Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

case fin...

Posts

case fin...

#1

case fin...

David Weaver

waiting to be moved upstairs. T&G is off on the back as I don't want it on the case until the last second (so that I can lift the top on and off easily).

The top case could've had more depth, but I copied the dimensions off of what we have already and I guess lack of depth does prevent hidden items on the top shelf (those things that aren't in front).

Moulding wrapped around the bottom of the top case is questionable - it's a quirked bead - for some reason, I thought it would go with the doors, but instead, it mismatches the two top mouldings and the base stepped cove. There's enough wood there to tape off the case at a later date and cut the bead off into a cove with H&R and then blend it in with finish. The finish is earth pigments (as discussed on here - japan colors mixed into stain).

Photo makes top and bottom sides look drastically different in color, but the're much closer.

Looks kind of old, but not completely old, and looks a little bit worn to start (or hand rubbed at some point) and that's a good condition as small dents won't be noticed.




The mrs. is tasked with finding pulls as she doesn't want turned pulls. I've got loads of rosewood, etc, that would look nice and contrast the orangey brown cherry.

Re: case fin...

#2

The other astonishingly odd thing...

David Weaver

I almost forgot the overlay doors that are not on a frame and not inset in one. The mrs. gave me a hard order of no inset doors, and no center post. The doors on the consumer commodity cabinet that this is replacing are just the same way. I would've much preferred to face frame the thing and inset the doors but some of the game boxes that go in this cabinet are wider than one door, and so it is the way it's shown.

There won't be much chance of sagging as nothing is less than 3/4" solid on the cabinet and everything is dovetailed or dadoed.

Well, the door panels and the T&G back are less than 3/4", but that's it.

Re: case fin...

#3

Re: case fin...

Bruce, a MN Galoot

That’s a very fine cabinet. Thanks for bringing us along.

Re: case fin...

#4

That is fine woodworking

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

David, you are a secret furnituremaker! (Unless that is an unusual-looking Fender).

Overall, the piece works, and I really would not stress about one molding. Only you see an issue - is this not the maker thing ... we see our errors and everyone else sees the effort and class. I really like the finish and the joinery, doors, and composition are excellent.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: case fin...

#5

Re: case fin...

Wiley Horne

It’s handsome, David. What I like best is that the ageless look and coloring give the cabinet a sense of history. When you put it in place, it will look like it grew there.

The other best thing is that the wife is involved in picking the pulls, and made other design decisions. It’s a family project. So it does have a history!

Wiley

Re: case fin...

#6

Re: case fin...

John Jardin

Outstanding David

Re: case fin...

#7

Thanks, Bruce!


Re: case fin...

#8

Re: That is fine woodworking

David Weaver

Thanks for the kind words, Derek. Not a threat to make more furniture in the near future!

Save one possible piece started 14 years ago and never progressed....maybe in a few months.

You're right about the details - I'm annoyed by them, but only because of the constant looking at the case. It'll be put in its permanent spot and I"ll be back to making fender shaped fender copies. :)

Re: case fin...

#9

Thanks, Wiley!


Re: case fin...

#11

Re: case fin...

Hank Knight

That's a really nice piece, David. I agree with Derek: don't worry about the molding. Everybody, including me, will be impressed with the cabinet and nobody will notice the mismatched molding. I didn't. The real question is, how does your wife like it?

Re: case fin...

#12

Bright brass conventional knob

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Bright brass looks good on dark cherry. Nice piece. The panels are special.

Re: case fin...

#13

Re: case fin...

David Weaver

bill had a good idea - wrap a thin cove moulding around the base of the top case, pinned to the top of the case (these two won't be apart. It wasn't even necessary to build this as two separate pieces but somewhere in my mind, I have the notion that someone will gleefully put these two things in different locations and the bottom case needs to be able to stand on its own.

The reason the bottom moulding of the top case is so tall is the bottom shelf is embedded in it and then I needed some "holding wood" below the dovetails that hold the bottom shelf to the sides. They are the mechanism holding the case together - the next two shelves are full length dovetails - my spontaneous deconstruction fears are a bit overwrought. But the base (of the top case) is plain, tall and the point where i saw the clash isn't when building the pieces separately, but when first sitting the case on top of the bottom case.

I neglected to realize (as a non furniture builder) that the separation isn't between cases, but by distance of mouldings, so the view of that bottom is really against the top of the case below and not in reference to the top moulding. Lesson learned.

Bill's idea is to (at the very least) cut a cove moulding that can be applied to the bottom of the top case and pinned in place. This is an easy thing and can be done later with the case in place. I think it will be a big improvement. Its orientation in the middle of the case means that making it not very thick will be fine I'm thinking a simple cove about 7/8" tall with flats of about 1/4" at the bottom and 1/8th at the top. By orientation, I mean, it doesn't need to face up at some drastic angle, but face more out into the room to someone standing 6 or 10 feet away.

Re: case fin...

#14

Re: case fin...

Raymond in Trenton NJ

Very nice case piece David. I think it looks very smart the way it is. Having said that, I do understand what you mean about details bothering you. I believe that happens to all of us. I like your idea of letting it sit in place for a while. It may grow on you. And if not, there's always Bill's suggestion.

Thanks for sharing,

Raymond

Re: case fin...

#15

Re: Looks great Dave!


Re: case fin...

#16

Re: case fin...

Sgian Dubh

"I have the notion that someone will gleefully put these two things in different locations and the bottom case needs to be able to stand on its own."

David, when I first spotted your original post and photographs a few days ago I decided to not comment because I really, and immediately, found the piece visually uncomfortable.

However, you have since raised the issue yourself - the quotation above, about essentially what I saw at first look, i.e., two very well made and polished cabinets, very similar in overall appearance where, almost accidentally and fortuitously, the smaller cabinet fits reasonably well on the lower cabinet.

I know this was never 'accidental' on your part, and you outline your reasoning, the technical elements, and your lack of experience in furniture design in explanation, so I hope you won't feel I'm being overly and harshly judgemental, or unfair. Slainte.

Re: case fin...

#17

goodness...

David Weaver

..you could say you absolutely hate it and despise the idea of eschewing modern (much easier) ways of accomplishing things on this cabinet - like toning a modern finish and getting very even color with spraying.

I'd not be offended.

everything furniture related is a learning experience for me and some parts of the aesthetic that I do like (the not old but not new look) aren't going to be found favorable now.

The mrs. gives it more thumbs down than thumbs up so far, but I've learned what she likes. Milk paint.

(she doesn't like things not durable, so I spray a kitchen finish over the paint).

Bill's suggestion about softening the transition with moulding wrapped around the bottom of the top case with a cove will be enough to bail me out, and it'll be easy to execute. It won't please the mrs. but it'll please me!

Re: case fin...

#19

thanks raymond

David Weaver

you're right about the details. My house is a very boring (fine with me) 50s ranch type with old wood trim and plaster. It really isn't going to matter if this is made "right" in the long run.

https://i.imgur.com/N7U4KdC.jpg

https://i.imgur.com/62RO8H2.jpg?1

I also set out at the beginning not to make anything nice, and many things didn't get much forethought.

To use bill's words, it was more of a sock storage type piece of furniture and not something for looks.

I'm inclined to build something much more crisp for looks now, though.