Finding the answer rather than why not..
David Weaver
As you've seen, if you can find relatively unused planes that were probably made in the mid to late 1800s in England, they are probably the best wooden planes ever made.
I can match them in performance, but I can't better them (when they're refitted and forgiven for a century and a half or more of movement). At least in terms of trying planes, jointers and jack planes - I can make a coffin smoother plane work well, or make one that works well, but a common stanley 4 makes my heart swoon when it comes to smoothing.
When I was on my chase, I found the mathieson, griffits, etc, almost identical in the middle - the little nuances above the wear were related to how the makers cut the waste out of the cheeks (flat facet toward the center of the plane and then forward to the end of the eyes in another facet, or a single cut from the abutments all the way forward.
It takes finding out why something was done rather than trying to find a way to argue against the most likely scenarios. Simply, finding planes in the condition they would've been when this type took over and looking at them.
I had another reason for doing all of the buying - it wasn't to chase ideals and one up anything, it was the realization that if you're going to learn to make tools, and you've made tools before that come in second to tools you've bought for various reasons (studying poor examples or not understanding or executing details), it's worthwhile to spend a few hundred dollars and find the best working examples you can find. The english planes just ended up all being a whole lot less different in design and proportion than I expected they would.