The cove on the bottom...
David Weaver
First, I should probably apologize for overstating my anger level with this case and the damage - most of the scuffing on the front of the case is something that would've happened as I didn't have a good way to square up the base pieces and get them seated. I undercut the rebates that held them on and they weren't deadly straight wood - a bad combination, which resulted in clamping square things to the base pieces and then clamping the base pieces to the case with a little force.
I probably would've made that front damage regardless. I just don't have the bright red anger that I had when I was younger and now when something bad happens, I think about it for a while and resist the urge to come up with a quick solution and implement - or rip things apart. So I was exaggerating a little about perhaps seeming like the wrench and socket-throwing mechanic. I was that guy when I was younger, but comparing outcomes makes it easier to be mad and not do that.
Still, if this was "real" furniture, I couldn't have taken the opportunity to see what I could make of the error - it would have to be removed and redone or somehow visually eliminated.
On to the cove. I suspect that the base of this piece would be better off as something with no sharp corners, but I like the crisp little steps - they have the same effect as a small sharp bead. Someone will drag something out of the case and ding those up. Just as the top would've been just as good as a cyma recta, but I interrupted the pattern. I don't think it looks quite as good, but the purpose of this thing goes back to the same as fixing the corners instead of replacing the base (it really doesn't matter - it just needs to be done and if my wife has any concerns about looks, I've learned that beyond disputing color, anything else will be a surprise that I wouldn't have guessed).
The design is pretty easy to do with hand tools - two rebates with a moving fillister and then plane off the top of the cove waste and finish it out with a round plane. Sanded in this case to the same uniformity as the rest of the large surfaces in the case will be so that the stain is taken evenly when I get to that. It would look nice planed, but based on what we've seen, it wouldn't make a difference unless the finish was thin and sheer.
I'd like to redo the top moulding to something more crisp, but maybe some other day on another piece - i didn't put in the effort to find something more interesting and that's that. Next time, I'll choose a moulding and build planes to cut it for the purpose.
The doors are overlay, no frame. Since this is utility furniture and this house is full of door slammers, I'm using a euro style hinge with soft close. The mrs. said "nothing that will make the opening smaller and no center post" so a frame is out and the whole thing gets cheapened a little bit by the style constraints and hinge choices. I will fit the doors and adjust them to have even gaps and the plane the outside rails (hopefully not much) even with the case sides to make it look a little less gross.
With power tools and a couple of repetitions, I could make this thing really fast, though, and would never make the front mortise error a second time.