Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

japanese rip saw

Posts

japanese rip saw

#1

japanese rip saw

McKay

I have a number of western style hand saws for ripping, but they are 2300 miles from where I am. Does anyone have a favorite Japanese rip saw that they prefer? If so, what mm length? What should I steer clear of and what should I look for? Thanks in advance.

Re: japanese rip saw

#2

Re: japanese rip saw

David Weaver

Unless you're only ripping short little pieces, I'd order another western rip saw off of ebay. I never found a japanese saw that was capable of ripping western hardwoods well, productively and comfortably (I mean dimensioning work, not a test cut - when I proposed that years ago, I got lots of responses from some of the japanese tool gurus at the time with test cuts of 6 or 8 inches and then comments that they work better than western saws, and that you can't get work done hand ripping (far from the truth).

There is only one exception - a saw that stan covington had made custom - actually, he had two made. $750 each.

my hands ache thinking about cutting cherry and white oak with stuff like the 330 mm gyochuko katabas and ryobas.

Re: japanese rip saw

#3

Re: japanese rip saw

Wiley Horne

Agree with David. It will take a very expensive Japanese rip kataba to make a long rip the equal of a double-tapered vintage western saw. Traditional Japanese sawsmiths made double-tapered rip saws too. To get a new one would cost about what David quoted. From Heiji thru So Yamashita, for example.

If you do go to Ebay as David suggested, and you have a hankering for a Japanese saw, you might look for one on Ebay just as you would a Disston. If you find one that looks promising, check the tooth count—it is likely designed for soft wood.

Wiley

Re: japanese rip saw

#4

it would be nice...

David Weaver

..to know what each saw was intended for. Not just "softwood or hardwood", but what woods are they talking about and how much of them?

I like the Z saws a lot, as well as the gyochukos. Not for gizmosis, but because they're practical if not very technically impressive (thinking of plate grind and stiffness).

But everything that they make that rips rattles my hands to death.

The saw that Stan Covington had made had a thick plate and very western-like teeth on it and it was smooth through 4/4-10/4 wood. Just like a western saw would be.

I'd imagine what I was missing with something like the Z kataba with rip teeth is that nobody at Z ever intended someone to try to cut very hard thick billets with the saw (the teeth weren't close to optimized for it).

Re: japanese rip saw

#5

Depending on thickness...

Jim Matthews

I'm working a project that requires multiple 20" rips in in quartersawn White Oak.

It's for drawer guides, about 3/4" thick.

Gyucucho S-650 - no idea what the tooth count is, but it's fairly coarse.

I cut with boards mounted vertically in my Patternmaker's vise, with very little protruding.

This dampens the rattling effect descspecs.

There is always an optimal angle for the blade relative to the board face - rarely at 90° to the work. More muscle rarely makes for faster, or cleaner cutting. I have knocked teeth out of finer Japanese saws, from spirited abuse. This one seems to hold up OK.

It's impulse hardened - no sharpening possible.

Here's a link to the current version with similar specx.

https://www.amazon.com/Gyokucho-270%EF%BD%8D%EF%BD%8D-Double-Ryoba-Woodworker/dp/B000CED1NM/ref=sr_1_4?dchild=1&keywords=gyokucho+ryoba&qid=1588878050&sr=8-4


img

Re: japanese rip saw

#6

Re: it would be nice...

Wiley Horne

Yes, if McKay’s work involves short rips, there is a better answer. Because the Z and Gyokucho’s are plenty sharp, and therefore serviceable if you’re not going far. Or if the cut can be fenced (like Bill Tindall’s example not so long ago), then Z or Gyokucho will do fine.

And perhaps someone will come into this thread and prove my opinion wrong with a long cut they made with a modern machine-made saw. I certainly hope so!!

But a double-tapered saw, that is also tensioned, like you get in a vintage western or Japanese saw, is deserving of the highest respect. I don’t know if any of the modern west ern saws are double-tapered and tensioned. It’s two difficult operations, and amazing that Disston figured out a way to taper the plates without hand-scraping.

Wiley

Re: japanese rip saw

#7

I take it all back *LINK*

Wiley Horne

Hi McKay and all,

I am apologizing to you all, and taking back most of what I said above.

After I read Jim’s post, I went and found my Gyokucho S-655 270mm ryoba; 5 tpi rip and 10 tpi crosscut. I bought it originally to trim tree branches.

Anyway, I tested the saw ripping a scrap of 4/4 birch (25/32” actual). Fixed the saw in the vise more or less vertical. Marked a line, and ripped 18” just parallel to the mark. Was able to track Ok, and could have gone on indefinitely. I had thought the ryoba might start binding in the cut as soon as the crosscut teeth entered the cut, but it didn’t. Saw has enough set—and therefore clearance—to steer the cut even when both sets of teeth are in the cut.

Then I picked up a piece of 2x4 douglas fir, to see whether the saw would handle it, or would it get timber-bound. I went 15” before deciding the saw would manage that thickness just fine without getting timber-bound. I could have sawn on indefinitely without getting off line.

Kerf a little coarse in both cases, because of aggressive tooth rake and 5tpi, but saw not slow. I think (but am not sure) that a 240mm might be a bit flimsy for these cuts.

Here is the album showing what is described above:

https://www.flickr.com/photos/78661951@N07/albums/72157714210509033

Wiley...’It ain’t ignorance that’s the problem; it’s what folks know that ain’t so.’

[Variously attributed to Mark Twain, Will Rogers, and maybe Artemus Ward—but definitely not Yogi Berra.]


https://www.flickr.com/photos/78661951@N07/albums/72157714210509033

Re: japanese rip saw

#8

Re: I take it all back

David Weaver

That matches my experience - wood short enough to go in a vise, OK, as long as the blade doesn't wander. Wandering is a temporary thing - but adjustment back to course results in crosscut teeth sanding the cut some.

The issue is less a matter can't doing it and more a matter of a well sharpened disston saw taking much less effort (and should one want to do what you're doing with oak or something that's got lots of conviction in the length of the straws - it'll leave serious aching from bouncing).

In softwood, they work well in short cuts. In all woods, though, the purpose made japanese saws and the disstons work well if you're doing 5 inches or 50 feet in a given shop session.

Thus the what's being made question - if it's furniture, then buying a used rip saw off of ebay with good teeth is a good idea. If it's boxes or tools, then you can get by with the japanese saws.

All that said, those flat floppy machine made saws are very capable. When something goes awry resulting in a bent tooth, it can just be hammered back, and the back facet on the crosscut teeth can be sharpened easily with a stroke of a diamond file and the blades stretched out in life.

Re: japanese rip saw

#9

P.S.—I see my saw is the same

Wiley Horne

as Jim’s. It’s the one he linked to on Amazon.

Wiley

Re: japanese rip saw

#10

When the greatest strength is also a weakness

Jim Matthews

I think the greatest asset of these production Japanese saws is that they're already sharp. The downside is that the plates are effectively disposable when dulled.

It's taken me nearly 10 years faffing about with them to get a straight cut, without knocking out saw teeth - in a reasonable amount of time.

The real advantage over Western saws (without stiffening backs) is that I can clearly see where I'm cutting. Sawbenches are *just* out of focus with bifocals, but not far enough away to see unaided.

The Ryoba is at the Lagrange point for optimal (optical) inspection.

Re: japanese rip saw

#11

Re: I take it all back

Wiley Horne

Hi David,

I certainly agree that traditional saws—western or Japanese—are preferred.

However. I went back and re-read McKay’s original post. He’s not a novice—we’ve seen his work before, plus he’s got a bunch of western rip saws. He knows about Disston. But he’s a long way from his shop, and has a reason for asking after Japanese saws.

I’m satisfied he can make that ryoba work, at least within the examples shown in this thread. The only limit I found was that I would need to saw a little fat and plane 3-4 passes to the gauge line, because the saw has a pretty wide set and is 5 tpi with an aggressive rake. It’s the wide set that makes it work rip, because the crosscut teeth don’t get fouled in the cut.

Wiley

Re: japanese rip saw

#12

Re: japanese rip saw

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

McKay, I’m coming in late here, but suggest you look for a kataba style saw. I have a 13 tpi Ikeda Kataba 270mm long. (I also know of a 9tpi 300mm). The 270mm does an excellent job. Aggressive cutter. The kataba is a single-sided plate, compared to the double-sided ryoba.

Regards from Perth

Derek