Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

more buffer bull-stuff - scrapers

Posts

more buffer bull-stuff - scrapers

#1

more buffer bull-stuff - scrapers

David Weaver

I suspect that there are a lot of uses for the buffer for the lazy, and not posting out of anything other than curiosity.

I scrape some. Not much compared to someone who scrapes everything, and a lot compared to someone who sands everything. Early on, it was necessary to spend some time over a day or two figuring out how to make scraper preparation easy with a burr because a burr on a scraper means longevity and control of how much the scraper is taking in a pass.

If you prepare a few edges on a card scraper, you can generally keep yourself busy for a while with nothing more than a burnisher.

I like the washita - it removes file marks fast, isn't threatened by scraper hardness and it leaves a reasonably fine edge on a scraper (and even when you wipe the swarf off, the oil is already there). One stone, you can do it freehand all the way. File two edges, clean them up and roll a burr in two minutes for the dullest of scrapers.

BUT, aside from the orientation of the burr, nothing else on the scraper is that critical.

I so i filed the top edge of my scraper off about 20 degrees (it's essentially a one-side scraper) and made one pass across the deburr wheel and one pass across the buff wheel (five seconds combined for both - I tried deburr only, etc).

A light pass across the corner of the buff to keep the front side of this steep bevel clean, both sides are polished.

You can scrape with the thing straight away, but the buffer removes the hook - it's short lived. with the burnisher in hand, one stroke across the face of the scraper and then one perpendicular to the top (since we've re-oriented the bevel a little bit) and the action of the scraper is sublime.

You can do it many times before the burr becomes ratty, and then five seconds on the deburring wheel and the buff again. If the geometry ever gets wonky, just refile the edge and restart.

These are direct links so you can see the pictures full size. The wood is english sycamore. The shavings are plentiful and have no hard bits in them, so they make a great burnisher. This camera has an anti reflection control in it, but the shine on the wood is good enough that I can get partially past it.

https://i.imgur.com/sdT9zFU.jpg

https://i.imgur.com/pmBuh9f.jpg

https://i.imgur.com/zUXeO0t.jpg

I've got a few curved scrapers that aren't necessarily that difficult to care for, but this will make those even easier.




Re: more buffer bull-stuff - scrapers

#2

really great for harder blades...

David Weaver

..derek has posted before about maintaining harder scrapers. One could easily be made and hardened wider than a plane iron if desirable.

There's no rolling a burr on something harder than about 55 or 56 or so - it breaks off (which is why the solignen knives don't seem that great once you buy even a lower tier japanese knife - they have to retain the ability to be steeled).

I used the chinese blade that bill is now familiar with (they're an almost M2 high speed steel - short of tungsten and molybdenum, which must be expensive relative to the other alloying elements), deburred it to about the same angle as the scraper mentioned, and polished off the burr on the buff.

It scrapes fabulously. An even hand with the deburring wheel doesn't threaten edge geometry much, and if it does, a regrind or honing off of the edge is fine, but it won't be necessary often.

Same extremely clean unbroken shavings (which tells you that the underlying surface won't be fuzzy) as the burr. I like the burr better, but burrs on scrapers don't last long on some guitar parts (ebony fingerboards, etc) and at the same time, after you plane a neck radius, if scraping the facets of the radius off results in much fuzz, that's just followed by much sanding and you can lose the geometry you carefully made. This can be seen as the frets aren't that flexible and undulations on a fingerboard of any type (especially at the edge) show up as little dark gaps under the frets.

That's enough for now. I have paying things to do today, but am always pleased to find something that's even lazier (but with better results) than the lazy methods that I use that are lazier than the methods generally taught.

Re: more buffer bull-stuff - scrapers

#3

I will make a video...

David Weaver

...nobody as excited about this kind of stuff as me, so i'm just obligating myself to put this in video form as it will show just how lazy it is much more easily.

Re: more buffer bull-stuff - scrapers

#4

Throwing down the gaunlett

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

You will not find a faster more effective way of scraper preparation than that described in the Paul Hamler(the scraper guru)video on the topic. Only tools necessary are an 8" file and burnisher. The result is the most long lasting edge I have experienced.

Re: more buffer bull-stuff - scrapers

#5

Re: Throwing down the gaunlett

David Weaver

Hamler has expended 1000 thought molecules on scraping for every one that I have. His method is probably better - the more you do things, the lazier you get if standards will allow (the unproductively lazy will allow standards to drop, but I know he's not that guy).

I snapped off a half day of vacation at work so that I could go hang up some stuff for the kids in the yard and made the video already. I'll post it this evening.

the deburr wheel and buffer works a treat for hardened plane irons used to scrape, too. That doesn't offer me much because I hate the feel of using plane irons to scrape, but it offers quite a lot considering I can cut a piece of 1084 or o1 or whatever else (i wonder how XHP would do for this) to make a hardened scraper of any shape).

Re: more buffer bull-stuff - scrapers

#6

Re: really great for harder blades...

Don Peters

I suspect we've all futzed with scrapers at least enough to know that there's no black art to them. And the next thing we learn is that there are a lot of ways to sharpen and use them. And then the search begins: how do I quickly develop, perfect and refresh that edge? But one also learns that the futzing, while sometimes fun, is profoundly unproductive.

Anything I can reasonably do to spend less time sharpening and more time using a tool well is worth seriously exploring. And scrapers are at the top of my work/pleasure vision quest. I've futzed with simplifying and shortening the "quickly develop, perfect and refresh" processes with inconclusive results. So this thread is singing to me.

So apologies if this was answered elsewhere, but would David please define his deburring setup and buffer setup: speeds, grits, diameters, motor details, names or types of product, etc. Photos might also be helpful... maybe interdict some of my futzing.

Thanks very much,

Don Peters

Re: more buffer bull-stuff - scrapers

#7

Some specs here...

Wiley Horne

David starts out describing the buffing wheel itself:

http://www.woodcentral.com/woodworking/forum/handtools.pl/page/1/md/read/id/493199/sbj/short-version/

Wiley

Re: more buffer bull-stuff - scrapers

#8

Re: really great for harder blades...

David Weaver

The scotch brite wheel says 2xf on the side.

Re: more buffer bull-stuff - scrapers

#9

Video

David Weaver

I'm not sharp enough to rename this video from the phone app.

Before anyone gets smart, I realize that the point of the round radius scraper is the small inside radii, but I wanted to work the outside radius to scrape a hollow.

https://youtu.be/HxlZkoWv4HA

Re: more buffer bull-stuff - scrapers

#11

Re: Throwing down the gaunlett

Wiley Horne

Hi Bill and all,

Not taking sides, as I equally like David’s adventures and Paul Hamler’s instructional videos.

Hamler is absolutely fascinating. I was watching his long video (1 hr 36 min) on fixed blade scrapers. As Bill said, Paul’s preparation of fixed scrapers (as in scraper planes) involves a single-cut file, a stone, and a burnisher. For his own production methods, he makes some fancy gizmos but they are for when he is prepping a large number of edges.

He showed something I had not seen or heard tell of before—double-working the burr to work-harden and extra-sharpen it. He also uses one heavy burnishing stroke—one pass only, his reasoning being that not many can maintain the same angle thru multiple passes.

At about 1hr 06min, he describes how to make a very fine veneer saw by impressing the tooth pattern of a jeweler’s file onto an exacto knife blade—lightly hammer the file down onto the edge of the knife. Said this technique was done by some watchmakers to make an anchor point for the mainspring. He goes on to describe file cleaning—shows converting a brass cartridge to do the job, but then immediately goes on to show his ultimate file cleaner, a bamboo chopstick. The bamboo is both tenacious enough but also will take the tooth pattern of the file, so it really gets down into the grooves.

David’s experiments I find equally stimulating.

Wiley

Re: more buffer bull-stuff - scrapers

#12

Re: Throwing down the gaunlett

David Weaver

Paul's experiments are neatly done and high class. He knows more about this stuff (the scrapers and what you can do them) than I'll ever learn.

All of his videos are great, because he knows what he's talking about and he's done a lot of it.

Re: more buffer bull-stuff - scrapers

#13

Paul's woodworking hand tools

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.


for scale note size of print. Case is about 30" wide.

Re: more buffer bull-stuff - scrapers

#14

Re: Paul's woodworking hand tools

David Weaver

That's fine work in wood and metal. I am unfamiliar with such things.

I remember him making scrapers for stanley planes that were intermittently available (he appears to be a curious maker, and making single things in volume is always going to conflict with that).

His use of scrapers is on another level and is a reminder you can get really good with anything if you feel the need to do it (or if there's a need, even if you don't feel it).

Re: more buffer bull-stuff - scrapers

#15

Stanley scraper inserts

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Paul transferred that business to another person. He was selling them at the demonstration I attended. What impressed me with the card scraper preparation was its ease and durability of the edge. I think his work hardening routine is a key element. His emphasis on cleaning the burr must also be important, but I don't know why.

We were going to have him for our May meeting but that fell victim to the Virus.

He uses a common spring stock "1095" for scrapers. It is a high carbon steel at Rc 50 something or another.

Re: more buffer bull-stuff - scrapers

#16

cleaning the burr??

David Weaver

do you mean cleaning it of wood scuzz or cleaning it of bits of metal? I've noticed that it can't really have anything on it of either type if you want it to be really polished and smooth and even. There are older videos of other instructors showing long honing routines of the edges and faces and it's agonizing to do that in a shop when you're trying to work on something, and there's filth and grit everywhere (with the buffer on the floor, there's no filthy hands, and the filth stays on the floor).

I made a video of the process which is by no means necessary to watch, but I like the effect of this process after you get away from the file for a round as the second version of the edge is better than the first. I would guess that it's me being too chicken to really blast the very last bits of the file burr off of the edge on the buffing wheel (fear of round over), but will continue experimenting.

The other nice thing about the buffer is it blasts off anything on both edges and the metal is very clean and smooth for rolling the burr. The buff wheel can be made to do very little using the corner of it instead of heavy pressure straight on and I'll see over time - it may not be necessary to file more than once every several hours of scraper use with an even hand on the deburring wheel.

1095 stock is what most of the better scrapers are made from, but some of the older english companies make stock that feels soft and with a relatively coarse surface finish.

Re: more buffer bull-stuff - scrapers

#17

experience in 10 minutes of playing

David Weaver

sometimes, you can't remember why you did certain things. I remember developing a sensitivity to cherry dust and having asthma attacks afterwards (mild/moderate - not emergency, but required inhaler - hate that).

But I couldn't remember that much from scraping other than that I learned early on to set burrs on scraping planes and #s 80 stanley because I thought they'd be heavily used. I still have one 80.

I scraped the sides of my cabinet at lunch, and then planed (jointed) and then intentionally used the #80 and a card scraper to prepare the face of a macassar ebony board about 48 x 6 inches. It worked pretty well, removed all of the tearout on one burr - I'm sure it's got considerable wear, though (same with the card - one roll of the burr and that was it - way nicer looking shavings than the delicate things I got in the video with the english sycamore).

And then when I came in and sat down, I have chest tightness from asthma because cherry and macassar ebony are both dusty when you scrape them, even if you get nice long shavings. I don't know which one excited the tightness, but my hands were filthy from the macassar board despite getting long continuous shavings on the scrapers.

I can see why scraping would be attractive to someone who didn't want to buy boutique planes, but who hadn't figured out the cap iron. on really tricky woods, it's about even up as you have to take more final shavings with a double iron, on softer woods, it's not a wash, but it's not intolerable (much faster than sanding multiple steps).

Re: more buffer bull-stuff - scrapers

#18

On sensitivities to allergens

Jim Matthews

Sensitivities can "stack" with repeated exposure. Even the most stoic should notify their physician regarding remarkable episodes.

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2975603/

****

Do you observe dust containment, by keeping dedicated shoes for the shop and immediately changing clothes? I've got an athsmatic kid, and try to be careful.

I run my cheapo air filter, if I start sneezing (not an asthmatic, my own self).

I was advised to rinse out my mouth and nose with tap water, when this happens.

****

This is the first mention you've made regarding this.

Re: more buffer bull-stuff - scrapers

#19

Re: On sensitivities to allergens

David Weaver

yes on the cherry - asthma was much worse when I was a kid (bronchitis four times a year is more like 1 now) and exercise triggered it every time (leading to getting coached up by teachers during field day about "not being so lazy" as I was choking for air).

Sensitizers give you feedback right away - as you say, the more you're exposed, the worse things get - usually, but some separation for a while and it seems like some of the memory of certain things are gone.

Doesn't always make sense (no sensitivity to cocobolo, but sensitivity to cherry - with more exposure, that could probably change, but maybe the sensitizing isn't asthmatic for cocobolo? don't know).

This and a lack of desire in installing any significant dust collection (and listening to it run all the time, or constantly wasting money on sanding kit) covers the rest of it. Scraping the cherry case yesterday (some at face level) probably had a lot to do with the issues and a simple box fan sending the dust out the front of the garage would've been enough to avoid it. More likely the macassar board had nothing to do with it - just the last thing i scraped before some tightness.

I just *can't wait* to get covid and see how it goes :b colds turn into bronchitis about 90% of the time (inflammatory response to the cough), but I've had bronchitis so many times (probably between 75 and 100) that it's familiar and it is the same negative experience that it becomes for someone who gets it the first time.