Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

strop only uni

Posts

strop only uni

#1

strop only uni

David Weaver

scraped off my clean strop and applied the yellowcake (in the interest of finding the fastest way to do the manual uni rather than using a really fine strop compound).

It took about 100 full strokes (or a good fraction of a minute) to get the same amount of edge profile on a chisel that the buffer does (the high speed buffer with the same compound takes about 5 seconds).

Many won't find the minute factor that much of a problem - but it does take two hands on the chisel and a fair amount of physical effort.

a shorter steeper edge curve may be a cheat to get almost the same benefit without doing as much work as the buffer does.

Edge finish is very good, but it's not quite as sharp as the buffer leaves the chisel.

Stone and then buff off the stone rounding wire edge is about half the work and half the time if done with swiftness.

for guide users, the earlier test of four strokes in a guide at 34 degrees with diamond on cast was almost as good as the unicorn, and almost as sharp feeling. The wire edge for all practical purposes fell off with that. No significant damage was observed with that, and when I did my test for the forthcoming article, only the sorby at 34 wasn't completely accommodated with a flat bevel.

The condition for the cast is that the lap needs to be really good quality and well done to work with 1 micron diamonds and not have the mill marks in the cast itself damage the edge at a fine level.

Re: strop only uni

#2

Re: How much is enough

Steve Voigt

Presumably you are determining how many strokes are needed by looking at the profile. Are you able to do this with the naked eye, or do you need magnification?

Re: strop only uni

#3

Finish on Cast iron substrate for diamonds

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

This comment comes with all the qualifications of my planing needs vs David's. I have used Blanchard ground cast iron plates now for many years. Blanchard grinding leaves large swirl marks on the plate. And I have some plates ground on a surface grinder to a fine finish. I don't experience any difference between using these different surface plates.

The purpose of this comment is to encourage trying what you have and see if it works for your needs. The level of success on a less than perfect piece of cast iron may be good enough.

The first chisel I Unicorned was 5 +/- strokes on 1 micron diamond on Blanchard ground cast iron followed by 5 +/- strokes on leather with green stuff. The chisel finished a set of 5 ash drawers. If you are selling a drawer where this chiseling is hidden from view your satisfaction with results could be different from plane making.

Re: strop only uni

#4

Once you've done the buffer, you can...

David Weaver

..get a good idea of how big the buffed stripe looks.

At 50 strokes, the dangling wire edge is also an indication that not nearly as much has been done because that is long gone very quickly in the buffing wheel, but if you just buff for a second or so, you can see what it looks like partially removed with the "stripe" not that well established.

Same thing with plane irons, it takes quite a while even at a steep angle just to get the wire edge off. Once the wire edge is gone, the strop doesn't really raise another one so i don't think it's an issue of stringing more wire edge out.

Just punching some calculator buttons, I'd imagine on the 3600 rpm buff, about 80-90 linear feet of wheel is contacting the edge each second and for some reason, the job that it does on the edge is keener than hand stropping. Adjust the number for the width of the cotton outside the stitch (so 5/8ths of buff material on a 1 inch chisel, 85*5/8 = 53 feet per second. Hard to match.

I never got militant about preaching the roll on the stone (it's a good technique) because most people first argue that it's not sharp, and half of the other 1-most get insulted if anyone suggests they're probably not finishing the edges of the tools as well as they think they are, or seeing damage ("i don't see any damage at my chisel edges, they all hold up well"). Also, I think it's still the case that the roll is dominant on chisels but protective and not dominant on plane irons (it's dominant for protection, but giving up a little bit of planed length in clean wood). Most people want one single paint by number way to work things. Thus, those kinds of nuances never get discussed. Most knife sharpeners show up on razor forums wanting to sharpen their razors the same way they sharpen knives, etc., and mechanical engineers who are close to machined tolerances in machines want to lay that on hand tools. It's not exclusive to woodworking

The roll felt as sharp, too, as well sharpened as flat facets, but it didn't feel sharper like the buff does.

Also, I expected that I'd post the original post about this and the post would die because it sounds dumb. I urged the roll on a few people, but I don't think any ever did it. "what angle is it?" i don't know what it is, who cares what it is. It's round.

Re: strop only uni

#5

cast plates...

David Weaver

i'm assuming the blanchard ground finish is similar to the one that Phil sent to me. For whatever reason, the grinding on that late looks like it's relatively coarse, but the plate cuts very finely.

I didn't find the same to be true with lapped plane soles or lapped mild steel plates - they would raise a wire edge on a chisel by themselves and I thought the problem was 0.5 micron diamonds cutting too fast and raising a wire edge.

The "try it" point is important, though - if 9 people have tried castings that spoil an edge and the person asking the question has a lap that doesn't, taking the advice of the other 9 isn't very accurate. Trying most of these things only takes a minute or two with a huge potential payoff.

Re: strop only uni

#6

Angle?

Winston

> scraped off my clean strop and applied the yellowcake (in the interest of finding the fastest way to do the manual uni rather than using a really fine strop compound).

>

> It took about 100 full strokes (or a good fraction of a minute) to get the same amount of edge profile on a chisel that the buffer does (the high speed buffer with the same compound takes about 5 seconds).

>

> Many won't find the minute factor that much of a problem - but it does take two hands on the chisel and a fair amount of physical effort.

What angle did you strop? When I tested with a strop, I used 40-45 degrees and pretty light pressure (like drawing a pencil line on paper), for just a couple dozen strokes. I had pretty good results with that. That process left a micro bevel that looked similar to what I got from the buffer, though it didn't hold up quite as well.

Re: strop only uni

#7

about 45 degrees

David Weaver

I could try again adding more "cake" to the strop, as I'd just penciled a few lines on with the wax bar and mixed them in with a drop of oil.

I had pretty significant improvement and a tiny stripe almost right away, but some of the wire edge remnants were more persistent and held on for a while. to duplicate the larger robust stripe too much longer.

The edge holds up well, though. it works, just as a stone roll does. I now realize that when I was rolling with a stone, I should've just done some light work to follow it with a loaded strop. It would've made for a better edge, but I was looking - as bill says - to be able to use a chisel for a long time. In my terms, I want to be able to mortise a plane with a chisel and still be able to pare sides without having to stop to sharpen a few times.

Diamond on cast is so much more aggressive, even for its fineness, that it may be more ideal for a hand roll, and if cast is found that isn't rough, it's cheap.

Re: strop only uni

#8

more cake

David Weaver

60 strokes on heavily saturated leather to get to this point:

(buffed chisel on right - both same brand from same set)

The light situation makes both strips look wider than the are, and I cropped this out of a bigger picture, so it didn't turn out as good as hoped. The buffed strip with better clarity is slightly larger.


Wire edge with more abrasive left much faster, but getting the stripe to be appreciable in small size was still a lot of work, 60 firm strokes, two hands.

Buffed chisel is mildly sharper paring despite the bigger buffed area, but they're close in sharpness. Didn't pound maple but would expect both to hold up.

Re: strop only uni

#9

Re: strop only uni "yellowcake" & leather question

John Aniano in central NJ

David,

Which compound is "yellowcake" again? Where did you get it? McMaster Carr? Part #?

Which side of the leather did you use - flesh side (inside) or the hair side (outside)?

Thanks

Re: strop only uni

#10

yellow compound product number

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Buffing compound can be ordered from McMaster Carr, Yellow is part number 4784A14.

Re: strop only uni

#11

Re: strop only uni "yellowcake" & leather question

David Weaver

Bill got it - there's three sizes of that at mcmaster.

I used horse butt smooth side out, but it's been used so much and scraped off so many times and has enough oil in it that it's pretty soft.

I would think bovine leather either way would be more like what it is now (hair or body side) as it's lost that hardness and tooth that the hair side of butt strip typically has.

Re: strop only uni

#12

Why the interest in Strop-Only Unicorning?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I am not understanding the interest in only stropping to get a Unicorn Profile. We know from the photographs what the edge needs to look like. We are already using something as the last abrasive step in traditional sharpening. It seems to make most sense to use the last sharping step we already use to at least begin the Unicorning profile to shorten, or even eliminate, the stropping.

Measured by edge longevity I successfully Unicorned a chisel with about 5 rocking pull strokes with 1 micron diamond, followed by about 5 rocking pull strokes on a strop that may, or may not, have done anything useful. Any final finish stone would have done the same I suspect.

How this all went down. I was dovetailing and Unicorning seem to provide meaningful benefit to the process. I asked David about stropping to that end as I did not own a buff. David said it could work but would be slow. It did not take much thought to see how to speed up creating the profile without a buff.

Re: strop only uni

#13

strop vs. freehand

David Weaver

I think a lot of people who rely on a guide feel comfortable stropping. Never surveyed why people are asking.

That combined with a group of folks who really don't want a buffer and may not want to be seen using a buffer (or saying they are).

My encouragement for the roll of the edge that you did on cast never met success with anyone that I'm aware of. I think people think it sounds nice, and someone (won't say who, it wasn't Wiley) told me that So yamashita does it on chisels that he sets up and sharpens for people.

I think for guide users, the roll sounds intimidating.

The next best thing to it is the tiniest of tiny 34 degree microbevels. That's the angle where most mediocre to good tools stop seeing significant edge damage. For anyone who hates buffers, hates freehand sharpening, etc, that's a decent way to go - replacing the unicorn edge with a tiny microbevel.

Re: strop only uni

#14

Re: cast plates...

E Phillip Smith

The plate I sent you is the same as Bill's plate. When we had those machined I think we made something around a dozen. On a large grinder you can grind several at the same time. Cost is in setup.

Re: strop only uni

#15

The significance

David Weaver

The significance of the finish on those plates is that the edges of the mill marks are not burred, and somehow the surface is very smooth.

If one is to attempt use a plane sole filed and then sanded to a fine finish, all of the marks in it from doing that will both hold diamond between the tooth of the sanded ridges (even if very finely sanded) and the surface of the ridges will cut edges and hone them.

I learned this the hard way. What i didn't think of at the time was the potential if one is going to use their own cast lap or try to improve an older piece of cast like from an old table saw, it may be possible to buff the surface of the lap to lose the tooth that the lap gets from sanding.

For whatever reason, the good quality blanchard grind didn't leave any of that toothiness on the plate surface and they were actually flat instead of sort of flat and sort of not in some places. A sanded plane sole or table saw scrap vs. the laps you had made is literally the difference between not working properly and working superbly.

Re: strop only uni

#16

Re: strop vs. freehand

Mike In Los Angeles

I asked about the strop because my four buffers are outside. If I made chairs and cabinets I might put one inside, but since I have electronics, finish, etc close by I’m not eager to start throwing compound around the place. Other people might have different reasons.

Re: strop only uni

#17

Re: strop vs. freehand

John Aniano in central NJ

David and Bill,

I really don't want a grinder in my "clean" shop, the one that sees customers (in non-covid19 times). So stropping would be better for me in that shop. However...

A good friend has a vintage hand operated geared grindstone unit he's going to sell me that I'll retrofit for my buffing needs. I already use something similar to hand drill holes in making and repairing bows. If that doesn't work well for the unicorning (now it's a verb) I always have my trusty Rusnok milling machine that can easily spin a buffing wheel. Plus the roll method works fine too.

Really, there are so many choices that have been thought of and tested here to establish that tiny, sharp, obtuse bevel edge, the unicorn of edges. Thanks to all!

John

Re: strop only uni

#18

sorry to catch you guys in the net...

David Weaver

..Mike and John, I wouldn't figure either of you as folks who wouldn't manage a buffer or have any issue with freehand honing.

Shop cleanliness or look are two legitimate reasons to not want a buffer (if I ever peddled double iron planes and went to a show and talked about working entirely by hand and then stuck a buffer at the end of the bench and said "I am becoming reliant on this", then people would make fun of me. Which just makes me want to prove them wrong rather than wilt :)

My net is intended more to catch people who say they just don't do enough sharpening to learn to sharpen freehand, or the considerable number of people who have asked (fewer now) through youtube comments and messages if I would just share the angle that the microbevel should be and how big it should be instead of talking about all of this buffer stuff.

I kind of feel like this whole effort is much like going bonkers examining everything in 2012 with the cap iron so the article would be relevant and so that I could test a bunch of stuff in the moment (the shape, angle and height of the leading edge, etc) and then sit on it instead of being stuck in an endless loop of still thinking further (something I might do).

Thus, I've done the stone roll for a long time, but didn't bring it up, because the perceived sharpness isn't any better, and because nobody ever bit on it. And then the strop, which I find to be much more work and physically dissatisfying and mentally unstimulating at that - but it can work if done long enough, and testing the yellowcake yesterday shows that it's fine enough. The finish from it is finer than a black oilstone even though it's monstrously aggresive on a hard surface).

Re: strop only uni

#19

Re: strop vs. freehand

David Weaver

Forgot!! I think you mentioned before that you have a felt wheel around somewhere...

on a hand crank grinder, it may be a better idea. A cotton buff is an enormous energy pig at high speed. The tool doesn't get that hot, the buff doesn't get that hot, but it probably consumes "full on bicycle pedal power". the heat must get dissipated into the air from the buff.

But felt is much stronger cutting (more efficient) and would probably be a good match to a hand crank grinder where you also have much more control over speed.

Re: strop only uni

#20

Re: strop vs. freehand

Mike In Los Angeles

I think any time you contradict conventional wisdom you’ll get pushback, and anticipating that pushback becomes part of the narrative. I’m not pushing back against the buffer, I think it’s great that you’re taking so much time and being so empirical about the approach and the findings. I would, though, expect you to want to compare the photos of the new thing to photos of the old thing, for your own curiosity and to head off some small percent of the foolishness that must be shaping up in your comments section.

When I found out that burn-in balm prevents steam blushing a lacquer finish, I got a lot of push back so I stopped telling people.

I think what you’re doing is super cool, I just know to keep the buffing stuff outside and I also know I would use this newfound information to better effect if I didn’t have to go outside to reap its benefits.

Thanks again man!