Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Testing stropping at a high angle

Posts

Testing stropping at a high angle

#1

Testing stropping at a high angle

Winston

I know there have been a LOT of posts about this topic recently and I don't want to add noise, but I figured that this was worth sharing. This time I did a test with a chisel stropped at a high angle.

After honing the 30-degree bevel on a Shapton Pro 1000, I stropped it at about 40-45 degrees, using a strop loaded with 1 micron green compound made by JacksonLea (ordered from McMaster-Carr). To remove any burr, I lightly stropped the back of the chisel a couple of times, and then did a couple passes on the bevel and then the back again.


After stropping, the reflection from the tiny microbevel at the edge looks like this:


The process of stropping can vary depending on pressure, amount of compound, etc., so I can't recommened an exact procedure with particular number of strokes or anything like that. If you try this, what you want to do is strop your chisel until it looks like the one here. And maybe keep stropping some more. (More on that later.)

The test is the same one I've been doing: chop off total twenty pieces off the end of a 3/4" thick piece of soft maple, with each piece 1/16" wide. This is what it looks like at the end.


I actually ran two tests with a stropped chisel. With the first test, I didn't get quite the edge durability that I had hoped for, so I honed it and stropped it again, but this time I slathered on more of the green compound, and I stropped more times. Maybe 20 or so? The result: it held up almost as well as when buffed. It's possible that more stropping would have done better, but I don't know for sure. It's still miles ahead of the flat-honed chisel, and close enough to the buffed chisel that I think it's a completely usable alternative to buffing.

One thing I've learned from this experience and others, if the edge isn't as durable as I expect, I just go back and do more stropping/buffing, and it helps durability without increasing cut resistance. Other than perhaps my first couple of tries, I don't think I've ever over-buffed (or stropped) a chisel, to the point where the edge was rounded or dull; I've only under-done it.

In the pictures below, you'll see that the initial condition of the edge isn't quite as good as the buffed chisel, and it develops a bit more damage in the test. It's possible that more stropping could help, but that's just a guess at this point.

This is the initial state of the chisel:


At the end, the chisel could still easily shave hair. To the naked eye, it looked completely undamaged. Under the scope, you can see there was a little edge damage, but still almost nothing compared to the flat-honed chisel. This is what it looked like at the end.




Based on this test, I think it's fair to say that stropping can provide most of the benefits that buffing does. If you have a strop sitting around, I suggest trying this out: strop a chisel at a high angle (I did 40-45 degrees) and see how it works for you. If the edge doesn't hold up dramatically better, try stropping it some more and see if that helps.

Re: Testing stropping at a high angle

#2

Deficiency easily overcome

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Deficiency being defined as many stropping strokes to accomplish the desired profile.

Everyone is going to be doing some refining step before the strop. A few, for me it was about 5, rolling pull strokes on this final media accomplished what many more on the strop would accomplish. As I recall I was about 5 on the "stone" and 5 on the strop to achieve a robust edge, the one I made the 5 drawers with without edge damage.

You make a key point about "overdoing it", namely it is unlikely overdoing it will lead to an undesirable result that will be annoying to recover from. This fact should comfort the beginner.

Re: Testing stropping at a high angle

#3

Re: Testing stropping at a high angle

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

It would be informative to see a picture of the stropped profile compared to the buffed.

Re: Testing stropping at a high angle

#5

I have a few thoughts on this...

David Weaver

..maybe nobody wants to hear them.

I did the "roll", or the unicorn for a few years on stones. at some point, I have posted several times that beginners start the sharpening foray looking for stones that work really fast for whatever their claimed grit level is.

Eventually, if you do enough woodworking and you freehand hone everything, you find that slower stones are faster than faster cutting stones. They give you control to do things like the unicorn.

I've also used a strop to do it, hard and leather, but I have a real aversion to something that maybe others aren't bothered by - the tiny defects that happen in an edge if there are any contaminants on the surface of a strop or a hard stone. you can make efforts to keep contaminants off of your strops and hard stones, but it just adds to the work.

I haven't done this with a spyderco, but the following are really good for a rolled edge:

* a completely settled in trans or high quality black stone (if you want buffer sharpness, then followed with a little bit of stropping)

* an aluminum oxide solid fine stone that I found from japan called "barber's oilstone" I can compare scratches from it at some point. it's slow compared to shaptons and kings, but it gives you the precision to do something like this quickly. I've been using it for quite a while

* diamonds on wood (have to charge often, but finish level is really high).

* diamonds on cast (have to strop afterwards and mind the pressure - I think the edge of a chisel can be bent a little bit with pressure, or possibly chipped off).

I'd bet whatever paul sellers is doing kind of unicorns things at the tip of a chisel, but the method to hand hone the rest of the bevel is goofery.

All of the hard surfaces above are super sensitive to any contaminants on them. anything at all, you get a notch.

Leather surfaces get a piece of wire edge? Stray piece of metal or abrasive particle? You get a notch.

The real beauty of the buffer is that it does four things:

* it either absorbs or expels contaminants

* it does an amount of physical work that we can't hope to duplicate in terms of time. This amount of work does what I see most people not doing - completing the sharpening job.

* it can take a very cheap abrasive and the issue of wax build up, etc, on a flat strop (large amounts of green stick or any stick need to be applied with extra oil or WD 40 so that the abrasive still moves around) is nonexistent on a buffing wheel. I've never cleaned my wheel - the chisel itself acts as sort of a comb vs. buffing a flat surface

*the give in the wheel takes a fairly coarse fast yellowcake (that's what I'd call that yellow stick if I marketed the system :) ) stick and makes an edge finer than anyone can hone in any reasonable period of time by hand.

The cost of most of my slow stones is the same or higher than a buffer, though. The japanese stone that I mention is great, but the only way I've seen to get it is to sort through antique store lots on yahoo japan (where they're selling 25 or 30 stones - sometimes there's one or two in those lots). They remind me of a spyderco, but they're not so cheap with material as the spyderco stones - they're 8x3x1 and stay put better.

Re: Testing stropping at a high angle

#6

Re: Testing stropping at a high angle

Steve Voigt

Great test Winston. I suspect a lot of people (like me, John, etc) have some interested in a non-motorized approach, so this is super useful.

One question: are you always honing at 30 for these tests? I know Dave stressed the idea of a sub 25 bevel prior to buffing, so just curious if you've tried that.

I hope--when I get around to unpacking my chisels--I can test both possibilities. I'm sure there are some tradeoffs between durability and reduced cutting resistance, and it will take some effort to find the happy medium.

Re: Testing stropping at a high angle

#7

Re: Contamination

Steve Voigt

I have a real aversion to something that maybe others aren't bothered by - the tiny defects that happen in an edge if there are any contaminants on the surface of a strop or a hard stone.

You definitely aren't the only one--this is a constant issue for me (and we've talked about it before).

I've mostly neutralized stone contamination by removing India stones from my normal honing routine, and only using them when necessary. The Washita and trans Ark are hard enough that bits of steel rarely get stuck in the surface, so assiduous wiping with oil and occasional resurfacing with a diamond stone keeps my oil stones pretty clean.

Stropping is a whole 'nother story. I've never found a good way to avoid burr remnants that will quickly foul the edge and make stropping a harmful rather than helpful process. A virgin or newly resurfaced strop is great, but things can go down hill quickly, and resurfacing a strop is a time consuming pain.

I kind of figured this is where you were going with the buffing wheel--that contaminants aren't as much of an issue. As much as I like the idea of manual stropping I can see why the buffing wheel would be attractive.

Re: Testing stropping at a high angle

#8

Re: Testing stropping at a high angle

Winston

I've been using a 30 degree bevel for all my tests so far, but not because I think it's optimal. It's mostly laziness -- that's what the chisel started at, and if I wanted to compare a flat 30 degree bevel to a 25 degree buffed/stropped bevel, that's just more work, especially if I want to go back and forth between those conditions.

Based on others' experiences, and my understanding of how it works, I have every reason to believe a 25 degree bevel will hold up just as well, and of course, move through the material more easily.

If you're feeling bold, you could even try out lower angles, like 20 degrees. Hm, maybe that's worth me testing out. Chopping with a 20 degree bevel would surely be a different experience than with 30 degrees. With these cheap chisels, there's not much to lose even if there's some sort of horrendous edge failure.

Re: Testing stropping at a high angle

#9

Re: Testing stropping at a high angle

David Weaver

I'll volunteer a chisel or two to test a shallower bevel angle. My primary is already at 19 or 20, so I'm not sure what's practical, but 15 may be doable without issue.

the first natural step is to round over the tip and eliminate failure. The second natural step to shallow the bevel behind the round over comes when you find you have an unfailing edge, but separate fibers in softer woods (or you just get the urge to find something for nothing, or at least less of something else).

i'm sure the single example of oddly sharpened chisels that I have was given a delicate primary in the range of 15 degrees (straight razors are generally around 16 degrees or so, but they're double bevel - looking at one laying on its side gives a good idea of what the primary would look like).

I would be surprised to find that the edge on a 15 degree primary and a 18-20 degree secondary would fail from proper use. But at some point, we'll find out when folks who can't resist the urge to twist a chisel a little to tear fibers off will manage to break off a triangle of metal.

I have so many chisels that potentially damaging one or two is an afterthought, and much current and past toolmaking gives me a good setup to regrind. It's a matter of 2 or 3 minutes.

Someone on the UK site mentioned when I brought this up that long ago, they used chisels with a shallower bevel and just sharpened the tips, and that at one point, they were urged or curious to go to a higher angle and have hated it ever since. That suggests to me that changing bevels on chisels is going to be a big deal to the average person.

For anyone who is pondering this and dreading the possibility of burning an edge, rather than spraying water on chisels or dipping in cups, consider putting a small wad of wet paper towel (very wet, like dripping) under your thumb or fingers to hold the bevel of a chisel on a grinding wheel. This may sound fiddly, but the edge won't burn even if the paper towel is a small fraction of an inch behind the edge (it'll just get sloughed off by the grinder wheel in the event it gets too close to an edge, and it doesn't have enough strength to be grabbed and turned into a disaster).

Re: Testing stropping at a high angle

#10

Re: Contamination

Winston

For a while, I've had a strop with 1 micron diamonds, but I rarely used it. In this test, I used a new strop with fresh compound. So I haven't had experience with strop contamination causing damage.

Is the damage from contamination that you guys have experienced large enough to cause problems for a chisel?

Re: Testing stropping at a high angle

#11

Re: Contamination - stones vs. strops..

David Weaver

steve is talking about the tendency of india stones to pin with particles that come off. For example, if grinding with carborundum, and then honing with an india stone, some of the stuff that sloughs off of the edge can get pinned on the stone surface and really ding the edge.

I don't want to suggest you watch any of my videos, but in the one that I just posted unicorning plane irons, I reached for a block of wax that I pulled off of the floor. It had a small brass particle on the edge. That wax is very soft (Despite being hard for a wax) and you can drag it backwards over the edge of a plane with no issue. But the single small flat filing of brass notched the edge, and the next shaving was split.

The pinning on an india stone can be a lot. What I've found with leather strops is that eventually, something will get in the strop that spiderwebs a polished area. It will sometimes also spoil edges. On a chopping chisel, this is an annoyance (especially given the size of edge failures we've seen).

Steve is paring show surfaces. It's intolerable on those, even if the notch is a thousandth.

For finish planing, the same is true. The notches are usually big enough to split a thin shaving, but a thicker shaving will stay together (giving an indication of the size without having to go to a scope to see them).

Bill is a good calibrator for zeroing in on this part - where I'm getting annoyed by things that wouldn't bother most people.

The top side of a scraper, by the way, is good for scraping slough off of a leather strop (won't hurt the strop, even if there's a burr - it'll just cake over the edge) in the event that the offending particles can't be found. But even then, sometimes said stuff is left behind in the leather only to annoy again, and more scraping is needed.

The buffer becomes the missing link in that there's little question of effort, there's absolutely no real chance of precision to get lost in - who could possibly grasp what's actually going on where the buff is? It's immensely complex and varying and not worth worrying about. It just does the job quickly and gently at the same time.

Re: Testing stropping at a high angle

#12

Perspective

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

If you are building planes for a discriminating woodworker clientele you can fret over these kind of issues. After all, it is a few inches of show chiseling. If you are knocking out a 7 drawer bureau for your sister in law and your brother is waiting on a desk, you probably work to a different standard.

Some of the things David is concerned with are of no importance to many people building furniture in a mixed power hand tool shop. In other cases a perfectly chiseled surface brings joy to some even if the surface never sees a pair of socks stored within it.

One needs to know what sphere their woodworking occurs in, especially beginners. If a beginner takes to heart the concern over some bit on a stone resulting in a 0.001" line on a chiseled dovetail socket they risk getting bogged down with irrelevant worries and never make a piece of practical furniture. On the other hand, a piece of practical furniture may not be a goal. An hour of peace in the shop may be the goal.

Re: Testing stropping at a high angle

#13

Profile picture

Winston

To get this picture, it probably took me 20 minutes to get the microscope, mirror and all that set up, but I finally managed to do it. All that stuff is really fiddly and I had a hard time keeping dust off the blade. Anyway, here's the profile of the stropped chisel. The red lines represent the original profile of the blade before stropping.


This is the same chisel, from the test where it was buffed.


*****

Using an online protractor, it looks like the angle of the stropped chisel very near the tip is around 50 degrees, maybe slightly more. The blurriness of the image makes it hard to tell exactly where the apex is.


The angle of the buffed profile was closer to 60. Again, it was hard to get an accurate location of the apex, and if anything, the angle was even greater than 60.


The larger angle may explain why the edge had essentially no visible damage at all in the buffed condition.

Re: Testing stropping at a high angle

#14

Well said

Jim Matthews

This is perhaps the best description of nuance I've read, and an explanation of why paid instructors apply dogma when training beginners.

When starting out *any* repeatable method will do. It's only after sawing a half mile or planing a basketball court can a user register feedback from tools and materials.

"If a beginner takes to heart the concern over some bit on a stone resulting in a 0.001" line on a chiseled dovetail socket they risk getting bogged down with irrelevant worries and never make a piece of practical furniture."

(Practice musical scales until automatic)

"On the other hand, a piece of practical furniture may not be a goal. An hour of peace in the shop may be the goal."

(Music theory and composition)

Kudos

Re: Testing stropping at a high angle

#15

Re: Contamination

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I have been stropping (clean leather) since 1965. I stopped sanding in 1978. Since then everything that has gone out the door has been straight from a stropped tool: planing, turning, carving, moldings.

I am not having contamination problems. I am sorry to say that I can't think why my routine might be different.

Re: Testing stropping at a high angle

#16

Probably because...

David Weaver

..of things you don't do in your shop.

I do some metal work (by hand, but by had still creates filings) in the shop, some saw filing, sometimes repair of other things. My powered grinder is 20 feet away, so it's not the cause of any of this.

When it comes to razors, I learned long ago that the best way to avoid strop contamination is to hang the strop vertically. Whatever may be around in the basement (I'd never leave my razor strop in the shop), which is much less than my shop, not much can settle on something hanging vertically. This would probably be true sans wire edge particles ending up in strops in the shop, even with some metal work.

But I have to admit that I have zero interest in covering strops, putting them away or hanging them up every time I sharpen something.

This includes attempting to tease all of the wire edge off on the finish stone so that it doesn't get to the strop in any significant amount.

As i enter my mid 40s, my eyes and my brain's coordination with them are getting worse. My vision as checked when I was 40 was 20/12, but age-related fatigue is setting in (as I can see things close very clearly, but adjustment to close things isn't as fast as it used to be and the result is pain). I probably see more than the average person does. If strop contamination is something you've never seen, I would probably have seen it somewhere.

If you've never had any bit of a wire edge disappear into your strop and foul anything, I find that to be unlikely unless your work volume is very low. There is some missing data on that end, too. We don't know what kind of work you do because even verbal descriptions are missing. How many planes, chisels and carving tools are sharpened in an average week? What is the nature of the work (making furniture, carving, repair, sash, mouldings? What proportions, and what volume?). Is this work your sole or primary means of income over that period, and if not, what is?

Regardless of any of this, the buffer is tolerant without as much care (even living adjacent to and below a power grinder, unlike my strops), and it's faster, even if just using a clean edge to strop.

Re: Testing stropping at a high angle

#17

Re: Probably because...

Warren in Lancaster, PA

My work has been varied, all of the things you have mentioned. I have probably sharpened 50 to 150 tools per week, so around 5000 a year for decades. I had very good eyes when I was young, tested better than 20/20 also. When I was 49 I started using reading glasses for carving, but could still read the stock pages, which had small print.

It just could be that I sharpen often enough that the burrs are pretty small, but I know others who strop their tools, especially carvers.

Re: Testing stropping at a high angle

#18

Re: Probably because...

David Weaver

it could be any number of things. even different leather.

But I will make no claims about my shop being contaminant free. One thing I decided early on was that I could either do all of the things I mentioned in one spot, or I could make things complicated and section everything off. I figured that before I section everything off (And get duplicate benches, etc), I would give doing everything in one area a shot and it's generally not been an issue. spiderwebbing a blade may be something that happens one every 20 with a strop. If there's a layer of dust on a strop (even if it's just settled from sawing) then I scrape it.

There have been cases where the contaminant is metallic (most likely wire edge, I don't file over the strops - they're a few feet away), but I don't generally try to figure out what it is, I just scrape the leather (which must not remove much of anything other than swarf as I've never thinned out the leather on a paddle strop to the point of disuse, and I only have two that I use regularly).

I have no clue what it's like to work with metal using power tools in general, or high speed belt grinders, so I'll defer to the folks who demand shops be separated by wall or door where that's the case.

As far as contamination, I'm not the first person to mention this, though usually when I see it come up as a forum topic, the notching is much worse than just webbing. Tiny webbing doesn't necessarily split a shaving or show up visible to the naked eye, but it does leave lines on work, and the higher the level of surface polish, the harder it is to hide it. One of the reasons that I like to finish plane off of a settled in washita - uniformity seems to be easier.

The blinding reflectiveness of the method discussed here recently would make finish planing somewhat more difficult, but the case is the same with japanese planes.