Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Diamonds on corian

Posts

Diamonds on corian

#1

Diamonds on corian

David Weaver

I finally tried this - will report back with more use at some point, but initial thoughts:

* better and more resiliant than wood, better feel

* working small areas like bevels, etc, you won't have the potential of creating a bit of a wire edge if you lift the chisel to do the "roll".

https://i.imgur.com/AKHIDNZ.jpg

The diamonds do embed. How much? I don't know.

Feel is excellent. Worthy of using if you have corian scraps around.

I lubricated the surface with WD 40, as usual.

The picture above is 1 micron diamonds, no stropping, no perceptible wire edge and a lot of the small lines in the picture may be WD 40 - it's difficult to wipe all of the stuff off of an edge for microscope pictures as any tiny amount left is reflective. This is after about 10 wipes on a shirt in different spots.

Here is a dan's black ark (that's only been used for razors before the iron test) for comparison in regard to fineness.

Both of these levels of fineness work well in actual work, but you can feel that the diamond edge is sharper, and in the durability test, it lasted longer.

https://i.imgur.com/lxt9uYz.jpg

Re: Diamonds on corian

#2

Re: Diamonds on corian

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Thanks for posting that, David. After I asked the question I tried it myself. I use 1 micron paste, so I don’t need WD40. My results are the same as yours.

I wondered about the lack of a wire edge, which would have been minimal, but the results are very good. I have no way of telling how deeply the diamonds embed, but even though it doesn’t give much resistance, the edge comes away very sharp. I only have O1 and A2, plus whatever a Berg chisel uses (though I suspect it’s pretty close to a W1), so can’t say anything about PMV11. Everything comes away very sharp. Haven’t tried rolling the edge yet.

That piece of Corian now stays on the bench.

Re: Diamonds on corian

#3

no lube?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

1 micron paste, so I don’t need WD40.

I always juice up a plate with WD 40. Doesn't it get sticky without lube to float the gung away?

Re: Diamonds on corian

#4

Re: no lube?

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I haven’t used the corian enough to need it yet. I do clean the cast iron fairly often. I’m almost out of the 1 micron paste so I’m stingy with it for the time being.

Re: Diamonds on corian

#5

More about Corian

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I evaluated acrylic, Plexiglas, when we studied loose diamond sharpening. It was good for coarse grits because they embedded better than the not at all on cast iron. But it was "sticky", which was cured with propylene glycol lube. I never tried 1 micron diamond on it.

Corian is this same acrylic filled with hydrated alumina. Colors are pigments of some sort. All this filler would do nothing but improve acrylic as a substrate and could eliminate the stickiness. Another experiment to try is alumina on Corian.

I am concerned with WD 40 as a lube. It could soften it, but maybe not. Needs testing on Plexiglas where the result will be easier to tell......I will do it. Water may work well or light oil for that matter.

Weaver has turned this Forum into the Journal of Woodworking Research. We need to start peer reviewing :) David get this Corian thing out on your Facebook account. It solves the expense of cast iron and the carry over issue. Contaminate the 1 micron plate....toss it. Everywhere has a Corian cabinet shop. They generate gobs of scrap.

Re: Diamonds on corian

#6

Re: More about Corian

David Weaver

no likey on the facebook thing!! :)

not into that site, but I will remember to come back to this regarding whether or not I see any degradation due to WD-40.

I just hardly know what to do now with all of my stones and now the buffer and corian fighting for time

Re: Diamonds on corian

#7

Re: More about Corian

Jonathan Elliott

I really like the Journal of Woodworking Research! This is great stuff. Is that why professionals read journals in their fields?? :)

I'm curious for some more details on loading the diamonds on a given substrate. I know it's been mentioned before but Bill, you recently said at the beginning you used much more than was needed.

What is a good amount? How does one go about spreading evenly on a given substrate? Does it differ for coarse vs fine grits?

Thanks!

Jonathan

Re: Diamonds on corian

#8

dry diamonds

David Weaver

I can comment on the dry diamond side. A tiny sprinkle of the diamonds and a few drops of WD40 is enough for them pretty much to spread all over the place.

(this is for fine diamonds).

when the WD moves around and is milky because of the diamonds, you know they're getting everywhere. They're cheap enough now that it doesn't matter that much if some are wasted (talking $10 a year for heavy use of several fine grits cheap).

Eventually like stone slurry, it darkens. You can push some of the slurry away from an area on the stone or surface that you're using and then run the bevel of the chisel over the cleared area. It will darken the surface quickly, you're good to go until the surface isn't darkened quickly. This is easier on corian than cast, because the cast can do a little bit of work on its own and is about the same color as swarf.

I've only used large loose diamonds on a mild steel plate, and that wasn't ideal, so I'll defer to bill on those. They rolled on the steel plate for a while and the whole shebang worked better with a bunch of rolling diamonds, but that's far from ideal (they're abrading the substrate and the object to be ground at the same time).

Re: Diamonds on corian

#9

answers

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Is that why professionals read journals in their fields?? Yes, research builds on what came before. Need to know what came before to inspire the next step.

What is a good amount? a 1/4" "worm" of paste from a syringe will charge a 3 x 12" plate.

How does one go about spreading evenly on a given substrate? Tow tasks to be accomplished. Spreading and embedding. Finger, piece of hard flat rock like agate, the tool being sharpened. The people that use diamond for faceting stones squirt some paste on the plate then use a hard flat stone to spread and push diamond into the substrate. Does it differ for coarse vs fine grits? no

Thanks!

Jonathan

Re: Diamonds on corian

#10

Re: dry diamonds

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

agree on all points. A 1 mm mound of dry on the top of a spatula is plenty, probably way less than a milligram. As David says, the plate will become milky at first from the diamond slurry.

I've only used large loose diamonds on a mild steel plate, and that wasn't ideal, so I'll defer to bill on those. They rolled on the steel plate for a while and the whole shebang worked better with a bunch of rolling diamonds, but that's far from ideal (they're abrading the substrate and the object to be ground at the same time).

Same experience with cast iron, which is why I explored using acrylic for the coarser grits. Large particles embed better on a softer substrate.

I think diamond 30 micron and less is the practical range for cast iron and this range is good for most tasks.

Re: Diamonds on corian

#11

What you do on a copper lap

John in NM

Is spread the diamond + oil, then roll them in gently with an old bearing on a stick.

I just replaced a couple bearings in my table saw motor so I may do that with some corian. I know a corian installer locally, I really like that idea.

Re: Diamonds on corian

#12

That helps

Jonathan Elliott

Thanks for those explanations, that helps give me a good understanding. I didn't know dry diamonds were an option so that was informative too!

Re: Diamonds on corian

#13

I tried copper copper lap

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

It quickly accumulated a layer of gunk that became sticky. There is almost no friction on cast iron. I have not done Corian yet.

Re: Diamonds on corian

#14

Copper is for coarse grit

John in NM

I've never tried it with a blade, but I find it useful for stone up to 600 grit.

However, the point is that you can similarly roll the diamond into any soft surface.