Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

second unicorn edge retention test

Posts

second unicorn edge retention test

#1

second unicorn edge retention test

David Weaver

This time, I used apple for a specific reason - I have an offcut just under 3/4ths inch wide, which means I can use the sorby chisels to cut it without holding wood on the side.

First test, same chisels (unicorn 1 inch, 28 degree 3/4ths inch) using the edges shown in the angle pictures (not resharpened, etc). flat bevel is 1 micron diamond, unicorn is yellow stuff.

83 strikes to get the flat bevel chisel through the apple, 60 to get the unicorn chisel through the apple:

edge damage to the flat bevel - 3/4 inch sorby:


This apple feels a little bit harder and drier if that makes sense vs. the beech billet. The edge failure is much more uniform in it. If you check this chisel with your finger, it feels like a wire edge has been raised (a small one, but you can easily feel it.)

1 inch chisel - unicorn edge. No visible damage. It's hard not to tap the mallet more lightly even from the start as it gets through the wood much more easily.


Next, swap the chisels, unicorn the 3/4th chisel and flat bevel on the 1 inch chisel to make sure it's not the chisels and lack of consistency. (i've never perceived much variance in three sets of these chisels, but you have to check and make sure it's not also related to a bigger chisel transferring more of the mallet energy).

80 strikes with the flat bevel, 55 with the unicorn. I paid a little bit more attention to not let off of the striking pressure since the unicorn was getting through the wood more easily.

28 degree bevel, 1 inch chisel:


Then, the 3/4th inch chisel unicorned:


I'm not sure if any of that is minor edge damage.

I drew 10 sections in each inch of malleting here. Again, wood narrower than the chisel width so no holding wood.

Re: second unicorn edge retention test

#2

Re: second unicorn edge retention test

David Weaver

..to get that much damage out of an edge. It's probably 3 thousandths or 4 thousandths deep in some spots.

The first time I unicorned the 28 degree chisel, I used it, there was no additional edge damage but strangely, some of the deep bits of prior damage was still there, and I had to redo that test. Bizarre to see a perfectly even defected edge!!

I thought that I'd done enough to hone it out, but wasn't correct. Which means if you encounter this edge damage and refresh your bevel and raise a large wire edge, you're still probably not getting it all out. It's better to avoid it.

When we were doing the plane iron testing and the sentiment was that the iron's behavior changes after damage, I'd imagine that in reality the damage hasn't all been removed because you can't see this tiny damage, and after honing, you can't feel it either. The microscope sees it pretty easily, though. It's unusual looking when it's there but the edge is straight.

For what it's worth, when I did the plane iron test, when the maple damaged the irons, once it was honed out completely as confirmed by the microscope, I didn't notice any difference in edge behavior.

The next test of interest will be to see if the sorby chisel can outrun a V11 chisel with a flat bevel if the sorby has the unicorn. Outrun means retain unicorn status (better edge retention and more ease through the material being chiseled).

I was already convinced that this is superior, but now after redoing this test and swapping chisels, I have no doubt I can demonstrate it over and over without favoring one method or another.

Re: second unicorn edge retention test

#3

interesting turn

David Weaver

as this test starts to run out, I figured I'd increase the angle to 32 (i have a stop set at 32 from years ago, an angle type, not distance, so it's true 32).

The sorby chisel held up better in apple and did better. I haven't had great experience in soft woods at 32 degrees, but this isn't soft woods.

It took fewer strikes than the damaged 28 edge. But there was an annoying tendency for the edge to sever the chips off of the test piece and shoot them into me, bouncing them off of my stomach, chest and face (this is at 32). The first step toward any of this years ago, chiseling cocobolo for planes and steepening a stanley saw the same thing, except i'm standing perpendicular to the direction of shaving travel and those shavings just shot across the shop. There's some magic point where wood doesn't lay over as a leaf but rather shoots off of the work piece.


The next experiment was to apply the 32 to a much better chisel - ashley iles mk2. These are my favorite modern chisel. they have proportions like an older chisel and the steel is in the sweet spot (60-62).


How about that - no damage with a 32 degree microbevel in the same test.

about 70 strikes for the sorby and 65 for the iles. This iles chisel did nearly as well as the unicorn for effort. Sharpening is a bit more tedious, and the stinging face from chips remains.

long dried apple will do that, but I doubt cherry chips would fly off like that.

Re: second unicorn edge retention test

#4

the interesting turn got less interesting...

David Weaver

...as I move down the length of the apple stick, the heart is more prominent in it and it's softer.

The 32 degree bevels holding up is nice. Getting closer to the number of strikes to chop off an inch of wood in tenth inch slices as I see with the unicorn edge was also nice.

And then I followed those two by unicorning the ashley iles chisel and it took 40 strikes. I'll do this test right (with hard maple - finally may have a way to burn through some of it) when the V11 chisel arrives.

Perhaps all 1" chisels, and each getting an opportunity to work 28 and 32 degree flat bevels, as well as unicorning.

Re: second unicorn edge retention test

#5

testing a good chisel in maple

David Weaver

ashley iles mk 2 bench chisel.

Test is chopping an inch off of the end of a maple board 7/8ths wide and 1 1/2 inches tall.

Two edges (number of strikes):

* 1 micron 30º microbevel (155)

* unicorn (102)

(hard maple), 10 leaves of cutting. This is a bit aggressive - I thought the apple might be harder, but I think it's not - the maple resists more (The volume of wood is close to double) and warms the chisel more.

The 30 degree "normal" edge. Damage is mostly metal gone and not a leaf of deformed metal, but minor compared to the much softer sorby in other test. The sorby chisel would died in this test.

some damage was slightly worse than this, there were two bigger notches and then some areas with a little bit less damage, but no section of image was completely undamaged.


Unicorn (this is the same chisel back - the software adjusts gain based on what it sees and my handle rest may have been at a slightly different angle.


I ran my thumb over the edge after this test to feel for a burr and may have pulled the oil to the edge that's there. If there is oil anywhere on the chisel, the sides, the back, anywhere, you will find it under the microscope. If you chisel something and then so much as feel the back, the thin layer of oil is everywhere. When I tested plane blades, I learned that the bevel had to be wiped off thoroughly and then all strokes with the rag had to be wiped from the edge toward the other end of the iron. If a single wipe was done like I did here with my thumb, the area looked like it's covered with oil again. I don't think it obscured anything.

As with planing hard maple, lots of heat is generated and the chisel was very warm - maybe it thinned the oil.

If buffers and inexpensive small abrasives existed in the time of nicholson, this sharpening method would have been prescribed. It is better than any method that has two planes meeting. The added bonus is that the maple still shot off of the end of the board with a 30 degree microbevel (some going in my eye, around my glasses) but most of it was laid over neatly with the unicorn.

The iles chisels generally hold up as well or better than vintage chisels, perhaps with the exception of ward.

V11 still hasn't shipped, so it may be a while before these three chisels are compared (sorby, v11 and AI).

It'll be separately interesting to see how AI and V11 compare as the AI chisels are about 1/3rd the cost. Of minor interest will also be whether or not the slickness of the V11 can be felt malleting out maple.

Re: second unicorn edge retention test

#6

Question

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

what is the total description of the bevel(s) on these chisels.

Re: second unicorn edge retention test

#7

Re: Question

David Weaver

Primary around 20. Flat secondary bevel is about 1/32nd of an inch long at 30 degrees. The entire amount of the edge in the scope picture is within that secondary.

Unicorn is 1000 grit china diamond hone then buff with McMaster yellowcake.

Re: second unicorn edge retention test

#8

Re: Question

Winston

Have you considered testing a chisel with a 45-degree micro-micro-bevel from your finest stone? Like on the scale of .002".

Re: second unicorn edge retention test

#9

Re: Question

Wiley Horne

Similar suggestion. How would AI do in this test with a 35 degree microbevel? 30 is quite acute for chopping 1/10” leaves 7/8 wide and 1-1/2 deep.

No estimate is given for the effective (final) angle of the unicorn. But surely it’s at least 35.

All that said, that’s an amazing result for the rounded edge.

David, I’ve lost track—what is the approx. length of the unicorn bevel?

Thanks for sharing!

Wiley

Re: second unicorn edge retention test

#10

Re: Question

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Primary bevel about 20 degrees. This bevel ground with 1000 diamond. Yes?

In one case a 28 or 30 (both are claimed)degree secondary bevel was ground using what?

In the other case the Unicorn Profile was added to the 20 degree bevel. Yes?

Re: second unicorn edge retention test

#11

Re: Question

David Weaver

Will do 32 later with Ai, which performs well on old dry apple. If that doesn't satisfy, then will do 35.

Unicorn buff is about 8 thousandths but roundover is only significant the last 4 thousandth or so.

Will try a tiny steep bevel as Winston suggests, too.

Re: second unicorn edge retention test

#12

Re: Question

David Weaver

30 degree secondary on 20 grind. Secondary made with diamond hone and then polished with 1 micron diamonds on cast.

Re: second unicorn edge retention test

#13

Iles chisel tolerates hard maple at 32 degrees

David Weaver

The iles chisel with a 2 1/2 hundredth long 32 degree microbevel (honed to 1 micron diamond finish and lightly leather stropped) tolerates maple

38% more strikes than "unicorn" and the level is getting steep enough that the edge bounces in maple a little bit. I shot for 12 slices through the inch of maple this time, but with the edge bouncing (this wood is resting on a piece of softwood plywood and is held in place with a holdfast - the softwood ply underneath may be aiding the bouncing) it's not really any better.

https://i.imgur.com/opkWz3L.jpg

not 100% damage free, but very good given how abusive hard maple can be cutting perpendicular to the grain.

I will try one more thing - a low 20s secondary angle with only a tiny tiny microbevel a little steeper to see if we're really all wasting our time making big visible microbevels. This has the best chance (I think) to match the buffed edge in combining effort and durability.

Re: second unicorn edge retention test

#14

tiny microbevel

David Weaver

* 20 degree primary, 23 degree secondary, four strokes on cast diamond lap with 1 micron diamond at 34 degrees.

better than any of the other larger microbevels - no edge failure of any particular concern, 127 mallet strikes for an inch of maple.

Bevel being much steeper is important so that even the tiny microbevel removes all diamond hone scratches.

* just for calibration, unicorned the AI chisels here and chopped the next inch of the maple board - 107 strikes.

Re: second unicorn edge retention test

#15

putting into perspective

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

If I had built the drawers for the desk I am building out of maple entirely I would have pounded the chisel through maple 10 times more distance than this test. A reasonable estimate is that I drove a chisel through 1.5 feet of ash, 50% more than this test, with no visible at 10X damage to a Unicorn edge on a Narex. These estimates from one trial is reason to pursue exploring what appears to be an effective means of vastly improving edge life when cutting cross grain with a chisel.

Re: second unicorn edge retention test

#16

tiny microbevel

David Weaver

* 20 degree primary, 23 degree secondary, four strokes on cast diamond lap with 1 micron diamond at 34 degrees.

better than any of the other larger microbevels - no edge failure of any particular concern, 127 mallet strikes for an inch of maple.

Bevel being much steeper is important so that even the tiny microbevel removes all diamond hone scratches.

* just for calibration, unicorned the AI chisels here and chopped the next inch of the maple board - 107 strikes.

Re: second unicorn edge retention test

#17

Re: tiny microbevel

Wiley Horne

“ four strokes on cast diamond lap with 1 micron diamond at 34 degrees.”

This appears to be big news. Four strokes at 34 degrees is perfectly repeatable, compared to buffer magic. And requires no shop footprint beyond the existing sharpening station.

Thanks for following on Winston’s suggestion and reporting!

Wiley

Re: second unicorn edge retention test

#18

glad to try it...

David Weaver

Will stop for now. Don't want to burn myself out and then fail to test the V11/Sorby/AI chisel rotation when the V11 chisel comes.

But it's nice to get a shot at all of these things and really test what's what before running a "test" later only to find out some method not shown does a lot better.

Re: second unicorn edge retention test

#19

Re: glad to try it...

Wiley Horne

I hear you. But it sounded as though the microbevel (4 strokes) had an equivalent effect to the buffed edge.

Your production is incredible!

Wiley

Re: second unicorn edge retention test

#20

Thanks to the shallow primary......

David Weaver

and my constant making of tools when a grind does need to occur (That's less than a two minute penalty if something needs adjusting from any angle close), each of these tests and pictures only takes about 15 or 20 minutes.

Waiting on the kids to decide what they want to do today, too. I never watch TV other than very late at night for a few minutes. This stuff sprinkled in here or there for 20 minutes or a half hour is my version of TV.

Re: second unicorn edge retention test

#21

Re: tiny microbevel

Les Groeller

Would this “mini-microbevel” be a recommendation for paring chisels as well or is the “stoutness” of that edge not as critical while paring?

Re: second unicorn edge retention test

#22

you can definitely damage the edge...

David Weaver

..on a paring chisel. I didn't mallet this edge at first, rather used it to pare shoulders and miters. I hate it when paring chisels get edge damage and leave lines all over everything (it usually doesn't matter, but on the corners of planes, it does).

I think the lack of resistance in the roundover vs. even a tiny microbevel makes the buffed edge better for paring.

Re: second unicorn edge retention test

#23

Thanks


Re: second unicorn edge retention test

#24

Re: tiny microbevel

Jonathan Elliott

I'm probably missing something obvious but what purpose does the 23 deg secondary bevel serve? Why not just do the 4 stroke 34 deg microbevel directly off the 20 deg primary or make the primary 23 deg and then do the 34 deg mircrobevel?

Thanks!

Jonathan

Re: second unicorn edge retention test

#25

Re: tiny microbevel

Michael Todrin

Very interesting David. Thanks for sharing. It really does appear to be a unicorn.

How many strokes on the 1000 diamond plate does it take to remove the unicorn?