Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Dia-Sharp Extra-Extra-Fine Question

Posts

Dia-Sharp Extra-Extra-Fine Question

#1

Dia-Sharp Extra-Extra-Fine Question

Pat Riley

So, since this diamond stone was mentioned earlier, I thought I would ask for some first hand information.

As I mentioned in a previous post, I have all kinds of sharpening equipment, and use what I feel is best and fastest for each different application. These days I use DMT diamond stones for my plane blades. I end with the extra fine, then use a nice strop with green compound to finish. This produces an edge that is as sharp as any other method I have used or witnessed.

Recently the Extra Extra Fine D8EE was mentioned here, and I think it might show up at my house soon. (due to Father's Day). Have those of you that own this stone found it to be something you need? or just a luxury? Is it worth having one? I have never felt like I needed one, but have to admit, it would be fun to have.

Anyone have much first hand experience?

Thanks

Re: Dia-Sharp Extra-Extra-Fine Question

#2

no and yes

David Weaver

I have not used this particular stone, but I have used diamonds of the same size on a substrate (i think it's 3 micron - I have 2.5 loose).

I don't think you'll want to drop your regimen of green stropping afterwards as even broken in, the edge can be a tad coarse (lack of bright finish, etc - it's certainly usable in a way that a 1200 grit unstropped edge isn't), but I also think you're going to get a better and more uniform finish with your green stuff after this than you will manage to get after the 1200 grit plate.

Plus, it'll get you on the doorstep of carving tool ready or any other such things.

The more uniform the finish, the better the edge is going to wear and the longer it will last. Steve elliot tested that and then I did last year embedded in v11 testing. the spectrum of edge life planing was something like 1 micron diamonds being my fine standard for the test, 5 lasted about 66% of the footage (never nearly as nice to use), aggressive 2.5 was slightly better, and 1 micron was the standard, so 50% longer than 5 micron diamonds (that's even bare stropped).

In order to really get something like a 1200 grit diamond edge uniform off of green stuff, you almost have to round it over.

Re: Dia-Sharp Extra-Extra-Fine Question

#3

Re: no and yes

Pat Riley

Good to know. Thanks for the information. As a side question, I am about out of my Formax green compound and need to make another purchase to get me through the next couple of years. Where is the best place to get it these days? Do you have a different stropping compound you favor?

Thanks again.

Re: Dia-Sharp Extra-Extra-Fine Question

#4

Re: Dia-Sharp Extra-Extra-Fine Question

Wiley Horne

Hi Pat,

The D8EE started as a luxury for me, but has become the go-to stone. If something happened to this one I’ve had for a long time, I’d buy another immediately.

The main reason that stone is important for me is alloy blades. It works well for light alloy like O-1. But when you get to A2 or PM V11, it’s the difference between really sharp in 20 seconds, or using quite a bit of elbow grease.

Particularly when the flats start growing (I hollow grind). What I find is that right off the hollow grind, I can get a keen edge quickly with almost any stone, but as the flats start growing, the alloy gets tougher to tame, and that’s when D8EE shines. My experience with DMT had been quick-dying stones, but this one has lasted since Jan. 2018. It has settled in, as David said, but not lost cutting power. If anything, it’s a little too brash when brand new, for an 8K stone.

I have begun to change several irons to PMV11, specifically because of the way they match up with D8EE. It will handle higher alloy too, like CPM 3V and M2, but I don’t expect many others have those.

The stone is quick. I like it for gouges, for example.

I keep a spray bottle of water nearby, for water stones, and use it for the diamond stone as well. I have cut the diamonds right off a couple of DMT Diasharp, from dry sharpening alloy on them. BTW, I’m not a fan of DMT—have generally not had good experience with them. But this stone is different, particularly using a cutting fluid (water).

Why did I buy it to begin with? It was because I understood Bill T. some time ago saying that the carving instructor Mary May used the stone on her gouges—maybe I got that wrong, but if so it was a happy mistake.

I strop with 0.5u graded green after the diamond stone, and agree with David’s remarks on the benefits of stropping after diamond.

Wiley

Re: Dia-Sharp Extra-Extra-Fine Question

#5

Ez-lap

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I bought my fixed diamond stones at IWF shows in Atlanta. Ex-lap had a booth and sold them at a fraction of retail. I like that I can get a 12" stone from them. Last I bought was an "extra fine" but I don't know what micron size it is nor whether they make something finer now. I follow the extra fine with 1 micron diamond on cast iron.

Re: Dia-Sharp Extra-Extra-Fine Question

#6

Re: no and yes

David Weaver

google and ebay will find you the best price on the formax/microfine compound.

From what I can tell under the microscope, it's more coarse than 0.5 micron by a long shot, but it's a little bit irregular in grading for the alumina (which isn't a bad thing). Point being, you can go two directions with honing compounds - very fine (true 0.5 micron chrome ox, or something like linde b alumina -which is 0.3 micron, but will be more expensive - or more coarse, like a 3 micron alumina.

I'd stick with the green stuff after 3 micron diamonds - it's a good fit.

Autosol paste is another option (from smell and feel, the tormek PA-70 paste is just autosol, too, but at a higher price) - it's supposedly something like 3 micron, but it's a bit faster than the green stuff and the abrasive is a less tough type of alumina. That would also follow 3 micron diamond well, but no need to go there if you like the green stuff.

There's a million green chrome sticks from something that's $1.99 in the clearance aisle at sears (will be a harder stick and coarser alumina) to truly pure green stuff sold for razors in wax only with no alumina - but the comments above hold - the combination in the microfine stick is good for practical use because it's not as fine as pure chrome ox, but not nearly as slow because of it.

Re: Dia-Sharp Extra-Extra-Fine Question

#7

extra fine?

David Weaver

I think I have what they call fine (marked 600 grit) and extra fine (was marked 1200 grit, but I lost the sticker).

They were both brash when new but are now a lot finer than their initial use after knocking off outliers. I haven't seen finer from them, but no problem as the cost of the 1 micron diamonds now is something like a quarter per carat in quantity. I'm not sure $25 worth of 1 micron diamonds could be used in two decades of full time work.

I like them more because they've settled in fine. The 600 is similar to a 1000 grit waterstone and subjectively, the 1200 settles in close to what a 2k grit stone is.

If you got your plate a long time ago, the composition might be different - mine are a combination of monocrystalline and polycrystalline diamonds.

My pair are not totally flat to each other, but they're close.

Re: Dia-Sharp Extra-Extra-Fine Question

#8

Re: extra fine?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I have fine and extra fine. Followed by 1 micron diamond on cast iron I don't see much difference between them. Both are years old, worn more or less I do like the 12" length.

Re: Dia-Sharp Extra-Extra-Fine Question

#9

as the world turns...

Bruce Mack

..and I'm using the two 12" cast iron plates I bought from you with 2000 and 14000 grit diamond paste. This is a nice combo, followed by the green stuff.

Re: Dia-Sharp Extra-Extra-Fine Question

#10

Question

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

What you are doing is faster than fixed diamond plates and it takes optimum advantage of diamond rapid cutting of any steel. However.....

When we began using loose diamond we experienced carryover of coarse grits to fine. However, at that time we were charging the plates with vastly more diamond than necessary. In any case, fearful of hopelessly contaminating the fine plates we stopped using a succession of loose diamond.

Carryover could only be significant for an overcharged plate, or it may be a fatal flaw in two step loose diamond sharpening.

What is your experience with the two step loose diamond procedure with regard to carryover, or any other comments ?

Re: Dia-Sharp Extra-Extra-Fine Question

#11

Re: Question

Bruce Mack

Bill - I wipe the oil and swarf residue of the 2000 grit honing from the blade with a paper towel. However, I use the same towel, folded, to wipe the excess from the 14,000 grit step to allow me to see and feel the edge. After a while with the back and forth I get sloppy and I know a small amount of 2000 paste must transfer to the 14,000 plate from my ungloved fingers and from towel re-use. This does not seem to affect the edge which takes a mirror shine off the CrO2 strop with no visible deeper scratches and cuts very well. When the plates need recharging I use a towel sprayed with WD-40 to clean first the 14,000 and then the 2000 plate.

Previously when I used a rolling guide and Shapton waterstones I was fastidious, washing the rollers between steps and driving myself nuts. Now freehand on a hollow ground bevel I sharpen way faster and better.

Re: Dia-Sharp Extra-Extra-Fine Question

#12

Re: Question

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Bill, I use pretty much the same method of cleaning my plates that Bruce does. I also wipe the blade or chisel very carefully with a cloth followed by my hand, and I’ve not had a problem with grit carryover. I use both sides of my plates, each with a different grit of diamond paste. I don’t use loose diamonds.

Re: Dia-Sharp Extra-Extra-Fine Question

#13

loose diamonds

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

My definitions are:

fixed diamond- diamonds bonded to metal substrate

loose diamond- diamond not bonded to a metal substrate

Re: Dia-Sharp Extra-Extra-Fine Question

#14

carry over

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The carryover I speak of is from the tool Some diamond embeds in the tool. This problem is well known. However, it may be that with the hard steel we used this issue is not significant.

Re: Dia-Sharp Extra-Extra-Fine Question

#15

See it with stone too

John in NM

The solution there is to wash the stone (or in our case the chisel), hands, anything else, with soapy water between grits.