Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Unicorn knife edges

Posts

Unicorn knife edges

#1

Unicorn knife edges

Bruce Mack

I like folding knives. In reading posts on sharpening on BladeForums.com under maintenance, tinkering, and embellishment I have noted no coterie favoring power sharpening. There are many posts on guided systems using carriers for diamond stones and films at set angles, I use the KME system to reprofile new blades to about 13° on each side followed by the Spyderco Sharpmaker with ceramic rods set at 15°, giving me an easily maintained microbevel. The edges are sharp but not as sharp as those produced by some freehand sharpeners who can split hairs (see Michael Christy on YouTube). My edges do devastate cardboard cartons, making them good users.

I tried the buffing wheels on my drill using a Spyderco Delica ZDP-189 blade which has a hardness of 64 Rc. The metal has a lot of detractors ("it takes a lousy edge but holds it forever") but some virtuosi can make it sing. My attempt on the wheels left mediocre push sharpness in paper compared to the Marples chisels, but of course, slicing and not surface finish is the knife user's goal. For that reason, some with expertise prefer a toothy edge on their blades. Sharpening both sides of the edge introduces variability which defeats me but not others.

David- have you any experience or comment on this? I know knives are not the focus of your exploration but would value your experience.

Re: Unicorn knife edges

#2

Re: Unicorn knife edges

Winston

This is just speculation, since I haven't tried unicorning any knives yet, but I think that the angle at the edge is probably too obtuse. From the profile pictures that I and David have taken, the angle at the edge from buffing one side is anywhere between 45 and 60+ degrees. Do that on both sides, and, well, that's a really broad angle.

I think you'll want to avoid increasing the angle too much, which means minimizing time spent buffing. You may want to try sharpening the blade on pretty fine stones so that the buffer won't have to do too much work, then buff it quickly.

Another thing you could try is lightly stropping each side at a high angle (for a knife), like between 20 to 30 degrees.

Re: Unicorn knife edges

#3

Re: Unicorn knife edges

David Weaver

Two ideas- first is to buff at near tangent to the wheel for longer on both sides and then just light passes slightly steeper on both sides and then light passes on the wheel corner to strop.

The other is to precede the buff wheel with a gray deburring wheel to set a flatter rounded area and then buff more lightly. I've been sharpening knives with this combination for a while, only returning to the stones to reset geometry if it starts to get funny. It is superb for steels that won't take or hold a fine edge well. I can't get good edges in sgps with any hand method, it gives up pocks to stones and then strops slowly, losing its edge even to them. It has a nice sharp edge on deburr and buff, though.

Re: Unicorn knife edges

#4

i made a video - I'll post it. 


Re: Unicorn knife edges

#5

Re: i made a video - I'll post it.

Mike In Los Angeles

Can’t speak for anyone but myself, but I get so confused when there isn’t a cute acoustic guitar intro

Re: Unicorn knife edges

#6

Re: Unicorn knife edges

John Jardin

David,

Your friend George Wilson posted on SC that he is alive and well.

His post led to an interview of several years ago which is absolutely fascinating.

Re: Unicorn knife edges

#7

I could....

David Weaver

...make something up and play it, but I think youtube's algorithm would pretty much pick up any string of notes as belonging to someone else and that would be the end of that!!

Re: Unicorn knife edges

#9

George should be....

David Weaver

...on the national historic register. He is rare. He's fine, though. I haven't talked to him in a week or so, and am surprised that he's posting on SMC. I think he's just been sparing his energy for elsewhere the last couple of years (other than online forums).

He's just about the most genuine person I've ever talked to, as accurate as he can be talking about anything, and never overstating what he knows about something.

Re: Unicorn knife edges

#10

Re: Unicorn knife edges

John in NM

Years ago at a gun show there was a guy sharpening knives for something like $2/blade. He had two wheels on a grinder, both pressed brown paper, one charged with polishing compound, the other with just wax. Put an amazing edge on the blade in less than a couple minutes. I don't recall the edge lasting well, but I carried a Victorinox back then. I would like to see the same on one of my carbon blades or a good stainless, maybe those would keep it a while.

That memory is part of the reason I've typically stuck to harder felt wheels, but these guys have me convinced to try a stitched wheel soon.

Re: Unicorn knife edges

#11

I have been doing it routinely

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

First I should explain that for me a knife is a tool used for some purpose. The test of the sharpened knife, in the words of the Forge in Fire judge is, "does it cut? Hence, my test of efficacy after Unicroning is, does it cut better? In all cases the answer is yes. Obviously other's results could differ depending on where one starts and the goal.

I have Unicorned paring knives, slicing knives, and my favorite chefs knife. Pocket knives will follow as needed and in deer season my skinner. Sometimes Unicorning followed a quick sharpening on a coarse/fine combination stone and sometimes following a previous Unicorning.

My first Unicorning was a paring knife that would not easily slice a grape. A few seconds of Unicorning and it did. Success. When I have tomatoes to slice I don't want to spend 5 min sharpening a knife that is not up to the task. Tomaotes were the second Unicrning success. I was hooked.

Summary, for me it has been an effective way to refine an edge, that takes seconds.

Re: Unicorn knife edges

#12

paper and felt and leather

David Weaver

From what I've seen of those systems, they work great, too. I haven't seen a professional knife sharpener using a buffer, so they're probably better than my setup of deburring wheel and buff (just making what works well for other stuff sort of fit knives).

Re: Unicorn knife edges

#13

Re: I could....

Mike In Los Angeles

Was kidding, yesterday morning I was showing my girl all the YouTube guys’ acoustic guitar intros and cracking up at how samey.

Re: Unicorn knife edges

#14

When your videos are so bad...

David Weaver

that it's evident that you will just walk into the shop after mowing the yard and record a video without cleaning anything up.....well, the number of video jockeys on youtube who tell you how to improve them soon goes away.

I did, early on, get a lot of expert opinion about editing, etc, and it does make a better video. So would pre-planning and sticking to a script, which would just about kill me with my wandering mind.

Anyway, youtube's content creator messages often tell me the same things "add an intro to give users this or that (a brand to your videos, something recognizable?)"

I could actually play a small acoustic intro that wouldn't be from the library of free license music, but it would threaten my videos because of the let down in content after the guitaring!!

Re: Unicorn knife edges

#15

Re: When your videos are so bad...

Steve Voigt

An intro would really tie the room, I mean video, together. ;)

Re: Unicorn knife edges

#16

CCR, if it wasn't licensed!


Re: Unicorn knife edges

#17

Re: CCR, if it wasn't licensed!

Mike In Los Angeles

Those intro jingles are so corny! CCR has proven to be dangerous even for fogerty! Incidentally, I think his les paul custom has a 3/4 scale neck, haven’t played it but I remember hearing that.

I have a Buick Electra that elicits constant restoration advice, so much that I hate driving it and often hate being in public at all. But the Pontiac is so horrifying to car lovers that I can see them stop themselves from whatever lame thing they are about to say. Your videos are great how they are, at least to me.

Re: Unicorn knife edges

#18

Re: CCR, if it wasn't licensed!

Mike In Los Angeles

Also, since I haven’t seen it mentioned in this unicorn conversation, it could be important for the carving axe people, who I’ve heard mention a dearth of modern cheap axes with good steel/tempering.

Re: Unicorn knife edges

#19

could be...

David Weaver

..I don't know where the lower limit of taste is where the unicorn will still work.

Many of the small axes sold now are fairly low carbon and may not have much potential.

Thanks to youtube, I realize that there are a lot of options in the $25 range and the wranglerstar-ish type videos where people virtue signal about how they're being taken advantage of with a $25 axe that could've been "so much better" :\

The harder scandinavian axes are so much of a pain to sharpen if they incur damage because they can't really be filed that they may also be a candidate for this. Axe sharpening with cheeks is already sort of like this, but we generally do leave the point on when filing from the edge in and maintaining a cheek profile.

I appreciate the nice comments on the videos being tolerable. Even if they aren't for most, the whole produced video thing is beyond my level of interest. My interest is in what's in the videos and when we're experimenting with something like this (even as insignificant as it really may be), my thoughts are going a lot of directions at once, just pondering all of the details and trying to make sure I'm not missing something even better that's right in front of me.

To derek, that's going to sound like a manic phase - I could only wish I ever experienced such a thing - I am tired *all the time* - it's more like hypervigilance (never wanting to miss the next possible thing) and observation due to it combined with my own garbage bag mind (whereas most people have a filing cabinet in their head).

Re: Unicorn knife edges

#20

Re: could be...

Mike In Los Angeles

Let’s hear it for the lower limit of taste!!

Re: Unicorn knife edges

#21

I'd not tried a chisel before...

John in NM

Just plane blades. Did a real quick buff on a freshly beveled edge to cut some delicate inletting on a pair of grip sides for a neighbor's old six shooter. Effortless in the making (as it is with plane blades when I've done this) and effortless in pushing the chisel - very nice idea.

I think I will get a sewn wheel. Its hard to hold the blade on a felt wheel while cranking my grinder. For some reason I've always been afraid of overheating with this setup. Got to get a power setup and I think the more open wheel will be the way to go on that - I always worried about heat on the felt and a power grinder. I should stick it on a grinder and burn something cheap to see how bad is the risk.

Re: Unicorn knife edges

#22

Re: Unicorn knife edges

Bruce Mack

Thanks Winston and David. No variation I tried worked for me. I got greedy.

Re: Unicorn knife edges

#23

Side comment about the buck knives...

David Weaver

I was able to find the buck 110 in the video on a sams deal for $55 with a buck 120. Both are made mostly by machine somewhere in the northwest USA, and before the buffer, I always felt like "if these were hardened closer to chisel hardness, they'd have something".

I sold the giant fixed blade knife for the cost of both (on ebay) and put the 110 aside.

But introducing it to the buffer has fixed every little nit that I'd have had with it for carrying a knife that stays really sharp. That being, if you used something like one of those two-plane sharpening gadgets (i don't know what they're all called) and then you did something like cutting a bunch of cardboard, you'd have a little deflected edge all over the place, and stropping the wire edge less than perfectly led to just pushing it back and forth (knife shaves easy on one side, and not on the other).

All of that is gone. You can cut until it's dull, on glinty edge, no blunt feeling to get rid of the glinty edge.

Whether or not any of that is an issue depends on what you're looking for, I guess. But, I have seen a practical example of this in real life. My dad, who doesn't want to learn anything well - he just wants to buy stuff and use it. His hunting knife is a camillus carbon steel air force knife. All he knows about it is that it "gets sharp" and is "worth a lot to him". Those knives are made of 1095 and they're hard and they drop their wire edge easily, so it doesn't take much knowledge about burrs to understand what to do with them.

I've given him some knives over the years that are like the 420HC that buck uses. He can't sharpen them. He's carved birds before as a hobby and maintains his bird carving knives only with gold compound on leather. At some point, I suggested he deal with the lingering edges on his knives with his no-longer-used carving knife strop and a washita stone that he had that he called "worthless" because it was slower than his synthetic stones and still left a wire edge on the rubbery knives. You'd have thought he saw a ghost when he realized that he could finish the edge on the other knives and I showed him how.

He sharpened a few of the rada kitchen knives that they have in their drawers, my mom cut herself using one despite being warned, and he as forced to blunt them to put them back to the way they were before :)