Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Solving this mystery of oval bolstered chisels..

Posts

Solving this mystery of oval bolstered chisels..

#1

Solving this mystery of oval bolstered chisels..

David Weaver

It's apparent to me, though people who haven't made chisels before are suggesting that they can't see why (on the UK forum) that my IH sorby chisels are fairly old and unmodified. Two of them are. The other two have only been used enough that the primary bevel has been chased a little steeper due to sharpening laziness - something I haven't corrected yet, but the roundover retains the original mill markings, which look like a powered wheel mark (probably silica) as the remaining few marks that peek through have little tears in the soft iron.

Thinking back to having used prior versions of these chisels (I sold the others when I found a matching set) with tall cross sections and a single bevel (which I prefer on smaller mortise chisels) the friction in riding a bevel that large, especially if it wasn't hardened steel, was pretty appalling.

I think to an uninitiated user of these, one guesses that the long factory bevel on them with a roundover implies they're used back to the work rather than bevel ridden, but I think given the UK forum assessment that they weren't standard kit, but rather something used in production work on deep mortises and perhaps in timber work, the intention is to ride the small round over deep into the mortise and in my experience, the shallower primary bevel allows the chisel to get further into the mortise before the top edge unintentionally bruises ends (something that was a problem with a large single bevel), but the tall cross section still works really well to rotate and push waste away from the cut line).

It's no secret that I like the economic argument when proving something out. The sellers gimmick video with glass has a lot of people claiming that nobody knew what they were doing and these chisels are just useless and clumsy (and a marples blue chip is much better) but separation in performance occurs quickly when mortises get bigger and the mallet grows to take advantage of the chisels' design.

I didn't go back and read any of Joel's post to see exactly what he said, but I think the roundover (the one at the top of the cross section, and not the roundver of the edge) makes moving these chisels a little bit to get some relief to break chips off far easier than a sharp top. That's important when the cut is deep to allow you to raise the chisel just a little bit to rotate when it's buried deep and forgoing the relief in favor of just muscling a deep cut out will lead to broken something and dented wood (or broken out wood).

Now, the search for catalog pictures of the older chisels that seem to have been sold with the round over (ward, I&H sorby) is fruitless, though I got plenty of answers about chisels made in the 1900s (where catalogs were more common). The folks over on the UK forum who do more book reading than building suggest that catalogs from these marks in the 1800s when they were with their original owners (IH sorby was sold around 1850) are very thin on the ground. That's a bummer.

I also suspect that the early ward and IH sorby chisels were better than most of the other makers as they appear to be more crisp and refined, but I suppose at some point, sheffield makers agreed to all charge the same price (and by then, I think the IH sorby mark was decades into subsequent ownership).

There's so much supposition about this or that during that period that it's hard to get a good answer. One of the responses supposed that I probably had modern chisels because the postage stamp maker's mark was too deep to have been made by hand, and didn't have enough flair in the serifs. I don't think that would be hard to disprove, and a subsequent search of the mark showed that IH sorby never really did have bold serifs and really thin lettering. Making a deep stamp on brightly heated wrought iron isn't very difficult compared to making it on wrought that's heated only to something like mid orange.

So, other than figuring out what way the chisels like to be used the best (the least effort, which is an economic argument - something masters and workmen would've figured out unless guilds disallowed improvement on an economic basis as a threat), I'm out.

Re: Solving this mystery of oval bolstered chisels..

#2

Re: Solving this mystery of oval bolstered chisels

Warren in Lancaster, PA

This is a complicated subject. Some mortising jobs were gradually taken over by machines in the 19th century. There was a fair in 1836 in which "very many new mortise and tenoning machines were exhibited". Because of this, it is more difficult to talk about mortise chisels in the 19th century than the 18th. It is difficult to know which trades continued to use hand methods and for what purposes.

After 1800 it seems that the mortise chisels became more robust and then split into the joiner's mortise chisel and the sash mortise chisel. This distinction does not seem to exist in the 18th century. I have seen a number of references to cabinetmakers using the lighter chisels. For a mortise like for a cabinet door that is fairly deep and not too long, a heavy Joiners (oval bolster) chisel is very clumsy.

Joel Moskowitz once published the method of mortising he was taught by Fraser. It involved setting the gauge 1/16 wider than the chisel, boring out the waste, and then cutting to the line with a mortise chisel and a paring chisel.

Frank Klausz grew up working in his father's shop, which had a mortising machine. I laughed when I read his 1979 article in Fine Woodworking where he was riding the back of the chisel to make a mortise by hand. By 2007 or so he was riding the bevel. Even an Old World cabinetmaker can learn hand methods here in America.

So yes, it is a complicated mystery. The 18th century is less complicated because the tools and techniques were more standard.

Re: Solving this mystery of oval bolstered chisels..

#3

The best I can figure of these from actual use..

David Weaver

..is bevel down and riding the small rounded bevel to avoid the friction of the long bevel.

Anything is possible. I could be guessing wrong. I guess on the roundover (on the top side of the larger chisels - larger in cross section) being a feature of factory grind because of how neat it remains on the very longest low wear chisels.

Once it's redone and the bevel is chased back, it gets sloppy (as in, whoever tries to refresh things doesn't do a very good job, or in some cases, the roundover is removed and the bevel is shallow but perfectly flat). I had a small group of these (a harlequin set) used and none remained neat as these do, but none were uniformly as long as this set, either.

It sounds like there's an information vacuum. I can only comment what these are good for. Mortises 2 inches deep and 3" long or better, they separate themselves from anything else I've used. Shorter than that, and the roundover is not far in the material and the extra size doesn't do that well.

I doubt they were ever used with a drill pilot hole - I'd imagine they were used end to end bevel down with the bevel being ridden, and the roundover on the back makes them hang up less inside of the mortise and slip over the edge of a mortise easier. They are fast to use without any help and lever out nice long neat chips that aren't wedged off or broken.

I would like to find a catalog of older IH sorby and ward items from the early-mid to mid 1800s, but it sounds like the only chance of that is buying books about those makers (there is apparently a comprehensive book about all of the sorby makers), and that's too much outlay for what may be a potential guess at features in the books, too.

The millwork chisels that we have over here don't behave the same way in a mortise (their cross section is closer to square). I have no idea how those were intended to be used or who they were intended for.

******

I should not have argued about this as much last week, either. It's fruitless given the lack of much publicly available information. It creates an endless loop if the conclusion of likelihood isn't the same each way, and I didn't know what your experience with these chisels was until you mentioned you had one that was poorly maintained. If I had two sets, I would send a couple and you could mallet a few deep mortises with them. As long as the small bevel is ridden, the strength of them (staying aligned, working quickly, pulling the material out of the mortise in a long thick neat leaf, even when it's deep) is apparent.

Re: Solving this mystery of oval bolstered chisels..

#4

Re: Solving this mystery of oval bolstered chisels

joel moskowitz

Warren,

You misquote me. You can bore out the waste but that wasn't how I was taught. On normal sized mortises it just doesn't save much if any time. (On big timberframe joints drilling out was the norm)

The method I was taught by Maurice Fraser was to scribe the mortise in any width you want, then use the next smallest mortise chisel you own (max undersize will be 1/16" then part to final dimensions. While I was taught this method by Fraser, it's actually the identical method described in Moxon.

I was also taught to go from top to bottom an a mortise, but there are so many ways of chopping, (which I haven't bothered to compare) that I have no way of saying if one method outshines the other.

Re: Solving this mystery of oval bolstered chisels..

#5

more pictures of roundovers..

David Weaver

..hopefully, this won't end with me finding a primo set of chisels and buying them.

https://www.oldhandtools.co.uk/edge-tools/2-military-heavy-duty-all-metal-chisels-by-f-g-pearson

An interesting military all steel pair of chisels from WWII. The top side of this chisel shows the same neat round over with the same finish as the rest of the chisel. No user would be able to repeat this. I have no clue what's going on with the second chisel, but it must be used to clear the bottoms of mortises or pry something. It retains part of its factory roundover even though it doesn't look like it would function with it. I have absolutely no clue what someone would be military mortising in WWII that would require the toughness of all metal handles, especially given the wide spread availability of power tools.

It looks like the user has neatly chased back part of the edge to ride the bevel on that flat. No clue where this would've ended if they'd used the chisel longer.

https://www.oldhandtools.co.uk/edge-tools/slim-cast-steel-mortice-chisel---332-inch

a chisel without the roundover, the top has been ground off. One could speculate that was factory until it's clear that the grind was done to the bevel, too. Once again, a smaller bevel to ride is maintained (my guess from experience being that I had one of these in the past and put a big 35 degree single bevel on it and the friction was enormous, and rotation in the mortise wasn't very good).

https://oldtools.co.uk/collections/mortice-chisels/products/3-vintage-mortice-chisels

a set of 3 - the one in the middle is stamped 1945 and the bolser is homely - I think the era of making these with much intent other than for the few who still wanted them was probably over (the UK board guys said the last one of these was made in 1971. not sure how they know that unless someone published that they were making the last one).

The chisel on the right is easier to see, but again, smaller bevel and round over.

None of these chisels look like they were used "unprofessionally" or sloppily.

https://oldtools.co.uk/collections/mortice-chisels/products/john-green-mortice-chisel-6-5mm

green, all steel, rounded. No way to tell if it's original, but the rounding is neat.

https://oldtools.co.uk/collections/mortice-chisels/products/3x-mortice-chisels

3 more. I can't tell much about the center one. The bottom one is neatly rounded (3rd on the right isn't oval bolstered).

https://oldtools.co.uk/collections/mortice-chisels/products/2-mortice-chisels

interestingly, one has two bevels and the other is hollow ground. No clue.

Comment in a long tang mortise chisel prior to this listing shows another one rounded over like the military mortise chisel and says that a user ground the chisel end rounded to use the mortise chisel as a round scraper on a lathe.

https://oldtools.co.uk/collections/mortice-chisels/products/3-kenyon-mortice-chisels

no clue. can't believe they'd have come like that - like the hollow ground one, they don't match any others.

https://oldtools.co.uk/collections/mortice-chisels/products/old-moseley-simpson-oval-mortice-chisel

this one looks shortened and the top isn't crisp, but the rounding isn't as wide of a radius nor as neat. Has a small secondary bevel, though.

None of these look to be recent use, but the use of a single bevel on any of them seems to be uncommon. I didn't exclude anything from either of these retailers except for those with pictures that you can't tell anything.

There were several pigstickers ground round or to a V - the listing for the large tang chisel suggests that all of them were probably modified to use for turning.

What's interesting about many of these as they're out there in great length. I'd imagine that it was hard to find many mortises outside of some production area that would've been deep enough to use the chisel type more productively than anything else.

Re: Solving this mystery of oval bolstered chisels..

#7

Re: Solving this mystery of oval bolstered chisels

joel moskowitz

Ah- These are Maurice's class notes. IIFC when I took the class he discussed an we practiced both ways. He personally favored boring the mortise's out with a drill press, but I never liked that method. I found (and I just don't remember when I started doing it "my way" ) that the drill holes weren't worth the time and could make the chisel wander. Also wasting material out with a mortise chisel is FAST.

In class he would start with the chisel and scribe larger because we weren't doing a specific project and we didn't have every size of chisel available. But for real work it was always figure out the size then pick the next chisel smaller.

Re: Solving this mystery of oval bolstered chisels..

#8

the military chisels..

David Weaver

..a closer look at one of the pictures shows that both have the round over, but that both are also rounded laterally in profile and probably never used for mortises but rather as lathe tools.

Which is another strike against the idea that they wouldn't have been rounded on the back from the factory.

Re: Solving this mystery of oval bolstered chisels..

#9

popularizing drilling and paring...

David Weaver

..this must've been an artifact of people trying to make mortises that would have through tenons sticking through.

On small work, it has some sense of putting socks in a ball, putting them in a shoe and then trying to put the shoes and socks on that way.

(of course, i tried all of these when I was a beginner).

I can see where it would make more sense in a very large mortise as it somewhere above 1/2" , deep mortises start to become shoulder torture and in green wood, the persistent "jammed socks" in the mortise wouldn't be so hard.

Re: Solving this mystery of oval bolstered chisels..

#10

I think it's a different artifact....

John in NM

There is a persistent theory that machine work is automatically faster and more accurate than hand work. Sometimes it is, sometimes it isn't. The owner of the shop I worked for would visibly cringe when you picked up a chisel to clean mortises :D

I've never seen the point in the drill and pare method. That is slooooow!

While a hollow chisel mortiser is faster than hand mortising, I've never found that it was worth setting up and using for just a couple of them. Up to about 6 mortises I go for the chisel as my machine has a huge bit in it by default. If it lived with a 5/16" bit installed I would use it more for the odd cabinet door and stuff that I typically now do by hand.

Re: Solving this mystery of oval bolstered chisels..

#11

Re: Solving this mystery of oval bolstered chisels

Mike In Los Angeles

This thread is really interesting and seems to be part of an ongoing conversation, is it possible to get a link to earlier in the conversation so as to have a better grasp of what’s being discussed? Apologies if I have missed the back story when it should have been easy to find. Thanks

Re: Solving this mystery of oval bolstered chisels..

#12

I think it's a fractured bunch of stuff...

David Weaver

..there is something that predates what I suggested that causes some tension with warren (joel's blog, maybe? I haven't gone back and read it other than maybe a brief glimpse, but vaguely recall it saying that pigstickers were rounded over).

There is little on the ground from the mid 1800s in England other than a marples catalog showing pigstickers, and it doesn't appear that any of the marples chisels have the round over. Most of the used versions don't, either. Also with that, their pigstickers have a less tall cross section (I've guessed from use that the taller that the chisels are, the more sense it makes to have the top of the bevel rounded over).

Warren took exception to the fact that I suggested some of the makers rounded these chisels over at the top from the factory because chisels before them don't show a round over, marples doesn't, and then there's a vacuum of what you'd find from ward or I sorby or ibbotson (i think the ibbotson were also rounded over, but ward and i sorby all have this similar roundover if it's done neatly (when a user chases a bevel back and redoes the roundover, it doesn't look as neat).

My supposition also with these is that I've used some with and without that have a tall cross section and the ones that have a sharp transition at the top of a thick (tall in profile) chisel are miserable to use and they don't move very easily inside a deep mortise. As soon as you go to rotate them, you have to fight them to move up or down to adjust where you're rotating (for example, to pull them up just slightly to sever a section of chip off where it doesn't break loose easily and just pulling harder may chip the edge off of a chisel). Chisels that have a nice gradual roundover move around very well in rotation in the bottom of a mortise, but to get a feel for it, the mortise has to be pretty deep, or the angle of attack shallow.

It's a stark thing inside of a deep mortise, and you cannot tell just how stark it is until you use one next to another with and without the roundover.

The next issue was whether or not the whole bevel profile was traditional - 25 degree primary more or less, the roundover, and then a steep small secondary bevel. I think the answer to that is yes for two reasons - friction and penetration. If you leave the cross section on a 3/4" tall chisel as a single flat pane (especially if the chisel is laminated), riding the bevel in a mortise creates a huge amount of friction - it's very obnoxious.

I have no proof of anything, and frankly, nobody seems to. We have one catalog from that era and most of the chisels from that brand look like they did in the catalog. The others that don't look like those, we have no catalogs showing pictures of them or drawings of them (ward and ibbotson), but the round over on a chisel that's not short always looks far too neat for the average person to maintain, and when full length, the top roundover has the same finish as the rest of the chisel (suggesting it's never been stoned or reground unless it was part of a concerted refinishing effort by someone very skilled).

This leads to another question - why are there so many of these chisels near full length? They couldn't have been cheap, especially the larger ones with really nice quality grinding work and precise proportions. I think it's because the bevel setup that works well for fast work in deep mortises (getting off the full bevel and riding only a small part of one) pushes the roundover on the back of the chisel so far away from the tip that the depth of the mortise at the ends needs to be significant for them to be worth using.

We're left with a lot of supposing. Supposing that catalogs from different eras or different makers are proof that the roundover wasn't factory, and supposing that so much consistency from those with roundovers is proof that they were factory created. The thinness of literature from mid-1800s england vs. mid-1900s doesn't answer much.

In terms of getting actual questions answered, the UK forum wasn't worth too much other than to clarify that there really isn't a lot of catalog literature from that time and the only real chance of finding pictures of factory ground chisels like that is to start buying books made about each brand where they're available.

phew.

(my guess in all of it after improving penetration with bench chisels by rounding over the edge and modifying the rest of the bevel is that the same modification on a mortise chisel as that has a lot to do with what I'm looking for - to reduce the amount of work it takes to do a given task).

Re: Solving this mystery of oval bolstered chisels..

#13

Re: I think it's a fractured bunch of stuff...

Mike In Los Angeles

Thanks for that explanation. This layout does seem to fracture a conversation, and it seems a lot of the ideas being shared are tossed into a long-spinning hopper that will just take a little time to catch up to. Thanks for your generosity in elaborating.

Re: Solving this mystery of oval bolstered chisels..

#14

Re: I think it's a fractured bunch of stuff... *LINK*

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Over the years I have posted maybe 20 pictures of mortise chisels that were published between 1667 and 1900. I could easily post more. All these pictures have two things in common: no rounding of the heel and no secondary bevel. In the 21st century a number of people have claimed that mortise chisels were used with a long primary bevel perhaps 20 degrees, a very short secondary bevel, and a rounded heel. They have offered no documentation, but David has found some mortise chisels which he believes are mint from the factory after 160 years or so, and do have the long bevel and round heel; I can't see them as well as he can.

Here is a mortise chisel profile from Andre Roubo, a third generation master woodworker, printed in 1769:


17th and early 18th century mortise chisels were thicker at the bevel and taper toward the bolster (They taper in width slightly also). You can see a hint of this taper in the engraving, but it is more noticeable in the full illustration. Later mortise chisels tapered in thickness the opposite way, thicker at the bolster.

As I mentioned sometime earlier, after 1830 there were mortising machines available, so there is some mystery about which trades continued to use mortise chisels and for what purposes.

Here is a link to a recent discussion David alludes to:


Old drawings

Re: Solving this mystery of oval bolstered chisels..

#15

Re: I think it's a fractured bunch of stuff...

Mike In Los Angeles

Thanks, Warren, that’s helpful. As an uninformed newcomer to the debate, I wonder if both profiles weren’t widely used at different places and times? You could say “people used a wooden horned plane,” and you wouldn’t be wrong?

Re: Solving this mystery of oval bolstered chisels..

#16

Re: I think it's a fractured bunch of stuff...

Warren in Lancaster, PA

You could say people used horned planes because we have pictures of them from the 17th and 18th centuries. We also have pictures of planes without horns from those centuries. We don't seem to have pictures of secondary bevels on mortise chisels from the hand tool era.

Re: Solving this mystery of oval bolstered chisels..

#17

Re: I think it's a fractured bunch of stuff...

David Weaver

I can't imagine that every shop would've quickly gotten a mortising machine shortly after 1830. I don't know who the pig stickers were marketed to, but one account on the uk forum was that they were intended at least in some cases for production mortising.

Re: Solving this mystery of oval bolstered chisels..

#18

Re: I think it's a fractured bunch of stuff...

David Weaver

We have plenty of pictures of period chisels with long thin bevels that wouldn't have held up to mortising without steepened bevels added.

The drawing on this page shows a rounded over back as well as the bevel top. Note the flat chisels shows a defined line showing a single flat bevel with a sharp transition.

https://toolsforworkingwood.com/store/blog/629

Re: Solving this mystery of oval bolstered chisels..

#19

Re: I think it's a fractured bunch of stuff...

Mike In Los Angeles

I can see how a chisel prepared like yours would reduce friction and bruising, I've bought used chisels prepared that way but I never considered if they were manufactured that way or not.

At the risk of derailing the topic, do you chop bevel down in both directions? I learned to ride the back in one direction and ride the bevel on the way back.

Re: Solving this mystery of oval bolstered chisels..

#20

Re: I think it's a fractured bunch of stuff...

David Weaver

Yes, always bevel down. But not dogmatically, it just seems easiest.

Re: Solving this mystery of oval bolstered chisels..

#21

Re: I think it's a fractured bunch of stuff...

Mike In Los Angeles

I’ll give that a spin, I have been doing it like Bill Carter shows in his youtube. My mortises are big wide ones, wider than my biggest chisel, mostly in hard maple, so anything that helps is welcome.