Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Why I'm enamored with small rounding..

Posts

Why I'm enamored with small rounding..

#1

Why I'm enamored with small rounding..

David Weaver

(applicability of the rabbit hole below in a second post)

This follows on the post I made a couple of weeks ago about exploring rounding off the area on chisels that fails and guessing (Without testing so far) that if it's done correctly, it doesn't have an effect on cut resistance.

Wiley and Bill and I had a discussion about it. I tried to measure the tiny rounding, but I'm not sure how accurately I measured it. Also measured the other angles on chisels that I thought I was grinding around 25 degrees (my grinder rest is always set to 90 degrees and I gauge refreshing a hollow with my fingers as a fence on the edge of it).

Turned out on a sorby chisel that I tried this method on to be 19 degrees primary

Secondary honed bevel was 25 (thought that would be steeper, too) and the final rounding was somewhere around 33 or something, but the very tip of it could be slightly steeper.

This picture shows about how long the rounding is on a small file knife (I taking a chisel picture at a later date will require elevating the microscope and making an alternate fixture to capture the bevel).

This method makes a sorby chisel tolerable - most would find them intolerable on anything other than the softest softwoods and mahogany. They are at least as soft as the modern blue chip chisels I've tried, but they have "proportional potential", and I could probably reharden them, but won't do that yet.

It also makes these little knives zip through cardboard for the recycle bin to the point that they might be dangerous for the uninitiated.

Here's the trade - the very edge is rounded over. This rounding is a matter of a few thousandths, not a big chunk of the bevel. If it's kept small, there's no perception of extra resistance. I started thinking about this after watching cliff stamp talk about better performance from cheap thin knives in the kitchen than overbuilt fat ones that cost 20 times as much. And realized that previously, I'd done this to stanley chisels mortising a couple of cocobolo blanks (they held up better than expensive chisels that were just set up with a flat bevel around 28 or 30 degrees....actually much better).

the rounding is the minus on resistance, but combined with the thin follow on bevels, the cut resistance isn't more. Sharpening goes to almost nothing unless you abuse tools.

The equalizer in this is using something that's very fine. In the case of this knife, the rounding is done with a hard buff and 5 micron abrasive. The edge is as good as anything I've ever used (the abrasive is a cheap yellow stick from mcmaster carr - it's terrible on the hard surface).

https://imgur.com/gWaLfNX

Note that the scratching that you see in this picture is from a deburring wheel. I smash files into these thin utility knives and then maintain them with a deburr and then a buff. you can see that the only part of the edge that's really steeply rounded is the very edge - the dark area where the scratches disappear completely is probably 2 or 3 thousandths. The darkness is a consequence of metallurgical scopes (without complex lighting solutions) being very sensitive to light reflecting from directly overhead. As the bevel rounds, this doesn't occur evenly since the bevel is no longer flat.

So, the focus is just then the evenness of the edge as it'll show you any scratches that the light doesn't catch (as notching).

Here's one of plane iron test edges from black arkasnas. Some of the deflection occurs due to stropping on bare leather (extremly lightly for this test to get the best looking edge I could get).

https://i.imgur.com/lxt9uYz.jpg

The evenness of this buff is similar to the way submicron abrasives finish an edge, but with a cheap 5 micron al-ox stick. we saw in the wear tests that the appearance of this black ark edge isn't that big of a deal on a plane as it leaves a nice surface and on O1, evidence of it is worn off evenly, anyway. But it does cause edge life to be less than 1 micron diamonds (Something steve elliot also found)

https://i.imgur.com/neyObEz.jpg

(I just got a new scope yesterday - the one I used last year doesn't work with win 10, which is a pain, because the scopes that mount on microscopes aren't any $15 type like you find with hand helds).

Re: Why I'm enamored with small rounding..

#2

The actual purpose of this...

David Weaver

This isn't an edge chasing issue, it's a laziness issue and an issue of making something slightly subpar (like sorby, or even the narex chisels - which are middling and made much better with a trick like this) perform as well or better than a typical setup method for a high cost chisel.

Without losing anything. If it's kept small, it doesn't affect bevel riding. It doesn't affect resistance through the wood, and if the abrasive is fine and slow, it speeds up subsequent sharpening. you can do it by hand without a buffer if you try to imitate the same thing.

If you have chisels you like a lot but they perform poorly if you use stringy woods like white oak, etc, then this will get you right through all of the work without searching the internet to spend more money.

This is a picture of what the sorby chisel looks like after a light trip on the buff. The bright white is the rounded part (taken with a phone camera). https://i.imgur.com/tN4PfxO.jpg

The next dark strip is about 25 degrees, and the other two lines are just two different primary grinds - there aren't four bevels.

The sharpness of this chisel is something that I cannot match with stones. It's not really the sharpness that I'm after, though, it's preventing edge failure without making the chisel feel blunt.

Over the years, I've switched to slower stones and doing this on the very tip of a chisel out of laziness. Not laziness for not making textbook geometric planes, but wanting to use the tools at hand without any other modification and with less time spent sharpening. Once in a while, I will make a comment that total sharpening with slower and finer stones is less than it is with faster stones. This is why. faster stones just make doing something this fine more difficult. The buffer is really lazy, but a slow really fine stone does this well. The second bevel isn't particularly fine - it's something like 1k diamond.

I've sometimes gotten the question about how this is different than sellers' method. It should be pretty easy to see now that I have pictures. I'm not guruing and I'm sure that carvers and many others have done this in the past - nothing that you figure out ends up really being any unique discovery.

Re: Why I'm enamored with small rounding..

#3

for japanese chisels ,too - no planes

David Weaver

I should add to this (i'm sure it's not easy to grasp what I'm getting at with this rabbit hole because it doesn't come with paint by numbers).....it's not just soft chisels that I learned this from.

I also use it on japanese chisels, as it's nice to keep the primary of those chisels in the high 20s, but you can get lots of chipping at the very edge. They are notoriously hard and don't take deep scratches from natural stones right at the very edge, so this is superb if you're using them to do something like chop half blinds (with minor malice -not dilly dally).

Translation of what that adds is if you have to chop 6 feet of dovetails in a given case (half blind or otherwise) you can do all of your chopping with nothing more than a finish stone nearby. And with an edge at the end that's about as good as the one that you had at the beginning.

If you see chipping in japanese chisels, the suggestion is often to set the whole bevel steeper - some advocating as much as 35 degrees. That's a lot of wedging work in chopping (Friction, etc, prying) and while it might protect the edge, it'll punish the chopper.