Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A new block plane question

Posts

A new block plane question

#1

A new block plane question

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Disclaimer: This question is entirely a result of curiosity. I do not expect the answers to be of any practical value to me or others.

Without thinking I used a block plane today, when earlier I said I never used one. I overlooked a common planing operation.

I make traditional drawers. I face the same tasks to make a drawer as someone in 1840. What differs, more or less, are the tools we use. The drawers are made. I am refining the fit to the openings with a plane, an operation presumably identical to 1840. I am planing the sides to clean up dovetails and refine the clearance. I am using a metal plane vs wood in 1840. No significant difference in method or result, just the details of the tool.

Planing strokes are front to back along the drawer side. Pins on back board are unsupported end grain. They will splinter if the blade exits the unsupported back side. I, and I am guessing the 1840 drawer maker, chamfers the back vertical edge of the drawer to eliminate the risk splintering the end grain pin on the back side.

I used a block plane. A one handed plane was handy because I could position the drawer with one hand/arm and plane with the other. I did not need to fixture the drawer to the bench.

Presuming the 1840 drawer maker also chamfered this edge , what would they have used?

A more global question, the block plane is a one handed plane. Some planing operations are most handy done one handed on the plane. Are the coffin planes described earlier serviceable for the occasions where a one handed plane would be the best planing option? Some other means to this end in 1840?

Re: A new block plane question

#2

Re: A new block plane question

John Aniano in central NJ

Bill,

I have a number of small coffin shaped wooden smoothing planes that would be used with one hand. In fact, some are so small you can't really use two hands. They have flat bottoms and range from maybe 2-1/2" long upwards to 6" or so. They look like miniature smoothers, which is really what they are. Most are of beech and a few are boxwood. Most have single blades that are bevel down. The larger of them have double blades. As far as I can tell, they are all English or Scottish made.

I've got a few similar sized ones with convex curved bottoms so they are miniature compass planes. I'll have to check my PC for photos...

John

Re: A new block plane question

#3

Re: A new block plane question

Wiley Horne

John,

Do any of those planes have commercial maker’s marks? Or are they shop made?

Wiley

Re: A new block plane question

#4

Re: A new block plane question

Warren in Lancaster, PA

About a month ago I read on a forum about a guy who was in a museum in Rhode Island looking at a chest of a famous Newport maker from maybe 240 years ago. The fellow got a docent to open up a drawer so he could look at the dovetails and judge skill of the maker. What is weird is that the maker was probably more concerned about moldings and carvings. I guess that if there is no turning, no carving, no moldings, no special finishing, no inlay, and everything is just sanded to a uniform dullness, the drawer dovetails become high art.

I often just make a chamfer with a chisel. I found some that I made decades ago with no apparent chamfer, or possibly just very small. I also found some 18th century drawer sides with chamfers which appeared to be made with a plane. One 18th century drawer side had a big chamfer on the sides and also top and bottom, as if to help ease it into the drawer opening.

You can make a chamfer one handed with a #3 plane or a wooden smoother pretty easily.

Re: A new block plane question

#5

Re: A new block plane question

David Weaver

i use a stanley 4 for this, askew (facing downhill to the grain) and can't remember thinking much about tearing off corners.

Of course, I've done this on more plane bodies than drawers.

Re: A new block plane question

#6

Re: A new block plane question

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I didn't understand what the 1st paragraph had to do with the question, or what it was all about. The last sentence answered it. There were planes in 1840 that could be employed one handed.

When the world went to metal I suppose the need for a one handed plane was better met with a block plane configuration.

Re: A new block plane question

#7

i have a couple of thoughts..

David Weaver

..small metal planes would've been really expensive, and they're not necessary, which is probably the biggest impediment to them getting to market.

But I have another quibble with them. Even on small chamfers, etc, you get tearout, and on anything big enough to use two hands, you can still do the chamfer with one or two hands with a smoother (and not have tearout issues).

Plus, it's one less plane to get out.

A typical coffin smoother is less heavy than a stanley 4 and anything that's too small to use it on is pretty easy to chisel cleanly.

Re: A new block plane question

#8

An unrelated question

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

In 1930 +/- would the manufacturing cost of a #4 be more or less than a wood equivalent coffin plane? Related, what factor drove wood planes from the market?

Re: A new block plane question

#9

preference

David Weaver

I'm guessing here, but the decline of tools other than for site use (I can't imagine that plane use was even that significant in factories where a lot of trade workers were already working by then - at least by notes that I've received in sharpening stones) must've had something to do with it.

I've seen accounts from folks on SMC a decade and a half ago when I first started where they mentioned their grandparents' (or older) celebration of metal planes that didn't move seasonally.

There's a huge number of wooden planes left in england and they were made in ever faster traditional fashion up to the end (60s? 70s?), and the fellow who got me into woodworking had a dad who was a joiner from 40s through 80s. He had a bullnose infill, a stanley 4 and a record 5 1/2 - no wooden planes).

I get the sense that a typical stanley plane was around 1/2 day to 1 day's pay for a skilled tradesman in the early 1900s. I'd be surprised if a wooden plane cost that much. an old ward's catalog around that time would probably be helpful.

Re: A new block plane question

#10

Re: An unrelated question

Steve Voigt

In 1930 +/- would the manufacturing cost of a #4 be more or less than a wood equivalent coffin plane? Related, what factor drove wood planes from the market?

In the U.S. the last wooden plane co. (Sandusky) went belly up in 1926, I believe.

When Stanleys first appeared they were more expensive, something like twice the price, than woodies, but the price came down as manufacturing scaled up.

Woodies were driven from the market partly by all-metal Stanley/Bailey planes, but also by transitionals, which were very popular and much cheaper than the all-metal designs.

It's worth understanding the overall picture. Woodies were already in decline when S/Bs hit the scene; manufacturers were using prison labor to flood the market with cheap, low-quality planes, kind of like what's done with low quality import goods today.

They were declining because hand work of all types was declining. By the end of the civil war, most furniture here was made in factories. Homes were stick framed and wooden wall panels were replaced with plaster. Windows, doors, mouldings, could be purchased. And on and on.

The typical homeowner around the turn of the century probably used a plane the way today's homeowners use cheap consumer-grade power tools:once in a while, without much skill. Like Dave said, they didn't want to tune the sole (with another plane) every time they picked it up. They didn't use the plane enough to become proficient at hammer setting. In short, metal planes took over, to a large extent, because they're easier for the casual user.

As Dave indicated, the dynamic was different in England because hand work in general hung on a lot longer.

Re: A new block plane question

#11

Re: An unrelated question *LINK*

Warren in Lancaster, PA

From a 1938 Marples catalog:

single iron beech smoother: 3 shillings

double iron beech smoother: 5 shillings 6 pence to 7 shillings 6 pence.

parallel iron 6d extra

Iron plane #4 13 shillings 6 pence


1938 Marples

Re: A new block plane question

#12

Thanks, Warren...

David Weaver

...worth a chuckle that the double iron version of the smoother brings almost twice as much.

I've had planes that look like those (the smoother shows hand cut eyes, but the jacks show eyes I've seen on a lot of marples planes that are just a half moon rotary dip).

At some point, grain orientation became questionable and I've seen one or two (had one was unused NOS) where the wood was 90 degrees off of proper orientation - which would make for a fast wearing plane sole.

For all of the plane irons that seem to be early to mid 1900s, things went soft (presumably due to the type of customer) in the laminated irons. The solid taper irons that I've used all feel like oil hardening steel on the stones, and can often be soft, too.

not a tool historian, but have had tang chisels of the same style and mark as in that catalog and they have been good and not suffered the same reduction in hardness that the irons in the wooden planes did.

With changes occurring over time, it's hard to guess which things were intentional and which weren't. A site user would appreciate an iron that's a bit softer, and someone doing cabinetmaking would probably prefer something closer to typical stanley hardness. The average plane iron that I've sharpened from that era (laminated) is well less hard than a typical stanley iron at the same time.