Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

There's a humorous thread...

Posts

There's a humorous thread...

#1

There's a humorous thread...

David Weaver

...on the blue forum about sharpening, that's heavy into dogma about bevel types and wire edge removal.

One thing I like about this forum is the group is far enough along not to get into dogma about sharpening single bevels vs. multiple if the business part of the edge is doing the same thing.

The arguments about wire edges damaging stones are entertaining!

Re: There's a humorous thread...

#2

Which is the blue forum?

John in NM

I only read this one....

Wire edges damage stones? That's a good one, they sound like rivet counters over there. Best one I heard at work (where they should know better, being rocket scientists and all) is that low speed operation is really hard on ball bearings. Oh, that and that aluminum is stronger than steel :D

Re: There's a humorous thread...

#3

Re: Which is the blue forum?

David Weaver

sawmill creek.

It's a much more diverse group and the owners kind of frown on what we're doing here, which is trying to make definitive progress and weed out the "everything is the same, and we're better off if we just all agree with each other and nobody disagrees"

It's hard to "fine" any discussion over there because the demand from moderation that all points of view are equally valid means the one in ten accurate and correct statements just get lost.

Not knocking that it's around - it's tempting to feel like you have good advice to provide over there because of the level of discussion, delving into what's true and what's OWTs like we do here causes hurt feelings and locked threads.

Re: There's a humorous thread...

#4

Re: Which is the blue forum?

John in NM

Gotcha. I never liked the atmosphere over there, haven't been back in 12 years or so.

Re: There's a humorous thread...

#5

Not my preference, but...

David Weaver

..I'd say it's not my preference. It's not good form for me to say something about another forum on this forum. I'll admit.

I will say in their defense that there are a lot of long-time members there who like the format.

I "met" george wilson over there when I posted a saw that I was proud of as a first saw and wedge my phone number out of me and called and said "I'd like to talk to you about some improvements you can make". He more or less said "i see something that tells me you can do better work". I thought it was an obligation that I didn't want to pull around.

George's friendship has been one of the greatest things I've ever run into on the internet. I've talked to him on the phone literally hundreds of times - it turns out that most of the things that I'd like to learn to do well, he does well.

That aside, I have to remind myself that while I'm often staying in a very narrow lane so as not to do a bunch of things that feel like a waste time after I do them, there are lots of folks who don't have the same drive, or who want to make more things than I do and get no charge out of really pushing into the minutiae. I'm glad that all of the forums around exist. This one remains the only one that seems to have continuous appeal to me because we can have such an obnoxious overdetailed discussion about something as simple as sticking a tool into a buffer and instead of it turning into an argument, a whole bunch of people try it instead. And then those who try it, contribute to trying to make it better.

I'm thankful to ellis for that.

I've made an attempt or two at getting george over here, but I think his ship has sailed on forums, and he was born before WWII And finds the site harder to navigate. the fact that it takes some effort to navigate probably works as a light protective barrier for us.

Re: There's a humorous thread...

#6

Two different camps "over there"

Jim Matthews

Most of the actual builders that make furniture of things for homes congregate on the main power tool forum on TBS (the Blue site). That's the "Look what I made" camp.

The handtool forum tends toward tool collecting and deciderata of rare or unobtainable things (of marginal utility). That's the "Look what I found" camp.

*******

I try to keep in mind that for the vast majority of us - this is a hobby.

We're genuinely fortunate when experienced makers are generous.

Re: There's a humorous thread...

#7

Re: Which is the blue forum?

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Some years ago there was a discussion about stropping and rounding the edge on Sawmill creek forum. Among the participants were David Weaver and me.

Re: There's a humorous thread...

#8

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Re: Which is the blue forum?

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Keith kicked Bill Grumbine and me off about ten years ago. Supposedly we ere both "Banned for Life."

Re: There's a humorous thread...

#9

Re: Two different camps "over there"

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Most of the actual builders that make furniture of things for homes congregate on the main power tool forum on TBS (the Blue site). That's the "Look what I made" camp.

The handtool forum tends toward tool collecting and deciderata of rare or unobtainable things (of marginal utility). That's the "Look what I found" camp.

*******

I try to keep in mind that for the vast majority of us - this is a hobby.

We're genuinely fortunate when experienced makers are generous.

Jim, that is generally true for WoodCentral as well. The Messages forum tends to be where builds go these days. One of the reasons for this is that there are few, if any, builds that are purely hand tool only. Most also use machines. The greater percentage of threads on the Hand Tool forum are about sharpening or steel composition. I am not knocking this, just stating a fact. If you want to discuss construction or joinery or design, there will be more interaction on the Messages forum. I post builds simultaneously on the two fori as I believe there are some here who do not venture there. I do hope for discussion.

On other woodwork forums on the web, there is a great deal of "look what I bought!", and links to videos made by others. These resemble a club-come-Facebook experience, and which is hardly satisfying to someone wanting to further their woodworking knowledge and expertise. These are the forums for the new generation starting out. The "old timers" have largely left the building.

Sawmill Creek is closer to WoodCentral than those here may appreciate, but in more ways resembles the Australian forum, where there are several fori that deal with different areas, and within them there are ongoing discussions at levels between moderate to expert. Very few absolute beginners at SMC. A number of the members here, including myself, Jim and Warren, frequent SMC on a regular basis. David used to, as did George. They chose to leave. SMC is poorer for their absence. I do not blame the rules there for this. There are rules everywhere and they are not that different.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: There's a humorous thread...

#10

Why I hold your work high in esteem

Jim Matthews

Your website and willing engagement in these "fori" (foramen?) coupled with beautiful proofs of your concepts are exemplars of what a group like this *can* be.

It illuminates a path already cleared.

It's exceptional when someone who is genuinely accomplished willingly shares what they know.

*****

I'm coming to the end of hand tool only purity. While it can be done, the physical toll is no longer trivial - nor are the results satisfactory as my standards rise.

Kudos to you and the other Big Dogs who patiently engage Newbies who ask the same questions posed by us all.

Re: There's a humorous thread...

#11

Re: Which is the blue forum?

David Weaver

I'm guessing you guys must've turned a couple of pens and sent them to someone other than their "not for profit" organization :)

Re: There's a humorous thread...

#13

I'm well supplied

Jim Matthews

I get my dose every night, before bed.

It comes with a handy pull tab, in 12 ounce containers.