Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

15 degree primary is a no

Posts

15 degree primary is a no

#1

15 degree primary is a no

David Weaver

Catastrophic failure. 15 primary, secondary bevel right around 20 or slightly below, then normal buff. Deep and immediate damage in maple malleting.

I think it may be tricky for the average woodworker to grind that thin, too.

Re: 15 degree primary is a no

#2

Picture?

Winston

Do you have a picture? I'd love to see what it looks like.

Re: 15 degree primary is a no

#3

Re: Picture

David Weaver


Less than 1/4 inch of maple chopping.

Re: 15 degree primary is a no

#4

Re: Picture

Les Groeller

Is it possible that that this is a new chisel that has a millimeter or two of less than adequate metal right at the tip. If I recall correctly David you were waiting for a new PM-V11 chisel for this test? Might it need to be ground back a bit?

Re: 15 degree primary is a no

#5

Used Footprint

David Weaver

This is a used wooden handle sheffield footprint chisels. It's a good chisel and re-establishing the bevel at a steeper angle (without adjusting the grind) and then buffing the tip over again yielded good performance).

I think in this case, the rounded tip was probably fine, but the bevel behind it wasn't enough to keep the rounded edge from breaking off or getting pushed back into the secondary bevel.

The damage didn't come close to getting into the grind itself, as you can see, and resetting the secondary bevel (which probably removed a few thousandths) to something closer to what's described elsewhere solved the problem (there is a concern of mine with very thin grinds, and that's the practicality of doing them without introducing a lot of heat over a thin cross section. I'm sure a metallurgist could describe, but I get the sense that a thicker cross section is much more efficient at transporting heat generated at the edge into the thicker body of the chisel. This is with a broken in 80 grit CBN wheel, too.

To the extent that heat is mostly unavoidable, I'd think something like a tormek is more appropriate for such a thin grind -it would be possible to maintain by hand, too, but tedious due to the shallow angle.

V11 behaves differently than the other steels in the unicorn. I did grind a bit off of the V11 chisel that I tested, though, with a wet paper towel laying on the chisel -because of V11s somewhat different behavior, and slow grinding and creation of much more heat grinding, I used the footprint chisel.

These chisels are spec at 61 hardness, or similar to the AI MK2. One of the last good mass produced chisels from sheffield that later got a clumsy grind (some seemed to just be rebadged late sheffield marples) and then went overseas - I have no experience with the ones made outside of England. Long story short, they're pretty good chisels when you can find them, and with patience, not that expensive (perhaps $50 for an NOS set of 4)

TMI, I'm sure.

Re: 15 degree primary is a no

#6

Re: Used Footprint

Les Groeller

Thanks for clearing up my confusion...trying hard to follow the play by play! 😊 As a hobbyist, one that works wood in fits and starts, the practices that result in repeatable (good) results need to be a simple as possible and this “unicorning” should help, without a doubt. Thanks to you and all the rest who have contributed!

Re: 15 degree primary is a no

#7

Re: Paring

Steve Voigt

I wonder if it might hold up for paring only. I get that for the purposes of testing, you and Winston (and others) have focused on chopping, and durability is getting the most emphasis, but the possibility of reduced effort when paring is equally interesting, at least to me.

15° is kind of a pain to grind, but high teens is not so bad, and i could see doing that, honing at around 20°, and then buff or strop. Will try to give it a go soon.

Re: 15 degree primary is a no

#8

Re: Paring

David Weaver

It's possible that it might hold up. I'm sure there's almost a magic point where an edge goes from being bad to being good.

corners where I usually see the first wear on a paring chisel outside of planes (from slicing into a marked line from right to left or left to right). I'd be concerned about them at lower angle, too, since they have support only on one side.

Re: 15 degree primary is a no

#9

Re: Paring

Wiley Horne

Agree! If we’re talking about paring end grain, as in paring to the scribe line, I am finding that it is at least as hard on the tip as mortising. Which is completely non-intuitive.

A possible explanation is that tip damage (chipping) comes from shear, when the chisel is forced laterally in the cut, either by inadvertent hand-steering or wedging action of the bevel. Plus breaking through the paring cut into a shock when it hits the backing. Whereas mortising, if you avoid heavy levering, which I do, involves driving the chisel into support on both sides, so that shear is avoided because the lateral force generated by the bevel when the mallet hits the chisel with a shock, is avoided by the chisel tip burying into support on both sides. Just my theory.

I tested an extreme paring situation with a light 3/8” Imai White steel chisel—got chipping with flat bevel in the low 30s, and zero chipping repeating the same test after buffing, with attack angle 2 or 3 degrees higher. The test was paring off 3 lineal inches of red oak, taking approx. 1/32” per slice in 80 cuts, each slice 5/16 wide and 13/16 deep (to the backing).

Wiley