Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Success on the coloring...I think.

Posts

Success on the coloring...I think.

#1

Success on the coloring...I think.

David Weaver

I'm getting close to putting the stuff together on the cabinet - I need to make a small bottom moulding and then pre-finish the door panels and bits and pieces.

The mrs still wants color- i want natural. Color to her is just short of paint (She would prefer paint - I would not). All canned minwax stains came up short and I am not spraying this to tone something as I have no dedicated spray area and I can spray clear, but colored something or other sprayed would have a permanent effect!), so japan color mixed with minwax stain base, and if there's some kind of problem with that (don't spoil my fun yet, bill), I'll just use straight micronized pigment from kremer (i have the same colors of pigment).

This is a test with minwax gunstock (sort of the color the mrs. likes, some kind of reddish brown, but way too weak) stain mixed roughly 2 parts stain, 1 part raw umber ronan japan color, and one part same thing burnt sienna. I doubt much of the color at this point is minwax stain, I just need the liquid to make it a little bit more runny to apply it.

From right to left is:

far right:

* early attempts at finding the darkest possible stain and applying it over and over. It looks bad because it's not intended to do what i'm looking for. I found the stain condition to be no help with this

* Then, the mix mentioned above (extremely potent)

* and, just to the left, the gunstock stain only with a little bit of raw umber japan color added (less potent).

* far left is obviously bare wood

This goes on easy - you wipe it on and done. not sloppy wet, just dampened on a tshirt and it's uniform in one pass. make another pass while still damp, it seems to make no difference - no more sticks, so the uniformity is good. No tons of oil carrying pigment down into other areas.


Note that the middle two pieces are just planed, not sanded. there is runout on the piece second from the right, so any lack of uniformity is about as bad as it will get anywhere on the cabinet.

Re: Success on the coloring...I think.

#2

.....planed boards....

David Weaver

..these were not finish planed, either. They're just scrap door sticking that was planed to size.

Re: Success on the coloring...I think.

#3

the way I apply shellac

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I use a rubber like applying shellac. In my case a wad of wool inside a cotton clothe. Dab it in the stain, bounce the pad to distribute and rub to transfer like padding shellac. Enables control of take onto the wood.

Re: Success on the coloring...I think.

#4

Re: .....planed boards....

Keith Newton

If I were you, I would still flip that far right board over and try your final choice on the other side. And of final note, you mentioned that these boards were not sanded. Most woods that sit for a while will form a crust or film, if you will, that resist absorption. Even a very light hand sanding with the grain will change that. There is a test you can easily do to see this by applying a drop of water on the bare surface and another on the just sanded area just beside it. On the unsanded area, the surface tension will allow the drop to just stand up there, while on the sanded it will quickly flatten out and start to absorb.

I'm only mentioning that because you said the later boards were not sanded, so this may be acting somewhat like a washcoat does, then when you use the same stain on a freshly sanded project, the results may suck the stain into those end-grain areas and be blotchy.

Re: Success on the coloring...I think.

#5

Re: Success on the coloring...I think.

Wiley Horne

Hi David,

I like the second from left.

One thing you might try....On two new offcuts, precoat the final raw wood (planed) surface with a resist layer of shellac—1/2lb cut on one and 1lb cut on the other (in other words, 2-3 coats of the 1/2lb). I’m assuming there’s nothing alcohol-soluble in your colorants.

The shellac precoat may even the pigment uptake a bit. Combine with Bill’s padding idea. I have grown to like blotching, but it’s an acquired taste for most.

Wiley

Re: Success on the coloring...I think.

#6

planed and sanded...

David Weaver

I had the same fear, so I tried four bits on the same board:

* planed (as it was left - these were recently planed)

* sanded

* 2-o steel wool

* scraped

I'm showing the planed and sanded boards below. I was worried that there would be more uptake on the sanded board (220), but it's about the same - fortunately.

the steel wool and scraped boards behaved differently - they look distressed - the grain is dark, but the rest is definitely burnished and the color absorption isn't as even. It's forgiving enough to apply a little more dry later to make things even out. I'm staining the door panel backs to see how it applies, and as bill said, controlled amounts seems to be best - it can be touched up with another layer on the panels that absorb a little less.



Re: Success on the coloring...I think.

#7

top pic planed, bottom sanded


Re: Success on the coloring...I think.

#8

Re: Success on the coloring...I think.

David Weaver

Will give the wash coat a try on a couple of pieces. You're right on the Japan colors. Aromatic distillate and anti freeze plus pigment.

I agree on the blotch. The wife likes none. I like some as long as it's due to wood characteristics and not tearout.

Re: Success on the coloring...I think.

#9

kind of what I'm looking for..

David Weaver

This is the back of a door panel as a trial area. Shellac over yesterday's stain.

I want the final look not to look brand new, not perfect, but not beat up. The front of the door panels are a little bit more refined in terms of surface.

This is shellac applied padded and then oiled like french polished, but only a thin film and the process not followed through. the final result will be waxed.

I'd thought about applying polyurethane, but it looks sterile compared to shellac - there is something about the darker shellacs and their tone that is really pleasing. durability won't be an issue - if it needs touch up later, no problem. not close to any food areas and won't get water (next to a fireplace in a far corner of the house).


https://i.imgur.com/ecqq2rK.jpg

(ignore the glare area- there's bright white LED overhead and the piece will not get nearly as much light where it's sitting - the picture is so close up that the lines in the center are shading from 220 grit sandpaper - hand sanded - no kidding).

Re: Success on the coloring...I think.

#10

Rich tone!  Does look ageless.


Re: Success on the coloring...I think.

#11

Resemblance

Jim Matthews

Reminds me of a finely made cup of coffee, before the kids get out of bed.

Re: Success on the coloring...I think.

#12

Re: Resemblance

David Weaver

coffee is a popular thing here!!

I would've much ( by a factor of 10 ) preferred natural for this case as it's been a pain faffing with stains, etc, but coffee looking is something I can live with.

Re: Success on the coloring...I think.

#13

reminds me of sherwin williams..

David Weaver

colored the fronts of the door panels after being comfortable with the back. they are better finished than the fronts. First panel, I tried some way to get my power sanders involved to at least justify having them, but it was nothing but a waste of time.

A fast scrape and then 220 grit machine paper with the grain ending with a light touch and application is easy and even.

The uniformity after the first coat, but wood grain remains.

https://i.imgur.com/aGAykb1.jpg

The panels after 2 - overhead lighting goes a long way to making this look less even than it is, and making the panel on the left turned away from the lights look much darker.

https://i.imgur.com/YaPed6S.jpg

amber shellac will obscure some of the irregularity that is in it, and may add some (pleasant type).

The cost to make a can of this is about 30-35 bucks. I can see that as undesirable. It goes so far, though, that i think it would color about 6 large projects. it's too concentrated to penetrate much, so you lay it onto a surface and it's only mildly wet, make sure you've gotten it on everything without leaving a cake anywhere, and then just turn the rag to the side and use the dry rag to even out and remove any excess. The excess instead of being a liquid and penetrating into areas just sits on top like a thin cakey film. super easy, no waiting for anything. If you see a spot that looks a little bit too thick in different light a couple of minutes later, you can still use a bit of dry rag and rub it to lighten it, but only the excess comes off easily and then the rest of what's there doesn't come off further and leave a light spot.

From now on, anything furniture that gets stained, I will do like this. It will make things like the quirk next to the bead easy because the quirk will take color, but there's plenty of time to run something down the length of the quirk to remove the excess - and without removing color.

I'd really dreaded figuring out a good lightfast color and whatever process it might take to prep for it, but easy prep seems to work better than arduous.

Re: Success on the coloring...I think.

#14

forgot the S-W reference

David Weaver

after part of a lifetime of using cheap paints that must have some consumer forgiving quality combined with lower pigment concentration, we had a room done.

The contractor gave me S-W numbers for the trim and wall based on what we wanted (higher dollar contractor who is hands on, no interest in flooring or paint but he'll help you get the right stuff) - he said something like pro block (which is sandable in an hour after prime) and then the paint was a high solids trim paint and he said "paint it on, don't play with it. you can't go back and fiddle with something you painted - just paint and move on".

This stain is like that - there's nothing to play with. It's on, and then it's off. If you faff with it too much, the result is worse, no better. Given that I don't particularly favor sanding or staining in general, this is a nice thing.

(I've spent the money for S-W paint since then - I think it's a bit steep, but it's twice as fast to paint with. My FIL likes to help paint here sometimes and he really gets satisfaction from playing with an area that he's painting for a long time, so we buy him paint at home depot. I have no idea what he's doing, but it's an old PA dutch kind of thing I think - self torture through some unnecessary work to absolve guilt - "no schusslich, take your time" or you could end up getting quick and making "hinkel drecht")

(translated, a fast sloppy effort that doesn't show great care will lead to chicken poop).

- another unexpected side benefit from this is finding a method and a concentration that will work well on guitars, which I've thus far not colored beyond whatever is in a given finish. Most guitars are colored with dye, which is better than it probably was 50 years ago, but it's still not lightfast.

Re: Success on the coloring...I think.

#15

The humor of experimenting with something..

David Weaver

Bill or someone mentioned (when I brought up pigments) that artists colors or japan colors often are of better quality, but I can't remember the conclusion of the initial discussion.

I'm so pleased with the outcome of this experiment because it will allow for uniform permanent pigment staining of things in the future, but I figured I'd look around for japan colors and staining on google (especially since Ronan listed furniture and furniture restoration as a principal use).

There are references to making or fortifying stains with japan colors all the way back to 1996 on the internet - some on woodweb, etc (a side I don't remember ever reading much of). And I'd bet there are probably tons of texts advising the same thing.

Not going to go out to youtube and find out how many people suggested the same thing on there already, too :| Though getting information on youtube isn't difficult. Getting good information from people with a lot of experience is less common and far less promoted by the youtube algorithm.

Re: Success on the coloring...I think.

#16

color on the case

David Weaver

Just starting to apply shellac to the case top, and padding the insides. I will do a semi-french polish type process on the case as only the left side, top, and front will really be visible.

The upside down top cabinet shows the junk wood on the right, but that side will be about 2 inches from the wall in the corner.

https://i.imgur.com/Iehxajr.jpg

Pleased with the uniformity of the color, still.

I'm thinking that the easiest way (once these are ready) to fit the doors will be to lay these two cases on their backs. The doors have case parts to sit on, so no reason to hold them up.

Re: Success on the coloring...I think.

#17

Re: That looks nice, David


Re: Success on the coloring...I think.

#18

Thanks, Hank!

David Weaver

The method did turn out to have merit in making things look a little less rustic without making them look new or commercial.