Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

made chisel, Unicorned it, chopped dovetails

Posts

made chisel, Unicorned it, chopped dovetails

#1

made chisel, Unicorned it, chopped dovetails

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I have had an unhandled Narex chisel I have been wanting to put in service. I tapered the sides for dovetailing on the grinding wheel. Thinned the blade on a belt sander. Turned and mounted a dogwood handle. That's enough modification to claim partial credit for "making a chisel".



Used a flawed technique to drive the handle on. Searched for a wooden knight to pull the sword(chisel) out of the rock(wood). Split rock from sword.

Flattened back and polished to 1 micron diamond. Forgot how fast 15 micron on cast iron cuts compared to a fine Ezlap plate. Wow. Flat ground bevel at 25 degrees through 1 micron diamond. Then at most spent 3 seconds adding the Unicorn Profile with fuzzy wheel, yellow 5 micron compound, 3600 rpm. I could see the narrow glint of the Unicorn bevel.

Dashed out a series of dovetails like the ones I recently chopped for drawers so I would remember some comparison. Did not coping saw waste, chiseled it more aggressively than normal.



Results:

1.normally when I remove waste with 30 degree bevel chisel, without coping sawing, the last bit of waste breaks off leaving a butt hole in the tail. Not this time. And I was not being dainty with the blows.

2 Penetration remarkably easier than 30 degree bevel.

3. No damage to edge I could see at 10X.

Discussion:

This is a mild test of the chisel, not how well I can make a dovetail. (It was a test of how quick though.) But the results encourage further exploration. And it showed the easier penetration could be beneficial even in my hands. I don't think refinement through 1 micron diamond is necessary. Will explore stopping at coarser grit then Unicorning. Will explore hollow grind.

Re: made chisel, Unicorned it, chopped dovetails

#2

Lower bevel angles

Winston

With the chisels I've been testing, they started with a 30 degree bevel, so that's what I've been using before buffing the chisel. But it makes sense that a significantly lower bevel angle should work fine with the unicorn profile.

At least for the Buck Brothers chisel, the edge damage from chopping maple was within approximately .002" of the edge. This is the flat-honed condition, of course; when it was buffed, the chisel had no visible damage. If a chisel with a 25-degree bevel ends up with a similar profile very near the when buffed, then it seems likely that it will also stand up just fine to chopping, but also move through the wood with less resistance from wedging. That's an exciting possibility: a sharper, much longer lasting, faster and cheaper and easier-to-sharpen edge, which also cuts with less resistance from wedging.

I have a pair of Japanese paring chisels that I got about ten years ago which were sharpened to 20 degrees. They chipped like crazy, though, and I always wondered if was doing something wrong. I gave up on using them and they've been sitting in a closet, but maybe I'll try buffing them to see if there's a significant improvement.

Just speculating: it's possible that a much harder and chip-prone steel would still be chippy even with the buffed bevel. But with the edge durability that I've observed, there's much less of a need for really hard steel in a chisel. Maybe I'll even take a cheap chisel, grind it down to 20 degrees, and see how it holds up.

Re: made chisel, Unicorned it, chopped dovetails

#3

Re: Lower bevel angles

Wiley Horne

Winston,

Those Japanese paring chisels will come back fine. Based on some experience I had just today, I think you may need to take the final buffed bevel to the mid-30s, if they’re hard tempered, like more than Rc62. I hope you test them!

Wiley

Re: made chisel, Unicorned it, chopped dovetails

#4

Re: Lower bevel angles

Winston

Are you saying you hope I test chopping with the paring chisels? Even with a buffed edge, I'd be worried about ending up with a pile of steel fragments by the time I'm done. :D

Looking forward to seeing your results!

Re: made chisel, Unicorned it, chopped dovetails

#5

kicked out of class

David Weaver

I don't want to be kicked out of class, but my paring chisels for planemaking are unicorned now. Life is far better.

If they're in an area where i'm afraid they may push through and blow out the back side of a cut, then I will tap them with a mallet.

I wouldn't cut dovetails with them, but with the right setup, I'd bet an enterprising oppositional person could do it and beat a beginner with bench chisels by a large margin :O

Re: made chisel, Unicorned it, chopped dovetails

#6

Re: Lower bevel angles

Wiley Horne

Hi Winston and all,

I understood from original post that you got lots of chipping from paring at 20 degrees. I am prepared to bet that these same chisels unicorned to an effective cutting angle of, say, 35 degrees, will pare 4/4 oak for many cuts without damage, and without objectionable resistance.

One other point, not in regard to what you said, but just because it comes to mind

.....In my experience, paring through 4/4 hardwood endgrain to the scribe line, taking say 1/64-1/32” slices, is cut-for-cut harder on a chisel edge than chopping half blinds. Mortising is a different thing of course, but cut-for-cut not vastly harder on the edge. The very words chop and pare suggest that any chopping application will be harder on a chisel than paring. I may get some grief for this opinion/experience, but it’s my story and I’m sticking to it😀😀.

Will try to get my paring adventure up in pictures.

Wiley

Re: made chisel, Unicorned it, chopped dovetails

#7

hard wood paring...

David Weaver

is tough on an edge. On any flat angle that one can tolerate for paring directly across endgrain (productively, as in actual work removing any significant amount), an edge will lose the ability to shave hair cleanly pretty quickly.

I did all of the paring on my case with a $2hf chisel before posting about this buffing (paring was the reason reason that I was trying to chase the second and first bevels down - the lower they are, the easier it is to pair. You can't just gain 100 pounds to push harder).

Paring is also a much bigger opportunity for disaster (overcut) if you bear down and push too hard.

I pared all of the tenon shoulders on my case (usually chisel them) without any issues on a set of HF chisels that are probably slightly softer than the sorby chisels. Not by much, but they're soft and I've kept them around solely for things like chiseling adhesive off of the wall, etc, when redoing trim. They're now usable, but really long and light compared to most of what we use.

(the other desire here is to use western parers, which I really like the action of, without them having to be really ideally hardened chisels).

The lower the follow-on angles to the edge, the more waste you can pare easily above a shoulder line without pushing the line down any appreciable amount. This difference is very practically significant.