Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Unicorning plane blades

Posts

Unicorning plane blades

#1

Unicorning plane blades

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Unicorning an edge seems to confer two possible benefits to an edge- sharpness and durability. If the goal is to refine sharpness it would seem that the flat side of the blade should receive the treatment, not the bevel side. Thoughts?

Re: Unicorning plane blades

#2

My preference...

David Weaver

..is not to change the geometry on the front of a plane because I'm using it for a fair amount of heavy work. I'm sure that someone could work up a way to refresh the bevel and deburr and then buff the back of a plane blade and do it indefinitely, but the result would be a steeper edge being chased back.

As far as how often most people get all of the wear off of the back of the plane blade, I'd say anyone using really fine abrasives probably isn't finishing the job as well as they think they are as you can raise a pretty large wire edge, eliminate all visible evidence of scratches and then go to the microscope and see the small wear grooves remaining.

The fact that they can't be discerned in use or seen suggests that it's not that big of a deal, but it's an illustration for people finish planing why you want to prevent damage at the edge (if the edge is just worn and the bevel is refreshed, there will be no evidence on the surface).

I unicorned a few planes yesterday and made a video using one. I'm using a washita with 1 micron diamonds dribbled on it (they're probably long gone) to remove the back wear before buffing the bevel side, and I forgot to remove the back wear on the stone on one and noticed that the wire edge remained much more persistent. If you're deburring the back, then that wouldn't be an issue, but I suspect the wire edge was hanging around somewhere other than the very back after buffing (on a worn edge) and it was surprisingly persistent.

With the process of:

*1000 grit diamond hone slightly steeper than primary grind

* washita on the back for 10 seconds to remove wear

* buffing at a less steep angle

The result is easy and good. I can't see a good reason to skip the stone as it's only 10 seconds and it really keeps the geometry in order.

Buffing the flat face of the iron is something I did on beading planes and their performance is greatly improved in less than stellar wood, so there's probably a place for it. I have seen many moulding planes that have intentionally had what looks like a tiny roundover installed on the face side, and I'm sure they were in professional use because it was done identically on those that came in groups.

(the buffed process that I mentioned above with a worn in washita as as sharp as any plane iron that I've ever sharpened by hand, and the plane will pick up a very thin shaving at the start of a board without much attention paid to anything other than the plane being flat on a board. That's the first area where a lack of clearance starts to rear its head - thin shavings at the start of a board - from a hand tooler's perspective, the inability to start that shaving cleanly is intolerable because it threatens the ability to remove a uniform amount of wood and create a very flat surface on a board. )

Re: Unicorning plane blades

#3

Instead lo of the "ruler trick"?

Jim Matthews

That's intriguing.

Skip a step (lapping the back at less than 180°, and gaining durability.

I'm not clear on how this can avoid chasing a burr.

Still - if it works...

Re: Unicorning plane blades

#4

Re: Unicorning plane blades

Wiley Horne

Hi Bill,

If you unicorn the face of a bevel-down plane blade, you creaTe a steeper cutting angle. F’rinstance, if it’s your 605, bedded at 45, with an iron that is flat beveled at 32 degrees, then your cutting angle is 45, and you have 13 degrees of clearance. If you round (unicorn) the face, adding say 5 degrees, to where your included angle at the very tip is now 37, then your clearance remains 13, but your cutting angle increases to 50 degrees.

We used to talk about using such a device to get a higher attack angle to reduce tearout, back in the “high angle” days🙂.

Surely you would also get a more durable edge, such as is happening with chisels. Interesting conjecture!

Wiley

Re: Unicorning plane blades

#5

try it

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Instead of talking about it I wish one of you all that has a feel for planing would try it. We all were surprised at what a tiny secondary bevel will do for a chisel with no sacrifice in cutting force. Might be similar surprises for a plane blade. If nothing else it would make sharpening faster and no wire edge would remain.

I could certainly do it but I plane so little I would have no idea what was different, if anything.

Re: Unicorning plane blades

#6

Re: try it

Wiley Horne

Bill,

Please see my late edit (last sentence), put up same time as you Were posting. It’s a good experiment IMO. Predict longer runs—only question in my mind is whether you get same surface gloss at the higher angle.

Wiley

Re: Unicorning plane blades

#7

surface gloss irrelevant factor

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

About 3 people in the world care about "surface gloss".

*maybe an overstatement, but it is easy for the planing enthusiasts to loose sight of the fact that most planing is done to remove wood with no regard to surface gloss. The surface either won't be seen in the final product or it will be covered up by finish that will determine surface gloss.

What is important to most:

Time and skill to get sharp enough (could be a benefit here)

edge durability (probably not a factor)

Re: Unicorning plane blades

#8

Re: surface gloss irrelevant factor

David Weaver

If you're trimming joints and such, it may not be as big of a deal to increase the planing effort a little bit.

I think the stoning of the back of the blade is so easy and it improves the bevel side behavior when buffing (by locating the wire edge at a specific spot on the blade) that I wouldn't want to chase the edge.

If I were still going to chase the edge on a junk blade (I can try this) I'd want to do it with a light pass on the deburring wheel or something a little bit stronger/stiffer to avoid really rounding the very edge a lot.

Actually, I have a zillion of those chinese blades like the one I sent you, I can use one of those.

The vast majority of the footage that I'm planing is trying to get something flat (or should I just say, it's trying?). It's very important that the plane starts easy at the far end of a board and cuts everything easily, so it's different for me than the person who is removing plane chatter or bringing one edge on a drawer that's a bit higher than another down to an equal level.

I believe if you round over the front edge, though, you'll be sharpening twice as often and this will be less than a lateral move.

Re: Unicorning plane blades

#9

why

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I believe if you round over the front edge, though, you'll be sharpening twice as often and this will be less than a lateral move. I do not see why this conjecture would be the case for a 0.005" buff on the back. I am at that point from wear in the course of my planing.

You stone the back. Does anyone else? Appears too fiddly so I never attempted to learn to do it. If 1 second across the buff that now will be sitting on the bench for chisels gets me to the same place as your back stoning I would regard this discovery right up there with the chisel work. If I had the ability to reliably test this hypothesis it would already be done. But my planing is measured by wood going away without tear-out and I will miss even substantial differences A vs B.

I agree if some "massive" amount of rounding is done on a deburing wheel, performance will suffer with no benefit. I am thinking along the lines of the most delicate pass on the buff that only profiles the last 0.005" of the tip. This tiny profile is not going to effect planing resistance any more than on a chisel. It seems it will sharpen reliably and quick just like the chisel. It may even have the benefit of mitigating tear-out without the price to pay for the case of a large top bevel.

Re: Unicorning plane blades

#10

not the benefit I hope for

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Surely you would also get a more durable edge, such as is happening with chisels. Interesting conjecture!

Durable edge not usually important if the plane dulls by wear rather than chipping or deformation as is the case with a chopping chisel.

For a chisel the benefits are durability, durability at lower bevel angle(penetration ease), and quickness and reliability of sharpening. It is the last benefit I expect from a delicate buff on the blade face. It could be the equivalent of David's back stoning, or ruler tricks, and done with a buffer that may be at hand from doing chisels. And easily mastered.

This profile could even aid tear-out mitigation without the disadvantages of a long back bevel or high frog angle. The effect would be too subtle for me to reliably assess. But I may claim it and challenge someone to prove me wrong.

Re: Unicorning plane blades

#11

Re: why

David Weaver

steeper angle of attack on a plane is associated with two things:

* higher wear rate on the iron

* lower ability to start a shaving and less downward force created by the planing action itself at the start (They go hand in hand, I guess).

I noticed with the moulding plane irons that I could visually affect little but the very edge on the face of a beading plane and still greatly reduce tearout without having to do anything fiddly around the very edge. I think it may be difficult to work both sides of the edge in very small amounts, get a reasonably uniform result and keep it.

I found when I was testing irons that the ruler trick was "ok" policy until you scrutinized the edge itself and made the pictures of the irons photo perfect. I did the ruler trick only on 1 micron diamonds, but the bevel itself on a steel rule eventually got longer and longer.

I could very well have decided that I would only do the ruler trick to an extent that would not chase it to be larger and larger, which is an issue when removing wear that compounds quickly (if it gets bigger, then the action of just removing the wear gets slower and slower) - but that would have left us with irons in the test that had some visible wear grooves remaining somewhere on them (but felt otherwise sharp).

I believe that carbon steel (better than XHP/V11) still maintains a uniform edge better in less than ideal situations and the reason that warren prefers it and I've gone back to preferring it for rough work is that you can hone out the damage that occurs with the jack plane and the try plane more easily. In an ideal situation (smoothing in wood that doesn't have silica or other contaminants), we already know the results of that test.

At any rate, stoning of the back of a plane iron for 10 seconds is preferable for me. Stoning of the bevel side is necessary to maintain decent geometry, so I'm starting at the stones no matter what.

I don't see appreciable anything on the back of the chisel, so that back stoning isn't necessary.

I think in the balance of things, if it's desirable to deburr or buff both the bevel and the face side of an iron, it can be done. I think the chance that it provides some appreciable gain over 10 seconds of stone work on the back of a plane iron is very low, or near zero. It's possible that doing the method that I'm suggesting for a plane iron (stoning the bevel with a diamond hone, stoning the back with a finer slower stone, and then buffing the bevel) may outperform my previous favorite honing method of lower primary and then secondary (or tertiary if two stones are used) bevels in the low/mid 30s. That remains to be seen.