Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

making my life difficult on the cabinets..

Posts

making my life difficult on the cabinets..

#1

making my life difficult on the cabinets..

David Weaver

Not on purpose as I drag this build out (just never get motivated to do much continuous work on furniture)......

I neglected to account for the door thickness on the front of the bottom cabinet, which means I need to add a moulding that does it, but I don't want that fat thickness around the side of the cabinet - it would look terrible.

So, the solution is to cut the moulding (this is all by hand, I don't have another way), then resaw the excess thickness off of the pieces, leaving me with this little mickey mouse project on the front (the corner of the moulding needs to meet ahead of the case).

This isn't a huge time soak, just a bump in the road, and though it'll look a little funny, this case is going to be stained dark as night, so it won't matter that much.

Quiz question for you guys guessing on how to trim the side of the cabinet into the flat thickness of this - how would you do it. I know the best answer from doing a lot of roughing work by hand, but it may be useful to you sometime (I can tell you how to do it with two tools - just pushing a flat chisel that isn't extremely narrow into it is a bad idea).



Re: making my life difficult on the cabinets..

#2

Re: making my life difficult on the cabinets..

David Weaver

(the tool of choice for this is...

.... a patternmaker's crank neck incannel gouge. something that you can sometimes struggle to find a use for. it always minds its business in a cut (cutting only what's in the curve and only part of it is directly across end grain, some is more of a shear cut) and it cuts the end grain very easily.

A patternmaker's crank chisel is far less pleasant to use, but you can turn it on edge so that it's more controllable and do most of the paring in narrow strips before turning it over the other way and then paring off whatever is left. The issue here is that anything that requires significant force can spoil the top of the miter for slipping through and over cutting.

I've used incannel patternmaker's gouges (I don't have straight or firmer type) quite a bit opening the handle mortises on planes and cutting cavities in guitar bodies - very pleased once I learned how to maintain them for what is essentially roughing work.

Re: making my life difficult on the cabinets..

#3

ensuing cork-up

David Weaver



Loved finding that void in the moulding (no sign of it in the wood until cutting into it). The mouldings are plain enough and this cabinet will be dark enough that it doesn't matter. I'll just leave it as is or fill it afterwards.

I did this to the inside of the stock before fitting it by hand adjusting the border to get a tight fit.


Re: making my life difficult on the cabinets..

#4

Re: ensuing cork-up

Wiley Horne

David,

That’s a really tight corner fit. Coupla suggestions: If you have a burn-in shellac kit, that’s s trivial fix. Otherwise, make a pile of moulding sawdust from offcuts, and make a paste with hide glue—an even better fix.

Corner looks great!

Wiley

Re: making my life difficult on the cabinets..

#5

Filing for future reference

Jim Matthews

The Iwasaki carving file works for me.

Re: making my life difficult on the cabinets..

#6

Re: same as an option...

David Weaver

..I don't have the iwasakis, but have an assortment now of the nicholson super shears.

They're a little awkward to use on the side cut that I mentioned for the patternmaker's crank neck gouge (the crank gouge makes the whole thing take a fraction of a minute whereas you can end up filing unevenly, etc, and with much more work).

But the super shear/iwasaki type file is an excellent option to fit the side piece to the front miter.

I ended up using the long plane lap with sandpaper on it (a little faster), but admit that's a bit ungainly - sanding off bits of a moulding piece with a fairly small contact area, but you can freehand it a little and check.

The super shear style file is a fantastic tool to have, though.

Re: making my life difficult on the cabinets..

#7

Re: ensuing cork-up

David Weaver

I do have a burn kit, and agree on the sawdust. I've got a couple of other little dings on this already that I'm going to wait until finished and burn in but am hoping to experiment on making beaumontage for the front void.

I don't really like building the furniture, but if I was retired and it didn't suck up all of my minimal build time in a given week, I'd probably build some along with guitars and tools (something a little bit more interesting than this case).

Re: making my life difficult on the cabinets..

#8

Impressive miter

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

You have a calling to make fine furniture

Re: making my life difficult on the cabinets..

#9

Maybe when I retire...

David Weaver

...I don't have what it takes to build furniture right now - it's the playing with the hand tools that ties it together and the little challenges like this. I think people who build good furniture over and over are creatures of routine and I'm thrilled by figuring things out and moving onto the next thing.

Personal flaw, I guess. Not sure how I managed to build so many planes, but if the routine to build them became less freehand, I'm sure I'd quit doing that, too.

Re: making my life difficult on the cabinets..

#10

You have given Derek an invitation.....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

....to correct this misconception.

"I think people who build good furniture over and over are creatures of routine and I'm thrilled by figuring things out and moving onto the next thing."

No doubt he will review what he has built in the last 5 years to demonstrate that a large part of the satisfaction of making custom furniture is "figuring things out". Perhaps what you lack are customers. Works for me.

Re: making my life difficult on the cabinets..

#11

Everything involves some problem solving..

David Weaver

..it's not a case of furniture work being devoid of problem solving, rather the methods to do things are generally more prescriptive among the good makers.

Maybe that's an unfair statement. I don't make guitars the way the guitar folks do, either.

There is some satisfaction in building something 20 times and getting good at it (which takes repetition), but the bug isn't there for me for furniture at this point.

After making some boring plain moulding profiles, I would like to make some complex moulding planes though, and thought about one to cut the mouldings on this thing project, but I'm trying to keep in mind that once it gets covered with dark stain and shoved in a corner, nobody will care much (at least not here) and it's a cabinet that the kids use, so it'll take a beating.

Re: making my life difficult on the cabinets..

#12

Re: Everything involves some problem solving..

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

David, how long does it take you to build a guitar? How long does it take you to build a complex moulding plane?

I suspect that the reason you like building guitars and planes over furniture is that they take much less time than the average of three or four months it takes for me to build something substantial, such as the hall table for my niece (and even more - the Lingerie Chest took 18 months).

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: making my life difficult on the cabinets..

#13

The guitar would depend..

David Weaver

If I made a good archtop guitar, it would probably take a little bit longer than one of your typical (if there is such a thing) projects. I'm working up to that. If I can learn to do tasteful inlay and more intricate binding work, it will add more. I can't gather much from months, but rather hours involved.

An infill plane of decent quality from scratch takes about 80 hours. I'd guess the easy guitars that I'm building are probably 35 - 40? I've never counted it. Fender says 7 hours, but I haven't got their setup.

None of it is short.

The reason that I don't build furniture isn't the duration - it's because of lack of interest. The double case that I"m building probably really isn't that much in total hours - if it's more than 80, I'd be surprised (even with mostly hand dimensioning), but I don't get much of a buzz off of building it and tend to do an hour or two here or there whereas I can get lost for the better part of a day building planes or guitars - until I get in trouble from upstairs.

I'd gather that what you like about the furniture is building it. Or maybe it's that your relatives want it - that's a two for one - if you like both of those. I don't have much demand for furniture and the tools (and using them) and guitars (and playing them) are the double interest.

If I get the urge to build furniture, it'll be a little more on the wacky side - but there's a cheap part of me from around here that thinks I could some really nice chests with uncommon wood in solid and then french polish them and have they look wonderful - and finding someone who wanted them would be difficult. If I couldn't work toward building archtop guitars (which have more use to me and then a stronger market if I decide they don't), I guess I'd consider building something pretty nutty on the furniture side that didn't have very many straight lines on it.

Re: making my life difficult on the cabinets..

#14

Interpretation of Comments on I-webs..

David Weaver

Derek, this isn't necessarily directed at your comments, just my observation of things over the years.

My thoughts on furniture are not what is. It's what is to me. there may be consensus builders on the internet (like the knots era when it was popular to claim building the most with the fewest tools and you were seen as a company plant - it was ridiculous), but consensus building isn't in my blood so I sometimes forget that what I find interesting or uninteresting can be interpreted as what others should think. That's a lot like politics to me - I hate politics. It's a way to pre-load an answer or determine that you have no regard for someone else because they don't like what you like. It's really weird.

The first thing I ever built was furniture. I was lukewarm about it, but thought it would catch on. Then, it never really did. I thought the first guitar that I built, when I was done, it might be crap or not work after I wired it and I'd throw it against the wall. But that didn't happen - it was thrilling and it sounded great.

But because I'm not on this knots-like bender that some are that the only thing that counts being built is furniture, I'm already pre-loaded to expect people to think that the tools and the guitars are goofy.

https://i.imgur.com/AC4GK9u.jpg

As this thing is getting ready wrap up soon after doors and finish, I'm glad to see it go. If I was good enough yet to build a spectacular archtop guitar (by that, I mean that nobody would look at and think any part of it in proportion or execution or timbre or volume would look remotely amateurish) in 200-300 hours or so, that would be just wonderful. It'll be a while, but it will be interesting to me along the way.

When I'm cutting rows of half blinds and dovetails, it becomes a sport to see how fast I can do them, not how well I can do them. When I cut a moulding like the one on the front of this and out of the plane cuttings appears a hole, if that were a guitar, it would go in the trash. On the furniture, I think, oh well, that's the breaks. I'll fill it with something at the end of this.

I'm glad that the era of knots and the mels of the world (harrassing anyone who he didn't think was building something nice enough, furniture enough, with few enough and low cost enough tools) seems to have disappeared from the forum.

Re: making my life difficult on the cabinets..

#15

you are describing drawers

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I find no joy in building drawers. Indeed they are all the same. You might like planing to fit them though.

Re: making my life difficult on the cabinets..

#16

I would probably...

David Weaver

..enjoy one of those little contests where you try to build a case where pushing one drawer in pushes another one out. Or speculating on how to make one like that where seasonal movement wouldn't have much effect.

I'd probably fail at it, though.

Re: making my life difficult on the cabinets..

#17

not hard to do

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"enjoy one of those little contests where you try to build a case where pushing one drawer in pushes another one out. Or speculating on how to make one like that where seasonal movement wouldn't have much effect."

Well fit drawers in a tight case will perform this trick if the drawers are lubed with wax and otherwise work smoothly. While I build to "make do" specifications in most parts of a dresser to store socks I spend the time to get drawers fit as perfect as I can get them. The result is a drawer that is a tactical pleasure to open because it opens so smoothly and it won't rack upon closure. When this goal is achieved a drawer closed smartly will indeed open another- unless there are dust panels which I eschew and the case bottom is left open, which I usually do. This feature, while it might be impressive to other woodworkers, is a pain to the owner of the socks. There is little functional benefit to having to close two drawers to get one closed.

Re: making my life difficult on the cabinets..

#18

Re: not hard to do

David Weaver

Bill, I've always admired how everything is just in place in your furniture - the drawers are neatly fitted and not sloppy with an even gap everywhere and you've mentioned often that everything is functional.

I agree on the drawers being a pain if they open each other when one is closed - it's a neat novelty.

I like the tactile comment - making things that you have to do (opening drawers, driving cars, shaving, etc) feel good to do is one of the little spices of life.