Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

oh my (operator error on the case)

Posts

oh my (operator error on the case)

#1

oh my (operator error on the case)

David Weaver

gluing the base on this case - I always like to make a solid 8/4 base on cases. It's unnecessarily heavy, but it accomplishes two things - it's simple and permanent looking wherever the case sits, and it prevents the kids from losing things under cabinets.

The same user error exists at the bottom of this case (no drawn out plans, little experience building furniture - especially without frames - and I didn't leave a lip out of the bottom of the case to accommodate for the door thickness.

I cut the rabbet shallow on the front piece of base wood to make room for that and figured I'd just change the angles for the miter. To say that wasn't thinking it through (they could've just been done like the miters on the top of the case. It would've been weird, but so what) would be an understatement.

The result is this:

https://i.imgur.com/k8ZYpdQ.jpg

https://i.imgur.com/ZVzzPaE.jpg

damnit.

I'm not looking for extra effort to finish this and was about ready to tear everything off and "do it right" but changed my mind and figured it might be an interesting opportunity to see if I could blend the two mismatches together and allow a little bit of endgrain to show (where this thing will sit, it's between a wall and a hearth, so only the front will be easily visible).

When I turn this over later today, I'll address the little bit of the top that needs to be matched up. Too risky to fix that upside down.

terrible!

Re: oh my (operator error on the case)

#2

Re: oh my (operator error on the case)

David Weaver

Probably recoverable, but in anger with the base, it looks like I got a little bit rammy with the clamps.


Re: oh my (operator error on the case)

#3

Have courage...

Jim Matthews

Expose the assembly to children and "weathering" will cover all apologies.

My best projects should look so clean.

Re: oh my (operator error on the case)

#4

Re: Have courage...

David Weaver

Yes sir, the kids will take care of any notion that it'll sta perfect. I have plenty of room to plane the filth off of the front later specifically because of the errors on the corners. The miter meets elsewhere back the side some. I have the missing piece broken off of the ledge in the front, it's just the triangle that's the trouble. The cove can be moved back a little to accommodate.

Re: oh my (operator error on the case)

#5

Among the many many things I has

Wiley Horne

learned the hard way....

The very instant I realize I have blown a woodworking step—planing through veneer, cutting an inch shy, leaving short grain and then knocking it off, ...there are a thousand of these—that very instant, the very second, drop what’s in my hands, and walk away. Just walk right out of that shop. Let the work slide off my shoulders, down my back, and lay on the shop floor. Don’t even start doing something else. Don’t start any thing new. Get a cup of coffee. Sit down. Take a breath. Don’t come back til tomorrow. Your mileage may vary.

Wiley

Re: oh my (operator error on the case)

#6

Re: Among the many many things I has

David Weaver

Agree...the little triangle is actually from clamping things a bit tight. The bit that chipped off of the front (much worse) Is sort of a grain anomaly, but can be glued back on cleanly.

In my younger days, I may have heaved the vacuum across the shop, but I just don't have that kind of fire any longer and the "in anger" was more of in panic trying to keep things square to minimize the follow up work.

The reason I didn't fix those things already is age has taught me to wait until the end as I could very well scuff up the fixed area. Much luck in this case that everything has room for adjustment to the front to make it all disappear.

I wonder where that youth fire went. I'd have never waited to see if I could make the fix interesting as it has become.

Re: oh my (operator error on the case)

#7

interesting base molding profile

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I have to admit I got lost with what the problem was and how it got fixed. What ever it was I find that as I make more stuff the errors of what came before don't happen again. They become permanent teaching lessons.

What is/was the door issue? Are the doors overlay and not inset?

That fact that us amateurs can successfully build anything is a tribute to our determination and ingenuity. We haven't been apprentices (though courses help if taken with an apprentice mind set) and we usually only build one of something.

I think to have made a living at it the furniture makers of 1820 likely settled on some basic designs and decoration and replicated them more or less. But to gain speed the next desk would need to look much like the last.

Which brings me to the base molding profile. Not common to see just a cove down there. They usually live up top. That said, the profile of this cove is inviting. It snatches this design out of Period Furniture and into a modern time. I liked the result and will consider it in the future.

But, I may not be able to make your cove. Coves made with a router bit cove cutter are some section of a circle. A cove made with bedded blade of circle section profile will be a section of an ellipse, and look different, likely better.

Re: oh my (operator error on the case)

#8

The cove on the bottom...

David Weaver

First, I should probably apologize for overstating my anger level with this case and the damage - most of the scuffing on the front of the case is something that would've happened as I didn't have a good way to square up the base pieces and get them seated. I undercut the rebates that held them on and they weren't deadly straight wood - a bad combination, which resulted in clamping square things to the base pieces and then clamping the base pieces to the case with a little force.

I probably would've made that front damage regardless. I just don't have the bright red anger that I had when I was younger and now when something bad happens, I think about it for a while and resist the urge to come up with a quick solution and implement - or rip things apart. So I was exaggerating a little about perhaps seeming like the wrench and socket-throwing mechanic. I was that guy when I was younger, but comparing outcomes makes it easier to be mad and not do that.

Still, if this was "real" furniture, I couldn't have taken the opportunity to see what I could make of the error - it would have to be removed and redone or somehow visually eliminated.

On to the cove. I suspect that the base of this piece would be better off as something with no sharp corners, but I like the crisp little steps - they have the same effect as a small sharp bead. Someone will drag something out of the case and ding those up. Just as the top would've been just as good as a cyma recta, but I interrupted the pattern. I don't think it looks quite as good, but the purpose of this thing goes back to the same as fixing the corners instead of replacing the base (it really doesn't matter - it just needs to be done and if my wife has any concerns about looks, I've learned that beyond disputing color, anything else will be a surprise that I wouldn't have guessed).

The design is pretty easy to do with hand tools - two rebates with a moving fillister and then plane off the top of the cove waste and finish it out with a round plane. Sanded in this case to the same uniformity as the rest of the large surfaces in the case will be so that the stain is taken evenly when I get to that. It would look nice planed, but based on what we've seen, it wouldn't make a difference unless the finish was thin and sheer.

I'd like to redo the top moulding to something more crisp, but maybe some other day on another piece - i didn't put in the effort to find something more interesting and that's that. Next time, I'll choose a moulding and build planes to cut it for the purpose.

The doors are overlay, no frame. Since this is utility furniture and this house is full of door slammers, I'm using a euro style hinge with soft close. The mrs. said "nothing that will make the opening smaller and no center post" so a frame is out and the whole thing gets cheapened a little bit by the style constraints and hinge choices. I will fit the doors and adjust them to have even gaps and the plane the outside rails (hopefully not much) even with the case sides to make it look a little less gross.

With power tools and a couple of repetitions, I could make this thing really fast, though, and would never make the front mortise error a second time.

Re: oh my (operator error on the case)

#9

the idea of making a bunch of these ...

David Weaver

..your comment about a shop (at least in the time that we've all been alive) coming up with a design and settling on it matches what I see in my grandparents' furniture.

They're deceased, but a local clock maker and cabinetmaker (have to wear more than one hat, I guess) did really tidy work - and of the type that maybe he used hand plane somewhere on it, but I wouldn't be able to tell. As far as I know, he worked as a one-man maker from the 1930s to 1960s and his furniture was well regarded locally by folks who were looking for practical, spartan but high quality.

He did as you say - he had a few design elements that he'd settled on that were basic and attractive and the chests and corner cabinets, etc, all pretty much looked the same.

I came up with this cheap little idea for the cove on the bottom on the first case that I've built and it shows the danger of coming up with something OK and figuring you'll think harder on the next one. In real life, nobody has ever said boo about it one way or another - only the multitudes of internet critics could decry its ugliness or lack of prior use. And if they do, that's fine.

I know they'd find issues with the man who made my grandfather's corner cupboard - but that fellow's stuff still sells well locally when someone dies. Well enough that it could be made profitably if new sold for the same price.