When Unicorn-19..
David Weaver
...jumps borders and starts to infect their threads, I don't think some folks will handle it well.
A method that takes 30 seconds and costs less than a high grit finish stone will be referred to as "too complicated"

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
When Unicorn-19..
David Weaver
...jumps borders and starts to infect their threads, I don't think some folks will handle it well.
A method that takes 30 seconds and costs less than a high grit finish stone will be referred to as "too complicated"

Re: Predictions
Steve Voigt
Based on my experience from the cap iron saga, I predict both good and bad things will happen.
One the bad side of the ledger, people on forums will argue, dismiss it, misconstrue it. YouTubers and bloggers will present it as their own idea and hog the credit. In four or five years, magazines will write about it, without attributing credit where it's due.
On the good side, eventually lots of people will adopt it. I have not been able to experiment yet, but based on what I'm reading, it's a lot like the cap iron in that it requires touch, discernment, nuance, so it will never become fully mainstream. But as with the cap iron, it will change the way a ton of people work, and allow them to get good results from very plain chisels, just as the cap iron has allowed people to do great work with bog-standard planes.
I should set a calendar alert to reread this post in exactly eight years. 
easy to do
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
it's a lot like the cap iron in that it requires touch, discernment, nuance, It is nothing like the cap iron. All these requirements may be necessary to tease all that Wiley and David get from it. But so far nobody has failed to get the speed and robust edge advantage.
I'm a make something ok to store your socks kind of person. Touch, and nuance is not my strong suit. If I have to go there it ain't fun. You don't have to go there to improve a chisel edge enough to easily see the improvement with on eye shut and the other squinted.
you'll be pleased...
David Weaver
...if you shallow the primary a little bit on a chisel, hone a shallow secondary and then just buff the chisel edged at something like 45 degrees to the wheel surface until you see a small shiny stripe, that's pretty much it.
I haven't really found any way to unintentionally screw it up.
Once the cap iron becomes familiar, it's easy to see that it has a pretty generous working range, but developing some sense with it is probably a lot harder.
I do recall posting the cap iron article and then about a month later getting PMs from a few people that Chris Schwarz was posting blogs about starting to use the cap iron and that "I should go read his blog if I'm interested in the cap iron and would like to learn more about it".
If Chris was a pirate, we'd call him a sawbuckler. he does nice work on the books, though, and that work aside from a printed stinker or two (modernized commentary that one may think was intentional trolling because it's so far off base) has probably helped a lot of people who start in a vacuum.
I would recommend starting a different place
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
I would start a different place. Do what ever you now do to sharpen a chisel. When done, buff for 3 seconds. If you have a metallurgically challenged chisel the result will be obvious. If you have an excellent chisel ground at an angle where it is already robust you may not see a benefit starting here.
I don't have any intention of regrinding the 28-30 degree primary bevel on any of my chisels until they need substantial resharpening. Then I may go to 25. Maybe eventually I may get to David's 20. But the advantage of 20 vs 25 or even 30 is minor to me compared to the improvement in edge robustness for what I do.
The next advantage is for advanced chiselers- more acute chisel grinds. Go there after comfortable with step 1.
Agree, what I found is
Wiley Horne
that buffing turns out to be very forgiving. You will not damage a chisel, even on the first try.
But. You don’t know that in the beginning. Follow Bill’s advice and wade in from the shallow end of the pool.
Everything David says is right—and David is the originator who has rediscovered this approach—but you’ll be comfortable with Bill’s start.
Wiley
Re: you'll be pleased...
Rafael E. Herrera
Let us know when Chris blogs about it ;-)
By the way, finding David's article about setting the cap iron was extremely helpful to me, thanks again David.
Great article on the same topic in Mortise & Tenon issue six, Steve.
That sounds like a challenge...
Jim Matthews
"I haven't really found any way to unintentionally screw it up."
I will, no doubt.
I am late to the party here
Richard Darjes
I have been following this discussion of buffing chisels as a last step in sharpening, although I have not read every post, so I may be adding something that has already been discussed.
I was fortunate enough to attend Woodworking in America in 2010 where Marc Adams presented on sharpening chisels and scrapers. He used Sandvik chisels with red plastic handles that he had used for years. His technique involved pushing the chisel into a buffer wheel bevel down as the last step to "remove the burr." I thought he attributed the method to someone like Taig Frid, but I could be wrong on that. It clearly worked when he demonstrated it, but given what everyone else who taught sharpening at that time was saying, it felt like I was watching some kind of magic trick that seemed too simple to be true. I do remember grimacing when he shoved that chisel straight into the buffing wheel - no way that could do anything but round over the edge! But the chisel cut a hanging piece of paper just like chisels sharpened all the other ways.
He didn't make any special claims for this being a "better" way to get chisels sharp, just that this is the way he did it and it was a fast way to get the chisels sharp enough for him over the many years he had been using the method.
The presentation was early, like 9 am and it seemed to me that the people in the room were just like me- we just didn't get it. I gather he has continued to teach this method of sharpening chisels, but it hasn't taken the woodworking world by storm up until now. I do think the current discussion that includes microscope pictures and explanations of why it works will go a long way to adding this approach to the sharpening arsenal of more people.
Re: I am late to the party here
David Weaver
I remember hearing at least at one point that Friday used a sander and then another with a cork belt to sharpen. My parents live a couple of miles from supergrit, and they have cork belts, so I figured I'd give it a try.
Their cork belts beat up edges, and that was that. The devil is always in the details, I guess.
Why David moved the needle
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
As a means of modestly improving sharpening it has an uphill battle to overcome everyone's inertia that already is satisfied with what they are doing.
Almost everyone that is chopping dovetails sees chisel edge damage that requires more frequent sharpening. When David reported that mushy Sorby chisels did not deform at an astonishing 20 degrees , that was the potential for a huge improvement in performance for an inexpensive chisel. I sold a set of Sorby because they were too soft to dovetail with. When Winston showed that he could Unicorn a Buck and it would perform competitively with a LV, that was a needle mover.
Sold as a better means of sharpening the method may never have gained interest. Demonstrated as means of turning an inexpensive chisel into a durable one, that got people's attention.
So, the needle mover was recognizing a new benefit more people could take advantage of.
Amazed and delighted
Bruce Mack
I took my 3/8" Marples chisel (yeah, the one with the deformed edge from paring) and sharpened it to 1-micron diamond paste on cast iron, followed by stropping with the chromium oxide on leather. It was sharp. I took this 25 degree bevel and held it to the buffing wheel at about 45 degrees for ~5 seconds. I then pared end grain cherry until I tired of the waxy shavings, and found the edge to still push-cut card stock like nothing in my experience, including a Koyamaichi. After further tinkering, I thought maybe the edge was dulling. Ten more seconds on the cast iron, 10 on the strop, and 5 on the buffer, and again I had the sharpest, the easiest, the most durable, and the most amazing edge I have ever coaxed from a chisel. Thank you, David!!
Re: Amazed and delighted
Winston
Excellent to hear that you got it working right away!
I think that you'll find that you'll be able to skip the finer stones, diamonds, and strop, and replace all of those steps with buffing.
Re: Amazed and delighted
David Weaver
I'm happy to see this. I think Bill's favorite thing from this is the ability to step up underperforming chisels, and that's certainly the biggest gain.
Expensive chisels (Generally, the robt sorby chisels are actually pretty expensive) still do a little bit better than substandard chisels, though, especially in regard to their edge fineness.
Some of that could literally be attributed to my use of a washita on the backs of the chisels in the test, though (the scratches in the sorby from a washita are much deeper than a chisel closer to Rc62 hardness).
Re: Amazed and delighted
Bruce Mack
My favorite result is sharpness. I have never obtained such sharpness from anything. A close second is durability. I think I recall the late Chris Hall resharpening frequently to maintain the surface off the blade that he wanted. Cost, speed of edge acquisition, and transformation of mediocre chisels are not important to me but, even here, this method seems to excel. Toss the Shapton super-fine, remove the ritual, call off the hunt for the last blade forged by the immortal bladesmith, and get indecently great edges with little effort. I have loved the search for better edges and will miss it.
Re: Amazed and delighted
David Weaver
Me, too, probably on the order of 400 stones in and out, with at least 100 remaining here. I still love them. I have achieved the same level of sharpness, but never in combination with durability and achievement of the sharpness level consistently is not quick.
Or, in short, even when achieving that level of oxide sharpening completeness, the edge doesn't last.
Examining razors gave me an indication with hand sharpening just how much work is involved if you're really going to go to the no-visible scratches level vs. something more typical like the black ark/shapton 12000 level which is quite a bit more coarse.
Even the wonderful 1 micron diamonds, which are fast and fine, don't provide a feel equal to the cheap 5 micron calcined alumina bar on the buff.
I suppose a buffer isn't a job site tool, but japanese tools take an even sweeter edge off of the buffer than do the softer tools.
Re: Amazed and delighted
Wiley Horne
Hi David and all,
Like Bruce, I’m really pleased. In my case, it’s with hard Japanese chisels. Mortising in red oak. I have done three repetitions with an Imai 1/4” mortise chisel (white steel #1). Each mortise was the chisel width, 1-1/2” long and 1” deep. In each case, I logged 100 strikes with a vera wood mallet, almost as hard as I could hit (harder than for an actual mortise). That got me to the depth and width, though I should say I don’t do heavy levering with a mortise chisel. Preparation: Chisel was sharpened flat bevel to ~31-32 degrees cutting angle, newsprint carving sharp; buffing then took it to 34-35 degree cutting angle. Result: zero chipping in any of the tests. I never had a bad chipping problem, but would occasionally lose a tiny triangle off a corner in some woods, like in satinwood or hard maple.
So. Buffing is great for soft chisels. And also for very hard chisels. Deals with folding and chipping.
Wiley
Re: Amazed and delighted
David Weaver
our testing isn't getting the lost corners thing ,but I gave up using japanese chisels at shallower angles both for the edge chipping, but also because an ouchi set that I had came sharpened around 25 degrees. When those chisels lost corners, it was spectacular.

The buffed corners can look pretty drastic, but I haven't had any work that didn't get completed cleanly.
Same scale as all of my other pictures, so the roundover looks large, but the really steeply rounded part is only a couple of thousandths.
My favorite chisels (i have no clue who the maker is, they're a slightly thinner set of oire that I got from japan's version of ebay) were the sweetest in the test. Same effort more or less as V11, slightly better sharpening and less edge failure. they are hard enough that if you get rough with them, they could shed a corner, but I think this method will result in less of that.
They cut facets on the butt of a chisel now that look like they've been waxed. Literally - so clean that the cedar looks darker and is shiny on end grain.