Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Weaver grind v/s Japanese feathering

Posts

Weaver grind v/s Japanese feathering

#1

Weaver grind v/s Japanese feathering

david charlesworth

It seems to me that David's polishing technique may be somewhat similar to the Feathering technique discussed on page 156 of Toshio Odate's book

"Japanese Woodworking Tools their Tradition Spirit and Use."

I will summarize. When working timbers high in silica, shokunin use the feathering technique when their plane blades chip. Dubbing over the edge makes the blade less sensitive , and so less prone to chipping, but you should do this only when you have to.

The picture shows a plane blade, bevel down being moved backwards. It starts at about 30 degrees and rises to about 60 degrees. The text says two or three times.

Re: Weaver grind v/s Japanese feathering

#2

Re: Weaver grind v/s Japanese feathering

David Weaver

sort of.

I hope my name doesn't get permanently attached to this!!

odate's book (I don't have copy in hand) talks about using this on overhard blades or when planing teak, though there may be some suggestion of actually making the charlesworth back bevel (there....look how I made that your name!!).

I've been rolling over the tips on chisels for years so that I can make the rest of the bevel smaller, but haven't really gotten carried away with where this has gone now at this point. For bill, it was just as toshio states, but I never liked the fact that there's a lot more resistance and sometimes it's enough to lose the clean finish on a surface (inside dovetails, especially on ash or something, who cares about the finish - and the wood is strong and dense enough that it won't crush between the pins).

What I've become somewhat needlessly fascinated with now is the ability to use this to change the geometry behind the tiny round over so that the total outcome is a chisel that actually feels and behaves sharper and still holds its edge better than a flat facet.

The fact that a full resharpening takes 30 seconds is nice, too, but applying it as such is probably not easy to describe to someone who is new to the hobby.

My thinking behind this probably comes more from japanese vegetable knives. If you do a very deliberate single grind all the way down to the edge on a thin japanese knife, it'll be otherworldly through vegetables or soft meat - it's like power steering feels in a car. But it'll be not long before you have some damage to relieve. You can continue to chase the bevel up to a point that it doesn't chip,but then if the whole bevel or a large microbevel is like that, the power steering feel is gone.

if you eliminate only the very tip of the blade where the damage first occurs, and replace it with a tiny rounded part, the damage doesn't occur and the feel isn't different or is only very minimally different from the edge that doesn't hold up. This is sublime, sharper than any steeled knife could possibly be (they just aren't hard enough, and if they were, they wouldn't be able to be steeled), and maintenance is literally sharpening a tiny bit every several months.

So, maybe this has a place in chisels. Which comes up because years ago, there was some old wives tailing on sawmill creek about how a 6" grinder couldn't make an edge that could be used for woodworking. There were a couple of folks missing nerve endings who really went on with this. At the time, I was using a 6" grinder - still am. I thought to ask then if anyone had ever seen a properly used woodworking chisel with a 6" grinder hollow, a microbevel or flat honed at the edge, and damage that went into the hollow.

no. nobody even tried to fib about that. Of course you can pry with a chisel or drop one and break the edge up into the handle. I've whacked the tiny rounded bevel shallow chisel like I proposed here hard enough to knock corners off of the chisel above the tiny rounding, but I was being a bad boy deliberately to see where this would occur. the proposal to make a conceptually strong (but unnecessarily so) bevel was to round over the whole thing so that in practical work it was even steeper than a typical flat bevel. Making an actual compromise (a drawback) to deal with an imaginary problem.

So, what bill has taken from this is the odate type mod - take the chisel whatever it already is and round the tip (that's good - it works well - hard woods, substandard chisels - no problem), but I'm in a rabbit hole after being somewhat surprised that a 20 degree primary, small 25 degree secondary and then a tiny deliberately buffed tip feels sharper (for everything - with less cut resistance than any flat bevel angle that I've ever used that's held up) and holds its edge better. in short, I'm chasing what I've seen on the knives, where the idea of some perfect apex right at the edge isn't really that important. And, in fact, this is much like a straight razor, where our razor settles into a very nice standard of performance once the strop and linen have dealt with the very tip - without doing much of anything to the bevel. Those who use a more aggressive abrasive on a razor need to go back to a stone more often to remove abrasion that went further than it should have into the bevel.

I cannot deny that at this point, it's more effective than anything I've done on stones if the objective is to use the chisel to do things like pare or any significant chopping (not prying, and it's not applicable for mortise chisels when you want to ride the bevel - still need the bevel to ride there,but if they don't hold up well, even there a tiny rounding (the odate thing) greatly improves their performance.

The feel is super lovely for dropping a chisel into a marked line and then paring waste. And it works well even if the chisel is a little bit substandard. less wedging in the cut, less accidental compression of the wood at or behind the marked line.

So that's all of the bits and pieces at once (easier cutting, less damage, less time to sharpen, etc).

Re: Weaver grind v/s Japanese feathering

#3

Re: Weaver grind v/s Japanese feathering

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

On a Narex chisel I started on a 1 micron diamond charged cast iron plate and for a few back strokes raised the chisel from the primary bevel of 30 degrees to at most 40. Then a few strokes on green stuff charged leather, same technique. The result was impressive. The result was just a glint of brightness across the edge when the light reflected just right. So, is it equivalent?

David's approach of using a buffing wheel is superior for several reasons. but what I did was proof of concept for my situation. I am already contemplating how to add the buffing wheel to my routine.

Re: Weaver grind v/s Japanese feathering

#4

Unicorn profile...

David Weaver

I'd like to propose a name change (as I don't like having my name on something that I know has been done before, even if the precise bits and pieces haven't been published as such for tools).

Since the idea of bettering a flat edge in penetration, honing time, and edge holding is sort of like chasing a unicorn, I think unicorn profile is a good name.

However, in fairness to wiley (since I attach the message to the person often and manage to unintentionally offend folks who like to separate both), this idea (Even if not original) and me are one in and the same, so if someone thinks it's dumb or unoriginal, I won't be offended in the least to have it assaulted and my introduction of it (by name) attached to the assault. I'd prefer to be dressed down via idea/points arguments if it leads to learning something and I might miss it if you don't accuse me in the process!

Re: Weaver grind v/s Japanese feathering

#5

Re: Weaver grind v/s Japanese feathering

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Bill, as I recall, Odate refers to increasing the angle at the leading edge to roughly 80 degrees. Years ago I was taught a technique by Harrelson Stanley, which he referred to as “jointing the edge”. This involved standing the bevel vertically and running it very lightly across the stone.

Ironically, for the past few years I avoided using a leather strop owing to the threat of dubbing. This past weekend, inspired by David’s postings, I decided to try a variant of the rounded bevel using one of my old strops loaded with green compound.

The chisels were a couple of vintage Boxwood marples with 20 degree hollow ground bevels. These were kept for delicate paring, and did not hold an edge long (frankly, I was wondering whether I should have given them such a low bevel at all). I was working on some Hard Maple end grain (kitchen cabinet doors). The chisels were pulled back along the strop on the hollow, and then lifted about 10 degrees (ala Paul Sellers). 4 or 5 strokes created a very fine wire, which was rubbed off on the strop.

The edge appeared as sharp as ever (compared with the other chisel, which was honed just with stones). Subjectively, it seemed to hold an edge better than before. But I emphasize that this is subjective. Objective testing needs to follow.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Weaver grind v/s Japanese feathering

#6

Unicorn Profile it is

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I agree it is only reasonable that the inventor has naming rights. Hence, I yield to the Unicorn Profile.

The added benefit is someone is apt to see the term and be tempted to find an answer to the question, what the hell is that all about?

Against all advice I don't sharpen when I need to but rather at the end of a project or at least at the conclusion of a large step. I'll be giving the Corian substrate (needs a name) method a workout soon as the desk is near done.

BTW, I did sharpen planes before doing drawer sides. I went nuts setting the cap iron close. I was barely strong enough to push up a 2" shaving. I got to thinking what a massive force was being applied through the shaving and onto the surface of the wood at the blade tip. ( I backed it off some as the shaving was buckling)

Re: Weaver grind v/s Japanese feathering

#7

Re: Weaver grind v/s Japanese feathering

Winston

> I'm chasing what I've seen on the knives, where the idea of some perfect apex right at the edge isn't really that important.

From the testing and pictures I did with buffed chisels, I'm coming around to the idea that a one-atom thick apex isn't necessary for good performance cutting wood, and that it can harm edge durability. Of course, I wasn't able to see exactly what the edge profile is -- I think you'd need an electron microscope for that -- but the light reflections suggest that the edge is rounded over a bit after buffing, and also, a rounded edge is what one would expect from rubbing a soft abrasive object on a hard edge.

The fact that the rounded, higher-angle edge has less cutting resistance (as David experienced), or has about the same resistance (as I experienced) as a flat, unbuffed edge is interesting. It makes me wonder if much of the cut resistance with the flat unbuffed blades, comes from wedging very (very!) close to the edge, instead of forces right at the apex.

I said earlier that I think there are three possible things contributing to the edge durability for buffed blades: a higher angle at the edge, a rounded apex, and the smooth, uniform surface. (I know from the pictures that the buffed edge is significantly smoother and more uniform than what I get off a Shapton 12000.) I don't know the relative importance of each of these things, though.

Even if an unbuffed edge is sharper and cuts easier than a buffed one, I found that such an edge is visibly damaged even after a little paring of something as soft as pine, even with PM-V11. So for practical use, I don't think it would stay sharper than a buffed edge for long. But this does need more testing.

I'm curious if one can get the same effect with a strop. I think it would be kind of amusing if, after all the discussions people have had about stones, grits, bevel angles, and all that, it turns out that you don't have to worry much about the specific stone, or grit, or angle, and that just finishing with a strop makes more of an improvement than any of those other things.

I also wonder how well this works for plane blades. I had very brief experiment with buffing a plane blade, in which it was incredibly quick and easy to get a blade sharp enough to produce a maximally smooth wood surface. For me, getting blade sharpened to that level just on stones takes significantly more work. But it chipped out (probably due to either hitting something, or poor deburring) before I got much usage out of the blade. Even if buffed blades have clearance issues earlier than unbuffed ones, they might be suitable for finish planing, where you won't go for a long time anyway before resharpening.

Re: Weaver grind v/s Japanese feathering

#8

Why I didn't further plane blades...

David Weaver

i sharpened one plane blade, maybe two - don't remember.

The nice thing about the chisel is that when you're moving the bevel edge back, you're going to end up removing most of the wear (near all?) on the back. So there's no great reason to do anything on the back with the buffer other than use the loose edge of the weave on the back to make sure there's no remaining burr.

But, there's a whole lot of wear on the back of a plane iron - longer scratches if not using a cap iron, and short deeper wear if the cap is used. I found for a hundredth set, probably 3 thousandths of wear. How much do we sharpen off? I have no idea. I'd be surprised if we knock 3 thousandths off working the bevel side.

So, you get stuck working the back, and then on top of that, the unicorn bevel may leave a more blindingly polished surface, but the way a plane iron wears is different (usually not much for edge defects and lots for wear that removes the initial edge quickly).

I could be wrong, though. It may be worth dedicating one iron to a shallower primary to solve the clearance issue.

Re: Weaver grind v/s Japanese feathering

#9

Re: Why I didn't further plane blades...

Winston

Just curious: how much do you work the back when you sharpen a plane blade?

Re: Weaver grind v/s Japanese feathering

#10

Re: Why I didn't further plane blades...

David Weaver

10 or 15 seconds briskly on a washita stone, which is a considerable amount.

I think if anything isn't completely sharpened on a plane iron normally, it's the tip of the iron on the back.

(that's also what I found when I was trying to make photo perfect completely prepared edges for the plane iron test - that if any part came up short, that was it).

Re: Weaver grind v/s Japanese feathering

#11

Just A Clarification, Here

Tom Colligan

Does this mostly apply to chisels? Or, is it equally effective for plane irons? Thx.,

Re: Weaver grind v/s Japanese feathering

#12

Chisels

David Weaver

it doesn't really address wear on the back of a plane iron, whereas that wear doesn't amount to much on a chisel.

Plus, chisels generally get resharpened due to impact, which is what this guards against, and planes generally due to wear.