Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Another wooden plane question

Posts

Another wooden plane question

#1

Another wooden plane question

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Most of the plane discussion that goes on here involves planes and planing what will become "show" surfaces. Among the people that I know building furniture this activity ranges from minor to absent from their work. The majority of the planing is a swish here and a swish there to fit something, accomplished with a #4 or #5 or maybe a #3, or some bevel up plane of similar size. The nimbleness I referred to below is a compelling attribute of the plane for these tasks, as well as a short sole.

So, what kind of wooden plane was/is used for fitting parts? A "coffin smoother" was shown earlier. But "smoother" was part of its name not coffin "fitter". Would there be any difference between a plane designed for smoothing and one ideal for fitting?

Re: Another wooden plane question

#2

Re: Another wooden plane question

David Weaver

can't comment on what was historically done, but I would look to common planes to guess what was used, and the coffin smoother works just as well as a stanley for fitting and working small areas. At least in relative comparison.

When you get into much harder woods, it gets easier to do faster work with a metal plane, but for typical drawer materials (pine, poplar, soft maple, chestnut, etc) I can't imagine any issue with a coffin smoother.

Since your latest drawers are ash with grain going all over the place, I think most people would do better with adjustment and cap iron set with a stanley for that.

Re: Another wooden plane question

#3

Only guessing (a SWAG)

Jim Matthews

Critical dimensions arise at the intersection of parts to be joined.

My SWAG is that panels to be fitted were brought to thickness and into plane with a Rebate or Fillister, where needed.

For chairs, or curved work I expect Spokeshaves were employed.

*****

So much of this was lost when kiln dried ( and machine planed ) stock became widely available.