Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Maebiki vs. Frame saw

Posts

Maebiki vs. Frame saw

#1

Maebiki vs. Frame saw

David Weaver

So, I've gotten two Maebiki - Japanese whaleback saws.

The point of getting them was two things:

1) I hope to get a log at some point an saw it into boards

2) curiosity resawing. It seems like when I've seen someone using one in a vise, they are resawing more slowly than a 4 foot frame saw

Getting these things isn't that difficult - go to proxy auctions in japan, wait for one or three to come up with all teeth, a maker's stamp (you want to get something that someone was proud enough to put their name on) and a cheap price, and the cost with shipping for the two averaged about $75. The auction close price for the last one that I got was $22.

I've sharpened one of the two and tried it. It's not ever going to be faster than the framesaw resawing dried wood. Here's what I can conclude about them:

* they come set up to saw logs, not dried lumber. They have a fairly large amount of set and the plates on them are thick

* they are not hard like a joinery saw - they are fairly soft, probably intentionally so since they're designed for wet wood (this is good because there's a near zero chance that you won't have to sharpen what you get)

* the tall spine makes them ungainly in a resaw until the kerf is well established (like 6 inches into a cut), but they're not hard to use. nearly 100% sure that they are intended to be used just about every way except standing up on a board in a vise (e.g., standing on long with the saw below your feet, standing under a log with the saw above your head, sitting with the saw on its side sawing a log). The tooth action is off.

Better idea for someone wanting to resaw by hand to by a long fast handsaw (the longer the better) or build a frame saw.

Since I have two, I will continue to sharpen the teeth more aggressively on the one i've sharpened and hammer almost all of the set out to see what the ideal limit is resawing. Use in dry wood and use in wet wood isn't going to be the same saw.

testing the one saw on two boards and just a few inches each reminds me that we get used to (our brains and muscles) certain motions and not others. The frame saw is much heavier and I file it so that it has enough bite to have a strong filing feel in the cut (but not a fight). The maebiki is more easy to pull as set, but I could still tell that I'd done several minutes of a motion that I don't usually do when I woke up the next day - that would go away after a few sessions, but maybe it's age showing in how little it took to result in some stiffness.

Re: Maebiki vs. Frame saw

#2

Re: Maebiki vs. Frame saw

Wiley Horne

I’ll be interested to see how your resaw goes.

My own limited experience: I wanted to resaw a sugar maple board. Tried both a big western rip saw and a Japanese 480mm saw with a combination tooth (a real one, double-tapered by hand). I started the cuts from both sides, making deep triangles, then sawing the center down, and repeat.

Both saws followed the grain. By that, I mean the saw plate stayed in the correct kerf on both sides of the board, but grain followed in the center, in one case actually daylighting in the middle while staying in the original kerfs on either side.

I didn’t have a frame saw, but that was my introduction to why they exist.

Your maebiki may have enough set to avoid my problem. Or maybe it was the hard maple, or more likely my technique wasn’t right.

Wiley

Re: Maebiki vs. Frame saw

#3

yes on following the grain...

David Weaver

That's probably another reason why the maebiki is as thick as it is - to have its own conviction in the cut.

Bandsaw wander on a mediocre bandsaw is one of the things that led me to make a frame saw. Since then, I've cut a few guitar tops with the frame saw (and wouldn't have been able to with the bandsaw that I had no matter what). Continued tinkering with the saw that I had may have solved the problem eventually.

Steering and perhaps grain direction can cause a little bit of wandering with the frame saw, but not too much (too much tension on it for it to get out of control quickly). I keep enough set on the frame saw to steer, but it's dry wood set vs. wet wood set. If it had more set, it would actually be harder to steer and focus in a given cut - it's not a completely fair comparison for the maebiki until I hammer a little bit more of the set out.

interestingly, the smaller maebiki (the one that I started with and sharpened) is 480mm long, the same size as you mentioned). plate thickness is .062" at the tooth line and .04" at the top of the spine. spine depth is about 30cm. The bigger saw doesn't have much extra length in tooth line, but visually, the tooth line is a little bit thicker and the height is much greater - It'll be better laying on its side if I ever manage to get a green log around here (no truck, no cart, firewood scavengers usually get to anything large enough to saw but light enough that I can lift an end - before I do).

Re: Maebiki vs. Frame saw

#4

Re: Maebiki vs. Frame saw

John Aniano in central NJ

David,

Please post some images of the two Maebiki "whaleback" saws. Not a name I've heard used to describe a Japanese saw, although I think I know what they look like. I may even own one and would like to compare...

John

Re: Maebiki vs. Frame saw

#5

Re: Maebiki vs. Frame saw

David Weaver

Hi, John - "big" saw on the top, small one in the middle, and then a 28" disston rip saw for scale (5 point).

https://i.imgur.com/9hxi6ia.jpg

They don't look that big, though they do look tall and the teeth are noticeably large.

The tang style on the middle one allows for testing without much pain (it's heavy steel, not just thin sheet), and presumably is made for a handle where the tang goes through the width.

The top tang style appears to be one where the tang goes into the end of the handle.

Though they don't look big in the picture due to their length, the top saw weighs 6 pounds and 2 ounces. They're heavy duty. The bottom saw is probably 80% of that (I didn't weigh it).

plate thickness on the taller saw at the tooth line is .075" at the teeth. Cumbersome to try to use them where a frame saw would normally be used.

Re: Maebiki vs. Frame saw

#6

Re: Maebiki vs. Frame saw

David Weaver

looking at the picture - my original comment is easier to see (About the teeth needing to be filed more aggressive).

Funny how you notice things in pictures, especially with another saw present, that you don't see in person.

The small maebiki appears to have had its rake adjusted a whole lot over time due to filing of the teeth (the top one doesn't suffer the same - the gullet work has been done more carefully, or it's still as stamped from the maker.

I will track down a knife edge file for the smaller saw and correct the rake. the gullets are less than 60 degrees by a fair amount, so I don't have a file on hand that can fit in there and do heavy work at the same time.

Re: Maebiki vs. Frame saw

#7

Re: Maebiki vs. Frame saw

William Duffield

I couldn't help but notice that both of your maebiki are filed with progressive pitch. From pictures of other maebiki, it seems that is a common feature on all of them. Any idea why, since it doesn't appear to be a common feature in Western two-man rip saws or frame saws?

Re: Maebiki vs. Frame saw

#8

getting the cut started...

David Weaver

...I've seen other people use the front edge to start a cut, like on a corner. A frame saw, you can sort of lay onto a board and it just kind of cuts (But the teeth on mine are smaller than these maebiki teet - my teeth are about 2.25 or so per inch, so that may have something to do with it.

starting the maebiki is a little bit harder, probably for two reasons - the tall shape that will wobble a little bit, and the really aggressive rake pulling back into the straws instead of severing them and pushing them out. If we have a bias with western saws, it's to bear down and go off of 90 in a direction that severs straws and pushes them off. If you bear down on a maebiki, it's hard to do that.

I haven't seen anyone demonstrate use of these in wet wood (the pitsaw demonstrations with large lumber appear to be cants that aren't dry), and the folks cutting dry wood logs with the maebiki provide times of like several hours for a 6 foot board about 14 inches wide.

Re: Maebiki vs. Frame saw

#9

"progressive pitch"

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I think I have seen, even used, pit saws that had graduated teeth from end to end. A saw that has many teeth in the cut can get into a harmonic vibration. The inside of the cut gets to be sort of a washboard and the saw chatters because all the teeth hit the washboard humps at the same time. A saw with graduated teeth would not have that problem.

The word pitch usually denotes an angle, not a spacing. In older texts pitch is used for the rake of a tooth, as in "common pitch".

Re: Maebiki vs. Frame saw

#10

Re: "progressive pitch"

David Weaver

The harmonic pattern is definitely evident when you work an area with floats (especially on end grain/plane beds) and with a frame saw that's poorly matched to the wood that it's sawing.

There's some to the small maebiki shown here, too (but the progressive part of the teeth is just at the beginning) - it creates an obnoxious chattering that we would normally solve with a hand saw by "getting behind the straws" a little bit and severing them off. with the maebiki, it's not that easy to get into that orientation, though.

The trick with the maebiki seems to be as with all other saws - finding the setup where the teeth will stay in the cut without much additional influence from the user, but not fishhook into the wood and grab.

Re: Maebiki vs. Frame saw

#11

more aggressive hook

David Weaver

I filed the teeth far more aggressive on the small maebiki last night (to add hook). It now works fine for poplar, but could probably use a little more yet. The teeth are so big that you can adjust the hook on the top 3rd to experiment before refiling the entire tooth.

I would call it usable. For comparison, I cut about a foot of a poplar board around 10" wide (Resawing) and then did the same with the frame saw. i don't think a maebiki will ever be a good match for a frame saw in the shop of a hand tool woodworker using dry wood. I have the set on the small maebiki narrow now, so it can cut accurately, but it just seems as if the design in general may be better for wet wood when the straws of the wood don't have such stiffness.

It cost more to make the frame saw (because of the 1095 and files), though, than the purchase price (before shipping) of both maebiki.

Re: Maebiki vs. Frame saw

#12

Re: "progressive pitch"

William Duffield

Aha! Of course. I should have been able to figure that out myself, but I usually rely on irregularities in the hand sharpened pitch to dampen vibrations of the saw plate.

I knew I would get the nomenclature wrong if I didn't look it up, so I looked it up.

https://toolsforworkingwood.com/blogimg/sawspectra.pdf

Joel was the first saw expert I found who had a clear explanation and geometric diagrams, so I used his definition. Language changes from place to place and time to time. That's what makes language, especially technical jargon, interesting. I'm used to using "pitch" according to the old definition to describe the angle of a bevel down plane blade, especially wooden moulding planes, but saw geometries are a bit more complicated than planes, or at least different.

Re: Maebiki vs. Frame saw

#13

Re: "progressive pitch"

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Holttzapffel and Disston both used pitch to describe the inclination of the tooth. I think I was sharpening saws for thirty years before this new definition was invented. I recall Adam Cherubini admitted he just made it up. Here is a snippet of Holtzapffel:


Re: Maebiki vs. Frame saw

#14

The nerve

Jim Matthews

" I recall Adam Cherubini admitted he just made it up."

He probably used that fancy movable type to distribute handbills at ten a penny, too.

Kids these days.

Re: Maebiki vs. Frame saw

#15

Borrowed meanings

John in NM

With machine screws and gears, pitch is used to describe number of teeth per unit distance. One of those words that mean slightly different things in different contexts - I bet that is the root of the recent change in use for saws.

Re: Maebiki vs. Frame saw

#16

Re: Borrowed meanings

Brad Chenoweth

In threading, it's become common in many shops to use "pitch" interchangeably with TPI. Most folks refer to a 20 TPI thread as "20 pitch", when its actually .050" pitch. Just one of those little things that drive me crazy, like people referring to rifle/pistol magazines as "clips" :>)

Re: Maebiki vs. Frame saw

#17

final preliminary conclusion

David Weaver

I added a handle to the small maebiki yesterday, which gives more options for reaching further down below the toothline to pull the saw. This is like changing hand position and rake angle on a dovetail saw (high back corner and strong handle rake and a dovetail saw can become difficult and aggressive quickly and needs to be filed accordingly).

This instantly brought the bite of the teeth to bear (i left the handle long to experiment) and a grip close to the tang is best where I've set the teeth). The filing feel that we all love with a saw (it's smooth through the cut with some resistance, but just the right amount, and without extra influence from the user) is present.

Iv'e cut poplar and cherry with it. It's not hard to learn to steer, but in use with wood in a vise and the need for accuracy, it's cleaner to start a resaw with another saw first and then allow the maebiki to cut a wider kerf through that - the saw is enough wider than a hand saw that it doesn't bind like you'd normally get swapping saws around doing this - it happily cuts right through the original line and widens it. Very nice.

It's usable. But, there's one thing you can't get around. Even with a smaller big saw like my small one, you will still be cutting a kerf somewhat wider than the saw plate , so you're probably slotting 8 hundredths or so of wood out of a cut (I could measure this - I will, actually) and this isn't that practical if you're resawing stock as you'll often bump up "I could've almost gotten 3 out of that instead of 2".

The kerf also dictates that you cannot get around actually doing a greater volume of work than a frame saw (.042" plate with minimal set). The toothline of a maebiki is deceiving - it's short, but you can push the saw forward almost out of the front of a workpiece and then pull it all the way through until just the nose is in the cut, and so on, so your cut length is longer than the tooth line. But removing the wide kerf is always going to mean more work, it may steer as easily ,but not easier, the frame saw can start its own cut, and if you were ever so lucky to have a willing person on the other side of a frame saw, you could really saw fast.

The maebiki will cut an 8" cherry board at about 2 inches per minute, and the frame saw 4. This difference may narrow slightly, but by the amount of physical work done, I wouldn't be capable of matching the frame saw without an exploding heart.

I'm anxious to find a log to try the other one. I think it will shine in wet wood. The frame saw betters it in dry wood work pretty easily.

One piece of advice for anyone who gets one of these without a handle - file the teeth as they are on the saw, and make a long handle first, find out where you like to grip it, and then trim. Gripping the tang on this saw made it so that your hand position is too high. Once I put the handle on it, I instantly was able to get more aggressive positions than needed and it made much more sense in use.

Sawing bulk amounts is a lot like planing (warren will probably agree). Lots of little things make the difference between being able to do it indefinitely or really wearing yourself out, and the cut rate is the same either way. For example, if a saw is so aggressive that it grabs at the very end of the cut, that seems innocent, but it is a shock to you (however small it may feel) and will leave your muscles burning fast. If the saw is just still sliding through the end of a cut, this fatigue doesn't occur. It didn't really take that long to find the sweet spot with the grip on the maebiki where the cut has that feel, but you're not pulling fishhooks through a board covered with eye bolts.

The frame saw is a wonderful thing for a one man shop with no band saw (and I've ruined far less wood with it). You have to tell yourself that you're blocking use off as exercise, but once it's set right, you could resaw everything you need for a large project (less planing is the result) in two morning sessions, or you can split the work up if you want to really make it exercise and push the pace for a half hour and be dragging on the floor when you're done.

Re: Maebiki vs. Frame saw

#18

Re: "progressive pitch"

William Duffield

I thought pitch was that gummy stuff that got stuck in your teeth after you've been cutting Pinus palusatris :D a.k.a. naval stores.

Was there a word they used back then for what we are now incorrectly calling "pitch" and should be using instead? I sure hope this discussion doesn't devolve into something like the "chip breaker" vs. "cap iron" polarization.

Re: Maebiki vs. Frame saw

#19

"progressive pitch"

David Weaver

Sounds like a liberal pine tree resin to me.