Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compound bonanza tonight

Posts

Compound bonanza tonight

#1

Compound bonanza tonight

David Weaver

If I can get to it. I now have:

LV green

McMaster green 1 micron

Gold 5 micron

Unidentified kocour white (well see what the scope says)

McMaster 0.5 micron rouge. I seriously doubt the avg scratch will meet that

I already have lots of pictures of diamond 1 micron

6 clean corian scraps still with tape on, so no contamination in the results

All of these hard bars apply very easily with a drop of wd40 or oil and none are expensive. The hardness is an asset when applying them to a 3600 rpm buff.

Re: Compound bonanza tonight

#2

McMaster 1 micron "Green" on Corian

David Weaver

The actual brand is jackson lea.

Smooth side of corian. Corian is so smooth that it's actually detrimental to getting contact of the tool with the surface. The off-side of corian is rough. I'll test it with dry WD40 to make sure that it has no real abrasive power.

If all samples have this stray scratching in them, I'll try the sticks on some other backer to make sure the stray scratches continue. I suspect that these scratches are due to particles that are out of spec (like the LV compound - spec is up to 6 micron), or perhaps in spec but large, and these particles don't really have enough size to cause a problem in a buff - problem is very obvious on a harder surface, though!)

same chisel will be used for all of these. AFter one cycle through, I will re-do each to make sure the same kind of stray scratches appear on both tries, too (vs. being scratches that were just never worked out).



In the scheme of woodworking, these are just cosmetic scratches, though - a tiny fraction of a thousandth in any depth or uniformity.

Re: Compound bonanza tonight

#3

mcmaster red rouge (1/2 micron)

David Weaver

No detectable cutting power unlike the dry pigment from iron oxide. No feel of any kind of abrasion or grip when scrubbing the block on the corian.

Will have to look at MSDS to see if it even has alumina in it. Unusable.

Not sure that the scratches are from the abrasive vs. brisk work on corian and a scrap of hardwood - neither surface induced any cutting power from the rouge.


Re: Compound bonanza tonight

#4

LV Green Compound /Formax Microfine

David Weaver

Unless LV has changed suppliers, this is the stuff that set the razor boards on fire when they looked under a scope and compared the scratches to green chrome ox.

very good cutting power, very usable.


in my opinion, the fact that the compound is charged with a lot of alumina makes it much more usable.

Downside is that it's very expensive for what it is. Cutting power of the mcmaster green is about as good. This compound sells for $10 + shipping to $19 with shipping on amazon, or 13.50 from LV.

Jackson lea green above is $14.50 or something like that for 3 pounds. If you're only using little bits, 6 ounces and 3 pounds are about the same unless you split the big bar in two for the inevitable situation when you misplace half of it.

Could be marked up by distribution channels for woodworkers, too.

Re: Compound bonanza tonight

#5

Red rouge MSDS

Winston

Oh, interesting, I thought I had the correct MSDS sheet for it earlier, but apparently not. The one I pointed to before said it was 70-80% aluminum oxide.

https://www.osborn.com/media/msds/pdf/47013.PDF

But it turns out there are SDS sheets on the McMaster site for the compounds. This one says that it's 70-90% iron oxide, and that's it (for abrasives).

https://www.mcmaster.com/4783A11/

So the one I found earlier must be the wrong one.

Re: Compound bonanza tonight

#6

Re: Red rouge MSDS

David Weaver

Looking at my receipt, the part number matches the stick that's true rouge.

The feel of it having no cutting power at all gives it away.

Even though the other sticks have very tiny particles, you can *feel* them abrading the corian a tiny bit. Corian itself is really hard and musical feeling - it feels unforgiving.

Addition of wax and oil makes something that cuts very slowly (iron oxide powder used dry) unusable on steel.

Re: Compound bonanza tonight

#7

hand american 0.5 micron green pigment

David Weaver

too slow for practical use, but makes for a spectacular picture.

You can see why it sets a razor out with a wonderful initial edge.

In the world of $600 razor stones, I have had more comfortable shaves with stones in some cases, but there literally is no natural stone on earth that comes close in fineness. This is a hard thing for some people to reckon with after they've just spent $600 on a yellow/green escher that's not even as big as a normal bench stone.

The dots are oil. no practical buffer use that I can think of, and I hope you like green if you plane to use it, because you'll have green fingers, green marks on your face, a green shirt, and if you ever drop the pigment anywhere, you'll never get it all out.


Re: Compound bonanza tonight

#8

white alumina - kocour brand

David Weaver

from mcmaster carr. I'm guessing this is the 2 micron type. It is not close to the gold in cutting power and not as strong of a cutter as the "microfine".


Re: Compound bonanza tonight

#9

mc master 5 micron gold...

David Weaver

has good cutting action feel when spreading on corian and strong cutting when using. FAR stronger than anything else in this group - blackens the corian all over quickly.


for contrast, this is what the gold does buffing the back of a chisel instead of being used on corian.


It's my choice for the buffer because of this. It has the power, but the buffer finish will be "fine" grained, even if it remains visible.