Re: why
David Weaver
steeper angle of attack on a plane is associated with two things:
* higher wear rate on the iron
* lower ability to start a shaving and less downward force created by the planing action itself at the start (They go hand in hand, I guess).
I noticed with the moulding plane irons that I could visually affect little but the very edge on the face of a beading plane and still greatly reduce tearout without having to do anything fiddly around the very edge. I think it may be difficult to work both sides of the edge in very small amounts, get a reasonably uniform result and keep it.
I found when I was testing irons that the ruler trick was "ok" policy until you scrutinized the edge itself and made the pictures of the irons photo perfect. I did the ruler trick only on 1 micron diamonds, but the bevel itself on a steel rule eventually got longer and longer.
I could very well have decided that I would only do the ruler trick to an extent that would not chase it to be larger and larger, which is an issue when removing wear that compounds quickly (if it gets bigger, then the action of just removing the wear gets slower and slower) - but that would have left us with irons in the test that had some visible wear grooves remaining somewhere on them (but felt otherwise sharp).
I believe that carbon steel (better than XHP/V11) still maintains a uniform edge better in less than ideal situations and the reason that warren prefers it and I've gone back to preferring it for rough work is that you can hone out the damage that occurs with the jack plane and the try plane more easily. In an ideal situation (smoothing in wood that doesn't have silica or other contaminants), we already know the results of that test.
At any rate, stoning of the back of a plane iron for 10 seconds is preferable for me. Stoning of the bevel side is necessary to maintain decent geometry, so I'm starting at the stones no matter what.
I don't see appreciable anything on the back of the chisel, so that back stoning isn't necessary.
I think in the balance of things, if it's desirable to deburr or buff both the bevel and the face side of an iron, it can be done. I think the chance that it provides some appreciable gain over 10 seconds of stone work on the back of a plane iron is very low, or near zero. It's possible that doing the method that I'm suggesting for a plane iron (stoning the bevel with a diamond hone, stoning the back with a finer slower stone, and then buffing the bevel) may outperform my previous favorite honing method of lower primary and then secondary (or tertiary if two stones are used) bevels in the low/mid 30s. That remains to be seen.