Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Wood ideas for Monticello book presses

Posts

Wood ideas for Monticello book presses

#1

Wood ideas for Monticello book presses

Tony Wilkins

My wife wants me to build her some bookcases for her homeschool room. We decided on the Monticello stacking book presses.

The bottom box is 4’x18”x13” on the plans. I had thought of using dimensional pine 1x12 but not so sure about that decision. The main advantage of it was not having to glue up long panels. The local lumber yard is advertising sugar pine 1x12 but in number 2 common. I don’t think either BORG would have anything better.

So I’m looking for ideas of what would be good wood to look at using. It doesn’t need to be too fancy since it’s location and use.

Here is the project...

https://www.popularwoodworking.com/projects/monticello’s-stacking-bookcases/

Re: Wood ideas for Monticello book presses

#2

Wide boards beside poplar and pine?

Tony Wilkins

Besides dimensional Softwood lumber and poplar, are there any other woods likely to be found in widths approaching 13”?

I have not ever tried glueing up a panel anywhere near 4’ long. How much harder is it to get a good glueing edge on a board that long? If I can’t find 13” wide boards, I think it should be fairly easy to find boards 6.5 to 7” I. A good, inexpensive wood, no?

Re: Wood ideas for Monticello book presses

#3

Unicorn content

Tony Wilkins

Would it help get input if I promised to buy a buffing wheel for the project?

Re: Wood ideas for Monticello book presses

#4

Re: Wood ideas for Monticello book presses

David Weaver

Soft maple or cherry would be my choice, poplar if painting.

Most of the school stuff here is oak. It's not pretty, but neither is what kids can do to furniture over a long period of time.

Re: Wood ideas for Monticello book presses

#5

read only the first post...

David Weaver

..and missed the comment about poplar in the second one.

Cherry or soft maple would be my choice.

Re: Wood ideas for Monticello book presses

#6

Re: Wood ideas for Monticello book presses

Wiley Horne

Hi Tony,

There’s a lot of wood in that project. The best wood is what David says. But there’s also the question of how much money do you want in functional furniture for the kids.

If you’re going to use the plan dimensions, it’ll be quite a job finding 13” wide boards of any species, short of sending to the northeast for eastern white pine.

As an alternative, is there a Lowes near you? I have better luck here with Lowes than with Home Depot when it comes to lumber. If you need to join 8” wide boards to make your width, you may appreciate working with flat straight material. Lowes out here carries an appearance pine or whitewood (forget exactly the marketing name), in 8” and 12” nominal width (7-1/4” and 11-1/4“ actual). This wood is very flat and straight to start with, and you can highgrade the pile to get the best they have. For double the price, you could consider poplar in 8” or 12” nominal width—I can almost always find flat and straight poplar boards at Lowes.

Anyway, if there is a Lowes not too far, suggest go looking there. Look online first to check their inventory—you want to get there not long after they put up new stock. The new stock will be high-graded pretty quickly—you want to be the one to do the high-grading.

Wiley

Re: Wood ideas for Monticello book presses

#7

Poplar

Tony Wilkins

Not opposed to poplar but I’m using it on a bookcase and Dutch Toolchest. (Waiting on finishing up both as I have a shop building almost finished and I’ll have a lot more room to move around.). Both projects are wide single boards so I know I can find it. I’m just so tired of looking at it lol.

Re: Wood ideas for Monticello book presses

#8

There is a Lowes

Tony Wilkins

I’ll look there. I’m basing my aversion to the Borg boards on spongy white pine from Home Depot — horrible stuff for the Dutch Toolchest I started to build with it (went to poplar).

The wideness of the boards needed is definitely a concern. Part of the reason I thought about using 1x12s. I’m coming to a realization that I might have to join two boards (hopefully just two). My anxiousness comes in that it will definitely be an extension of a skill to join panels that long. I’ve liked working in cherry and have not tried soft maple, as David suggests. Cost is an issue but all wood is a little pricy out here 100 miles past the last real tree.

Re: Wood ideas for Monticello book presses

#9

Making (wider) panels

Jim Matthews

I like to get two boards that are mostly flat in the rough and get two jointed edges facing each other. The Big Dogs will achieve tighter tolerances than I can manage, but search "sprung" joint for thd approach I use.

(Tight at both ends, small sliver of light peaking through the middle.)

It's easiest to do (when rough) if the boards are match planed at the same time.

This can be done with Handscrew clamps, on the floor.

Choosing mostly flat boards to start helps.

When the glue dries, scrub and flatten the panel.

Bob Rozaieski has a straight ahead video demonstration...

https://youtu.be/JZAaCaOJhkg

Re: Wood ideas for Monticello book presses

#10

wider panels, match planing, & spring joints

Tony Wilkins

So here’s the question then...

If I were to combine match planing with a spring joint achieved through the method David Charlesworth uses in his planing video*, will that create a sound joint over the 4’ of the long boards? I’d be using a #7. I have used that combination on shorter boards with pretty good results**.

* Rozaieski video iirc shows a similar technique of stop passes with the plane as Charlesworth shows in his technique.

** on an 18” long tabletop for a Shaker table early in learning to plane.

Re: Wood ideas for Monticello book presses

#11

Re: wider panels, match planing, & spring joints

Gary Focht

I just built a Shaker desk for my son. Top is 60” long. First time jointing by hand. Used a Veritas low angle jack plane and match planed and spring jointed. Came out great but took a few trials for each joint to get spring joint where I liked it. Did not start out thinking spring joint, but that seemed easier than getting each board perfectly straight.

In short, you can do it.

Re: Wood ideas for Monticello book presses

#12

Things that weren't obvious (to me)

Jim Matthews

It will be beneficial to try all the steps on a smaller panel of similar thickness before the Big Show with large stock. It's a cumbersome process until you find a comfortable working height for each step.

I followed Terry Gordon's approach on my last project which involved matchplaning two White Oak panels, 50 inches long.

This approach lays boards flat - on their sides - with a plywood spacer underneath.

Terry covers most of the pitfalls in selecting which edge and direction, among other things.

It bears repeated viewing.

https://youtu.be/Sw_scdtQoFE

***

If the boards to be matched cannot be clamped together for planing, they will never yield a flat panel of any appreciable thickness.

Each board in question will have a "direction" that allows easiest planing.

Make sure those face the same way, when matching.

Get close to straight with *each board FIRST* before matching.

I use a small square to get a rough idea of the edges.

The plane blade needs to be at least 1/3 wider than whatever you're planing.

A little exposure of the blade on either side.

I like to take a clean "heavy" shaving from edges. If you can read a newspaper through the shaving - you'll be there all day.

******

These are big panels. It's ambitious to take this on. Setbacks are likely, but if you hold off on finishing the panel until after gluing up you won't lose hours of effort.

At some point before glue is applied you should stack the panels up and inspect the joint.

Handscrew clamps can hold a panel edgewise on your bench - clamp those *to the bench*

lest you have a physics lesson in the dark.

A sliver of light near the middle is enough.

If it's dead straight along the length - you're a prodigy. A successful "rub joint" near 5 foot long defines rarity.

*****

Practice clamping dry.

*****

Leave it alone for a day - don't even look at it.

*****

If the joint fails, rip along the glue line and try again.

Re: Wood ideas for Monticello book presses

#13

Reputable Dealers

Hank Knight

Most of the reputable dealers carry common American hardwoods in wide sizes. I recently bought a 5/4 figured walnut board that's 12 feet long and 16" wide from Groff & Groff hardwoods in Pennsylvania. I've purchased wide walnut, cherry and maple from Hearn Hardwoods, also in Pennsylvania. Wide boards are sold at a premium, and you have to add shipping on top of that if you don't live close, so it's expensive. But working with wide stock is really nice. Dressing wide stock is an issue if you don't have wide power equipment to handle it - unless you don't mind doing the old fashioned way. Most of these dealers will dress rough lumber for you, also for a price. I order most of my hardwood from dealers by phone and have it shipped to me. I've found them very helpful and easy to deal with. Call them up and tell them what you need. I think you will be pleasantly surprised at the service you'll get.

Re: Wood ideas for Monticello book presses

#14

Re: Reputable Dealers

Tony Wilkins

Thanks for the suggestions. I hope the local dealer has something because I’m a bit fearful of what shipping would be from the east coast.