Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

When things don't go to plan...

Posts

When things don't go to plan...

#1

When things don't go to plan...

Jim Matthews

I'm curious what others do, when things go off the rails.

I'm making something to store socks in, entirely by hand.

Because the resulting cabinet is large (50×40 inches), I've resawn to 1/2" nominal thickness.

It will subdivide to three sets of cubbies, largest at the bottom for use in our entryway.

I've been finishing each panel as I go, because applying finish when assembled is daunting.

Here's the rub - I don't trust 1/2" dovetails in the Sugar Maple I'm using for the side panels.

****

When things go well, I'm knee deep in shavings.

When a project stumps me, I sweep.

My floor has been *very* clean, of late.

What do the rest of you do, when things go wrong?

Re: When things don't go to plan...

#2

Re: When things don't go to plan...

David Weaver

Same thing, sort of. I pick up a few things (especially if I'm suddenly angry and wait for the knee jerk reaction to go away and then start thinking of fixes.

I never do the first fix that comes to mind as it's always one extreme or another (sledgehammer for a nut problem like scrapping an entire project to start over, or hideously lazy)

Re: When things don't go to plan...

#3

Re: When things don't go to plan...

Wiley Horne

Hi Jim,

What is the structure like? How does the 50x40 break down? Are there internal members like drawer dividers? Vertical dividers?

I suspect there is plenty you can do with the back and with internal dividers to prevent racking.

Wiley

Re: When things don't go to plan...

#4

Re: When things don't go to plan...

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Jim, I walk away and let it sit for a while. I have been in this situation so many times that I know a solution will come. And it does - there are so many ways to skin a cat.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: When things don't go to plan...

#5

Re: When things don't go to plan...

Hank Knight

Out of frustration, my instinct is to keep working on it; but fighting the problem is a mistake. It almost always makes things worse. Like Derek, I've learned to walk away for a while, sometimes for days. Many times I wake up in the morning with a solution in mind. It's amazing how one's brain continues to work on the things, even when we're asleep.

Re: When things don't go to plan...

#6

Re: When things don't go to plan...

Raymond in Trenton NJ

Hi Jim,

Ditto what everyone said when things actually hit the fan. Been there, done that, all true. Secure everything and walk away and think about/do something else. Sweeping and straightening up work for me, and I get to stay in the shop and glare at the 'problem project' :o)

There are other times where it's not actually tanking, but I start feeling muddled, things take longer/are harder and I start fumbling. Clues to me that work is not flowing and I'm forcing too much (or tired). There I force myself to walk away and do something else. The engineering gene in me doesn't want to let go or stop. I can fix this right? There's also a bit of ... pride(?) ... in there having to admit that I'm stuck or can't do it. Walking away feels bad for an instant, but I've learned all to well that a solution will present itself. And when I least expect it. That feels good for a long time.

I definitely am my own worst enemy (and critic!).

Raymond

Re: When things don't go to plan...

#7

Re: When things don't go to plan...

AlanWS

"Here's the rub - I don't trust 1/2" dovetails in the Sugar Maple I'm using for the side panels. "

With that size 1/2" thick panels, I can imagine bending that could lead to problems, but dovetails cut in hard maple 1/2" thick? They should be plenty strong.

Maybe I misunderstood. In my world things not going to plan is the norm anyway.

Re: When things don't go to plan...

#8

Consider the overall dimensions

Jim Matthews

The entire assembly will be large.

Reliance on dovetails (alone) for structural integrity gave me pause.

The Maple used is soft "Sugar" Maple and has a tendency to chip on exposed ends.

I've set up a series of battens, instead.

Re: When things don't go to plan...

#9

Re: Consider the overall dimensions

William Duffield

I can't seem to get my head around using dovetail joinery for panel construction. Dovetails are for case construction (boxes, boxes-in-boxes, ad infinitum). For panels, you should be using mortise and tenon joinery (or maybe plywood) :) .

Your maple nomenclature is also incorrect. Hard maple is sugar maple is rock maple is Acer saccharum. Soft maples include silver maple A. saccharinum; red maple A. rubrum, big leaf maple A. macrophyllum, Japanese red maple A. palmatum, box elder A. negrundo, and many others. I think most woodworkers prefer rock maple for joinery vs. the soft maples, but prefer soft maples for workability and aesthetics (figure).

You would do well to get that straightened out if you want them to let you into Canada, or even Vermont. :D Note, however, that I don't have the energy today to discuss the nomenclatural subtleties of water maple, swamp maple, or planetree.

Re: When things don't go to plan...

#10

Re: Consider the overall dimensions

Jim Matthews

The panels are made with rubbed glue joints, not dovetails.

The finished dimensions are 14" deep and more than 48" long.

Joining the *completed* panels at corners that far apart, with the panels only 1/2" thick left too little glue area for my liking in dovetails.

(It's in a kitchen entryway with heavy traffic.)

Once I decided the corners required glue blocks for bracing, it came together.

The lumber was sold in Central Massachusetts as Sugar Maple.

The ends grain of the boards, after cutting to length are prone to splintering off.

This characteristic particularly worried me in cutting dovetails.

Pics of the finished project soon to come.

Re: When things don't go to plan...

#11

Re: Consider the overall dimensions

Philip F Duffy

Hard maple is hard and sugar maple is hard so I agree completely!! p