Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

laziness on the door miters...

Posts

laziness on the door miters...

#1

laziness on the door miters...

David Weaver

..on the last door yesterday (much interfering shop and yard stuff preventing work on the cabinet), I finally figured out that it's a whole lot easier to do the miter fitting if the cross rails are mitered to the depth of the bead quirk (not sure if I got terms correct) and the all final fitting done on the stiles until the miter is tight with the bottom of the rails dead on the marked line for door height (this will be adjusted later when fitting the doors to the cabinet - but it's nice to start with those marks being nailed so that the beads on all door rails are equally far apart from each other).

The thing that took me a while to figure out? the corner paring jig that I'd made a year or two ago to do this operation on kitchen cabinet doors has a rabbet less deep than the rail/stile thickness (good), which means it can be gripped from the side by a vise, or it can be held in place by a hold down. I prefer the former for no good reason. loosening and tightening things is fiddly.

On the very last door (last stile, even), I realized that once everything is in the jig, if the rail is already miter, it can be kept loose to test fit. Tiny extra cuts to the miter on the stiles to get the fit dead on are easiest made if nothing is loosened, but the (unfinished) far end of the door stile is tapped with a steel hammer to advance it just a tiny amount.

Much pain in the butt avoided, and each corner fiddle takes about 1 minute instead of a couple of minutes trying to place the corner miter in the same spot and then tighten it in the vise (or affix it with a hold down for the surface users).

I understand that this is not a preferred method after Bill and Derek coached up the fact that the miters could open over the long term. On a piece of cabinetry of the quality I'm making, that could just be addressed with a fill stick and some careful rubbing.

Re: laziness on the door miters...

#2

simple miter vs coped miter

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The coped miter is advocated as a better solution for it will cover any opening of the joint over time. I suspect this observation comes from examining antiques where the miter on a door bead has opened over centuries.

There are factors that make the potential deficiency of the simple miter, as you are doing, unlikely to occur. Your frame members are not very wide, the lumber is KD and this piece will live a sheltered life in a modest range of humidity changes. Our kitchen cabinet doors are mitered this way and the have not perceptibly opened after many years.

I believe many problems observed in antiques resulted from building with wood that was not as stable as what we have available today. I'll wager in a pinch furniture was built from wood not sufficiently dry. At best the wood was air dried and it is a fact that for some years this wood responds to humidity changes more than KD wood. Finally, it was not uncommon for furniture to go out of style, do service in the barn or chicken house and return to the home when fashion changed again. (This humidity experience could be stressful.) Out cherry dining table was rescued from service as a work bench.

Re: laziness on the door miters...

#3

Re: simple miter vs coped miter

David Weaver

agree with all of those. The size of the miter and all kinds of other things involved (as you mention, rail width, all the way down to where the glue hold is strongest in a mortise, sawn orientation of the wood....).

I've learned (in reading about baked wood that's becoming common for guitars now) that over a very long period of time as wood loses its volatiles, it will shrink each time it dries, but spring back less when absorbing moisture, over time shrinking in general. This matches what I see on japanese planes once they're a couple of decades old (and if they're fit tight laterally, tiny movements make a good fit suddenly become an iron that can't be relieved - and their grain orientation is unfavorable for this part of the fit to be favorable elsewhere).

Long story short, this wood is probably starting from a more stable position (KD and already several years old beyond that), but it could shrink over time some more. The miters are relatively short due to the size of the bead and I'm not sure that the furniture will last long enough to see that shrink. (and that's assuming that it would be considered good enough for it to matter - the truth is that the case itself isn't that special and it doesn't really matter -but I still take notes for the next one).

There are other little nits to deal with if you're cutting the bead by hand, etc (the depth of the bead needs to be identical - and I remember from my routering days, even if I was using a router, sometimes the depth of cut varies a little bit) - I'm guessing false cope avoids all of these things and allows for movement, it's just a better technical solution.

For someone like me, who doesn't read a whole lot, and who isn't going to buy furniture-related books, It's interesting that when you go out to google on a topic like this, or mouldings, you get:

* tons of conversations about commercial cabinets and customers (The discussions aren't that technical, more related to fairly blah topics where a customer wants something that they were told by a salesman and a builder does something different) in regard to cope and stick or mitered doors. Joints won't have anything to do with the service life of these cabinets, though - style and color will have them removed and junked or put in a hunting cabin long before construction is an issue

* crown moulding, how to install crown moulding :| Looking on google a couple of different times on installing furniture moulding on solid cases yielded endless DIY videos and advertising about installing or having crown moulding installed. Totally worthless results.

Thus, asked here.

Re: laziness on the door miters...

#4

KD wood

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"shrink each time it dries, but spring back less "

Well documented phenomena. In the typical KD process the wood is dried below the final target moisture content, then steamed back to 7%. The steaming is to relax drying stress. But the other benefit is that the wood becomes less responsive to humidity changes. I have heard loss of volatiles as an explanation but I believe there are significant chemical changes going on too.

Re: laziness on the door miters...

#5

Re: KD wood

David Weaver

I'm sure there are chemical changes. I have air dried beech and KD beech and now both are on the order of 4 years old. The feel of the KD beech is different - it feels less dry even though I'd bet both have similar moisture at this point (the air dried beech is actually a little bit more waxy feeling and a little more resistant to planing).

The only other fully dry wood I experienced this with was apple - first apple I ever used was air dried (i got it wet - a pain to follow around until it was partially dry - just like beech). The wood had a very waxy feel, and then I bought some blanks that looked the same and were kiln dried. More musical and dry/hard feeling, even though both stored here.

I've noticed the subsequent movement (of several year old KD wood) in two places - guitars on fingerboards (flatsawn maple fingerboards gradually get some fret sprout over time if frets are flush trimmed - tiny protruding amounts of fret, even a few thousands feel sharp and snag fingertips), and in planes where i made my first planes with the irons flush fit down at the mouth. The irons gradually got tight in them and I needed to remove more wood. These amounts of movement go unnoticed, but both wood samples where I saw this were commercially kiln dried.

The baked wood apparently transforms much further, but only if heat is above a key temperature (something like 380-390 degrees F). When cut, it still has a little bit of stress - it's steamed according to the seller I get it from to make it more workable and less splintery, but when mortising the truss rod groove by hand, the little splitout at the edge of the mortise (well hidden by the fingerboard) is really unusual.

Lots of ebay listings of baked wood that advertise lower temperatures, but the studies that I read suggest that those samples are just more thoroughly dried and not as transformed.

Fret "sprout" is a common complaint on purchased guitars because most buyers couldn't pour water, let alone fix anything - I would guess that the reason it's not as common as it used to be is a step in the process where fingerboards are heated before being installed on a guitar.

I asked george about this for guitar tops (where older tops will often eventually shrink and crack, even though they are quartered), and he mentioned that he always put tops in the oven at a low temperature for a while before trimming them to size and installing them on a guitar (if they spring back a little bit after installation, no problem. If they shrink attached to bracing, some part will crack at some point.

Again, all guitar and tool related - no issues with furniture in 15 years so far (except for the one case piece where I glued the moulding end to end heavily, the miters open and close a tiny amount with the season - that's just the result of poor method).

The preference for makers in the past wasn't just to get commercially dried wood, but if possible, pay the premium for nice samples of decades old wood to get past the initial shrink and subsequent lesser springback. No clue if anyone has documented the percentage of commercially dried wood in year such and such. I would guess based on how much my moulding planes have shrunk over several years and then seemingly stopped, that the vast majority occurs in 3-5 years or so and subsequent amounts are minimal over any reasonable period of time - even for tools.

Re: laziness on the door miters...

#6

The origins of interior design...

Jim Matthews

"Finally, it was not uncommon for furniture to go out of style, do service in the barn or chicken house and return to the home when fashion changed again..."

You mean the whitewash of "Shabby Chic" wasn't paint?

Re: laziness on the door miters...

#7

Re: The origins of interior design...

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

There was sometimes an intermediate stage, in which some furniture wound up in the kids' nurseries or the servants' quarters.