Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Buffing workable for plane irons

Posts

Buffing workable for plane irons

#1

Buffing workable for plane irons

David Weaver

But it has to include a step of bevel, iron back and then buffer.

the adjustment to the method is a low 20s primary bevel and then shallower attack on the buffer and for less time.

Straying to more time on the buffer (even at the same angle) makes for an iron that's less eager to pick up very thin shavings at the start of a cut (on the edge of a board). That's generally the first indication that an edge is starting to lose clearance, so we're trying to avoid it and get an iron that picks up a very thin shaving.

Sharpening cycle time, 55 seconds.

Add 30 seconds or so to take the plane iron apart and put it back together and it's very close to the cycle time that I'd have just sharpening by hand. The back wear step can't be avoided.

I'll report later how the edge holds up in use. Bargaining with the mrs. on making another shelving unit for another room in the house, but she wants it to be paint grade. if she tells me what it is that she actually wants, I'll be back into heavy dimensioning soon and get an idea about edge longevity. Averse to doing a couple of more a/b tests of a thousand or two thousand feet per iron.

compared to my normal regimen (shallow primary, then secondary somewhere around 30 and then final bevel ever so slightly higher (32/33? ) freehand and strop for finishing work, there's only intentional secondary bevel work on the bevel side around mid 20s to leave room for roundover to still have clearance.

I think this will be harder for someone to have success with (more touch, more sensitive to overwork, and stones and flat facets don't come up short on planes like they do on chisels.

Re: Buffing workable for plane irons

#2

pictures of shavings

David Weaver

Thinnest shavings from cherry - 1000 grit diamond hone on bevel, washita on back, buffer.

https://i.imgur.com/gtBAO50.jpg?1

These are unusually thin and fine. The pictures that I usually post from the washita look like this, but the shaving matrix is more like a yarn afghan. These are more uniform and thinner. The surface left behind on the wood is spectacularly bright.

It's entertaining, but I don't think it provides any practical difference in use - just shown because you can't get shavings like these full length if a plane won't stay in a cut without external downforce.

And a demonstration of something relatively unusual also, the ability to make rosewood shavings thin enough that they're not dark. Indian rosewood.

https://i.imgur.com/CR544f6.jpg

Like the neck blanks that I've used, this rosewood has silica in the matrix. It makes a bunch of small dings on edges. That's impact. I have another billet to size and see if this is protective against those. I'm skeptical about that.

Re: Buffing workable for plane irons

#3

Not as successful here

Winston

I tried buffing another plane blade. This was a PM-V11 blade in a bevel-down smoothing plane with a 45-degree bed. To avoid clearance issues, I lowered the bevel angle from 32 degrees to 25. I buffed the blade with the white rouge and the soft Ryobi wheel. As in my previous experiment with a buffed plane, the surface was super smooth.

One problem, though: after about 20 feet of planing white pine, I started noticing some tracks in the wood. Under the scope, I could see some big chips in the blade.


The missing chunks were significantly larger than the region that had been rounded over from buffing. Clearly, this isn't making for a more durable blade. I think that, in order for that to happen, I would have to have a larger rounded region, which will involve more time buffing or a more aggressive compound. But I think I'll also have to increase the bevel angle on the stones.

I should mention that with this particular blade, I have had chipping issues in the past, even with a 30-degree bevel (and no buffing).

Re: Buffing workable for plane irons

#4

Re: Not as successful here

David Weaver

That may be a blade issue. I have an xhp iron that I use fairly often (my v11 iron is gone) and in regular use, it will accumulate more chipping that my best O1 irons, but I attribute that to two things:

* it lasts twice as long

* it wears half as fast (and probably buffs half as fast)

I've used the buffed xhp iron sizing a rosewood plane blank, but that's not a reliable way to check for chipping because it's filled with silica. Everything gets little chips on it.

I buffed the xhp iron that I'm using "flatter".

I still think from the start that the technical issues to solve with plane sharpening (hitting a fairly narrow range to balance clearance and strength, usually no failure by impact, and having back wear to remove) makes the buffer another option to master, but the time savings and large improvement isn't there like it is for chisels and knives.

Re: Buffing workable for plane irons

#5

Could be just that blade

Winston

It's definitely possible that it's the blade. I've had issues with that blade chipping in the past.

Now that I think of it, I do have another PM-V11 plane blade which I've been using for a few months, and I haven't noticed any chipping issues with it. I'll try that one out, but that means more time at the grinder to lower the bevel angle. :\

If it is indeed that one blade that's chippy, I wonder if/how I'd be able to convince Lee Valley to replace it.

Re: Buffing workable for plane irons

#6

Re: Could be just that blade

Wiley Horne

“ If it is indeed that one blade that's chippy, I wonder if/how I'd be able to convince Lee Valley to replace it.”

Just call them up on the phone, or send an email. They’ll replace immediately, in my experience, and no hassle about it.

Wiley