before summer.

The week that I did the initial forced use was in late January or early February. Chris Griggs was on SMC and at the time, I bounced it off of him to see if he could make it work and he said it worked for him a little bit.

I sat on it some before posting and probably wasn't making much of anything at the time (in limbo moving from power tool use to hand tool), and as soon as I posted the post warren linked on the board, Bill sent me an email that said "I have something you might be interested in seeing".

So some folks who should've known better, followed me around after the article saying "you just repeated what you saw in the video", and I could tell the posers from the users immediately because the posers recommended following the distances in the video. The users made no such specific comment. I didn't find the preferred machine settings in the video after Bill sent a link to it to be very good, and that got codified in the article early on. A flat wall of 80 degrees is pretty miserable for someone using a hand plane. It also has a narrow range where it does nothing and then does something drastic. That's also gross. After the video came out, I tried the 80 degree wall in a japanese plane. It was awful. doing nothing (tearout) to oversensitive to back pressure and spoiling the surface.

I guess that works great in a machine where you can control the cut depth and the cap set to be super precise. It was better to figure it out without watching the video and experiment with a bunch of different planes to find out what actually worked well in hand tools.

My premise was false, though. I thought warren won a smoothing contest at WIA with a #4, and I thought I remembered the chip pictures in the leonard lee book showing an unbroken chip with a cap iron in use. (I think those were BU plane and steep plane angle respectively).

Fun remembering this stuff. I could barely recall clearance wars because it was nonsense, but this stuff was substance and was the first thing that made it realizable that you could work entirely by hand and that people who said you couldn't were full of it.

Re: Some accurate documented cap iron history

#8

History *LINK*

Warren in Lancaster, PA

So you were aware of the potential for the double iron in "late 2011"? Are your sure? This discussion took place on this forum December 15-19, 2011. I don't think we heard your voice. You were more interested in how Brian Greene sharpened.


Late 2011 discussion

Re: Some accurate documented cap iron history

#9

3 posts....

David Weaver

.that entire thread was 3 posts long. apparently of no interest to anyone else.

After the armchair experts came out in the next several years about "i've been doing that since forever", I searched all of the forums and other than bob strawn's experiments (he was also sharpening on thin strips of steel, which I couldn't make much of, but I could make work now if I had to)..

..there were two references of european or western planes and cap iron use. both were on the UK forum. one user was from finland and he said "i'm just going to say it works for me, but I don't want to get in a war about it".

That was well before 2012.

Never found anything else other than warren's posts (in any volume talking about using the cap iron in actual work).

Re: Some accurate documented cap iron history

#10

Re: Somebody wake me

Steve Voigt

…when this wretched thread is over. I sincerely regret bringing up the topic in a previous thread.

Everybody who helped explain, revive, popularize the double iron deserves credit. But nobody here deserves a Nobel prize, because nobody here invented it. If you can find the guy in the 18th century (or earlier) who first put two irons back to back; or if you can find the guy who first bolted the two irons together, let me know. I could care less though, about the petty crap. And I suspect very few other people care.

Re: Some accurate documented cap iron history

#11

let's be honest about all of this, too..

David Weaver

...there are a few of us using a double iron.

There are more people who know it can be used.

If the topic on this forum went away, and traffic stopped here, it would be erased in less than 10 years.

I expect that at some point, someone may dig up an old piece of text about rounding over the tip of a chisel and buffing it.

Side example about how everything has been done before - iwasaki is a famous razor maker because he had an intense interest in plain carbon steels and made some super hard razors, but his razors aren't any better than tanifuji razors (tanifuji actually finished a bunch of his razors for him). Not that important who either of these guys are.

Iwasaki had a document about sharpening, or one written by someone who visited him and discussed the topic and to the horror of all of the mortgage payment sized stone buyers, iwasaki apparently had graded 1 micron diamonds (this was a long time ago) and put them in a cloth or a soft piece of material and ran it over the edge of his expensively honed japanese natural stone edge.

Most of the people on the razor forums thought he was bonkers (he was an experimenter) because 1 micron diamonds are pretty harsh on something as thin as a bevel. I couldn't make sense of it, but for a guy to wipe off the finish of an ultra rare stone and scrub some harsh diamonds on the edge of a very expensive razor, some detail must've been missing.

....

..

The detail is that the diamonds don't work aggressively in a cloth, and they made a better edge (i'm sure they do) that a highly priced and prized high end japanese natural stone.

What he did suddenly seems not that much different than carefully preparing geometry and sticking it in a buff. That just came back to me the other day while walking around. I couldn't make sense of 1 micron diamonds at the time, but sure see what he was doing now.

Re: Some accurate documented cap iron history

#12

Amen

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

It seems that nobody on the Forum, or managing it, is willing to end the personal attacks from Warren at me. They have gone on for years. I'm tired of it all too. I will respond when I have the data.

Want it to stop? Stop Warren from bringing my name into discussions for no other purpose than hoping to promote my ignorance.

By all evidence the Kato video was the needle mover, followed by the Kees video. I have your emails to confirm. Doubt it and we can pursue off line.

Re: Some accurate documented cap iron history

#13

“there are a few of us

Wiley Horne

using a double iron.”

Hi David and all,

You might be surprised, David. I don't know, but suspect there has been a considerable adoption of double iron technique. And this because of the developmental work and testimony on this forum.

In my own case, just in the past year or so, I went from 0 to this:


These 5 planes are all running on capiron—4 Veritas bladesets + the LN4 with your great iron/capiron combo in it (thank you! It’s permanent).

I have 2 bladesets for the No. 4-type infill on the left—the original from Konrad and an alternate Veritas set that will work with an open mouth. It’s a favorite plane. Works great with either blade set.

Still have other favorites that don’t use double-iron, but consider myself an adopter at this point.

Please excuse the focus on self. My real point: There are likely more recent adopters than you suspect—thanks to all the developers and proponents on this forum.

Wiley

Re: Some accurate documented cap iron history

#14

Question about breath of usage

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

This exchange got me thinking......Has anyone seen a close set cap iron being used in a shop putting product out the door or in main line classes, Mark Adams, etc. ?

It is not promoted in the Lonie Byrd classes, he pushes students to a BU plane. The three furniture makers for money I know of regionally do not. I don't think the Headley shop does, but I have not asked specifically. I saw no evidence of it in the Krenov school. In my correspondence with Ron Hock he advocated a close set mouth and fine shaving to achieve the goal(some years ago).

One might respond, well none of these places emphasizes planed surfaces. But neither do I, yet I find application in building about everything I build. It clearly has application in any shop making stuff. Bring able to level a proud drawer divider or frame without risk of a divot is critical, for example. I used to safely sand them level for fear of an unexpected divot.

However, much like the Unicorned chisel edge, these places have obviously found other means to the end, I guess. But I never asked what was the solution.

Re: Some accurate documented cap iron history

#15

graham blackburn...

David Weaver

..after we wrote an article, someone said to me in an email "graham blackburn gave a talk at CW last year and said "give me any plane and I'll use it in any direction""

It was about the cap iron.

On the aussie forum where there's plenty of potential use (but adherence to using entirely hand tools is probably tempered by the wood use there, esp. in WA), most folks still seem to like other means.

I stopped offering it as advice to everyone last year without saying "if you do more with planes than remove chatter, then...."

forgetting that the biggest benefit to me is to be able to size wood with it and smooth quickly.

And as wiley showed, I finally had a way to make the older lighter infills work the way they were supposed to, and their careful filing up from the mouth to make room for the cap iron set all the way to the edge became apparent.

The unicorn thing has been fun, but I suspect it won't make a great dent as the gurus who sell stones along with their classes aren't going to push it for chisels.

Re: Some accurate documented cap iron history

#16

I could be wrong....

David Weaver

I hope I'm wrong....the double iron solved the mystery for me of the older double iron infills. A norris 2 or anything similar with the cap set is just a thing of joy.

There's a motivation even for someone using a lunch box planer (as I do once in a great while) and not wanting to spend lots of money on gadgetry - and that's to have a single smoother under the bench that can do everything with no need to make "in app purchases" at the bench to gain capabilities.

Re: Some accurate documented cap iron history

#17

Re: Somebody wake me

Monty Bates

I probably shouldn't do this but what the hell. Frankly I cannot believe what I am reading. I have been reading this forum since the very beginning and beyond to the Badger Pond days.

You people can't seem to accept that the collective efforts of members of this forum has forever fundamentally changed how a hand plane is used. Who cares if not everybody does it yet. It is a method that is growing and will continue to do so because it works.

Now you are on the cusp of changing sharpening forever. It too will grow because apparently it works.

Name me any other group that fundamentally changed a craft that has been around for at least 6000 years. You should be very proud instead of bickering like kids.

Re: Some accurate documented cap iron history

#18

Lunch box planer

Wiley Horne

David,

I plead guilty immediately. However, there are many, many times—most of the time I would say—when one must plane one side flat, in order to put the other side through the knives. How much perfect hardwood do we see, even if it’s already milled S2S, S3S, S4S?

I don’t have a machine jointer-planer, so usually need to make one flat side myself. Suspect many others do likewise.

Wiley

Re: Some accurate documented cap iron history

#19

Impact of unicorning

Winston

> The unicorn thing has been fun, but I suspect it won't make a great dent as the gurus who sell stones along with their classes aren't going to push it for chisels.

I think it'll have a much bigger impact than the double iron. There are a lot more woodworkers who use chisels than who use planes. There are a lot of woodworkers who aren't skilled at sharpening because they're intimidated, or because the stones are expensive, or whatever.

If all you need is a 1000 grit stone and a buffing wheel, and you can learn how to get an insanely sharp edge in a few minutes, that's a really big deal for most people. It's less of a big deal for sharpening experts who already have a pile of stones and the skill to sharpen a chisel freehand in one minute. But for someone who hasn't spent years thinking about sharpening and isn't interested in doing that, this opens up a lot of possibilities. In 15 minutes, I could teach a novice woodworker to get a sharper, more durable edge than almost anyone on this forum would have been able to get two months ago. That's a big deal.

Re: Some accurate documented cap iron history

#20

agree

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

One of the selling points, maybe the main selling point, of LV $100 chisels is durability. When LV went searching for a steel I think they were looking for a steel that could be taken to high hardness while preserving toughness for durability. They felt they could market such a chisel and they were right. Chisel users know about durability. Unicorn-Lite is a solution everyone can see and implement to achieve durability.

Re: Some accurate documented cap iron history

#21

The Rules of Contagion

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I received a timely book for my birthday today, whose title is in the title. Presumably this book will tell us how ideas and viruses spread. As soon as I learn what it will take to infect the woodworking community with Unicorn and Cap Iron Virus I'll let you all know. (I think we are using the term "cap iron" because that is how Mia translated the Japanese words for this thing that appeared in the translated articles and video).

Re: Some accurate documented cap iron history

#22

Re: graham blackburn...

Warren in Lancaster, PA

In 2011 I attended both the CW conference and the WIA in Cincinnati. Graham Blackburn was at the Cincinnati conference and I heard his lecture on the double iron.

I remember two peculiar ideas that Blackburn was very adamant about. One was that the cap iron needed to be sharpened every time the iron was sharpened. A few skeptics questioned him hard on this. I was sort of chuckling inside, imagining what a cap iron would look like after 5,000 sharpening cycles.

The other peculiar notion was that the cap iron distance from the edge needed to be the same as the shaving thickness. So if you were taking a .002 shaving the cap iron needed to be .002 as well. Because of the 45 degree geometry, this would put the cap iron tip down below the sole of the plane. Tough not to laugh.

In practice I don't think he actually put the cap iron that close. He had a plane set up for participants to try. The cap iron was way too close for the shaving thickness, so it left a horrible surface. There was no tear out, however.

In the 2007-2012 era, that is post Kato/Elliott and pre Weaver, Chris Schwarz and Larry Williams were claiming that the cap iron would not work unless it was placed within .004 of the edge. I think they were both light on experience, to put it mildly. A number of other people quoted this number, thinking that that is what Kato said.

Re: Some accurate documented cap iron history

#23

everything falls short once I know details...

David Weaver

too bad. I thought blackburn was maybe using it in practice, but it sounds like he understood sort of how it worked and the rest of the variables showed no real exposure in much work.

The bit of my article early on that has stood the test of working is not following the video (on hand tools) and what at first seems like a tight range of setting distance from the edge is actually very forgiving. I enjoyed the challenge to figure the thing out without measuring anything or looking under any scope.

I set the cap too close when I first started, it was easy to set it too close because it's so exciting that there's no tearout. Discretion in use (for results and effort) leads to less of that, but setting it enough. It's a very natural thing if it's just used in work.

2, 4 and 8 thousandths as measured (which I did later) under the scope look *very* different to the naked eye when setting a plane and looking for reflection of the iron edge. It just isn't as hard as it was ever made out to be if it's actually used. If someone wants to do it every 6 months, then I guess....i have no idea how that turns out. It's hard to do anything every 6 months and be any good at it, except maybe for using turbo tax.

Re: Some accurate documented cap iron history

#24

Re: Lunch box planer

David Weaver

I get no perfect hardwood, of course. When something can pretty much be planed from the start with the try plane, it's a treat, but if the thickness is different than finished, the jack work on the other side evens it all out, anyway. For anyone with someone asking for the finish product right away, the thickness planer is nice to have at that point, but I usually saw or thickness the other side. It feels like being cheated out of part of the work to not do it by hand if the wood is even mediocre in quality.

That may change over my lifetime.

Same with the jointer - I have no powered version, and I guess no power tool other than the small drill press and grinder that couldn't be hung on the wall. Air compressor probably wouldn't fare well hung on the wall, but it wouldn't be physically impossible with the little junker that I have.

Re: Some accurate documented cap iron history

#25

Re: Lunch box planer

Wiley Horne

I was just supporting your comment that everyone—even machine workers—need a plane and need to know how to use it. Very true!

Wiley