Quick question - I've used hot oxalic acid to bleach out some rust stains (from being nailed and getting wet) in some light maple moldings. Worked great to remove the rust markings. Before I apply a finish, should I neutralize the acid treatment?
Seems like a good idea until you consider with what and the result. I would wash it away instead. A guess....I never faced this problem .
oxallic acid combines with colored ferric iron to make colorless iron oxalate. Add base and I'll bet you will make red iron hydroxide and be back where you started.
I have used oxalic acid for about fifty years for removing iron tannate stains. Iron reacts with tannins in wood to make a black stain. It shows up especially in woods like oak and walnut where there have been nails. It is the same as gall ink that was used for centuries, so we use it on old ink stains also. The oxalic acid will turn the stain colorless and is washed away.
Oxalic acid is a very weak acid and does not cause a problem once you have wiped things dry. Even without any iron present, alkali like lye or ammonia will often discolor wood.
Yes, I would. I believe the box of acid I have recommends it. Since maple is not a high tannin wood, tap water should be fine. If like me and you put the hyphen in anal-retentive, distilled water is cleaner. I would wipe it with a wet (not dripping) rag a couple of times and let it dry. Sand as needed and finish as desired.
I used oxalic acid to get staining out of a friends oak floor (13' x 19') prior to finishing. Staining was probably 60%, but in spots close enough that we treated the whole floor. Some spots needed two applications. Afterwards, I wiped it down thoroughly with a wet sponge mop a couple of times. Because oak is high in tannins, we used fresh distilled water for each wipe. I did not flood the floor and used just under 2 gallons total. I am not a chemist or an chemical engineer and wasn't taking any chances with residues or possible reactions with the amount of work in the floor.
That was 15 years ago. They went with a clear varnish and the floor still looks good with it's patina of use.
Greenwich tap water would not be appropriate for a wash. We have an incredible amount of iron in our water. I always use deionized or distilled water, even on woods with little tannin. Maybe I'm being overly cautious, but I once tried to raise red oak grain with our tap water, and ended up with black spots all over the surface of the oak.
City supplied H2O is more treated than John/s well water. I have (yet another) friend in Imlaystown, just on the eastern side of Allentown a bit past John's. His tub and sinks have the red/orange staining of high iron content. Glad I at least mentioned distilled, that would be the way to go. Specially at $2 a gallon.
And the water not used for wood rinsing, John can use in his iron for his high collars and knickers.
To me wiping means moving something around without getting it off. Washing means removing it. Add water, mop up water, will remove what ever oxalic acid is dissolved in the water that is removed, as well as the colorless iron oxalate. I don't see that wiping with a damp rag will accomplish anything.
Iron can be in two forms, ferrous and ferric. Ferrous is lightly colored and soluble in water that is oxygen free. Ferric is highly colored and insoluble in water. Ferrous converts to ferric quickly in water that contains oxygen, then falls out of solution as red "rust".
If the water source is not precipitating rust in the sinks it will be suitable for washing the oxalic acid from the wood, if indeed this step is necessary. From the possible reaction of the hundreds of finish formulations with residual oxalic acid I would not want to speculate whether removal is necessary or not. Acids catalyze the formation of esters in shellac which leads to a bad result. Acids catalyze the desirable cross linking of conversion varnish, a good result.....for example. It's the iron I would want to get removed for fear it might find some means of becoming colored again.
I can imagine that hard water would be good to use. The pH buffering of hard water will neutralize oxalic acid and precipitate it as highly insoluble, and hence inert, calcium oxalate
Re: clarifying the iron in water issue and wiping.
Warren in Lancaster, PA
Sometimes experience is helpful. You don't talk like someone who has done this many times as I have. I believe the iron forms a complex ion with the oxalate; it certainly does not form a precipitate with hard water, and distilled water is not necessary. Nor is oxalic acid contamination a problem with finishes.
Re: clarifying the iron in water issue and wiping.
Raymond in Trenton NJ
Bill,
Thanks for the iron in water info. Nothing is ever simple :o) I don't remember John's fixtures having any staining.
Wiping vs washing ... semantics maybe?. I don't think flooding or flowing water over the surface is necessary. I had said "I would wipe it with a wet (not dripping) rag. I agree with you that a 'damp' rag would not be adequate. (not a chemist!) I think you need enough water to lower (neutralize) the pH rendering the acid 'not an acid' anymore. Re-reading the carton again I think the primary reason for neutralization is to halt the lightening action of the acid. Depending on the wood, staining present, acid concentration, application and possibly the phase of the moon, the acid may/could keep working and your dark spots could become light spots if not neutralized.
When I did the oak floor with the mop, the only water applied was from the mop. I didn't pour water and then start mopping. Also didn't scrub like normal cleaning, just wiped back and forth to ensure good coverage. There was a visible layer of water on the oak trailing from the mop. Because oak is ring porous I made sure there was adequate water. I rinsed the floor twice, no finishing interactions or continued lightening. Maple is not ring porous and I believe you can get by with less water to lower the acid pH. A wet rag (not dripping or damp) should be fine. I would still wipe a couple time, recharging the rag between with fresh water.
Sometimes experience is helpful. Undeniable, when relevant. The challenge with your experience is your choice to provide so few details of this experience leaves one not knowing if it is relevant.
You don't talk like someone who has done this many times as I have. Who knows?
I believe the iron forms a complex ion with the oxalate Indeed it does with ferric iron, three of them in fact, and not ferrous. The log of the formation constant is 9.4 indicating a strong ability to bind iron and the result is near colorless.
; it certainly does not form a precipitate with hard water The solubility of calcium oxalate is 0.0007g/100 mL water at 13 degrees C, for example., about half the solubility of limestone.
Nor is oxalic acid contamination a problem with finishes.How many do your have experience with? We don't know what finish will be applied. I was reading the technical data sheet for a Target waterborne and in the details it said not to use it over a specific red stain. Who would have anticipated that detail? I will not predict that oxalic acid is benign in the boggling variety of finishing chemistries out there, especially when one gets into the touchy chemistry of the cross linking chemistry and waterbornes. Nor will I predict its effect over time.
I agree distilled water is unnecessary and possibly even not as good as hard water which will likely have sufficient buffering capacity to neutralize the acid.
If you take a nice piece of white oak and put a teaspoon of water on the surface and a bit of steel wool, you will have inky staining in a half hour. Why? Because there is an organic acid in the wood which reacts with iron. My guess is that John Aniano did not neutralize the acid when he made an oak joint stool. And my guess is he did not worry about finish compatibility and the like.
In 2005 you asked about "planing purists". When I responded about finishing off the plane you said you were not going to believe it. Fifteen years later you are finally trying it. How many times does this have to happen?
Sir William again verified here. Years ago my neighbor in the new digs was building his log cabin. Prior to staining he power washed the lower courses with his well water. Black stains still plague him. At least he caught the issue early and only the back of the house is discolored near the foundation. Free water come with a price here...